Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moral question for you all

482 replies

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 09:43

Imagine you go into a really nice small business selling either homewares or food. You pick something up that you really like, but it's the end of the month and you can't really afford it. What is the main reason that stops you from stealing it?

A.) Fear of getting caught, punished, criminal record, shame, losing your job
B.) Sympathy for the small business owner, not wanting them to lose money

Or something else.
For me it's massively more B but then I don't steal from chain stores, so I guess A must come into it then?
I just wonder where these moral decisions we make daily come from. Is it fear of repercussions or genuine moral compass? Why do a third of shoppers steal from self checkouts but wouldn't steal from a cashier at the till?
I think about the idea that if there wasn't law and order, then we would all steal and murder, but I genuinely believe that most of us wouldn't? I mean I've never felt compelled to, but why is that? Empathy?

OP posts:
TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 17:20

Rules areindeed rules, and rules should be followed.

Said every Nazi concentration camp guard.

The important thing is to only make good, relevant rules in the first place.

But this is impossible to ensure.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 17:19

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 17:09

In an extreme example of utilitarianism I’ve just remembered that old thought experiment: there’s a burning building, your own child(ren) (real or imagined) is/are through one door, there are x number through the other door. You get to go through one door and save whoever’s on the other side but you can only choose one. How many children would x have to be before you would choose that door?

I remember asking it on a forum once before and the vast majority of people said “no number is big enough, I’d always save my own child” (which is totally understandable) but couldn’t see that that may be what they would do, but it wasn’t morally right - no one said “I’d choose my own child but I’d feel terrible about it”, it was just a total no-brainer, like there was nothing even to debate and nothing to think about. To me it’s interesting how our loyalty to our families actually makes us technically immoral - sacrificing thousands of children to save one can’t possibly ever be “right”, can it…?

That's evolution for you! Evolution rewards the lifeforms that do best at preserving their own genes in the next generation.

Similarly, evolution doesn't give a shit about the suffering of the runt of the litter, or the gazelle that can't run as fast as its mates.

Evolution (as a system) isn't immoral, but I'd say its amoral? Right or wrong, or quantities of suffering simply aren't relevant.

PinkiOcelot · 22/08/2023 17:16

Icedlatteplease · 22/08/2023 09:47

C) it's just wrong, respect for other people and their property

I think your moral compass needs a reset

This.

I’m not a thief full stop.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 22/08/2023 17:11

I think we would all like to think we are B. But a lot of people are A. I would not like to be around a lot of As.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 17:09

In an extreme example of utilitarianism I’ve just remembered that old thought experiment: there’s a burning building, your own child(ren) (real or imagined) is/are through one door, there are x number through the other door. You get to go through one door and save whoever’s on the other side but you can only choose one. How many children would x have to be before you would choose that door?

I remember asking it on a forum once before and the vast majority of people said “no number is big enough, I’d always save my own child” (which is totally understandable) but couldn’t see that that may be what they would do, but it wasn’t morally right - no one said “I’d choose my own child but I’d feel terrible about it”, it was just a total no-brainer, like there was nothing even to debate and nothing to think about. To me it’s interesting how our loyalty to our families actually makes us technically immoral - sacrificing thousands of children to save one can’t possibly ever be “right”, can it…?

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/08/2023 17:09

One example that always baffles me is all the stories I see about kids being sent home from school or put in isolation because they have bows on their socks or hair 1mm too short and all the comments go “quite right, rules are rules!”. If you question someone about how the bows on the socks actually impact anyone’s learning or behaviour or experience of school, they just say “it doesn’t matter, rules are rules”. I just can’t get my head around this (but apparently I am in a tiny minority!).

I'm not sure the socks example has anything much to do with right and wrong tbh. Obviously it's not morally wrong to have bows on your socks. Organisations have some rules which have nothing to do with moral rectitude and more to do with image and marketing. By all means send your child to school in socks with bows and feel righteous in encouraging them to flout a (silly and unnecessary) rule, but if your child doesn't obey the rules of the school to which you chose to send them, the school is within its rights to issue sanctions.

Rules are indeed rules, and rules should be followed. The important thing is to only make good, relevant rules in the first place. Fwiw I'm a teacher and I am not in favour of school uniform at all, never mind daft sock rules.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:58

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 22/08/2023 16:54

And what about:

it’s wrong because it would hurt (inconvenience, upset etc. <= depends on the severity) other people?

that seems like an external focus to me.

Yes this confuses me too. I don’t base my actions on some random internal feeling that I “just know”, nor (entirely) on what the law or society tells me - the important thing to me is potential or actual harm or benefit to others. So is that internal or external?

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 22/08/2023 16:54

pam290358 · 22/08/2023 14:54

Interesting. So in the scenario where society has no rules, we could only hope there were more internally focused folk around than externally focused ?

And what about:

it’s wrong because it would hurt (inconvenience, upset etc. <= depends on the severity) other people?

that seems like an external focus to me.

LightSpeeds · 22/08/2023 16:51

A moral code!

DelilahsHaven · 22/08/2023 16:50

This is a really interesting question. One of my DC has complex neurodevelopmental problems and, despite our best efforts to teach him right from wrong, steals frequently from us, friends and family. We are still looking at ways to teach him. He struggles with understanding cause/effect and rewards/consequences too, which makes parenting him extremely tricky.

I try to get him to talk through his decision processes after an incident, it must be totally different from mine and I dont understand.

The rest of us are very much in the category of it just wouldn't occur to us to steal, so it's not just about upbringing.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:40

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 16:32

But doesn't that explain exactly why we have rules. Presumably although it is acceptable to you and Elsie it probably isn't acceptable to Betty.

Elsie’s fine by me. No-one needs several million pounds. From a utilitarian point of view I can’t see anything wrong with what Elsie’s done.

And who decides how much is too much. Is it acceptable to have ? 1 million, 3 million, 5 million. Where is the line that makes having that much money acceptable to being a victim of a smallish scam?

Or is it ok to scam just a small amount. So a couple of hundred - all good, a couple of grand - wrong?

I wonder how Betty would feel about it if she knew the circumstances? If I was a multi-millionaire and some destitute person stole a few hundred quid from me I think I’d have a hard time justifying anger towards them.

For me, in the exact case you describe, no harm is done to Betty and that validates Elsie’s action. What I can’t do is work out exactly where the line is drawn where it crosses over into unacceptability. If I say that what Elsie’s doing is fine, how rich do I have to be before I am morally wrong for not donating significant amounts of my money to charity? It’s not quite the same argument but there’s a train of thought that leads that way.

(I asked my kids your original question - my 9 year old said Elsie was wrong and my 6 year old said she was right, interestingly…)

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 16:38

(Utilitarianism fully acknowledges that there will be negative impacts of the correct course of action, but views these as morally acceptable provided they are outweighed by the positive impacts.)

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 16:37

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 16:32

But doesn't that explain exactly why we have rules. Presumably although it is acceptable to you and Elsie it probably isn't acceptable to Betty.

Elsie’s fine by me. No-one needs several million pounds. From a utilitarian point of view I can’t see anything wrong with what Elsie’s done.

And who decides how much is too much. Is it acceptable to have ? 1 million, 3 million, 5 million. Where is the line that makes having that much money acceptable to being a victim of a smallish scam?

Or is it ok to scam just a small amount. So a couple of hundred - all good, a couple of grand - wrong?

From a utilitarian point of view, it's very easy to draw the line.

Provided the negative impact on Betty < the positive impact on Elsie, then it's 'right'.

If the amount stolen was sufficient that the negative impact on Betty > the positive impact on Elsie, it would be 'wrong'.

You'd have to work out a way to quantify the impact, but that's how utilitarianism works. I'm not a utilitarian, but it is a coherent ethos.

CheshireCat1 · 22/08/2023 16:33

It’s wrong.

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 16:32

OK then, change ‘something you really like’ to something you really need. What would be your decision then, and why ?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/08/2023 16:32

But doesn't that explain exactly why we have rules. Presumably although it is acceptable to you and Elsie it probably isn't acceptable to Betty.

Elsie’s fine by me. No-one needs several million pounds. From a utilitarian point of view I can’t see anything wrong with what Elsie’s done.

And who decides how much is too much. Is it acceptable to have ? 1 million, 3 million, 5 million. Where is the line that makes having that much money acceptable to being a victim of a smallish scam?

Or is it ok to scam just a small amount. So a couple of hundred - all good, a couple of grand - wrong?

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 16:28

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:25

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist Yes, that’s exactly it. If your aim is the greatest good for the greatest number then yes it is absolutely correct to stab someone to death in a hospital, take all their organs out, and save however many other people - in fact even if you only save two it’s still correct. But who would actually do that and feel okay about it…?!

Mr Spock ? The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, or the one !

easterfloral · 22/08/2023 16:28

Both A and B that you've listed @WhaleSharkBootySweat

Also, I think I'd only ever imagine stealing in desperation and starvation (children) and all other outlets exhausted. Though I still don't think it would ever come to that. Your example wasn't a necessary item but something 'you really like' so there's no good reason to steal something like that.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:27

MysteryBelle · 22/08/2023 16:25

C. It is wrong

Ethics 101

😂 people are messed up in the noggin.

Basic ethics: do not lie, cheat, or steal. Even if you think you can get away with it. Especially if you think you could get away with it. Your character is what you do when you think nobody’s looking.

Your “Ethics 101” class would be pretty short if it consisted entirely of the assertion that actions abc are right and xyz are wrong and that’s all there is to it…

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 16:27

MysteryBelle · 22/08/2023 16:25

C. It is wrong

Ethics 101

😂 people are messed up in the noggin.

Basic ethics: do not lie, cheat, or steal. Even if you think you can get away with it. Especially if you think you could get away with it. Your character is what you do when you think nobody’s looking.

The question is how do you know it’s wrong. What informs that opinion ?

MysteryBelle · 22/08/2023 16:25

C. It is wrong

Ethics 101

😂 people are messed up in the noggin.

Basic ethics: do not lie, cheat, or steal. Even if you think you can get away with it. Especially if you think you could get away with it. Your character is what you do when you think nobody’s looking.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:25

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist Yes, that’s exactly it. If your aim is the greatest good for the greatest number then yes it is absolutely correct to stab someone to death in a hospital, take all their organs out, and save however many other people - in fact even if you only save two it’s still correct. But who would actually do that and feel okay about it…?!

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 16:22

I'm not a utilitarian btw - but the argument in favour of pursuing the most good for the greatest number is a coherent one.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 16:21

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 16:13

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist I mentioned utilitarianism but I realise it’s very flawed. After all according to utilitarianism it’s technically fine to kill one person so you can save several others with the use of their organs…

But can anyone conclusively say that would be morally wrong? After all, the aim is to save 10 people by killing 1 person. Wars are fought on a similar basis - taking life to preserve life (in theory at least, in a just war).

There are plenty of philosophical arguments about why it is wrong, but following those arguments does result in the greater number of people dying due to lack of organs.

Rosscameasdoody · 22/08/2023 16:17

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 15:04

@Rosscameasdoody well I'm working so I can only contribute minimally

Sorry, I meant in terms of how well people understood the intention behind the questions you posed. There was some confusion to begin with but it’s turned into an interesting discussion I think. Some food for thought.

Swipe left for the next trending thread