Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moral question for you all

482 replies

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 09:43

Imagine you go into a really nice small business selling either homewares or food. You pick something up that you really like, but it's the end of the month and you can't really afford it. What is the main reason that stops you from stealing it?

A.) Fear of getting caught, punished, criminal record, shame, losing your job
B.) Sympathy for the small business owner, not wanting them to lose money

Or something else.
For me it's massively more B but then I don't steal from chain stores, so I guess A must come into it then?
I just wonder where these moral decisions we make daily come from. Is it fear of repercussions or genuine moral compass? Why do a third of shoppers steal from self checkouts but wouldn't steal from a cashier at the till?
I think about the idea that if there wasn't law and order, then we would all steal and murder, but I genuinely believe that most of us wouldn't? I mean I've never felt compelled to, but why is that? Empathy?

OP posts:
TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 16:16

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:09

Yes totally agree. With the pandemic though I’d argue that I didn’t know enough about how the virus was transmitted to make up my own mind about what was the right thing to do - though even I could see that locking up playgrounds was totally unnecessary.

One example that always baffles me is all the stories I see about kids being sent home from school or put in isolation because they have bows on their socks or hair 1mm too short and all the comments go “quite right, rules are rules!”. If you question someone about how the bows on the socks actually impact anyone’s learning or behaviour or experience of school, they just say “it doesn’t matter, rules are rules”. I just can’t get my head around this (but apparently I am in a tiny minority!).

Totally agree about uniforms.

Saying "Pupils must wear grey trousers and a red jumper" is fair enough, that is similar to the requirements in many workplaces. But saying "pupils must have hair shorter than X, socks longer than Y, and shoes must be plain black but never patent leather or with bows on" is just control-freakery. Rules for the sake of it, which bear no relation to the conventions any adult has to live by.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:13

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist I mentioned utilitarianism but I realise it’s very flawed. After all according to utilitarianism it’s technically fine to kill one person so you can save several others with the use of their organs…

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 16:11

I think we are largely swayed by society. If everyone started stealing things in a certain situation, I believe a lot of people would. We generally think well if they're doing it then I will especially if we cannot see the person who the crime impacts, like during riots or using self service check outs

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:09

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 16:00

@ZebraDanios I agree. I'm always fascinated by people who just do or don't do things without questioning it. This was very evident during the pandemic.

Yes totally agree. With the pandemic though I’d argue that I didn’t know enough about how the virus was transmitted to make up my own mind about what was the right thing to do - though even I could see that locking up playgrounds was totally unnecessary.

One example that always baffles me is all the stories I see about kids being sent home from school or put in isolation because they have bows on their socks or hair 1mm too short and all the comments go “quite right, rules are rules!”. If you question someone about how the bows on the socks actually impact anyone’s learning or behaviour or experience of school, they just say “it doesn’t matter, rules are rules”. I just can’t get my head around this (but apparently I am in a tiny minority!).

BMW6 · 22/08/2023 16:05

All animals have societal rules. Ours have developed over thousands of years.

If there were no "rules" over ownership and not taking what doesn't belong to you we would be constantly physically fighting for food and possessions.

The strongest and most ruthless would thrive to the detriment of the old, ill, children. We wouldn't have Society, tribal cohesion, or even families.

To succeed as a species we HAD to work together. We HAD to develop hierarchy and societal rules that everyone understood and generally abided by. Those that don't were killed or cast out of the tribe.

So, Do Not Steal is deeply ingrained into our psyche.

WaitingPainting · 22/08/2023 16:05

Strange that you only have those two options. I wouldn't think to steal because stealing is wrong even if it's from Amazon. I would never steal and I judge people who do as scumbags!

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 16:04

I would prefer my own kids to do the right thing (or not do the wrong thing) because they understand the consequences it has for someone else rather than because they are following a series of what might otherwise seem like arbitrary rules.

I agree with this.

Because the law doesn't cover every moral question. Sometimes you will find yourself in a scenario where there are no rules to guide what you do, and the only way of deciding the right thing is by having an ethical code of some sort.

Someone upthread referred to utilitarianism - that's one method of determining what is 'right'. Kant's categorical imperative is another. My principle is to ask myself whether I would want to be on the receiving end of whatever action I am considering taking.

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 16:00

@ZebraDanios I agree. I'm always fascinated by people who just do or don't do things without questioning it. This was very evident during the pandemic.

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 15:58

Perhaps people who have turned out differently to their family are in a better position to answer?

It’s not quite answering your question but I don’t have a lot of time for the idea that “rules are rules” whereas my parents do. It used to drive me nuts when my parents would tell me not to do something “because I said so”, because I’d have liked an explanation of why it was wrong rather than be expected to obey unquestioningly. I would prefer my own kids to do the right thing (or not do the wrong thing) because they understand the consequences it has for someone else rather than because they are following a series of what might otherwise seem like arbitrary rules.

I wonder whether any of that made any sense…

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 15:57

@Wakintoblueskies well.. the law does.
And in the cases where the law doesn't apply the same punishment, there is outcry. For example, when that rapist in America was given a lenient sentence due to his blossoming swimming career... quite rightly, people were pissed off. The crime is the same. The impact is the same.

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 15:51

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 15:43

Or another scenario. Betty is a multi millionaire. Elsie is piss poor totally starving. Elsie scams Betty of a couple of hundred pounds. Not a victimless crime, but nobody has been hurt, Betty won't miss the money and Elsie will benefit enormously from the money. Acceptable or no?

Elsie’s fine by me. No-one needs several million pounds. From a utilitarian point of view I can’t see anything wrong with what Elsie’s done.

Q2C4 · 22/08/2023 15:50

Because I have no entitlement to it if I haven't paid for it. It belongs to the business and I respect property ownership.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 15:49

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist Similarly, the question of morality only comes into play for me when an action impacts someone else (even if the impact is indirect).

I’m with you on that. It’s one of those areas where I really struggle to understand the alternative viewpoint. I’m really surprised so many people here are saying “I know it’s wrong because that’s how I was brought up” or “I know it’s wrong because stealing is just wrong” or even as one poster pointed out because “thou shalt not steal” - isn’t it fairly obvious that stealing is wrong because someone is harmed by it?

Wakintoblueskies · 22/08/2023 15:48

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 15:47

We lump Winona Ryder and a woman who steals to feed her child in together as both committing the same act.

Who is this "we" you're referring to? Because I don't know anybody that would view both as the same.

Do you mean the act of stealing is the same? It is stealing.

However also don’t think anybody puts the two examples you have given in the same category?

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 15:47

We lump Winona Ryder and a woman who steals to feed her child in together as both committing the same act.

Who is this "we" you're referring to? Because I don't know anybody that would view both as the same.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 15:43

Or another scenario. Betty is a multi millionaire. Elsie is piss poor totally starving. Elsie scams Betty of a couple of hundred pounds. Not a victimless crime, but nobody has been hurt, Betty won't miss the money and Elsie will benefit enormously from the money. Acceptable or no?

Wakintoblueskies · 22/08/2023 15:39

And why it's so rigid.

It isn’t rigid as many people on this thread have said that stealing to survive is different to stealing for gratification.

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 15:35

I suppose I think that there are grey areas. It's not right or wrong, it's about context. Tax evasion is stealing to me. Underpaying workers is stealing. Claiming to work from home and doing household chores is stealing. Lying about your expenses is stealing. Companies who charge extortionate amounts for parking fines is stealing.
We lump Winona Ryder and a woman who steals to feed her child in together as both committing the same act. But it's not is it? One act was committed for a thrill or possibly self sabotage or a cry for jelp, the other was to survive.
I'm not condoning stealing but I do wonder where morality comes from. And why it's so rigid.

OP posts:
Wakintoblueskies · 22/08/2023 15:25

MrsMarzetti · 22/08/2023 15:24

Neither A or B, i don't steal because it is wrong. Simple as that.

I think the question has moved on to how do you know it’s wrong?

MrsMarzetti · 22/08/2023 15:24

Neither A or B, i don't steal because it is wrong. Simple as that.

KinellMate · 22/08/2023 15:23

If I was 100% sure I would get away with it I would steal. Getting caught, losing my job, people's opinion of me stop me from stealing, not the fact that it's wrong.

Wakintoblueskies · 22/08/2023 15:20

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 15:15

So let's take it a step further. If stealing because you are starving is acceptable, are there levels of food you should be stealing? A loaf of value bread and a tin of value beans would stave of hunger equally as well as a wagyu steak and an M&S salad. Is one ok and the other wrong.

No stealing from M&S or Tesco are irrelevant. It depends why a person was stealing. That is where my morals are seemingly flexible.

However… if an alcoholic steals a bottle of vodka because they have a disease and need alcohol, is it any different to a drug addict stealing someone’s phone in order to sell to buy drugs?

Maddy70 · 22/08/2023 15:20

I've never stolen anything in my life. It's just wrong , the value is being taken from someone so why would you do it ?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 15:15

So let's take it a step further. If stealing because you are starving is acceptable, are there levels of food you should be stealing? A loaf of value bread and a tin of value beans would stave of hunger equally as well as a wagyu steak and an M&S salad. Is one ok and the other wrong.

Wakintoblueskies · 22/08/2023 15:15

pam290358 · 22/08/2023 14:59

I was just reading through your last post and about to ask a question, but I think I get it now - you’re tapping into their personal belief system by asking not why do you think that, but how do you know that ?

How do I know it’s wrong?

Because it’s learned behaviour. Expectations (of not only my behaviour but respect) were learned at a very young age. These became second nature. From my parents viewpoint, they would also have learned right from wrong but they would have learned it from a Christian religion fear of repercussions from God.