Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go away on holiday on my 19 year olds birthday

135 replies

Guacamole123 · 21/08/2023 23:18

My husbands 40th is next year and it’s literally 10 days before my daughters 19th birthday - the date we’d be coming back due to dates he can have off work would mean we’d be returning actually on our daughters 19th birthday. She is invited on this holiday all paid for by us and we’re also going with my Inlaws, we have also invited her boyfriend of 2 years, providing he pays for his own flight, we’ve agreed to pay for the villa and all food etc . She doesn’t feel her boyfriend will beable to afford it and if he can’t go she also won’t entertain the idea of going. So this puts us in a dilemma as it would mean we wouldn’t see her on her birthday.
My husband feels that because she’s invited and won’t go if boyfriend can’t then we should go anyway as that’s her being awkward, however it isn’t sitting right with me and I feel uncomfortable with it and don’t know whether it’s right really
or whether I’m just being silly?
what’s everyone’s views on this?

OP posts:
Dogsaresooomucheasier · 22/08/2023 21:19

I’d just pay for his flight too so you don’t have to worry about it to be honest rather than ruining the holiday worrying about it x

Gumptionesque · 22/08/2023 21:14

I have absolutely no idea if I saw my parents on my 19th birthday. I suspect not as I’d have been at uni.

You made her a fair offer of a holiday and she’s chosen not to accept it, so leave it there. Given it’s a villa holiday next year, you can always book her a flight at a later date if she changes her mind, or they split up (again).

Manthide · 22/08/2023 19:19

Ds's birthday falls in peak exam time - even at university he has exams on his birthday! He was 20 this year and he came home for dd2's 30th and his gran's 80th joint party the week before. I don't think missing an adult child's birthday is a big thing and as they get older the occasions you actually see them on their birthday get rarer. I actually can't remember the last time I saw dd1 on her birthday- probably when she was 21 ( now almost 32).

my82my · 22/08/2023 19:15

It's fine you should go and enjoy your holiday.. very generous of you to even offer to pay for his food ect, do they work?
It's not like you've dumped it on them last minute.. he's got a year to save for flights if he wants to come.

tammie49 · 22/08/2023 19:08

I didn't see my mum on my 19th birthday because I was at uni. She's 19, she's chosen not to go. I don't see the dilemma to be honest.

KSJR · 22/08/2023 18:45

I had moved out when I was 19 she’s an adult. You have been more than generous offering to pay for her as an adult. I certainly wouldn’t be offering to pay for the boyfriend, he should have his own job and income if he isn’t going into further education. You have her a choice and she chose to stay at home. You have to think of it as soon she will fly the nest and all you will have is your husband for company you need to start putting each other first now.

LittleMonks11 · 22/08/2023 17:40

Her difficulties then. I wouldn't have responded in the airy way I did. Tricky one. Hope you work it out so everyone's happy.

Guacamole123 · 22/08/2023 16:56

LittleMonks11 · 22/08/2023 15:10

I do feel you should have put her diagnoses in the OP. I'm sorry you're all having a hard time about it all.

She hasn’t got an actual diagnose hence why I didn’t. She’s inconclusive for ADHD and traits of mild BPD but no formal diagnoses on either.

OP posts:
Guacamole123 · 22/08/2023 16:54

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 22/08/2023 16:40

I don't think her not going is an issue though..yes it's his 40th but she doesn't need to be there. They both sound intense.

Given Autism and ADHD are often hereditary does he possibly have it as well?

The only other thing that stands out is he left her during a mental health crisis for a couple of weeks at 12. She is the oldest and probably the most tuned in. I am guessing there were issues leading up to that, and following. I would not dismiss a parent with mental health issues as minor trauma personally.

Ty - I’m not dismissing it by any means- just pointing out that she hasn’t had a bad upbringing or been abused in anyway as instantly that’s what everyone thinks with BPD, this isn’t the case. What is trauma to some isn’t to others, that is all I was trying to get across. My husband wasn’t visibly in a bad way and didn’t discuss anything with the kids, he works away a lot and always has so youngest 2 didn’t even know he’d left as he was frequently away with work for a full week. However she was abit older and obviously aware something was going on at the time.

OP posts:
Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 22/08/2023 16:40

I don't think her not going is an issue though..yes it's his 40th but she doesn't need to be there. They both sound intense.

Given Autism and ADHD are often hereditary does he possibly have it as well?

The only other thing that stands out is he left her during a mental health crisis for a couple of weeks at 12. She is the oldest and probably the most tuned in. I am guessing there were issues leading up to that, and following. I would not dismiss a parent with mental health issues as minor trauma personally.

ActDottie · 22/08/2023 16:33

Just go she’s 19 I don’t think I saw my parents on my 19th/20th birthday no big deal

YukoandHiro · 22/08/2023 16:12

"My husband feels that because she’s invited and won’t go if boyfriend can’t then we should go anyway as that’s her being awkward."

He's right. Go and enjoy yourself. Celebrate on the next day. I don't think I saw my parents at all on my 19th or 20th birthdays. I did see them on my 21st because we made special plans (and on my 18TH because I still lived at home and was in the middle of my a levels)

Dontknowwhyidoit · 22/08/2023 16:10

She will be fine, I never saw my mum on my 18th as she was in another country working or my 21st as I lived a boat ride away and it hasn't harmed me. As long as you celebrate it with her either by phone or on another day, I don't see the problem.

Birch101 · 22/08/2023 15:59

I was.at university for my 19th and never saw my parents. It's not weird.
Also my aunt and uncle used to do the same thing they would pay for their daughter to go but partner had to pay for themselves , when in reality my cousin and partner would just split that cost between them.
If he is unable to go and she doesn't want to go that's her own choice

NotAMug · 22/08/2023 15:13

Guacamole123 · 22/08/2023 11:52

Maybe that’s why my poll is confusing then! I’ve 86% day I’m unreasonable. Which I took as u reasonable for going away which was my title question. So I’ve been sat here readin the comments thinking why is everyone for it but the poll is against! Lol 😂

I thought it meant YABU for worrying about whether you went or not also 🙈

LittleMonks11 · 22/08/2023 15:10

I do feel you should have put her diagnoses in the OP. I'm sorry you're all having a hard time about it all.

cheezncrackers · 22/08/2023 14:52

Oh FGS just go on your holiday and stop worrying about it! Most 19-year-olds are off living their lives on their 19th birthdays, they aren't spending them with their mum and dad.

LadyR77 · 22/08/2023 14:50

YANBU - it became a bit of a running joke once I hit that sort of age that my parents were ALWAYS away on my birthday (mid-September, so they'd take advantage of schools having gone back and the weather still being pretty reliable). It never bothered me at all, and they'd usually bring me back something nice from wherever they'd been as a bit of a bonus birthday present!

jeaux90 · 22/08/2023 14:44

So just seeing some of your replies OP I do get it. My DD14 is ASD and ADHD and part of the ongoing coaching is adapting.

The rigid thinking is the issue. It seems that time away might be good for everyone reading the replies from you (her resilience and the BFs time out) but perhaps it needs to be couched with her in a way that puts her dads birthday as a priority this time and to come with you?

Other than that if she really doesn't want to then I'd probably let her stay home and you still go. I'd feel uncomfortable about it though.

Guacamole123 · 22/08/2023 14:03

Guacamole123 · 22/08/2023 13:37

In what way does my husband seem not very nice?

My DD2 is autistic and my husband parents her extremely well so to say he seems unsuitable to parent an ND child is terrible. He has a great relationship with both his other 2 daughters but has always struggled with our eldest. They are similar in personality and she can’t handle any form of rules at home, fine outside the home but not at home. He can be quite strict at times and i too soft. We’re not perfect as is no parent and have made mistakes along the way. Trauma to one can be something very small that affects them as explained by her psychologist- just because she has these traits doesn’t mean she’s had major trauma in her life. If she does have ADHD that also means she’s high risk developing BPD aswell!

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 22/08/2023 13:53

All this is next year, by which time she may well not be with the bf.
Also, it sounds like he has plenty of time to get funds together for a flight if he wanted to come.
DH is right, DD is being difficult, and it's not nice of her to sabotage DHs birthday trip, BPD or not.
If she doesn't want to go, then she can celebrate her birthday at home with the bf, if he's still on the scene by then.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 22/08/2023 13:43

Book it and go. Leave her present & card to open or have flowers delivered on her birthday.
And before you leave make arrangements with her for her birthday celebration when you return.

So in her eyes lots of effort means you are still thinking of her. But away celebrating with your husband. Win win surely?

HollaHolla · 22/08/2023 13:37

Honestly, they're both grown ups - young adults, but adults nonetheless.
I'd say it's up to them. You set out the outlines, etc., but they have to make the decision.

I had a terrible relationship with my father at that age. Didn't even speak to him on his 50th, never mind do anything. He didn't come to my 21st. We've reconciled, and now have a decent relationship.
If they miss each other's birthdays, all is not lost.

Guacamole123 · 22/08/2023 13:37

itsmyp4rty · 22/08/2023 13:30

I don't think she's being unreasonable, she knows she'll be miserable if she goes without BF so there's no point in her going. She's accepted you might not be around for her birthday but she's not going to pretend she's ecstatic about it.

BPD doesn't come out of nowhere, there's been trauma of some sort in her past if she has it. However it's commonly misdiagnosed for ASD. You say she's already been assessed for possible ADHD so I'd be working on the assumption that she is ND and so could emotionally be up to 3 years behind her peers. ND adults though have a higher chance of also suffering from a personality disorder.

Personally I'd want to be around for her birthday and would find a way to accommodate it if she was really keen for me to be there. People on here talking about their kids, or when they were 19 are comparing apples and pears. Parenting a probably ND child with a possible personality disorder is not the same as parenting your average NT child.

Could you both come back a day early perhaps OP? Has she even asked her boyfriend if he could afford to come? I don't think your husband sounds very nice tbh and definitely not suitable for parenting an ND child.

In what way does my husband seem not very nice?

OP posts:
KingOfThieves · 22/08/2023 13:33

I can’t see the problem. You’re going away, she is invited. She would rather stay with her BF. That’s her choice.