Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Chersfrozenface · 23/08/2023 17:48

EsmaCannonball · 23/08/2023 17:42

Some doctor somewhere will be willing to attempt a uterus transplant into a man, and the men who want this kind of thing will be in it purely for the fetish of having a womb inside them. Some of these men have a pregnancy fetish which, hopefully, will be completely futile and some of them will just get off on having what they see as the holy grail of womanhood harvested from an actual woman and implanted inside them.

The idea of poor women having to sell body parts so men can get their kicks is repellent, and I can't imagine many women would be happy to think that after death their uterus could be gifted to some creep after his ultimate thrill.

One doctor has already said that he's planning to transplant a womb into a transwoman

In India, where all those women are being coerced into having hysterectomies.

https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/indian-doctor-plans-world-first-womb-transplant-into-trans-woman/

Indian doctor plans world first womb transplant into trans woman

An Indian doctor is planning the world's first womb transplant into a transgender woman who was born a male.

https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/indian-doctor-plans-world-first-womb-transplant-into-trans-woman

Islandermummy · 23/08/2023 17:47

Dinoboymama · 23/08/2023 10:43

I don't see the issue, I would happily donate my uterus when I die if it were to help someone. I wouldn't donate whilst still living due to caring reasons but if I were brain-dead they may as well take what they can to aid others.

Yes, I feel like it's up to the organ owner. Should never be without consent, or for cash, though

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:47

It's a tongue in cheek comment. There is no "2010 Gender Equality Act" in existence. It covers 9 protected characteristics, it isn't just about "gender". Clueless.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 17:46

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:45

Some doctor somewhere will be willing to attempt a uterus transplant into a man, and the men who want this kind of thing will be in it purely for the fetish of having a womb inside them. Some of these men have a pregnancy fetish which, hopefully, will be completely futile and some of them will just get off on having what they see as the holy grail of womanhood harvested from an actual woman and implanted inside them.

The idea of poor women having to sell body parts so men can get their kicks is repellent, and I can't imagine many women would be happy to think that after death their uterus could be gifted to some creep after his ultimate thrill.

Some people are extremely naive. If they weren't, all this wouldn't have got this far.

It wouldn't have got this far??

Like transplantation of limbs? Or skin? Or the research around pancreas transplants?

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 17:45

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:43

Yes, in that article he says (among others quoted around the world) that it is not yet technically feasible but his "suspicion is 10 to 20 years".

"Professor Smith said: 'We're very aware that 2010 Gender Equality Act mandates equal treatment for cisgender and transgender women."

He also thinks the Equality Act 2010 is just for the benefit of trans people, apparently Confused

Where does it say he thinks the equality act is "is just for the benefit of trans people". When the discussion is around trans, his answer will be in relation to that. He isn't going to mention ethnicity or disability when they are in no way connected to the conversation being had.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:45

Some doctor somewhere will be willing to attempt a uterus transplant into a man, and the men who want this kind of thing will be in it purely for the fetish of having a womb inside them. Some of these men have a pregnancy fetish which, hopefully, will be completely futile and some of them will just get off on having what they see as the holy grail of womanhood harvested from an actual woman and implanted inside them.

The idea of poor women having to sell body parts so men can get their kicks is repellent, and I can't imagine many women would be happy to think that after death their uterus could be gifted to some creep after his ultimate thrill.

Some people are extremely naive. If they weren't, all this wouldn't have got this far.

Chersfrozenface · 23/08/2023 17:43

Same story in the Independent
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/richard-smith-imperial-college-london-university-of-alabama-sweden-mailonline-b2397710.html

The media are reproducing a PA news agency which quotes Richard Smith.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:43

Yes, in that article he says (among others quoted around the world) that it is not yet technically feasible but his "suspicion is 10 to 20 years".

"Professor Smith said: 'We're very aware that 2010 Gender Equality Act mandates equal treatment for cisgender and transgender women."

He also thinks the Equality Act 2010 is just for the benefit of trans people, apparently Confused

EsmaCannonball · 23/08/2023 17:42

Some doctor somewhere will be willing to attempt a uterus transplant into a man, and the men who want this kind of thing will be in it purely for the fetish of having a womb inside them. Some of these men have a pregnancy fetish which, hopefully, will be completely futile and some of them will just get off on having what they see as the holy grail of womanhood harvested from an actual woman and implanted inside them.

The idea of poor women having to sell body parts so men can get their kicks is repellent, and I can't imagine many women would be happy to think that after death their uterus could be gifted to some creep after his ultimate thrill.

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 17:35

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 13:50

No one is making any suggestion that men will receive wombs. This is because medically that’s a nonsense.

I'm sorry, but you're wrong about the former. The male surgeon, J Richard Smith, was principal lead on a research study to find out the demand for males.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3605548-Imperial-College-Womb-Transplant-Survey-Redux

And yes, I know it's the Mail...

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-12435963/Trans-women-benefit-womb-transplant-breakthrough.html

Biological men set to benefit from womb transplant breakthrough

Biological males who identify as women could get a womb transplant within the next decade according to the surgeon who performed the UK's first pioneering operation on a female this year.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-12435963/Trans-women-benefit-womb-transplant-breakthrough.html

BIossomtoes · 23/08/2023 17:27

My first reaction was queasiness. It just instinctively feels wrong.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:23

They are also not the only research team in the world looking at it. There is one in India and two in the US that I can think of off the top of my head.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 17:22

Do people genuinely believe that there's no suggestion of men receiving a womb transplant? I feel like there's a bit of a twist of words/semantics but thats what research is isn't it? Looking into a suggestion to see if its medically possible?

Yes I believe that's what they were doing, and yes I believe it's a question of semantics. As @ArabeIIaScott pointed out.

I don't believe whether it will actually be possible is the issue here, FWIW I don't think it is. I care only that they did research on it, and I'm not convinced it was just to cover all bases because I don't see any end conclusions ruling out the possibility. So they have left it open, and indeed the lead researcher on the Imperial College paper, who was one of the surgeons involved, has commented in the media today that he believes it will be possible within the next couple of decades. So clearly not so "impossible" in their minds, as I pointed out repeatedly.

LlynTegid · 23/08/2023 17:19

Whilst as a medical procedure I welcome it, I share the OPs concerns about what could happen in future, and that pressure or economic circumstances could lead to donations that are not really a free choice.

One of what I think would need to be several or more safeguards would be a period of time between offering and the donation actually happening, probably a period of years.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 17:11

Megifer · 23/08/2023 17:05

Do people genuinely believe that there's no suggestion of men receiving a womb transplant? I feel like there's a bit of a twist of words/semantics but thats what research is isn't it? Looking into a suggestion to see if its medically possible?

Yes that’s what research is, it looks at the possibility of things. What it doesn’t do is answer the question if that possibility before and research has even been suggested. It also doesn’t change laws, account for wider ethical questions beyond consent or mean that the thing it’s researching is likely to ever happen.

It is not ‘just semantics’ to say the researcher here is not suggesting putting wombs in men, it’s fundamental to the argument because the semantics in this case are the difference between ‘we are planning to put a womb in a man’ and ‘we are not going to put a womb in a man but recognise that this is a plausible extension of my research into womb transplants for biological women’ - semantics is very, very important in scientific research and not understanding that is why people end up angry on the internet about things that aren’t true.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 17:06

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 16:33

Ok.

But in one of its hospitals? So using a theatre?

No, at a private hospital in a private theatre, paid for by a charity.

Megifer · 23/08/2023 17:05

Do people genuinely believe that there's no suggestion of men receiving a womb transplant? I feel like there's a bit of a twist of words/semantics but thats what research is isn't it? Looking into a suggestion to see if its medically possible?

Blueblell · 23/08/2023 16:58

Clarification * I do see a problem with vulnerable people being forced to donate obviously! but that is a separate issue.

Blueblell · 23/08/2023 16:57

Vulnerable women will be forced to donate but is it any worse than being forced to donate a kidney?

I don’t see a problem with it.

ArabeIIaScott · 23/08/2023 16:53

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:02

I think this is a natural end to the chat and thanks for it, it’s been interesting to understand where a lot of this rhetoric is coming from.

You’re labouring under a false assumption that the presence of further research or suggestions of applications is a confirmation of belief or support in a particular world view - it is not. The researcher here did not lie and the fact (immutable) remains that there is no suggestion of transplanting a womb into a biological man, and therefore including the trans debate in whether or not women should receive womb transplants is a bit of a moot point. It’s like arguing unicorns shouldn’t be allowed to work in cloud factories - it’s just pointless rhetoric.

You have not understood the premise of the research you’ve put forward which is unfortunate but that doesn’t mean you’re wrong - you’re absolutely right to question stuff like this when it arises, I just wish people waited and fully interrogated things before they go fully frothy.

The fact some people have removed themselves from the donor register despite the donor register for womb transplants being a totally separate process and nothing to do with organ donation is just further evidence that people on this thread have absolutely no interest in fact and just love a bit of outrage to stampede about.

I see you're trying to present your arguments as calm and rational. That's fine, but it kind of lets the side down when you try to paint others' as emotive.

'No one has considered transplanting a womb into a man and he has also gone a step further there and said he personally will never consider doing it. They have conducted preliminary research into the possibility of it'

Jolly good.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 16:45

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 16:33

Ok.

But in one of its hospitals? So using a theatre?

A hospital that has a private wing, so a theatre would be used in the same way they are for private surgery - at great cost which helps a hospital to make money. So actually, the NHS probably gained from it.

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 16:33

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:23

This procedure was not in any way funded or performed by the NHS.

Ok.

But in one of its hospitals? So using a theatre?

Cynicaltheorist · 23/08/2023 16:33

Iwantcakeeveryday · 23/08/2023 16:10

Completely agree with this. It is frustrating that people don't consider these possibilities that are outside our small bubble.

Me too. The fact that women appear to have learned nothing from the way in which gender ideology has taken hold of the western world, and the way in which rampant misogny and ruthless greed and lack of ethics in the medical profession is just ignored because 'it'll never happen' dumbfounds me. Why would researchers go to the trouble of asking detailed questions about trans women's desires for uteruses, vagina transplants and periods if 'this will never happen'? Has no one ever worked in marketing where you establish a need for a product in peoples' minds and then create the product? You start the process by thinking the unthinkable.

Wednesdaysotherchild · 23/08/2023 16:31

Tinysoxx · 23/08/2023 11:10

Surely the immunosuppressant drugs also mean that the embryo/ foetus will be affected by these too?

There are actually a decent history and evidence base for women on immunosuppressants during pregnancy as a means of preventing recurrent miscarriages due to an overactive immune system. Obviously ones that don’t harm the foetus.

Check out the Pred thread! I am on them myself (although not pregnant yet) and my treatment plan is for multiple immune suppressing drugs until approx 20 weeks (if I ever get there) but some with more autoimmune diseases are on them for the whole pregnancy.

Naunet · 23/08/2023 16:28

Frydaycryday · 23/08/2023 16:02

I work in organ Donation, that's not how organ donation works. It will always be to a recipient on a transplant list.

That would be a body donated to research.... Which I have actually left my body to research at a major university.

So you’re telling me organs that are not suitable for transplant are just left or binned? I’m pretty sure I’ve even read on an NHS website that they’ll be used for medical research if unsuitable for donation if your family agrees, although to be fair, maybe that’s out of date? I’ll have to see if I can find it.