Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moral question for you all

482 replies

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 09:43

Imagine you go into a really nice small business selling either homewares or food. You pick something up that you really like, but it's the end of the month and you can't really afford it. What is the main reason that stops you from stealing it?

A.) Fear of getting caught, punished, criminal record, shame, losing your job
B.) Sympathy for the small business owner, not wanting them to lose money

Or something else.
For me it's massively more B but then I don't steal from chain stores, so I guess A must come into it then?
I just wonder where these moral decisions we make daily come from. Is it fear of repercussions or genuine moral compass? Why do a third of shoppers steal from self checkouts but wouldn't steal from a cashier at the till?
I think about the idea that if there wasn't law and order, then we would all steal and murder, but I genuinely believe that most of us wouldn't? I mean I've never felt compelled to, but why is that? Empathy?

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/08/2023 15:10

We can’t think why it’s wrong when the options don’t include the most obvious one!

Yes we can. Lots of people on the thread have done just that. Just like many other thread discussions develop well beyond the basic scenario set out in the OP.

ABeesWings · 22/08/2023 15:10

In answer to why I think it’s wrong - it’s wrong because it belongs to someone else. I wouldn’t take something that belongs to someone else. I suppose in OPs choices that means I would feel sorry for the business owner.

Brokendaughter · 22/08/2023 15:09

Why I think it is wrong is something to do with believing that I do not have the right to have things just because I might want them.

While it might be harder to think of a large company like Tescos working to have things available to sell, they do put in money/time/effort to get products to put on their shelves.

I believe that labour/enterprise/effort should be supported, so if a shop has made/grown/purchased an item (or a person in their own home), then they can choose to exchange it for cash & I can choose to take them up on their offer because we have chosen cash as our method of exchange.

For this to work, we both understand that they own the item until I give them the thing they are willing to exchange it for, when it becomes mine.

So, they won't take it back after I've paid for it & I won't take it from them if I haven't paid for it, and nobody else will take it from me (in a law abiding society where people don't steal).

Because we uphold this system, shops will take the time to source products that I might like/want/need to buy which I might struggle to get without them.
e.g. I could never get a banana if shops didn't import them as they don't grow in this country.
I can make shoes, but only if someone lets me get the tools & materials to make them out of & I have the space & time to do it.
I'd rather pay someone else to have the tooling, materials, knowledge & skills to make shoes for me.
While in theory I can make/grow what I would need to survive, I would prefer to have the option to purchase many things that require specialisations & use my time in other ways.

Without a society wide belief/contract that I can own things with little fear of them being taken from me, or that a shop can own things with the same security, nobody would risk having those goods or would have to guard them like every banana or pair of shoes was the Crown Jewels.

The ability to trade is an important social contract that supports a society where people can specialise (so we all get nicer bread/shoes instead of being at the mercy of how good a baker/cobbler we might or might not be) & ultimately lift up all citizens.
Scientists can spend time working out how to cure diseases or heat homes efficiently instead of making their own shoes.
Farmers can develop methods to increase yields & feed more people instead of trying to make tyres for their tractors etc...

I believe that some of being part of a successful society is based on following certain rules such as not stealing, which should lead to a better, safer society for all.
So it's a 'for the greater good of society' in general over what is good for me right now sort of reason, which overall is good for me as it creates a society that is safer & better for me to be part of.

Ughhh, that feels like really muddy thinking & I will probably end up spending a week thinking about this.

RiverDulas · 22/08/2023 15:06

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 14:42

The question is WHY do you think it's wrong. If I said 'I think being gay is wrong' you would very rightly ask 'why do you think that?' so that's what I'm asking MN.

“Why do I think it’s wrong?”

I think it’s wrong because you are taking something that doesn’t belong to you. Also, you are breaking ‘the rules’. The rules are that the shop is selling something, and if you want it, you need to pay money in exchange for said item. By stealing it, you are not conforming to the rules of the game.

ABeesWings · 22/08/2023 15:05

I wouldn’t steal just because I wouldn’t steal and it wouldn’t cross my mind to.
Im the sort of person that even if a shop was giving out free samples I would be checking if it was really free and looking for a charity box to at least put a £1 in.

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 15:04

@Rosscameasdoody well I'm working so I can only contribute minimally

OP posts:
MontyDonsBlueScarf · 22/08/2023 15:03

@pam290358 exactly.

pam290358 · 22/08/2023 14:59

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 22/08/2023 14:52

This neatly illustrates the point I was trying to make. Why you think it's wrong, and what stops you, are two entirely different questions.

If you want to know why I think it's wrong then that's what you need to ask. I would probably answer 'I just know it's wrong' and if you want to probe deeper, you'd have to ask 'how is it that you know that?'

I was just reading through your last post and about to ask a question, but I think I get it now - you’re tapping into their personal belief system by asking not why do you think that, but how do you know that ?

pam290358 · 22/08/2023 14:54

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 22/08/2023 14:45

OK I'll have another go... I think there are situations where 'it's wrong' may just be a social construct (like walking on the wrong side of the escalator) but I think there's another level of wrong-ness that unfortunately doesn't have its own word. For the wrong side of the escalator stuff I think that being caught/nobody being hurt may well be a factor in deciding whether to do it or not. But for the next level of wrong-ness, that doesn't come into it, at least for me.

NLP has a concept of internal/external reference, which is basically about whether you are internally programmed to make judgments based on your own opinions or on the feedback of others. An internally focussed person will just say 'it's wrong because I know it's wrong' and if pressed, may say it's misaligned with their beliefs, values etc. An externally focussed person is more likely to say 'it's wrong because society says so' and if pressed, may refer to laws, customs and consequences.

I tend to believe that we all have a preference for one approach or the other, though it's rare to find anyone who will always operate the same way regardless of the circumstances.

I think that may explain why so many are saying 'it's just wrong'. If you want to know why we think it's wrong, it's no good asking whether it comes from this or that consequence. It doesn't come from any consequence, it comes from an internalised set of values and beliefs. Where they come from is indeed an interesting question, but it's not the question that was asked.

Interesting. So in the scenario where society has no rules, we could only hope there were more internally focused folk around than externally focused ?

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 22/08/2023 14:52

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 14:43

The question is why you think it’s wrong. What stops you ?

This neatly illustrates the point I was trying to make. Why you think it's wrong, and what stops you, are two entirely different questions.

If you want to know why I think it's wrong then that's what you need to ask. I would probably answer 'I just know it's wrong' and if you want to probe deeper, you'd have to ask 'how is it that you know that?'

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 14:52

Someone being gay does not impact people outside of the couple themselves, either negatively or positively. Therefore I would struggle to see any reason why it could be 'wrong'.

(^ rephrased as it's not just about the impact on me, but the impact on all other people.)

TheHolyGrailSpeaks · 22/08/2023 14:51

TibetanTerrah · 22/08/2023 09:52

It just wouldn't occur to me that stealing was an option Confused

If I couldn't afford it, I'd just wait til payday or not have it. Those are the options...

Same. If I were in that position, I probably wouldn’t be in the posh food/homewares shop just before pay day anyway!

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 14:49

Similarly, the question of morality only comes into play for me when an action impacts someone else (even if the impact is indirect).

Someone being gay does not impact me, either negatively or positively. Therefore I would struggle to see any reason why it could be 'wrong'.

Historically, the argument for homosexuality being 'wrong' was a religious one. However, I don't base any of my ethics on what an imaginary deity might have decreed thousands of years ago. I view religion as a tool that's used to control people, not a force for good.

Jifmicroliquid · 22/08/2023 14:47

There’s no A or B for me. It simply isn’t even in my thoughts to steal something.
my first thought would be “I wish I could afford that. Maybe I will get it next month.” Then I’d put it back and walk away.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 14:46

For me the question of whether something is right or wrong depends heavily on whether I would like to be on the receiving end of the action.

Would I like someone to take something of mine without permission? No. Therefore how could it be okay to inflict that on someone else?

Would the intention/circumstances of the thief make a different to me if I was the victim? Yes - if someone had stolen my lunch (for example) and I found out it was because they were starving, I would feel very differently to if they'd stolen something they just wanted.

FatBurger · 22/08/2023 14:45

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 14:42

The question is WHY do you think it's wrong. If I said 'I think being gay is wrong' you would very rightly ask 'why do you think that?' so that's what I'm asking MN.

It's wrong because someone else's property is theirs until given to me. Whether it's given through and exchange of goods and money or given as a gift is immaterial.

I wouldn't like someone taking something which belongs to me and I treat people and businesses as I want to be treated.

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 14:45

Wakintoblueskies · 22/08/2023 14:33

Interesting. Nature versus nurture. I’ve always thought risk taking is a personality trait, and apparently there is evidence that this can be linked with chosen lifestyle and career.

This worries me far more than you can imagine.

Worries me too !1

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 22/08/2023 14:45

OK I'll have another go... I think there are situations where 'it's wrong' may just be a social construct (like walking on the wrong side of the escalator) but I think there's another level of wrong-ness that unfortunately doesn't have its own word. For the wrong side of the escalator stuff I think that being caught/nobody being hurt may well be a factor in deciding whether to do it or not. But for the next level of wrong-ness, that doesn't come into it, at least for me.

NLP has a concept of internal/external reference, which is basically about whether you are internally programmed to make judgments based on your own opinions or on the feedback of others. An internally focussed person will just say 'it's wrong because I know it's wrong' and if pressed, may say it's misaligned with their beliefs, values etc. An externally focussed person is more likely to say 'it's wrong because society says so' and if pressed, may refer to laws, customs and consequences.

I tend to believe that we all have a preference for one approach or the other, though it's rare to find anyone who will always operate the same way regardless of the circumstances.

I think that may explain why so many are saying 'it's just wrong'. If you want to know why we think it's wrong, it's no good asking whether it comes from this or that consequence. It doesn't come from any consequence, it comes from an internalised set of values and beliefs. Where they come from is indeed an interesting question, but it's not the question that was asked.

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 14:44

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 14:42

The question is WHY do you think it's wrong. If I said 'I think being gay is wrong' you would very rightly ask 'why do you think that?' so that's what I'm asking MN.

OP- genuine question. How well do you think you’re doing in your effort to spark philosophical debate ?

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 14:43

FatBurger · 22/08/2023 14:35

This.

It's not fear of the repercussions that stop me but the basic knowledge that it's wrong.

The question is why you think it’s wrong. What stops you ?

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 14:42

The question is WHY do you think it's wrong. If I said 'I think being gay is wrong' you would very rightly ask 'why do you think that?' so that's what I'm asking MN.

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 22/08/2023 14:40

StrawberrySquash · 22/08/2023 14:31

B matters to me, but it's also applicable to bigger businesses. Big businesses go bust too. Or they close down your local branch because it's not viable any more. Or they have to lock loads of stuff up, making shopping a worse experience. The world only works properly if there's a certain amount of trust and you can't keep on eroding it and not expect that to make things worse.

You only have to look at what’s going on in the USA. I think it’s Walmart who have closed down stores in the poorer areas of some states because the authorities are turning a blind eye to the blatant and brazen theft going on. People going in and grabbing as much stuff as they can, and just leaving. Those same communities are now saying that Walmart are wrong to have closed the stores because they’ve left people with nowhere to buy food.

lljkk · 22/08/2023 14:38

I don't steal it because I don't need it. I don't have to indulge random wants.

TotalOverhaul · 22/08/2023 14:36

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 14:23

Whether or not you have the desire to steal is irrelevant I think. Because that wouldn’t stop you from having an opinion on the moral issues involved.

I don't agree. What would stop me from stealing something I wanted but which was too expensive would be the lack of desire to steal. The desire isn't there. It's not a desire which is curbed by a) or b) from the OP's choices. So my answer would still be C) I have no desire to steal.

FatBurger · 22/08/2023 14:35

Icedlatteplease · 22/08/2023 09:47

C) it's just wrong, respect for other people and their property

I think your moral compass needs a reset

This.

It's not fear of the repercussions that stop me but the basic knowledge that it's wrong.