Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lend my friend money?

167 replies

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 07:16

Friend is in really bad debt. He’s overwhelmed with interest fees. He lost the money through an investment in his own business, that wasn’t successful.

I do quite well financially, although I don’t have as much saved as I should (expensive divorce).

We just got into a lighthearted conversation about whether I’d be able to lend him some money, interest free, to clear some of the debt, but during the conversation I realised I actually could.

I am completely against either borrowing or lending money but for some reason I feel unexpectedly comfortable with this.

He has never ever been anything but super reliable, money-wise. I let him use my card for a while when he lost his while travelling, and he paid me back every single penny via bank transfer, immediately after he’d made each payment.

It’s a vast amount of money though. A year’s salary for some people. I can afford to lose it but I certainly hope not to!

We would have legal docs drawn up, which would stipulate the terms. I already have the drafts and I’m pretty comfortable with them.

I’m trying to think it through properly before I go ahead as I don’t want to be an idiot.

Assuming he pays me back, the only thing I have to lose is the interest I’d make having it in the bank, but it’s not a big enough amount to concern me.

What am I not thinking of?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LizzieSiddal · 30/08/2023 19:31

So sorry I’ve posted on the wrong thread. Will ask MNHQ to remove.

LizzieSiddal · 30/08/2023 19:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Lobelia123 · 30/08/2023 13:50

I'm relieved for you, and think you really have made the right call. This had all the potential to blow up in your face/

WrylyAmused · 30/08/2023 09:33

mscrooge · 30/08/2023 08:30

thanks all for this advice. I decided not to proceed. Appreciate everyone’s input.

Haven't read the whole thread, sorry, but one thing you possibly could do is support friend to write to all creditors (esp. if they're banks/credit cards) to get them to freeze the interest.

They usually won't do it for more than 12mths at a time, but they do do it, and it can make a significant difference to the repayment time, particularly high interest things like credit cards.

Debt charities will do the same kind of letters, so he could also go that route, but you can just write to them directly, and there are tons of template type letters online he could use.

Ladyj84 · 30/08/2023 08:51

Haven't you ever watched judge rinder never ever lend to a friend they will then either want more or you end up in a very bad situation between yous and don't get your money back. Stupidest thing I've ever heard. I wouldn't even give my bank card to a friend!

QuillBill · 30/08/2023 08:31

Good. I think you made the right decision.

mscrooge · 30/08/2023 08:30

thanks all for this advice. I decided not to proceed. Appreciate everyone’s input.

OP posts:
Notamushroomwearer · 23/08/2023 16:47

Ilovethewild · 23/08/2023 07:41

Op, if he is overwhelmed with interest fees, he has not sought help with his debts, except from someone else to pay them, the ultimate opt out.

he needs to seek debt advice as they can help reduce fees, manage payments etc. step change or other debt advice is the best option or he contacts his lenders direct and agrees better repayments.

if he is working he can make payments, it may take time but that is how debt is managed.

if in debt, ANY extra money to pay it off is helpful, but you paying it off won’t be good for his debt management learning. And you will lose both him and your money, even if you have it written up, it is just another unsecured debt that he has learnt not to pay.

from someone who has spent years paying off CC debts…

Totally this.
Don't be an enabler
He needs to go through the correct channels to learn money management.
Him asking you is a red flag that he hasnt learnt tbh

WhereTheTeapotsJibberJabberJoo · 23/08/2023 16:20

Don't loan money to friends, it's a sure fire way to ruin friendships. I've seen it happen too often. Give the money or don't give, but don't lend.

OhComeOnFFS · 23/08/2023 15:55

Op, you can get help with plotting if you google 'creative writing' on Amazon.

mumda · 23/08/2023 15:54

No.
It'll change your friendship and even if you don't expect it back, he's bad with money and it won't help him.
Get him debt advice if that's what he needs.

Flipflipmania · 23/08/2023 15:37

velvetandsatin · 23/08/2023 14:16

So, it's a "vast amount" but at the same time it's "two weeks' salary" for you, and somehow this fact eluded you until some time into this thread, and yet at the same time, even though it's only two weeks' salary, you say you're"actually getting legal advice on how I incorporate my right to ask for immediate full repayment, in such an event".

This

it’s a bit… holey isn’t it

caramacyears · 23/08/2023 15:33

You are not thinking of the effect it might have on your friendship if he is unable to repay the debt and the balance of power changes. You may begin to resent him which is not a factor in most 'friendships'.

Tiqtaq · 23/08/2023 15:25

Maybe watch a few episodes of Judge Rinder to be aware of any potential pitfalls.

velvetandsatin · 23/08/2023 14:16

So, it's a "vast amount" but at the same time it's "two weeks' salary" for you, and somehow this fact eluded you until some time into this thread, and yet at the same time, even though it's only two weeks' salary, you say you're"actually getting legal advice on how I incorporate my right to ask for immediate full repayment, in such an event".

Densol57 · 23/08/2023 13:58

Just lend him the money / you clearly want to
If its just two weeks salary its a drop in the ocean for you
No legal document in the world will save you if he doesnt have assets or goes bankrupt as he cannot “prefer” his creditors to pay you over other possibly higher ranking creditors

Ihadenough22 · 23/08/2023 13:48

Personally I would not lend him money. Instead I would encourage him to contact stepchange as they can give him help and advice. They may be able to chat to his creditor's and get the interest/additional charges stopped on his borrowings. They will work out a budget plan for him to help him get out of debt in X period of time.

The reality is that you have a good income but you had an expensive divorce. You need to keep what ever savings you have as you don't know what will happen in your future. Also if you invest your savings long term it benefits you more.

I saw what giving money to a friend did to a friend of mine.

A few years ago one of my friends won some money. They gave a friend £1500 of this and bought them on a cheap holiday. The friend was going through a hard time back then.
A few years later the same friend came into money. They never said anything to my friend but suddenly were driving a far better car that was 9 years younger than their previous car.
They never offered my friend as much as a £ 100.

My friend also give them advice and they have refused to listen to it. The friend that got help from my friend now spends hardly any time with my friend and always has an excuse when my friend tries to meet them. My friend has had enough and I know they will be having it out with this friend soon.
My friend told me that they were sorry for helping out this person in the past and that doing this won't make a friendships better. The person you help will just take you for granted and down the line there is a good chance they will let you down.

My friend has put a lot of work into improving their own life and learning to say no more since this happened. My friend told me I have to consider my own life and I am doing things now that will benefit me long term. It not been selfish but its having boundaries in place.

Ihadenough22 · 23/08/2023 13:48

Personally I would not lend him money. Instead I would encourage him to contact stepchange as they can give him help and advice. They may be able to chat to his creditor's and get the interest/additional charges stopped on his borrowings. They will work out a budget plan for him to help him get out of debt in X period of time.

The reality is that you have a good income but you had an expensive divorce. You need to keep what ever savings you have as you don't know what will happen in your future. Also if you invest your savings long term it benefits you more.

I saw what giving money to a friend did to a friend of mine.

A few years ago one of my friends won some money. They gave a friend £1500 of this and bought them on a cheap holiday. The friend was going through a hard time back then.
A few years later the same friend came into money. They never said anything to my friend but suddenly were driving a far better car that was 9 years younger than their previous car.
They never offered my friend as much as a £ 100.

My friend also give them advice and they have refused to listen to it. The friend that got help from my friend now spends hardly any time with my friend and always has an excuse when my friend tries to meet them. My friend has had enough and I know they will be having it out with this friend soon.
My friend told me that they were sorry for helping out this person in the past and that doing this won't make a friendships better. The person you help will just take you for granted and down the line there is a good chance they will let you down.

My friend has put a lot of work into improving their own life and learning to say no more since this happened. My friend told me I have to consider my own life and I am doing things now that will benefit me long term. It not been selfish but its having boundaries in place.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 23/08/2023 12:45

The only time I felt moved to offer was a friend who needed to divorce her arse of a husband. But I Gifted it, not lent cos that way it never impacted our friendship which I valued. And I was absolutely clear that it was a gift.

SnakesandKnives · 23/08/2023 12:15

I’ve lent several people money over the years with the view that I could afford to lose it if they didn’t pay me - basically taken the Judge Judy recommended approach.

all have paid me back and it’s not been awkward with anyone.

i think it totally depends on the people involved. I have several friends I definitely wouldn’t do this with as well!

i think I’d be quite sad if I didn’t trust close friends (close enough for this convo to come up) enough to help them when I easily could and not really suffer if it went wrong.

all that said, many more people have bad experiences of lending friends money than good ones it would seem from this thread…..

tryanotherone123 · 23/08/2023 12:12

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 12:01

Correct, yes.

It still feels a large £ amount to give someone though. I haven’t always been a high earner so it feels vast. My brain never really caught up to my earnings. 5 years ago I was earning an average salary. I hadn’t considered it was two weeks’ salary until a PP asked.

If you can earn the money you are planning to lend in 2 weeks I don't see why you don't just five it as a gift and stop all this other nonsense. You really don't need to understand anymore than you do, the risk to you is almost negligeable and there really is no conceivable reason why you would need to ask for it back in an emergency or otherwise.

I gave a friend £1800 because covid hit them financially no questions asked. That's a months salary for me and took me a good while to save. I think you can manage the a gift. You'll feel better for it and your friend won't be beholden to you.

mscrooge · 23/08/2023 12:01

InsectBiscuits · 23/08/2023 11:51

2 weeks post tax salary?? So you'd only have to work 2 weeks to gain the same amount of money in your bank account?

Correct, yes.

It still feels a large £ amount to give someone though. I haven’t always been a high earner so it feels vast. My brain never really caught up to my earnings. 5 years ago I was earning an average salary. I hadn’t considered it was two weeks’ salary until a PP asked.

OP posts:
ChristmasFluff · 23/08/2023 11:51

Yeah, I have given friends and family money many times. I NEVER lend money.

If someone wants to return my money when they are back on their feet, it's a happy bonus, and some have. But I always make it clear it is a gift.

This is by far the best way to do it, as it really focusses the mind on whether you can truly afford to lose the money - because how are you realistically going to get it back if he defaults? You'd have to pay to enforce the contract, (plus pay to set one up in the first place), and it could well be throwing good money after bad.

IMO, if you can't afford to give it as a gift, you can't afford to lend it either.

InsectBiscuits · 23/08/2023 11:51

2 weeks post tax salary?? So you'd only have to work 2 weeks to gain the same amount of money in your bank account?

Zoreos · 23/08/2023 11:47

Your friend needs to speak with an Insolvency practitioner as a matter of urgency if he’s struggling to stay on top of his interest and repayments. There are multiple avenues that a person can go down and lots of charities that can help direct him to the right place in his situation. That would be the most kind thing you can do as a friend . Lending him money may not fix the problem but it could exacerbate it if in reality he’s actually not all that financially reliable/stable. At this point being sensible the best thing you can do is reassure, encourage and support emotionally to legally take steps to sort this out. As others have said never a lender or borrower be although it’s really admirable you’d go to such lengths for a friend.