Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult Children

116 replies

RaquelCC · 22/08/2023 18:54

I wish someone would invent a word for them. My daughter is currently 'ghosting' me. Despite my best efforts she is refusing to communicate with me and I really can't see it changing for the foreseeable future. There have been attachment issues since she was a little girl. My dilemma is as it's her 35th birthday in a few weeks time do I carry on as normal and send a card and gift or just a card or a card and token gesture small gift like a smelly candle. Would appreciate your advice please.

OP posts:
GarlicGrace · 23/08/2023 04:23

the rapist still sends cards. Every birthday, every Christmas

God, that's grotesque. Like he's pulling the stitches in a wound he caused 😡

But - gently - it isn't the same as the absent/ignorant mother sending cards, is it?

GarlicGrace · 23/08/2023 04:17

In these sorts of situation or similar where there have been very good reasons for you perhaps not always being emotionally or physically there for her, I think you need to look at the situation from her perspective and actually think bout what it must have been like for her.

Nicely said, @anunlikelyseahorse. I forced my mother to discuss this, in detail, over several days. I was in therapy and fairly confident I could handle the confrontation as gently as she needed - though it wore me out! She was a kind & caring woman in an unkind marriage, unable to deal with the harsh realities of her family life. I knew this, of course.

I needed her to recognise the harm done to me. I didn't expect her to fix it - I was doing that, in therapy - or even to alter her deluded view of her marriage, as I knew she couldn't. I wanted her to properly hear me, not 'moaning' or blaming her, but telling her what I wish she could have done to protect us. And to be sorry for the damage I suffered.

We got there. The issue isn't 'resolved' like it would be in a film; the point is that it is aired and our understanding of our shared history is now an honest one.

If you leave things under the carpet, they build up dust & spiders!

ThinWomansBrain · 23/08/2023 04:01

I was no/low contact with my mother for most of my adult life.
She was always incredibly manipulative, but the main reason was that I believe she knew about sexual abuse when I was a child, and she remained close to the rapist. A conversation with her when we were talking confirmed this.
She is long dead, but the rapist still sends cards. Every birthday, every Christmas. Moonpig, so he hasn't physically touched them, but seeing them drop through the door makes my stomach churn, fifty years on. They never get opened after the first ones, and one year when Moonpig (I assume) mistakenly sent two.
Do not keep sending cards/gifts as if nothing had happened - "least said soonest mended" is not an appropriate attitude - unless by "least said" you mean dropping the fucking cards and stop spoiling her birthday.

Coyoacan · 23/08/2023 03:41

The automatic assumption by many people that the mother must be terribly at fault and the dd have valid reasons is bizarre.

We don't know these people and there is nothing in the little the mother has written to indicate that she is horrible.

Why does the order they came into the world mean that mothers are always baddies and daughters are always victims. If the daughter's daughter goes no contact with her, does that mean she is suddenly evil?

Ontheperiphery79 · 23/08/2023 01:48

@girlfriend44 when my Mother died, I was relieved and pleased a) because she could no longer cause any suffering and because b) death released her from her own suffering (alcoholism, addiction to pain medication and, at the very end, brain and lung cancer, I'm told).

Was I sad? Yes, for the Mum I never had; yes, for my sister, who saw her die. Did it make me happy? No. And, what do I feel now about her? Like she never really existed.

Hemax1 · 23/08/2023 01:47

For a bit of context I’ve been NC for some time with my mother. You’ve said that you don’t understand why your daughter might be ghosting you and communication has broken down.

For me it took a long time to come to terms that I couldn’t go on having a relationship. I wasn’t listened to, boundaries were trampled on and there was emotional and financial manipulation going on. Demands were constantly being placed on me regarding my time ( to spend more with her after she divorced my dad ) although it was incredibly difficult to spend time with her as I was walking on eggshells all the time.

It got too much, she wouldn’t listen to me trying to tell her about anything and it came to a head when she was challenged about a situation. None of it, predictably, was her fault and she’d taken decisions regarding aspects of my daughter future without consulting me. I cooled things rapidly to try and see if we could work through it later and decided not to after receiving a letter which was basically her calling me all sorts of things.

Only you can know what has happened in the past. The end situation brought about the NC with me but it really was a build up of a lot of things that weren’t right - but maybe some of the things I’ve detailed might give you an insight if you unpick your relationship from your side about what may have gone wrong between you. I’m certainly not a saint, but for me and my mental health, going NC was the right choice.

As for birthday / Christmas, the cards I receive go in the bin now, she isn’t really interested in making any changes to herself and they feel more about her than me as she’s still not acknowledging my boundaries. Any cash gets spent on my children.

Presents for my children are just another attempt to emotionally manipulate. She will only see my eldest ( older teen ) if she’s got something to hand over to me or the others. And as she’s off to uni soon stated to her that she’s lost her middle man and to tell me that if I wanted gifts for the little two I had to call her. ( on the flip side if she really wanted to gift things for her grandchildren she could make arrangements ). I’m not calling.

As others have said though it isn’t a decision taken lightly to stop contact with a family member, and if you do want contact to resume you will have to be patient and wait for her to come to you.

anunlikelyseahorse · 23/08/2023 01:35

Should you send a birthday card? Well that depends:
Do you know the reason why she is going no contact?
Do you think she's justified?
Did you do something which perhaps wasn't great, but you were struggling at the time yourself, (just a random example of what I mean; you were widowed when she was thirteen, you struggled to come to terms with being widowed, fell into depression and couldn't be there for her emotionally; she's now angry at you and feels you weren't meeting her needs having already lost a parent. Or perhaps you had been divorced, met someone fell in love and got married and your dd, suddenly finds herself thrown into a turmoil of emotions, and feels you put your own happiness ahead of hers. In these sorts of situation or similar where there have been very good reasons for you perhaps not always being emotionally or physically there for her, I think you need to look at the situation from her perspective and actually think bout what it must have been like for her.
If you feel something like the above happened then I think you should send a birthday card with an apology BUT DO NOT excuse your behaviour, because the minute you say "sorry but..." is the minute you've alienated her again. You need to apologise, because although you had good reason for doing X,Y and Z, she still feels you failed her as a mother, it doesn't matter if you had a reason, you needed to be there and you weren't, that what matters to her.

If you really, really genuinely don't know what you've done to upset her, then I don't think you should send a card.

Op my mil had a very strained relationship with her daughter. They were / are complicated characters. But from an outsider perspective, the first time I met MIL it was obvious that DH was her 'golden child'. Mil never saw it, vehemently denied it even, and yet to an outsider it was as clear as day.
MIL and SIL would also have 'competitive' Ill health competitions too, they both had / have health issues, SIL has to be very careful with her diet or she's extremely ill, MIL had rheumatoid arthritis so was in a lot of pain and discomfort, the arguing between them was something else.
I'm not saying this is your situation, and maybe your dd is currently pissed off at the world (for whatever reason) and taking it out on you, but if that's the case definitely do not send the card.
Anyway good luck to both of you, I hope it gets resolved.

determinedtomakethiswork · 23/08/2023 00:38

Adult children are ghosting their parents all over the place at the moment. On this board people are telling other people to go no contact and quite often the other person might be a bit irritating but hasn't really done much at all to warrant that.

I think I would send a card and write in it something like "hello, I've been thinking about you so much lately. I really hope you have a good birthday and spend some time with people you love. I am so sorry you feel that you can't talk to me at the moment, and I hope that sometime in the future you will feel that you can, whether that's face-to-face, with a counsellor or just in a message. I'm always thinking of you and I love you."

hopsalong · 22/08/2023 23:57

You're focussing on the wrong thing. Birthdays are trivial in themselves.

The important question is why she is ghosting you, when this pattern of rejecting behaviour started, and how you've reacted to it in the last. Ghosting a parent is a painful and very deliberate thing to do and your daughter wouldn't be doing it unless she found your behaviour not only profoundly hurtful but also incapable of alteration. What happened, and why do you think she's not willing to give you another chance?

fabmaccawhackyrhumbsaloft · 22/08/2023 23:25

Send a gift

Send Freddie's flowers or bloom and wild

Send a card . Keep
Trying , do t give up

caramacyears · 22/08/2023 23:23

lavendersbluedillydilly12 · 22/08/2023 23:17

I've just gone NC with my mum. I'm 37 and she is 65. I wish she'd fought for me. I went NC upon legal advice because one of my siblings made a malicious report to SS. It's acknowledged by the authorities that it was malicious but it was still scary! My mum seemed to think she couldn't take sides or something but she did in not speaking up for me. Anyway, I don't think I'll ever see her again now but she could have fought for our relationship. I would with my children :-)

I'd send a card!

That is sad. I'm sorry she didn't fight for you and I will take your advice

lavendersbluedillydilly12 · 22/08/2023 23:17

I've just gone NC with my mum. I'm 37 and she is 65. I wish she'd fought for me. I went NC upon legal advice because one of my siblings made a malicious report to SS. It's acknowledged by the authorities that it was malicious but it was still scary! My mum seemed to think she couldn't take sides or something but she did in not speaking up for me. Anyway, I don't think I'll ever see her again now but she could have fought for our relationship. I would with my children :-)

I'd send a card!

caramacyears · 22/08/2023 22:56

imho

caramacyears · 22/08/2023 22:55

Bunnyhair · 22/08/2023 21:14

@girlfriend44 I work with people who have become estranged from their parents and it is never a decision anyone enters into lightly. Most times there’s been physical / sexual /
severe psychological abuse, neglect, addiction, religious extremism. Compulsive lying, involving children in things they shouldn’t be involved in, using children as weapons against other family members. Inciting children to abuse one another.

I’ve never seen anyone just estrange themselves on a whim.

This is quite a severe take on a very common problem? Also one person doesn't 'estrange themselves'. It is usually a two way street where two or more people become estranged from eachother inho

CrazyFrogDingDing · 22/08/2023 22:41

Hbh17 · 22/08/2023 19:50

Agreed. That puts unbearable pressure on someone who wants minimal contact, and would probably kill any relationship forever.

I don't mean paragraphs of soppiness, I mean just something simple like...
Happy birthday daughter.
I love and miss you.
Love mum.

That kind of thing.

moveoverhogger · 22/08/2023 22:09

Please send her a card & gift, she will still want her mum to show she cares about her on her birthday.

Today is my birthday & I am in regular contact with my shit mother, I haven't received so much as a text from her. I can't even explain how hurtful it is to know my own mother doesn't care enough to wish me happy birthday 😔

whathappenedtosummer23 · 22/08/2023 22:04

girlfriend44 · 22/08/2023 21:08

Do daughters ever do anything wrong?

No one is perfect.

People are quick to estranged today.

How would they feel.if their mums died?

I am extremely low contact with my mother. I don’t like her, I think she’s selfish, self centred and always put herself first. I have zero interest in discussing it with her because I don’t care enough about her to bother improving the relationship. She has zero self awareness and thinks she’s mother of the century. I imagine when she dies I’ll just feel a weight off my shoulders

Stompythedinosaur · 22/08/2023 21:55

I cannot imagine a situation where I would give up on my relationship with my dc.

So I would send a card with a message like, "Thinking you on your birthday, love mum".

RaquelCC · 22/08/2023 21:48

Thank you all for your advice, I have read them all and appreciate the suggestions. I purposely didn't put a lot of detail for a number of reasons but trying to make sure that all is not lost. The 'least said soonest mended was a reference to the amount of content in my posts. Like I said it goes back to when she was a little girl and when she was in her twenties I did apologise for any mistakes that I had made which had affected and hurt her. I had a wonderful mother and they are our main role models aren't they? I felt sad when one or two members seem to think I have lost her for ever. I hope not. I have suggested for us to go for counselling - for her to choose a counsellor and I would pay but nothing came of it unfortunately. She hasn't asked me not to contact her, just doesn't reply to any of my messages. I feel that as she is an adult too then she should tell me what I have done which makes her want to have zero contact with me. I maybe hadn't explained myself very well, I would quite happy go over old ground and do whatever it takes for us to be in each others' lives again but have to be realistic and recognise that this may never happen now.
This paragraph really scared me
''Most times there’s been physical / sexual /
severe psychological abuse, neglect, addiction, religious extremism. Compulsive lying, involving children in things they shouldn’t be involved in, using children as weapons against other family members. Inciting children to abuse one another. '' and I hope hand on my heart that she does not feel that she/we have been involved in any of these practices.
I really do feel that I still can't do right for doing wrong but if I don't send a card or gift it's another nail in the coffin and I feel my daughter is much too precious not to carry on trying.
Thank you again for your pearls of wisdom, wish me luck!!

OP posts:
Escapetofrance · 22/08/2023 21:37

Don’t give up. Definitely send her a card/gift and apologise-even if you don’t know what you’ve done wrong, though I expect you may have an inkling.

TammyJones · 22/08/2023 21:34

@girlfriend44

Do daughters ever do anything wrong?

No one is perfect.

People are quick to estranged today.

How would they feel.if their mums died?

^^^^

I actually asked this once.
Answers varied from - sad - to nothing, to relieved,

I lost my mum in my very early twenties, and as a daughter I certainly made mistakes.

I agree people are quick to estrange

Though for others it takes years ...

And sometimes it is certainly for the best. Some people struggle so much with boundaries no contact is blessed relief.

You only have go on the stately home thread to see that.

Personally if I fell out with anyone- they'd know why.

Lurkylurks · 22/08/2023 21:27

Theborder · 22/08/2023 21:22

@Vergeofbreakdown23

That would piss me off even more tbh if I wasn’t speaking to my mum. It would feel like she was over riding my wishes and it would be feel quite manipulative.

I would feel this way too.

Theborder · 22/08/2023 21:22

@Vergeofbreakdown23

That would piss me off even more tbh if I wasn’t speaking to my mum. It would feel like she was over riding my wishes and it would be feel quite manipulative.

Vergeofbreakdown23 · 22/08/2023 21:21

Definitely send her a card x If you want to put a token gift in then so, but the most important thing is you send the card. If you don't it's another black mark against you ♥️

Theborder · 22/08/2023 21:20

Im your daughters age. It is rare to completely ghost. Even if your mothers a pain in the arse most people do still want contact. I am afraid you should do nothing and respect her decision. She clearly feels better currently having zero comms with you and I guess she has her reasons. Most adults really don’t want to cut contact with their mother without a very good reason.

Swipe left for the next trending thread