Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moral question for you all

482 replies

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 22/08/2023 09:43

Imagine you go into a really nice small business selling either homewares or food. You pick something up that you really like, but it's the end of the month and you can't really afford it. What is the main reason that stops you from stealing it?

A.) Fear of getting caught, punished, criminal record, shame, losing your job
B.) Sympathy for the small business owner, not wanting them to lose money

Or something else.
For me it's massively more B but then I don't steal from chain stores, so I guess A must come into it then?
I just wonder where these moral decisions we make daily come from. Is it fear of repercussions or genuine moral compass? Why do a third of shoppers steal from self checkouts but wouldn't steal from a cashier at the till?
I think about the idea that if there wasn't law and order, then we would all steal and murder, but I genuinely believe that most of us wouldn't? I mean I've never felt compelled to, but why is that? Empathy?

OP posts:
overtaxedoverworked · 22/08/2023 13:07

The reason many of us don't take things that aren't ours is that having your child ask you "Jimmy says you're a thief, is it true?" is too awful to contemplate.
I was once accused at work of something that I didn't do and the accuser's comment that "we're only questioning your honesty and integrity" told me everything about her lack of standards - and that I needed out.

DameCurlyBassey · 22/08/2023 13:07

BadlydoneHelen · 22/08/2023 09:49

I'm also C: It's wrong
I think it's strange that this option didn't occur to you

I think OP is asking us why we think it's wrong, which is quite interesting.

As Mrs Merton would say "Let's have a heated debate."

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 13:06

@yellowsmileyface Excellent point! Surely having actually thought about why stealing is wrong makes you more moral than just stating that stealing is wrong because that’s just what you’ve been told and you accept it without question…?

(There’s a whole other can of worms here about whether morality really is based on harms and benefits or whether it’s just about societal norms and disgust but I don’t think there’s much point going into that here…!)

dottiedodah · 22/08/2023 13:04

Its wrong to steal ,end of. I have never been tempted! As far as taking from big companies is concerned people say they "wont miss it" Well they will ,and worse increase prices to the detriment of honest shoppers ,even security bar codes cost money!

5128gap · 22/08/2023 13:03

Its both. What we term as our 'morality' is just a combination of our empathy for others plus the consequences to us of breaching societal norms. Some people's thinking weighs more heavily towards one than the others.

DisforDarkChocolate · 22/08/2023 13:01

None, stealing would never even cross my mind.

declutteringmymind · 22/08/2023 12:58

Option c

It's wrong.

3luckystars · 22/08/2023 12:57

I would have no luck for it.

Its just wrong anyway you look at it.

yellowsmileyface · 22/08/2023 12:57

I find all of the "because it's wrong to steal... duh!" answers so boring. Where's your sense of philosophical curiosity? Do you really just accept social norms without ever questioning them? I think questioning these things shows greater morals than not questioning them.

I subscribe to a more utilitarian code of ethics, so I believe the end justifies the means, and consequences are of more moral relevance than the action itself.

I wouldn't steal from an independent business because of B, and I wouldn't steal from larger businesses because of A. I'm fortunate enough though that I can afford the things I need, so I don't need to steal.

However, I wouldn't consider it morally wrong for a homeless person to steal food from a supermarket, or for a struggling single mum to steal nappies for her baby. I consider it a greater moral injustice that we live in a society where some people don't have access to life's necessities.

Of course this is a very simplistic take and people have written entire dissertations on the subject. That's what makes philosophy so very fascinating, there are no simple answers!

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 12:56

Apexroof · 22/08/2023 12:40

Depressing to think there are some who just don't have 'thou shalt not steal' somewhere in their minds.

Or is that what we've become to as a society?

I'm not really arguing in favour of organised religion but I do think the decline in religious observance has had this sort of effect as all religions have this kind of basic morality at the heart.

This thread is full of people who are so horrified by the mere existence of stealing that they can’t even entertain the concept of a thought experiment about it. I don’t think you need to worry too much about anyone’s morality here…

DorasAuntie · 22/08/2023 12:52

What a weird post.
And nothing more from the OP after she's thrown in the grenade.

Taking something you have not paid for, which doesn't belong to you, is theft.

It's called stealing.

Feeling sorry for the business owner or the risk of being caught aren't relevant.

If they were, the same logic would apply to anything that is morally wrong.

Murder
Arson
Being unfaithful
Fraud

Uppitywoman · 22/08/2023 12:50

Because it doesn’t belong to me.

guzzleandstuff · 22/08/2023 12:49

It's a mix - society is a social contract. We don't want a society where everybody can steal from everybody else because then it just comes down to who has the biggest gang and the most powerful weapons. So we agree - I won't steal from you if you don't steal from me.
But this "contract" has to be based on some sort of perceived fairness - which is why some people start to think it's reasonable to steal from big business or from rich people who "wouldn't miss it" or from old people who "don't need it".
Our position in society affords us a lot of things - safety, protection, respect, ease - and that is threatened if we are shamed - hence "getting caught" is also a factor.
The balance is not absolute... things change in times of trouble or war or famine for example.
I have never and (think) I would never steal because it's wrong... but that's in this society, now.

MsCactus · 22/08/2023 12:45

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/08/2023 12:09

(I think big businesses exploit and "take" from people at a large, global scale. If a poor person steals from a big chain, I see that as moral and right.*

Really? So if, for example, your child or partner stole something from a big business, you'd be pleased and congratulate them?

It depends if they needed it. I'm quite wealthy so I wouldn't - but I definitely would if my children needed food, medicine, the basics etc. I think it'd be morally wrong not to do so

Eviebeans · 22/08/2023 12:43

I don’t think it would enter my head to steal it. The thought wouldn’t be in my head to make a choice about.
I’m more likely to think - if it’s still here when I’m next here I’ll get one.

Wasteddaysanddays · 22/08/2023 12:41

I am a law abider by nature so just don't take what isn't mine.
What I don't understand though is how people don't realise that price increases are partly based on unexplained loss I.e. theft.

Someone has to pay for the shortfall when things are stolen or damaged and that is you the customer. Included in that shortfall are plastic carrier bags not paid for, produce not weighed correctly and items skip scanned at self scan tills. Also unwanted frozen and chilled food not put back in fridges or freezers and vandalism to toilets and in car parks.

Apexroof · 22/08/2023 12:40

Depressing to think there are some who just don't have 'thou shalt not steal' somewhere in their minds.

Or is that what we've become to as a society?

I'm not really arguing in favour of organised religion but I do think the decline in religious observance has had this sort of effect as all religions have this kind of basic morality at the heart.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 12:40

primoseyellow · 22/08/2023 12:34

I wouldn't be able to enjoy having the item as I knew id stolen it, same as why I wouldn't cheat in an exam. Even if there was a guarantee no one would find out, I just couldn't do it.

See this is at the heart of this question. If you answer that you wouldn’t steal even if there was no law against it because you would be shunned by society, you then need to ask yourself whether you’d steal even with a cast-iron guarantee you’d never be found. That’s where it gets really interesting IMO.

ZebraDanios · 22/08/2023 12:37

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/08/2023 12:25

So my neighbour has a nice car I can just take it, the next neighbour leaves their door unlocked I can go in and take what I want from their house, there is a nice bottle of whisky at the off license I can just have that, my child wants the latest ipad they can just take it of the shelf.

Is this less boring?

Oh fgs. The poster was saying it was boring not to engage with the moral question, not that it's boring not to steal stuff. Questions about ethics and the motivation behind them have been discussed for thousands of years. They are at the centre of what's fascinating about human behaviour. I can just imagine Plato and Socrates going 'Nope, it's just wrong, innit? End of'.

Exactly @AllProperTeaIsTheft. Imagine every hypothetical question throughout history being answered with a simple “well I just wouldn’t do that”…

primoseyellow · 22/08/2023 12:34

I wouldn't be able to enjoy having the item as I knew id stolen it, same as why I wouldn't cheat in an exam. Even if there was a guarantee no one would find out, I just couldn't do it.

Dolores87 · 22/08/2023 12:32

Lentilweaver · 22/08/2023 12:19

so all rich people deserve to be stolen from?

Are we talking rich people or billionaires?

Rich is subjective but there is a point where rich is rich to the detriment to everyone else.

BlueMongoose · 22/08/2023 12:30

Because it is dishonest. A complex society like ours needs us all to be honest for it to be fair for everyone.
I don't like liars and I don't like thieves. They are parasites quite apart from anything else and the other harms they do. And my definition of both is wider than most people's these days- I'll give you an example, if people skive off work but take the pay, they are stealing from their employer/customer. In the case of, well, let's take one example, MPs, if they skive off, their employer is us, so in my book they are stealing from us.

Riiiiighty · 22/08/2023 12:30

I am not a criminal. That's why. Jeez!

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 22/08/2023 12:29

MsCactus · 22/08/2023 12:02

I feel differently from most posters.

I think big businesses exploit and "take" from people at a large, global scale. If a poor person steals from a big chain, I see that as moral and right.

I think we're all monkeys and no one really owns anything. The big corporations are evil in the way they exploit people a lot of the time. I don't have an issue with a needy person stealing. If the person stealing is wealthy that's a different matter tbh.

But big businesses do not bear the costs of theft - they pass it on to their customers, @MsCactus. Everything you or I buy from, say, Tesco, has a percentage built into the price to cover loss by theft - so whenever anyone steals from Tesco, I am paying some of that cost.

So it doesn't punish the evil corporation or its shareholders - it punishes the rest of us.

Strugglingtodomybest · 22/08/2023 12:26

Alighttouchonthetiller · 22/08/2023 10:12

It's morally wrong to steal things, and that's that.

God, MN is weird.

Philosophy isn't weird!