Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult Children

116 replies

RaquelCC · 22/08/2023 18:54

I wish someone would invent a word for them. My daughter is currently 'ghosting' me. Despite my best efforts she is refusing to communicate with me and I really can't see it changing for the foreseeable future. There have been attachment issues since she was a little girl. My dilemma is as it's her 35th birthday in a few weeks time do I carry on as normal and send a card and gift or just a card or a card and token gesture small gift like a smelly candle. Would appreciate your advice please.

OP posts:
Bunnyhair · 22/08/2023 21:17

@girlfriend44 and when their estranged relatives die, yes, their feelings are very mixed, but the prevailing sense is one of relief from the shame and terror and trappedness they felt when the relative was alive.

Bunnyhair · 22/08/2023 21:14

@girlfriend44 I work with people who have become estranged from their parents and it is never a decision anyone enters into lightly. Most times there’s been physical / sexual /
severe psychological abuse, neglect, addiction, religious extremism. Compulsive lying, involving children in things they shouldn’t be involved in, using children as weapons against other family members. Inciting children to abuse one another.

I’ve never seen anyone just estrange themselves on a whim.

girlfriend44 · 22/08/2023 21:08

TammyJones · 22/08/2023 19:30

I know many mums in this position.
In a couple of cases I know the daughters too.
In both cases the mums are saying the same thing- 'I just don't know what I've done wrong'
If you talk to the daughters they can give you, a very justifiable, laundry list, of all the things they done wrong lol.
It completely mystifies me how these 2 mother lack such simple self awareness.
Maybe that's the entire problem.

Do daughters ever do anything wrong?

No one is perfect.

People are quick to estranged today.

How would they feel.if their mums died?

MachineBee · 22/08/2023 21:08

I would send a card with simple message and gift. And then just send the occasional text without any expectation of a reply, nothing passive aggressive, with a simple ‘thinking of you, hope you’re well’.

A couple of my DHs adult DCs suddenly decided to stop contacting him. This was after an emotional family funeral and a lot of hurtful accusations were flung at him that took him completely by surprise and he just didn’t know how to respond. I encouraged him to keep sending simple texts every few weeks, occasional voicemails and simple birthday and Xmas presents (usually something homemade). The intention was to demonstrate that he hadn’t given up on them.

After a couple of years there was the occasional text reply and now they even call him to wish him happy birthday or Christmas. It’s not perfect but it is improving slowly. Hopefully this will continue and they will establish more regular contact. He also hopes that one day he’ll be able to have a conversation about where he went wrong. He hasn’t asked them as he thinks it should be something to address on his DCs terms and timescale.

caramacyears · 22/08/2023 21:05

Kidult is the best word I've come across

CleverLilViper · 22/08/2023 21:05

From what you have said, there's been a historical issue that has happened and you want to find a way to move forward that doesn't involve going over old ground.

Perhaps-as others have said, you need to go over the old ground for her sake and acknowledge how she feels and work through it with her? Just because you're ready to move forward doesn't mean that she is.

Typically, I don't think adult children simply go low or no contact with their parents out of the blue or for no good reason. Possibly sometimes, but rarely. So, I think you need to think about and be open to discussing with her the reasons why on her terms.

As for her birthday-I think the worst thing you can do is not acknowledge it with a card. I think that would suggest to her that you don't care about her enough to even send a card.

I'd send a card, wishing her a happy birthday and let her know you're thinking of her, but don't put any pressure on her. I wouldn't get a gift for her as it could backfire. A card will do and let her know you're thinking of her.

Anyport · 22/08/2023 21:02

Just send a card.

redskytwonight · 22/08/2023 20:58

RaquelCC · 22/08/2023 19:15

Least said soonest mended...

I am low contact with my parents. They don't want to go over things that have happened in the past they just want to move forward.

The trouble is we can only move forward by them acknowledging things that happened in the past and not brushing them under the carpet.

Sounds like OP may be in a similar conundrum.

redskytwonight · 22/08/2023 20:53

Unless she's asked for no contact, send her a card.

I personally wouldn't send a present. There is too much possibility you will get it horribly wrong and just end up annoying her further.

Anothernamethesamegame · 22/08/2023 20:48

op what is it about the birthday that makes you want to send something? What is your intention/end goal?

LocalHobo · 22/08/2023 20:45

Like previous ops, I know a couple of estranged adult children. They very much have reasons for no contact but, if those reasons are referred to when talking to the parents, they dismiss them as " not serious issues", "old ground that has been gone over endlessly" etc.
A card saying you apologise for any hurt she may feel seems appropriate.

MidFourtiesAlready · 22/08/2023 20:36

gullyhole · 22/08/2023 20:23

I went NC with my family last year. I got a gift for my last birthday, but I've moved house since then so she won't be able to send any more. I don't appreciate her cards and gifts as they are always unsuitable and really serves to underline the fact that she has never known me as a person at all. For me I want to break the contact and not ashame to acknowledge that she exists, because for me, she doesn't.

You have lost your daughter already. She doesn't want any more to do with you, and she doesn't want your cards or gifts. Leave her in peace.

:(

Gullyhole, I'm sorry to hear this :(

Can I ask what your mum did wrong? Mr DB went NC with my mum a few years ago and I fully fully understand his reasons.

However, on the flip.side, I have 2 DC and the thought of them cutting me off one day rips at my heart. I couldn't handle it. I adore them. I want to know how to make sure that never happens

💐

Aquamarine1029 · 22/08/2023 20:36

RaquelCC · 22/08/2023 19:27

It's an historical issue but she won't discuss it with me. I'm trying to find a way forward rather than go over old ground.

I'll bet my house it's not old ground for her. You saying that makes me wonder if you've been dismissive over things that have really, really wounded her. People don't tend to go NC with their mothers unless they feel that's their only option for peace and recovery.

Lurkylurks · 22/08/2023 20:30

A couple of people have mentioned this but it hasn't been answered yet as far as I can see - has she asked you not to contact her?

Workingmumchaos · 22/08/2023 20:28

I would send the card. Short sweet. Happy birthday. Wishing you health happiness etc. Love mum. And leave it at that.

Namechange62846 · 22/08/2023 20:27

Card and a bunch of flowers with a non committal message like "happy birthday, thinking of you, love Mum". Give with no expectations of contact or for any other reason than it's her birthday and go about your day.

Given the way you have posted in here in would suggest speaking to a therapist and airing all your angst out and find out the root of the problem. It may be an apology is needed from you, it may be an apology is too late and an acknowledgement from you of your part in all this may go a long way. By acknowledgement I mean "I screwed up here and I'm sorry" with not expectations back, not "I screwed up here, but you were a brat so I just reacted to it we all good now?".

gullyhole · 22/08/2023 20:23

I went NC with my family last year. I got a gift for my last birthday, but I've moved house since then so she won't be able to send any more. I don't appreciate her cards and gifts as they are always unsuitable and really serves to underline the fact that she has never known me as a person at all. For me I want to break the contact and not ashame to acknowledge that she exists, because for me, she doesn't.

You have lost your daughter already. She doesn't want any more to do with you, and she doesn't want your cards or gifts. Leave her in peace.

mondaytosunday · 22/08/2023 20:17

@Itsnotrightbutitsok if my mother sent me £10 (or the £20 mentioned upthread) when we were not communicating I'd take that as how much she valued our relationship! It's what you give a ten year old and a kids party, not a grown adult.
OP I'd send her a card with a simple message saying you are there when she wants to talk. A gift isnt required.

GardeningIdiot · 22/08/2023 20:17

I would love to have a conversation with her to try and put right what has obviously gone wrong.

Least said soonest mended...

These seem to contradict each other. Has she tried to talk to you before and been ignored/dismissed? And now won't put herself through that again? I'm guessing as you have explained so little.

LightSpeeds · 22/08/2023 20:12

Send her a card. Given the current situation, you're probably not going to be able to do anything right in her eyes, but not sending anything will give more reason for criticism.

TammyJones · 22/08/2023 20:09

@RaquelCC

May I ask if the daughters told the mothers this list though? I would love to have a conversation with her to try and put right what has obviously gone wrong. I can't if she won't communicate with me.

^^^^^
The first daughter ended up going to therapy. She'd been low contact for yeas anyway.
I think one of the things was her dm told her lies, about her dad (parents we're divorced)
In the end any questions were never going ti be answered truthfully but there was a lot of emotional back mail going on.
Her dm was very defensive and would play the martyr when challenged directly.
During therapy she realised, for her own sanity she would have to go no contact.
She's been no contact 4 years now.

The other daughter in her late 40's is still actually very, very low contact and getting lower.
One thing she has asked is that her mum not ring her after a certain time as she works.
Her mum completely takes no notice and rings up very late ( with random rubbish) - constantly..
and if dd try to put in boundaries- tears.
These relationships and not healthy and it's very sad to see , but sometimes it is best just to walk away.
Both ladies (daughters ) are both from divorced patents , really intelligent, very lovely and have a ton of friends - funny but neither have had children, are divorced and both high flyers ....

SpaceRaiders · 22/08/2023 20:05

@Hopingforagreatescape that’s exactly what I read from ops response.

You will need to go over old ground with the support of a professional if you have any hope of repairing this relationship.

There must be something you’re not seeing that has upset your daughter to the extent she’s gone refused contact with you. Do you have any family that you can talk to about it? Often having an unrelated third party gives insight that may not immediately be apparent.

ABeesWings · 22/08/2023 20:04

Seashor · 22/08/2023 19:55

If you don’t make every effort that you can, you will loose her. There is no way she’ll find her way back to you. Don’t stop those texts, birthday presents, etc. My parents did and I never saw them again. I just felt that they weren’t bothered about me and their lack of contact proved me right.

Totally agree. Same for me.
Send her kindness and she might come back to you eventually.

webster1987 · 22/08/2023 20:03

I went no contact with my mum last year. I won't go into the details but it was after years of problems. Having my own child last year opened my eyes to it all as I can't ever imagine treating my DS how she has treated me. I blocked her so she was unable to contact me by phone and she lives far away to get to my house.

Despite me cutting contact, I have anticipated every year on my birthday and chrismtas that she might send a card. That she might recognise in said card why I'm hurt and why I've had to make that decision. For each of them, she hasn't sent anything. It hurts as it just confirms to me she never did care and will never see the harm she has done.

Although you've not given any context, I would send the card. But only if you are able to recognise potential mistakes you've made and apologise for them. A child doesn't generally cut contact with their parent without it being a last resort.

Blondewithredlips · 22/08/2023 19:59

RaquelCC · 22/08/2023 19:15

Least said soonest mended...

This