Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know about DH's savings before marriage?

219 replies

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:08

As the title says really. We have been married 2 years and have just welcomed our first baby and also just bought our first house together (it's been intense!). My question arises after thinking a new kitchen would be too expensive (£10k altogether) but DH went ahead and did to which I felt really happy but also a bit guilty thinking it was too expensive. And then DH wanted to sort out the driveway and front and back garden for which we received a quote of £30k. We both thought it was expensive and I said I didn't think it made economical sense as I really thought it would be totally diminishing all the savings. The following evening DH came home from work and said the builders would start on the driveway the following day. I was really worried as I thought we couldn't possibly afford it. DH says we could afford it and I said that I thought we had a budget of £50k for renovations etc. He said we do but he's happy to dip into his savings. I thought the deposit for the house plus renovations was X but turns out DH had another £200k saved. AIBU to want to have known about it? I've been really stressed with how much we've been spending on renovating plus the fact that I'm on mat leave with SMP and trying to figure out how to organise things about going back to work. I said to DH I would like to know the full picture with all the savings he has. AIBU?

OP posts:
Parker231 · 22/08/2023 21:31

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 22/08/2023 21:16

I also think £90 for bedding is insane and I wonder if you’re a bit of a waster of money which is why he doesn’t tell you the full amount.

£90 is not insane for good quality bedding.

nobodysdaughternow · 22/08/2023 21:24

OP I think you need to see the paperwork which evidences the £200k savings.

Hopefully it's all ok but he could be taking out loans in your name or hiding something. Why doesn't he want his name on your deeds? My worry would be he already owns a property and wants to keep that from you in case of divorce.

Just make sure you have full disclosure and do not take his word as gospel.

DrManhattan · 22/08/2023 21:23

@JudgeJ £200k running away money! That's a long way to go.

Why would anyone marry someone they are not on the same page as when it comes to finances. Setting yourself up for disaster.

JudgeJ · 22/08/2023 21:21

Now you are married, he will have an entitlement to the property

As he contributed to the purchase with the deposit it's only fair he has an entitlement, women usually claim an entitlement even if they've contributed nothing!
In the MN lexicon is his £200,000 being kept as his running away money, the same as woemn are encouraged to conceal???

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 22/08/2023 21:19

EarringsandLipstick · 22/08/2023 21:13

I wouldn’t tell my partner how much my savings were. I only have less than £200 but it’s in my savings account as it’s for absolute emergencies and I wouldn’t count it as joint income unless an emergency came up.

Kindly, there's a major difference between £200 & £200k, in terms of disclosure!

I would definitely be keeping quiet about £200k though!

If someone said they had £200k in another account the other person may feel the need to spend it on unnecessary things and so I would definitely keep it quiet if I had that much.

I think your income should absolutely not be private and your partner should know what you earn but I think what you choose to put away in savings is up to you and your DH doesn’t need to know.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 22/08/2023 21:16

I also think £90 for bedding is insane and I wonder if you’re a bit of a waster of money which is why he doesn’t tell you the full amount.

Stef8 · 22/08/2023 21:15

If his take home is that much, he could pay it in a matter of months, regardless of savings. Also, it’s obviously easy to have a lot of savings when you earn that much. Yes, providing you don’t have a mortgage beyond your means. My husband can build his in a few months if he puts a little bit of effort in with not spending so much. Don’t think you really need to know about savings and I also think it’s a bit of a non-story for high earners to have savings which are relative to their earnings.

jazzyfips · 22/08/2023 21:14

You've been married for 2 years and not had a conversation about finances?

FrontEnd · 22/08/2023 21:13

How much deposit did he put into the house, if you don't mind me asking, OP?
Big difference between 25K and 250K (for example)

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 21:13

I think he should have told you. That said , if you came on here saying you had 200k savings and your potential DH only had 10k. That you were putting down a deposit but the mortgage was solely based on DH earnings and in his name, then you would be advised not to get married because it wouldn't be in your best interest.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/08/2023 21:13

I wouldn’t tell my partner how much my savings were. I only have less than £200 but it’s in my savings account as it’s for absolute emergencies and I wouldn’t count it as joint income unless an emergency came up.

Kindly, there's a major difference between £200 & £200k, in terms of disclosure!

EarringsandLipstick · 22/08/2023 21:11

I spent all my savings on our wedding

Oh God. On a £2k salary, he was ok with you spending all your savings on the wedding, while he had an untouched £200k.

That he never declared when the house was being purchased.

What a complete mess.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 22/08/2023 21:11

I think YABU

I wouldn’t tell my partner how much my savings were. I only have less than £200 but it’s in my savings account as it’s for absolute emergencies and I wouldn’t count it as joint income unless an emergency came up.

It would perhaps be different if you were both skint and couldn’t afford your rent but I think savings should be separate and only a percentage of each income should be joint.

I would never fully have all joint money with a DH as anything could happen.

And I’m quite surprised at the responses on here as I’ve read countless times how important it is to have your own money and almost have a secret egg that you can use if you ever need to.

pamplemoussemousse · 22/08/2023 21:11

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:24

Anyway, I feel like I have an answer with most people saying I am not being unreasonable. DH said he is trying to reconcile with the fact that I should have access to something he's spent his whole life saving but would like to be OK with it. I felt bad about that and hence made the thread.

So he didn't put any of this 200k towards a deposit that would have meant your borrowing could go so much further?

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 22/08/2023 21:09

So all the debt is in your name and all the savings are in his?

But by marraige, he is entitled to half the house if you split or all if you pass away but if you the reverse happens, you already have the house but how can you claim on savings that are presumably hidden away or pledge to someone else in a will?

I know I have adjusted for your child's share but you know what I mean?

If I were you, I would be asking suggesting going seeing a financial advisor on the basis that you are now parents and want to ensure life cover, pensions, inheritance are set up correctly if in event something happens on of you & thst you organise your wills etc.

Something doesn't sound right shout this.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/08/2023 21:08

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 22/08/2023 21:07

This is the strangest thing I’ve heard on here in a while! If my husband and father of my child dropped into conversation he had 200K in a secret bank account that he had NEVER mentioned in the years we had been together my jaw would drop to the floor and I would be fuming. How can you agree to marry someone and be with them forever and not tell them that (I’m not sure how long you’ve been together or how old you are, that prob does make a difference here).

It takes a LONG time to save 200k. I mean, even for high earners, years, presumably he’s had to pay rent to live somewhere and pay bills etc whilst saving this huge amount of money. He’ll be making a decent amount on interest alone from that. If he’s on an income of 7k a month he’s clearly a high earner and has been for a while.

It seems so odd that he’s prob had a high paying job for years, he had this huge secret savings pot and then just because he’s unemployed for a short amount of time (in between his very high paid jobs) you have to take out a mortgage on your own on your much lower salary for a house that is probably nowhere near what you wanted..

Pretty much cross-posted with all of this!

EarringsandLipstick · 22/08/2023 21:08

Last year we found this house but DH was unemployed at the time and we could only get a mortgage on my salary (which meant I could borrow very little)

This makes no sense.

You would have had to declare (or rather, should have, as a joint purchase) your savings.

It's not true that him being unemployed meant that he could not go on the mortgage - he had £200k in savings! Yes, it would still have affected your mortgage offer, but differently.

What house was it possible to get on £2k a month only salary? Now you are married, he will have an entitlement to the property.

The whole thing sounds a mess. I can't imagine how he had such significant savings, and kept this hidden. I also can't understand accumulating that much money on even a well-paying job, without something like profit share or exceptional bonuses.

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 22/08/2023 21:07

This is the strangest thing I’ve heard on here in a while! If my husband and father of my child dropped into conversation he had 200K in a secret bank account that he had NEVER mentioned in the years we had been together my jaw would drop to the floor and I would be fuming. How can you agree to marry someone and be with them forever and not tell them that (I’m not sure how long you’ve been together or how old you are, that prob does make a difference here).

It takes a LONG time to save 200k. I mean, even for high earners, years, presumably he’s had to pay rent to live somewhere and pay bills etc whilst saving this huge amount of money. He’ll be making a decent amount on interest alone from that. If he’s on an income of 7k a month he’s clearly a high earner and has been for a while.

It seems so odd that he’s prob had a high paying job for years, he had this huge secret savings pot and then just because he’s unemployed for a short amount of time (in between his very high paid jobs) you have to take out a mortgage on your own on your much lower salary for a house that is probably nowhere near what you wanted..

Parker231 · 22/08/2023 20:59

Very odd him not being on the house deeds. DH inherited our forever home in central London before we were married. We discussed finances when we got engaged - who had what salary, savings, the inheritance etc. When we got married DH added me to the house deeds and we put our savings and salaries into a joint account.

Waterlillyflower · 22/08/2023 20:57

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:56

He is a very good saver and not a spender at all

There you go.

He knows you will both want a forever home one day.

So just invest wisely now.

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:56

Waterlillyflower · 22/08/2023 20:53

He has told you know.
He may have just being careful because he was in a temp role.

Just have a chat now and you are bothnon the same page.

I dont agree he is hiding other stuff and red flags bla bla.

He earns more than you and if he was kot spending it obvs he is saving.

He is a very good saver and not a spender at all

OP posts:
Waterlillyflower · 22/08/2023 20:55

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:54

I haven't seen evidence but I have asked to see it.
He was at a reputable company that was being restructured and prior to that at another well known company so I didn't think his income was shady. DH would one day like us to have our forever home but I think he didn't want to spend everything on the house deposit because the repayments were going to be made by him from his savings while he didn't yet have a job. I hope that make sense.

Makes sense. Sounds very sensible.

Good luck to you both.

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:54

Spacecowboys · 22/08/2023 20:49

You can get a joint mortgage when only one person is working. Does that mean the house is only in your name too, or is dh on the deeds - where the mortgage company happy for this to happen if he is? I’m usually in favour of separate finances when both parties are happy but there’s a few red flags here I think.

The house is only in my name, DH isn't on the deeds.

OP posts:
EntreMummy · 22/08/2023 20:54

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:49

This is a genuine question in case tone come across wrong.

How is having a credit card any different from a joint account. DH can see what I spend either way if that's what you meant by controlling, no?

The credit card thing is controlling because it’s like him setting you a maximum amount of spending money. You aren’t getting full view of the accounts and full financial picture that way.

which is v different than two adults with shared financial responsibility and decision making having full access to all monies in a joint account.

Jinnywix · 22/08/2023 20:54

RoyKentsTieDyeTop · 22/08/2023 20:49

Have you actually seen evidence of his savings?

Insecure employment, not on the mortgage (didn’t want to go through the checks?) sudden big purchases. Shady shady.

It is absolute madness that he wouldn’t use some of his alleged savings for the deposit. Aren’t you a bit disgusted that you are in a budget house on an apparently luxury income if true? And unable to spend £90 on bedding (mine costs at least twice that btw, good bedding is worth spending on).

I haven't seen evidence but I have asked to see it.
He was at a reputable company that was being restructured and prior to that at another well known company so I didn't think his income was shady. DH would one day like us to have our forever home but I think he didn't want to spend everything on the house deposit because the repayments were going to be made by him from his savings while he didn't yet have a job. I hope that make sense.

OP posts: