Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go away on holiday on my 19 year olds birthday

135 replies

Guacamole123 · 21/08/2023 23:18

My husbands 40th is next year and it’s literally 10 days before my daughters 19th birthday - the date we’d be coming back due to dates he can have off work would mean we’d be returning actually on our daughters 19th birthday. She is invited on this holiday all paid for by us and we’re also going with my Inlaws, we have also invited her boyfriend of 2 years, providing he pays for his own flight, we’ve agreed to pay for the villa and all food etc . She doesn’t feel her boyfriend will beable to afford it and if he can’t go she also won’t entertain the idea of going. So this puts us in a dilemma as it would mean we wouldn’t see her on her birthday.
My husband feels that because she’s invited and won’t go if boyfriend can’t then we should go anyway as that’s her being awkward, however it isn’t sitting right with me and I feel uncomfortable with it and don’t know whether it’s right really
or whether I’m just being silly?
what’s everyone’s views on this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
geoqueen · 25/08/2023 23:37

Personally I’d pay for the boyfriends flight (if he’s in uni) no point offering him to come and not paying in my eyes. But if she still says no then go on ahead and arrange to see her asap

Kbroughton · 24/08/2023 07:20

I think you know the answer. You don't want to pay for him as you know its now not the right thing to do. I also think you may have been giving her too much slack with her BPD. Maybe it is because of BPD, but many many 19 year olds including me prioritise their boyfriend over everyone else. And many older people do. Like everything life teaches you things. It's not until we have prioritised our partners over everything only for the relationship to go south and we have to try to get our lives back thay we lewnr never to do that again. Even if it is BPD, she needs to learn life lessons. You need to make sure she is safe obviously, but beyond that allow her to make her choices. I don't think she's bothered at all. She told you her gut answer straight off. Then she hedged her bets with you after that by saying she's not happy. And you are pandering to it. You will be unfair on your husband if you continue this.

OhcantthInkofaname · 23/08/2023 22:11

BF maybe an ExBF by next year.

Jeannie88 · 23/08/2023 21:39

After the age of 18 I was away for my birthdays til I returned to my home town years later. Please forgive me if anyone thinks I'm wrong but most teenagers just want to be with their friends, boyfriend, of course family but in that order. Looking back we realise it does seem selfish. Our families want to share it with us, but just part of being young I guess and as parents we will experience the same and hopefully not feel personally by it. Xx

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 23/08/2023 21:01

Ponoka7 · 21/08/2023 23:57

Given her MH issues, I'd consider paying for him this time. But that would be her birthday present.

This. if you can afford it.
And mean it. the present is his flight.
how many more holidays will you have with your daughter now she's grown up?

Mymothersfavouritegirl · 23/08/2023 20:30

Speaking from experience here and the mother of 4, there comes a time when they go off doing their own thing without a backwards glance, the Bf has plenty of time to save up should he wish to go and budgeting for something like this is a useful skill to have. You have been very reasonable offering to pay for the food and accommodation so I would let it be their choice, it may do them both good to be away from you and living independently whilst you’re away or as in our case it made ours realise that family holidays are fun quality time together and they didn’t want to miss out on a subsidised holiday. Very often they do regroup so I don’t see it a problem this time or any other.

nillionaire · 23/08/2023 20:05

Mumkins42 · 23/08/2023 19:29

I'd just offer to pay his flight tbh. I read about the history last time - but there's something very welcoming and inclusive about saying 'we want you to join us and we're going to pay for your flight'. That speaks volumes to your daughter and him.

If he goes rogue again no more chances! 🤷‍♀️😁

He has truly had his chances.

DandDoodlz67 · 23/08/2023 19:30

I don’t see the problem! My parents have been away on my birthday for years! I don’t think that they even took me or my siblings away after we were 16

Mumkins42 · 23/08/2023 19:29

I'd just offer to pay his flight tbh. I read about the history last time - but there's something very welcoming and inclusive about saying 'we want you to join us and we're going to pay for your flight'. That speaks volumes to your daughter and him.

If he goes rogue again no more chances! 🤷‍♀️😁

nillionaire · 23/08/2023 19:26

Tbh I think she is a bit selfish not to come when it’s her dads 40th. Her choice. Do not pay for him again.

Ilovecleaning · 23/08/2023 19:02

SecondhandSalute · 23/08/2023 18:53

Because they’ve already paid for his flight to Florida, and were about to pay for his flight to NY when he dumped their daughter out of the blue because he was ‘depressed’. I don’t blame her for not wanting to continue to shell out large sums of cash to propitiate a troubled, fragile daughter by bringing her unstable, not-that-committed boyfriend on family holidays.

Lol 😂. That’s what happens when i can’t be bothered to read long threads. Glad you explained patiently tbh without telling me off. I now agree with you - she should definitely not pay for his flight. And the DD sounds spoiled.

SecondhandSalute · 23/08/2023 18:53

Ilovecleaning · 23/08/2023 18:28

If you feel it’s such a dilemma, why can’t you pay for boyfriend’s flight? I’m not suggesting you should. It just seems the easy answer.

Because they’ve already paid for his flight to Florida, and were about to pay for his flight to NY when he dumped their daughter out of the blue because he was ‘depressed’. I don’t blame her for not wanting to continue to shell out large sums of cash to propitiate a troubled, fragile daughter by bringing her unstable, not-that-committed boyfriend on family holidays.

MrsMarzetti · 23/08/2023 18:52

Your daughter is an adult and really doesn't care if she sees you on her birthday or not, she has already told you this by choosing not to go on holiday with you.. You have to stop seeing her has a child and stop paying for her boyfriend to go on holiday.

IndysMamaRex · 23/08/2023 18:50

She’s 19 so can look after herself while your away. My parents were on holiday on my 19th due to me unable to get the time off work but I didn’t begrudge them going. Just enjoyed the house to myself.

Personally I think she’s daft turning down a paid holiday just because her boyfriend can’t go. Can’t she really not go a week or so without seeing him? Doesn’t sound very healthy if she can’t

EatAllDay · 23/08/2023 18:49

19? Meh… she’d probably prefer the free house. I wasn’t with my son for his 19th this year. I felt bad but he was happy to have his friends over

Ilovecleaning · 23/08/2023 18:28

If you feel it’s such a dilemma, why can’t you pay for boyfriend’s flight? I’m not suggesting you should. It just seems the easy answer.

Diddlyumptious · 23/08/2023 18:05

I'm sure if it was a holiday your daughter was on when it was one of your birthdays she wouldn't bat an eyelid and just go. As it should be, she's not a baby!

KGlov · 23/08/2023 15:22

(Sorry for the long post)
I may be wrong, but it's coming across as, whether you're there or not for her birthday isnt the issue for her, it's whether she is with her BF or not. She doesn't want to be sad without her BF, and you/DH wouldn't want her miserable for DH 40th if she came alone. Maybe this would explain the "not happy" but also "not bothered" answer to you, she would like to go but without her BF she's not as bothered.

I would go, ultimately this is for your DHs 40th and that only happens once. Realistically you'll be back on her birthday or at the latest the very next day, it's not like her birthday is in the middle of a very long trip. I wouldn't pay for BFs flights, especially because of the past, maybe his circumstances won't allow it but if it's far enough in advance there should be time to save up and get time off. I agree with a previous reply saying that her spending her birthday travelling back doesn't sound fun, and she may want to hang out with others anyway.

I think you should focus more on the importance of celebrating DH 40th. Would you not go on holiday for DH40 if her BF couldn't come? I would find this way more unreasonable and unfair on DH and In-laws especially if those are the only dates he can take off. If she's caused issues between you and DH before because of her BPD not going on this holiday wouldn't help them. Although MH issues makes things more difficult we still have to make decisions as adults, situations like this will arise in the future and daughter's therapy should be preparing her with coping mechanisms for this sort of unavoidable thing, I recognise it's not easy and will never be 100% effective, but you won't be able to avoid all these similar situations in the future (I wish her luck btw).

Things I would personally consider:

  • If she/you/DH are disappointed she won't come for DH 40th without BF, maybe a compromise would be to do something smaller before or after the holiday for the 40th to include her, where the BF could come too, a meal or day out etc. As lots of people including myself are saying to celebrate her birthday the day after, it should be feasible to suggest celebrating DH birthday on multiple dates as a compromise?
  • Is it a long trip? If so could you cut it down by one day (come back day before her birthday) to ease anxieties?
  • Daughter and BF has been together for two years, could he lead on planning her birthday to be an event with friends (planning supported by you if needed)? I know she doesn't see them often and prefers BF, but this would mean she wouldn't feel alone and would also take the pressure off BF to be the sole person there for on her birthday, which must be tough. And you can go on holiday. It could be a really fun day for her and then you see her the day after.
  • Can she flag up with therapist that this situation will happen, so they can work on it in advance?

Best of luck x

Stacybrown · 23/08/2023 12:19

Ask her how she would feel about it? At 19 she may want to spend it with boyfriend and friends anyway.

converseandjeans · 23/08/2023 10:35

You should go & plan some sort of celebration when you get back. Family evening or day out & make a fuss of her.

If you stay home she may well spend the day with boyfriend anyway.

If DH is about to turn 40 and she 19 then presumably you were both about to become parents at not much older than she is.

user1492757084 · 23/08/2023 08:52

Due to your daughter's fagility I would consider paying for the boyfriend's flight.

If he breaks up with her you could ask another of her friends or a cousin to go in his place.

Your daughter having time away with you is healthy and important given the uncertainty of the boyfriend and her mental health issues.

Guacamole123 · 23/08/2023 08:44

JST88 · 22/08/2023 23:21

I’d really discourage her from being so attached to a boy at 19 where she’d deny herself the experience of a holiday. I’m not calling her a brat but slightly bratty behaviour almost holding you guys to ransom in hopes you’d pay for her bf to come on holiday with you all as well. I do understand the sadness felt around not seeing your child on their birthday but it would also possibly teach her that you’re not going to fold when she digs her heels over things like that.

The lads done that himself - since they split he’ll only see her twice a week now. Saturday only during school weeks and one day during week in holidays. She’s since spent abit of time with friends going for drives as some of her friends have cars now. They’re all off to uni however I’m sept so she won’t have them after that.
she doesn’t listen to anything we say- only person she listens to is her bf cos he is her favourite person- if she had fallen for a wrong un I dread to think what we’d have been up against, but thankfully she didn’t for her and us. We’ve had a really hard couple of years with her mental health because of the BPD traits but after a years therapy she’s seemed brighter last 6 months and her boyfriend keeping her at a distance is better for her as she’s seemed better mentally in herself aswell and socialised more with friends.
it’s absolutely heartbreaking for us to watch her go through everything and be so helpless.
She also has cronic pain which they think may be endometriosis aswell so she’s a lot to deal with.

OP posts:
Guacamole123 · 23/08/2023 08:38

SingaporeSlinky · 22/08/2023 21:50

Are you booking the same size villa regardless of whether your daughter goes? If so, could you just assume Dd and bf aren’t, and add flights at a later date if they are? Given bf has had an all expenses paid trip to Florida, I wouldn’t be paying for his flights for this holiday too. He’s an adult now, and there is a chance he/they are saying he can’t afford it, knowing you’ll give in and pay for everything, since you’ve paid before.
By the way, she’d actually be having a travel day on her actual birthday anyway, which isn’t much fun, so at least if she stays behind, she can make lovely plans for the day with him.

No we was gonna book a 3 bed as opposed to a 4 bed as other bedroom wouldn’t be needed as our autistic daughter shares a room with my husband and I as she’s too scared to sleep in a room alone. However we’ve said to them since I posted my thread that we’ll book the same villa we’ve seen and give them til January to decide whether they wanna come, so if he wants to he can start saving now and see how he gets on. My daughter is still at college as she’s resitting a-levels as didn’t do great the 1st year- he is currently looking for a full time job in IT so he’s only part time atm so doesn’t know what he’ll be earning when he gets a ft job. So if he wants to come and starts saving now and by January he’s a job and he’s comfortable saving we will buy his flight and he can pay us back monthly ( it’s a risk on our part incase they split and we never get it back ) - even if it takes him alittle longer than the 11 months til we go. Can’t be any fairer than that as we’d love them to come. He’s a lovely lad and having 3 girls hubby loves a lad to hang with and talk to especially as their both into tech stuff so he’ll enjoy his company as we all do and we’re both gutted deep down without showing to her that she might not come. We’re used to her not coming on holiday now as she hasn’t last couple of years however being a special birthday I think we hoped she might.

OP posts:
JST88 · 22/08/2023 23:21

I’d really discourage her from being so attached to a boy at 19 where she’d deny herself the experience of a holiday. I’m not calling her a brat but slightly bratty behaviour almost holding you guys to ransom in hopes you’d pay for her bf to come on holiday with you all as well. I do understand the sadness felt around not seeing your child on their birthday but it would also possibly teach her that you’re not going to fold when she digs her heels over things like that.

SingaporeSlinky · 22/08/2023 21:50

Are you booking the same size villa regardless of whether your daughter goes? If so, could you just assume Dd and bf aren’t, and add flights at a later date if they are? Given bf has had an all expenses paid trip to Florida, I wouldn’t be paying for his flights for this holiday too. He’s an adult now, and there is a chance he/they are saying he can’t afford it, knowing you’ll give in and pay for everything, since you’ve paid before.
By the way, she’d actually be having a travel day on her actual birthday anyway, which isn’t much fun, so at least if she stays behind, she can make lovely plans for the day with him.