Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lend my friend money?

167 replies

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 07:16

Friend is in really bad debt. He’s overwhelmed with interest fees. He lost the money through an investment in his own business, that wasn’t successful.

I do quite well financially, although I don’t have as much saved as I should (expensive divorce).

We just got into a lighthearted conversation about whether I’d be able to lend him some money, interest free, to clear some of the debt, but during the conversation I realised I actually could.

I am completely against either borrowing or lending money but for some reason I feel unexpectedly comfortable with this.

He has never ever been anything but super reliable, money-wise. I let him use my card for a while when he lost his while travelling, and he paid me back every single penny via bank transfer, immediately after he’d made each payment.

It’s a vast amount of money though. A year’s salary for some people. I can afford to lose it but I certainly hope not to!

We would have legal docs drawn up, which would stipulate the terms. I already have the drafts and I’m pretty comfortable with them.

I’m trying to think it through properly before I go ahead as I don’t want to be an idiot.

Assuming he pays me back, the only thing I have to lose is the interest I’d make having it in the bank, but it’s not a big enough amount to concern me.

What am I not thinking of?

OP posts:
Zaaarrr · 23/08/2023 08:34

I'd definitely think about the friendship aspect of it all. How would you feel if your relationship changed over this? There are just so many things that could go wrong.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 23/08/2023 08:25

Planesmistakenforstars · 23/08/2023 07:22

Only go through with this if you are prepared to lose both the money and the friendship. Otherwise no way, don't even contemplate it.

Absolutely this, give him money if you want to but absolutely don't lend him any.

Icycloud · 23/08/2023 08:22

If he can’t pay the bank back how could he ever pay you back? before agreeing to anything get it in writing how he is going to pay you back

Hesma · 23/08/2023 08:22

Neither a borrower or a lender be…

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 08:22

BarbaraofSeville · 23/08/2023 08:20

That's the thing, you have to be really sure that he can afford to repay it, even go as far as asking to see his incomings and outgoings like a commercial lender would, and also making an assessment of the type of person he is - if he lost his job, would he get another one quickly, or loaf around? Does he appear to be a spender, or a saver? If he had a bit of spare money, what would he prioritise, paying back the OP, or spending it on non essential treats?

Debt run up due to business failure isn't necessarily the same as that due to overspending. He could have been trying to pay his normal expenses on no or reduced income. He could have been left with business debts for rent, rates, equipment, stock etc, which can quickly add up. He could have paid franchise fees or similar and then the business not worked and paid him an income that he expected. Now he's working again, all that has gone but the debt remains.

So if he now has a stable job that pays him enough for him to pay his normal household expenses with a good surplus, and it's just the interest that's killing him, it's not necessarily a hard no for the OP to lend the money.

This is essentially the exact situation.

He is full speed ahead with paying off his debts. He’s made every possible life adjustment to do so. But the interest is making it a very slow process.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 23/08/2023 08:21

One thing that did help was that he told his family. His reason was in case he died I'd be paid back from the inheritance he'd otherwise get from his parents. But it also meant I knew they would hold him accountable.

If the friend here died before paying the money back, it would be very easy for the OP to no be paid back.

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 08:20

Bearpawk · 23/08/2023 08:14

What makes you think he can pay you back if he can't service his current debts ?

This is something I’m going to ask him more about.

He sold his house, moved in with his brother and got a different job when the business failed, so he could (and is….) making the repayments. But I agree I want to understand more.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 23/08/2023 08:20

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 08:09

Thanks all. This has given me a ton of food for thought. I’m going to have another conversation with him about getting advice for his consolidating his debt, repayment if I do lend it to him, and a very open conversation about my concerns.

That's the thing, you have to be really sure that he can afford to repay it, even go as far as asking to see his incomings and outgoings like a commercial lender would, and also making an assessment of the type of person he is - if he lost his job, would he get another one quickly, or loaf around? Does he appear to be a spender, or a saver? If he had a bit of spare money, what would he prioritise, paying back the OP, or spending it on non essential treats?

Debt run up due to business failure isn't necessarily the same as that due to overspending. He could have been trying to pay his normal expenses on no or reduced income. He could have been left with business debts for rent, rates, equipment, stock etc, which can quickly add up. He could have paid franchise fees or similar and then the business not worked and paid him an income that he expected. Now he's working again, all that has gone but the debt remains.

So if he now has a stable job that pays him enough for him to pay his normal household expenses with a good surplus, and it's just the interest that's killing him, it's not necessarily a hard no for the OP to lend the money.

RaidFlySpray · 23/08/2023 08:18

I'd be more willing to think about this kind of thing EXCEPT that he's obviously not been proactive and gone for debt advice, consolidated his debts etc. This means he's really not as switched on financially as you seem to think he is. That's no moral judgment btw- People have different attitudes to money- but it would make me wary of lending to him.

LizzieSiddal · 23/08/2023 08:16

Glad you’re rethinking.

You should also consider that if he goes to a charity, they may well beable to negotiate a repayment plan which is much better for your friend than your agreement would be.

Bearpawk · 23/08/2023 08:14

What makes you think he can pay you back if he can't service his current debts ?

rookiemere · 23/08/2023 08:13

How long have you been friends?
Who brought up the subject of him borrowing money from you ?
How good a friend is he ?

I'd avoid if possible. I'm a Mrs Fixit too, but DH keeps me in check.

Autieangel · 23/08/2023 08:13

I agree with an above poster about a no strings gift if you want to help

I'd watch out for his reaction when you talk if he tries to put pressure on you you are being played. But honestly this reads like he's targeting you

larlypops · 23/08/2023 08:11

It’s all well and good now but if something were to arise and he couldn’t pay, what then.
even with a court order he could offer minimal and while you said you can afford it, could you afford it if you suddenly needed a chunk for renovations or a new car etc.

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 08:09

Thanks all. This has given me a ton of food for thought. I’m going to have another conversation with him about getting advice for his consolidating his debt, repayment if I do lend it to him, and a very open conversation about my concerns.

OP posts:
mscrooge · 23/08/2023 08:08

molotovcupcakes · 23/08/2023 07:49

I do quite well financially, although I don’t have as much saved as I should (expensive divorce).

You have just been through a lot and you don’t need to be throwing yourself into another stressful situation please just accept that you are emotionally vulnerable at the moment and your friend knows you’ve just received a lot of money, he shouldn’t target you like this.
Give him a token amount if you must and take him to step change- same result.

Just to clarify, I’ve been divorced years and definitely haven’t just received money. I earned it!

OP posts:
Summerrainagain1 · 23/08/2023 08:07

"He has never ever been anything but super reliable, money-wise"

Clearly this is not true or he wouldn't be in masses of debt.

Giv eyou want to give him the money on the basis you might never see it again then do, but don't lend with the expectation you will be paid bad as you will be disappointed.

Autieangel · 23/08/2023 08:06

I wouldn't. A good friend wouldn't ask (unless it was a life/death emergency)

It reads like he orchestrated this. Once you lend the money your friendship dynamic will change. How will you feel if he takes out a expensive car loan or goes on a flash holiday while owning you money? And if he doesn't pay it back? You lose your money and a friend.

I do not see this ending well for you. I'd be interested to see how nice he is if you say no.

FedUpMumof10YO · 23/08/2023 08:04

Nah. I wouldn't.

You should never lend what you can't afford to lose.

WeirdBarbie · 23/08/2023 08:03

Honestly OP, I think even if you feel comfortable with this the dynamic of your friendship will likely change. It's really lovely of you, but probably isn't good for either of you long-term.

I'd refer him to debt services others have mentioned and - if you're feeling generous - gift him a chunk for short-term relief so he can breathe.

Even if you are okay to lose the money, if you did lose it you would inevitably lose the friendship too.

It's really not a good plan, though very lovely of you to consider it.

ringsaglitter · 23/08/2023 08:03

Never mix money with friends / family

Winter2020 · 23/08/2023 08:01

The quickest way to lose both your friend and the money will be to lend it.

Unless you are a debt councillor/experienced financial whizz you will have no idea if lending him this money is the best way to sort out his finances and I'm guessing it's not.

Let's say it's 20k he wants. To get it back in just over 4 years he will have to pay you £400 each month. Now there are many many reasons he might not be able yo pay you £400 a month... can't afford to from the offset, high rent, job loss, gets married, goes on holiday, has child, starts new business, simply doesn't choose to.

If he has a low income and his creditors (or you if you are his crefitor) took him to court the Court will only order him to pay what he can afford even if that is £5 each week.

If you are a good friend don't encourage him to set up a debt repayment method that could be completely unaffordable. If he is in problem debt he needs to speak to Stepchange or Christians Against Poverty and set up an affordable repayment plan. If his debts are unaffordable they may be able to get the interest frozen and if all he can afford is £10 a week then that is all he will be asked to pay.

Don't be guarantor on any loan for all the same reasons. If his finances are dire and yours are sound it is you who will be chased.

Offer to help him get all his info together and phone Christians Against Poverty or Stepchange (free to use debt charities). He should not use a company that you have to pay a fee to as that fee could be going off his debts.

Beware I have heard that firms can imitate the charities so make sure you are dealing with the legitimate websites and phonelines.

As a friend you would be much better to take around a takeaway and offer a listening ear while he is in the thick of paying off debt. If you still want to be friends in 4 years don't be his lender.

LizzieSiddal · 23/08/2023 07:59

Unless you can 100% honestly say “if I don’t get it back, I don’t care” then do not do it.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 23/08/2023 07:59

In the nicest way - don't be an idiot.

usedtobeasizeten · 23/08/2023 07:58

No. 1,000,000 no.

Swipe left for the next trending thread