Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moral question for you all

482 replies

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 09:43

Imagine you go into a really nice small business selling either homewares or food. You pick something up that you really like, but it's the end of the month and you can't really afford it. What is the main reason that stops you from stealing it?

A.) Fear of getting caught, punished, criminal record, shame, losing your job
B.) Sympathy for the small business owner, not wanting them to lose money

Or something else.
For me it's massively more B but then I don't steal from chain stores, so I guess A must come into it then?
I just wonder where these moral decisions we make daily come from. Is it fear of repercussions or genuine moral compass? Why do a third of shoppers steal from self checkouts but wouldn't steal from a cashier at the till?
I think about the idea that if there wasn't law and order, then we would all steal and murder, but I genuinely believe that most of us wouldn't? I mean I've never felt compelled to, but why is that? Empathy?

OP posts:
BadlydoneHelen · 22/08/2023 11:13

I put C:it's wrong right at the beginning of this thread. Coming back and reading the comments, I've thought about it some more and I suppose my full(er) answer would be
C: because I try to live my life according to the basic principle of 'do as you would be done by'. I believe that it would be wrong to deprive someone else of their property unless I would also be happy to have someone else take all my worldly goods if they felt like it.

TogetherInEclecticDreams · 22/08/2023 11:11

I grew up in a large poor family on a council estate but with a strict moral code. Anything illegal has no appeal, although I must look dodgy because I regularly get followed by security guards.
SIL looks typically middle class. She lives in a huge house in the SE and has no money worries. We visit fairly often and I always do a huge shop. Alongside she'll do some shopping herself. There is without fail (what I'd consider), a luxury item she won't scan. It's often an expensive plant (around £30). She has no reason to steal. It's never essential, but she does it all the time. She just says it wouldn't scan if stopped. I know she wouldn't steal in any other circumstances. Security don't give her a second glance, perhaps they have a stereotype of what a thief looks like.

drpet49 · 22/08/2023 11:11

Tinybrother · 22/08/2023 09:49

I just don’t steal. It’s not about being scared of being caught or sympathy for businesses, I just don’t do it.

This

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/08/2023 11:11

Well, no. Morals are morals - the basic understanding between right and wrong. Yes, it's up to each individual to 'choose their own morals'... but, if they do this, they probably can't consider themselves to have good morals.

That doesn't really make any sense. What does 'morals are morals' mean? Morals are dependent on culture and era as well as on individuals. It's ridiculous to say that people who choose their own morals can't consider themselves to have good morals. Literally everyone chooses their own morals, by adopting or rejecting those they were brought up with (whether or not they were based on religion). Different things are considered right or wrong in different eras and in different cultures.

TheWitchCirce · 22/08/2023 11:11

It's simply not yours to take. I wouldn't be so entitled as to consider taking it.

Thoughtful2355 · 22/08/2023 11:10

big store, A small store B.

HelpMeGetThrough · 22/08/2023 11:10

Neither A or B.

The thought just wouldn't enter my head to steal it.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/08/2023 11:10

I think a lot of people are being very pearl-clutchy on here - they don't do it because they don't want to get caught and suffer the consequences of it. Not because they have a superior moral compass.

If that isn't true, put your hand on heart and ask if you check your speed when you go through a speed camera. If you never speed because it's wrong, you don't need to check. But I bet you do. And it's arguably worse as you might kill or injure someone.

Far too much sanctimony on here. You must all think the rest of us were born yesterday.

Iloveanicegarden · 22/08/2023 11:09

@Pencilsaremylife Off on a tangent slightly.
DH was sat in stationary car in car park when he was hit from behind by another car. Low speed impact, little damage. Reported to insurance co for information. Then the phone calls started from claims companies urging him to make a claim. He told them there was no injuries to claim for, but they went on and on, justifying it by saying 'the money is just sitting there for you to claim. They didn't seem to understand it would be fraudulent and that in the end we all pay.
Question - if he'd given in and made a claim would it be theft? We said yes but what would you do oh wise ones?

VictoriaVenkman · 22/08/2023 11:09

Like PP, it wouldn't occur to me to steal it. I'd think, pity I can't afford it and move on.

BarbaraofSeville · 22/08/2023 11:09

supersop60 · 22/08/2023 10:57

It's wrong.
A THIRD of customers steal from self checkouts? Is that factual?

I don't know whether it's one of those '87% of statistics are made up on the spot' arguments or there's some truth behind it, ie answering yes to the question 'have you ever not paid for absolutely everything when using a self scan checkout' where some people have answered yes because once they didn't pay for a bag or told the machine they were buying bananas when they were actually buying cherries.

But it's obviously common enough that most supermarkets think it's worth putting cameras on them so you can see them recording you scanning everything correctly. The cost of which we will all pay for.

Wyks · 22/08/2023 11:09

It’s theft

its wrong on every level

Brokendaughter · 22/08/2023 11:08

It's wrong.
That's why I wouldn't consider it.
I have never for a second held an item in a shop & thought about taking it.

The only time I can imagine being conflicted is if I had a genuinely hungry child at home & it was food.

I'd still know it was wrong, but I can't say for sure I wouldn't do it if it was a case of my child starving or me stealing.

Icedlatteplease · 22/08/2023 11:08

TyrannosaurusSex · 22/08/2023 10:48

I mean - this is basically the existentialist question, is it not?

Do we have fundamental morals, guided by something other than simple human decision to follow some rules (eg by God)? Or do we decide our own morals and so are free to choose them as we think best?

I find it a bit disappointing so many are trying to shut down the debate, tbh. There is no 'end of' because all morals should be questioned regularly. As pp has said, homosexuality was once thought of as a fundamental wrong. Similarly, sex before marriage. Plus, morality is often society dependent with some societies following quite different moral codes.

To answer the OP, I really don't know. I am someone who feels a great deal of guilt if I do not follow my own moral code - which often seems to be harsher and more rigid than other people's (when it comes to my own behaviour). I had a spiritual upbringing, if not strictly religious. Mostly, I think guilt is why I don;t so some things. But where the guilt originates, I do not know!

Essentially questioning whether you have the right to steal is about getting onto communists principles. Do you have the right to hold property beyond your basic needs on the first place?

But actually it's not an existential question

By God's (Christian) law "thou shalt not steal" (im sure others can add , and as individuals we have made laws that say though shalt not steal.

Every society has viewed ownership as a reward for endeavour it not unreasonable to think a persons moral compass should reflect this.

I don't think it's unreasonable to say that the practicalities of theft should not be the primary concern as to whether you do something or not. Not if you have any kind of moral code. External or internal.

Still it does perhaps suggest a career in politics might be appropriate given present politicians

UrsulaBelle · 22/08/2023 11:07

C because it’s just basic morals. Stealing is wrong. I’d have more sympathy if it’s stealing food because of hunger due to grinding poverty, but I wouldn’t steal something I just liked the look of. I don’t get it? 🤷🏼‍♀️

TyrannosaurusSex · 22/08/2023 11:07

*'Do we have fundamental morals, guided by something other than simple human decision to follow some rules (eg by God)? Or do we decide our own morals and so are free to choose them as we think best?'

Well, no. Morals are morals - the basic understanding between right and wrong. Yes, it's up to each individual to 'choose their own morals'... but, if they do this, they probably can't consider themselves to have good morals.

It is universally accepted that it is wrong to steal. Period. If someone thinks there might be occasions where this could be justified, this is immoral.*

That's option A - it's just a different flavour of 'God decided'. It's saying that morals are already set in stone as fundamental truths that cannot be altered or changed. They are not decided by humans, they already exist as truths without us.

I am not sure I agree - but, as I say, existentialism has been debating it for decades so I don't suppose we'll find the answer on a mn thread Grin

TheInseparables · 22/08/2023 11:06

I find it a bit disappointing so many are trying to shut down the debate, tbh. There is no 'end of' because all morals should be questioned regularly. As pp has said, homosexuality was once thought of as a fundamental wrong.

Yes, it’s a much more interesting question than some people are giving OP credit for. Most people use a mixture of types of moral reasoning- rule-based (stealing is wrong), effects-based (don’t harm the business owner) and virtue-based (I don’t steal because I’m not a low-life) and all of them exist on this thread.

Not stealing is a relatively clear-cut question (most of the time but not all)- you can see why people have internalised moral rules about it that they don’t question much. Rule-based thinking is a great time-saver but doesn’t work so well for more complex problems (pace Kant). It also entrenches moral rules that ought to be questioned (eg homosexuality is wrong) and treats as absolute things which are actually culturally contingent (the concept of stealing can only exist in a society with a concept of personal property). Other moral questions lend themselves better to effects-based reasoning (should I tell my brother’s wife that I think he had an affair 5 years ago?).

mumu54 · 22/08/2023 11:05

Just shows how morals have declined generally if those are the only choices considered

Londisc · 22/08/2023 11:05

Most people don't steal because lesson A was fully absorbed and imprinted at a very young age: you will face negative personal consequences (punishment, shame, abandonment) if you steal --> "it's morally wrong, end of".

RaraRachael · 22/08/2023 11:04

I'd never steal anything under any circumstances. If I wanted it that desperately, I'd wait till I could afford it.

StEtienne93 · 22/08/2023 11:03

It's just not something that I've ever considered doing. Although that would potentially change if I was desperate - I.e. if I didn't have money for baby formula, but fortunately I've never been in that position.
I pride myself on being honest and trustworthy, so unless I was in a dire situation it wouldn't occur to me to steal from anywhere/anyone.

horseyhorsey17 · 22/08/2023 11:03

supersop60 · 22/08/2023 10:57

It's wrong.
A THIRD of customers steal from self checkouts? Is that factual?

Maybe it's unintentional? Quite easily done I should think.

Backtoreality1 · 22/08/2023 11:03

Wouldn't ever occur to me to steal something.

Jumpingthruhoops · 22/08/2023 11:02

TyrannosaurusSex · 22/08/2023 10:48

I mean - this is basically the existentialist question, is it not?

Do we have fundamental morals, guided by something other than simple human decision to follow some rules (eg by God)? Or do we decide our own morals and so are free to choose them as we think best?

I find it a bit disappointing so many are trying to shut down the debate, tbh. There is no 'end of' because all morals should be questioned regularly. As pp has said, homosexuality was once thought of as a fundamental wrong. Similarly, sex before marriage. Plus, morality is often society dependent with some societies following quite different moral codes.

To answer the OP, I really don't know. I am someone who feels a great deal of guilt if I do not follow my own moral code - which often seems to be harsher and more rigid than other people's (when it comes to my own behaviour). I had a spiritual upbringing, if not strictly religious. Mostly, I think guilt is why I don;t so some things. But where the guilt originates, I do not know!

'Do we have fundamental morals, guided by something other than simple human decision to follow some rules (eg by God)? Or do we decide our own morals and so are free to choose them as we think best?'

Well, no. Morals are morals - the basic understanding between right and wrong. Yes, it's up to each individual to 'choose their own morals'... but, if they do this, they probably can't consider themselves to have good morals.

It is universally accepted that it is wrong to steal. Period. If someone thinks there might be occasions where this could be justified, this is immoral.

horseyhorsey17 · 22/08/2023 11:02

It also wouldn't occur to me, but I wouldn't steal because it's objectively wrong. While I understand that desperate people do desperate things, and make some allowance for that, I am not desperate so for me it just wouldn't even cross my mind.

But btw we still pay for stuff that's stolen from big businesses - the insurance costs are passed onto the consumer, it's one of the drivers of food inflation. There's not really such a thing as a victimless crime here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread