Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not helping my dsis with her SN child

440 replies

Ghostedbyfriend · 21/08/2023 22:54

Not UK based, but would go back for one month during the summer. During the summer holidays,I have watched the children of other siblings. Took one NT niece for 5 days to our summer cottage, and another NT niece for 4 days whilst the siblings worked. We have children ourselves.
One sibling who is a single mum has a SN child (10), non verbal with challenging behaviour. Said child gets daytime support whilst my dsis works, however she thinks I am being unfair as summer cottage would be more fun. But I explained that I couldn’t keep my SN niece safe, because she’s a darter and she does not listen. When she was younger and smaller I would watch her for 3-4 days, but now that she’s more grown and larger (overweight) I can’t simply lift her out of “situations”. Sibling acts all hurt her child is being excluded from fun and not treated equally. In my defence, I did watch her over one weekend to give my dsis respite, but apparently that was not enough as I did not take her to the cottage. I watched her at my mother’s house, whilst my dm was busy with gardening and cooking etc (she usually watches my SN niece during the weekend).
Whenever I watch SN niece, my DH has to take full charge of our DCs as SN niece needs 110% attention, it’s simply not fair on my DH, my kids are primary aged. For example when I was talking to dsis over a cup of tea, my niece took a glass she was drinking from and threw it on the tiled floor shattering glasses everywhere. She threw it on purpose, for attention I think.
Yet, my dsis thinks I am being unreasonable for not giving her one week of respite (she thinks watching her child at night is a lot of work)… My DH has put his foot down, he asked me not to bring my SN niece to the cottage as she’s a lot of work and disturbs our family dynamic whereas the other nieces play well with our DCs.
I do feel very guilty of not helping my sis out but I also feel my DH won’t be able to cope. It’s our holiday after all. So AIBU?

OP posts:
ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 22/08/2023 06:57

Agree with others that you don't have to treat all your neices the same when their situations and behaviour are so different. But my god your husband sounds like a drip. He gets incredibly stressed at having responsibility for his own school-aged children? Diddums.

Wouldyouguess · 22/08/2023 06:57

Amethys · 21/08/2023 23:46

I wouldn’t allow a SEN relative to ruin our family holiday, no.

If your sister needs respite care that is absolutely understandable and if you are able to provide some that is fabulous and up to you. But it shouldn’t be taking DN on the family holiday and ruining the experience for all of the other people involved. It should be doing something else separately with DN.

SEN child ruining other people's holidays by their disability they didnt wish for, the wording of it is just so sad... Would you say the same if it was a wheelchair, and tell a kid 'oh ffs, we can't go to this restaurant because it's not wheelchair accessible, you ruined the holiday for us'.

Beersinshropshire · 22/08/2023 06:52

ExtraOnions · 21/08/2023 23:05

She’s your sister, she lives with that pressure 24 hours a day, 7 days of week … of course she is desperate for a break.
Me ? I would do it for a week, and be thankful that for the other 51 weeks of the year, I wasn’t having to manage that behaviour

This.

The excuse that your H can’t watch his own children alone is utterly pathetic.

Nosleepforthismum · 22/08/2023 06:51

Having a child with SN doesn’t automatically make you a good parent or a good person. Your sister actually sounds incredibly selfish. As another PP has suggested, this sounds less about DN’s needs or what would be best for her and more about free childcare. Your DSIS relies heavily on her elderly DM for childcare most weekends when she also works during the week which I actually think is dreadful of your DSIS. I say this as someone with an autistic child and I know how challenging they can be. I would be constantly on edge if someone had my child and I find it bizarre that your sister seemingly doesn’t give a shit about whether her daughter would even be happy with family she only sees once a year or whether she would even be safe on one of these trips (especially as she is a bolter!) but as long as she gets her respite … If it’s actually about your DN, your sister will bring her to visit the family with her there to supervise.

Kidsandcat · 22/08/2023 06:50

Why not compromise and have her for 2 days out of your month's holiday. Any longer say your sister has to stay too?

Ellie1015 · 22/08/2023 06:48

Yanbu. You are only visiting for a month. Dsis gets respite from school during the day and your mum at weekends. Dsis wont come to cottage as she acknowledges it will be harder than at home.

I appreciate your sister has it tough, but no i would not give up a week. Cheek to ask for a week.

ShoesoftheWorld · 22/08/2023 06:42

Jellycatspyjamas · 22/08/2023 00:48

Whenever I watch SN niece, my DH has to take full charge of our DCs as SN niece needs 110% attention, it’s simply not fair on my DH, my kids are primary aged.

Why is DH incapable of looking after his own school aged children?

You don’t want to do it, which is your choice but own it - nothing you’ve said is insurmountable, you don’t want the stress of caring for your niece on holiday which I can understand but just say that instead of putting your sister down, justifying yourself and making excuses.

These are my thoughts.

Reading between the lines, your dh sounds as if he's the type that considers looking after his own (NT!) children a massive chore and imposition. A very tiresome attitude.

If this were me, wouldn't necessarily have your niece to stay without her mum, but I would take her out/look after her for a couple of daytimes while dh did something with our children (and certainly wouldn't complain or 'feel stressed' about it).

Magneta · 22/08/2023 06:33

You're focussing on rationalisation and justification with your "rational brain". For her it's likely a more primal, emotional reaction - niece is being excluded, and that is only ever going to feel really shitty. You're talking at crossed purposes, with different languages really.

There was a thread recently about how a poster's SN son was excluded from his uncle's wedding. His brother, sister and mum were in the wedding party. He wasn"t even invited to the reception, just the evening. He was excluded from the photos. Whatever arguments you make, however right you are that it's not safe for you or fair to your husband, that rejection and difference is likely how it feels to her.

RhymesWithTangerine · 22/08/2023 06:31

I disagree with all the posters who are dismissing your DH or implying he is a poor parent or whatever. I think he gets a say in his own holiday.

Ofc he can look after his own DC but you say you will bring DN to the cottage and that sounds intense, disruptive and potentially unsafe. No wonder he thinks that’s too much.

if this is about the cottage, tell your DSis she can bring DN to the cottage. Alternatively, if this is about childcare, you could offer to go to your DMs.

Toohotrightnow · 22/08/2023 06:20

I feel that the majority of answers are focusing on ‘not your responsibility, it’s your holiday’ etc.
Personally, I would absolutely ‘ sacrifice’ a couple of days of our month long holiday to spend time with my DN and support my DSis.
You have a month! If it’s ‘not fair’ on your DH to take responsibility for 3 school aged children for 3 days, imagine how your DSis feels?
Working etc is not a break, the responsibility will still be there. Put yourself out and show your children that we help each other and that you value your DNs differences.
Exhausting it will be, but for 2-3 days only.

RecklessBlackberries · 22/08/2023 06:20

Codlingmoths · 22/08/2023 05:42

I don’t know, some mixed messages here. You can’t simultaneously say dsis gets SO much support and help and holidays away implying it all should be perfectly manageable and also say you can’t do a few days anymore as it’s too stressful. You can’t simultaneously say it’s too physically challenging to look after her now she’s bigger and that also your presumably older mum does a lot. It’s obviously shit, and it can’t help one bit you telling your sister but the other nieces are lovely and FUN. Because obviously you’re saying you don’t want to spend any time with hers. I’d take her for a couple of days and I’d look after her not my Dh- he should be able to cope with his own kids.

No mixed messages here. It would be a mixed message if OP was saying "this is impossible for a week, you keep doing it all the time forever", but that isn't the situation! The sister is never looking after her child fully for a whole week!

The options here are OP takes her and is responsible for her 24/7 for a whole week. Or her sister does her usual routine of being responsible for her weekday evenings and palms her off on their mother for full days and overnight on the weekend.

The OP would do more caring for this child in a week than their own mother does in a fortnight.

Thehonestbadger · 22/08/2023 06:18

This is so hard. I have an ASD non verbal 3yo DS (very large for his age, size of a 6yo) and a NT 2yo DD.

Even though I fully understand why everyone wants DD but not DS it’s still a bitter pill to swallow. I didn’t ask for a SEN child and for exactly the same reasons everyone else struggles with him (doesn’t listen, runs off, needs constant 1:1 attention) I struggle with him too! I don’t think caring for him any easier than anyone else but I’m just stuck here. It’s all well and good when people say
’well whenever you have a child this is the risk’ but let’s be honest, when you have no family history on either side NO ONE actually thinks it’s going to happen to them and no one would choose it.

I think the problem here is you offering experiences to your other family kids and not her. My MIL watches all the grandkids except my DS and it makes me pretty resentful.
Maybe dial back what you do with the others if you can’t offer some level of equality.
SEN parents (remember I have one of each and my NT DD is highly strung and hard work so not like I have it easy) need the break even more than NT parents. SEN parenting, in my experience of both, is about 500% harder, because it’s thankless and you don’t get the connection or responses. It feels like banging your head against a wall endlessly. She’s going to resent you giving your other siblings more respite than her!

xx

TerrorAustralis · 22/08/2023 06:07

You are all being unreasonable to a certain extent.

Your DH for not being able to care for his own primary-aged children.

Your DSis for pretending that taking your other DNs on holiday is the same as taking care of her DD. And for insisting that you either have to take her DD alone or not at all.

You for enabling your DH’s incompetent parenting.

I’d offer a final compromise. Something like, DN can come for two nights if she has a carer/respite worker with her. Then between three adults you can manage DN and your own kids.

Out of everyone, it sounds like your DM needs the holiday most of all!

Autieangel · 22/08/2023 05:57

You mention that your sister doesn't bring dn to the cottage due to her challenging behaviour. So why would she want to put you and her dc through that? I would be clear you will help at her house or your mothers but you do not feel capable to manage at the cottage.

You say she gets carers and dm helps a lot. Does she get respite? In our area we have something called short breaks where people can get funding for respite through the council. It might be worth her checking if her local council do similar to easy burden on your mum.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 22/08/2023 05:52

This simply is not a situation where all the DC can be treated equally.

Why should DH look after his children in his own on a "family holiday" and why should the op have to provide respite care while on her own holiday?

Taking the other DNs actually makes the holiday easier and more fun because their own DC have other children to play with.

But just as I wouldn't takes 2 year old on my teen DC's holiday I wouldn't take an SN child with a mental age of 2. It is no longer a holiday.

The only possible way to do it would be to hire someone to provide the care, and they can also go with you, but that is supposing the holiday venue is suitable which it doesn't sound as though it is.

And whoever it was who said they would be devastated at their DC being seen as a chore, that is exactly what they are? I care for my extended family but I don't love them in the same way as I do my own DC. So having to look after young children of the extended family IS a chore!

I don't impose on my family to look after my DC because it's a chore for them, whereas for me I adore them so my reward is greater than the "chore".

Tourmalines · 22/08/2023 05:46

Fraaahnces · 22/08/2023 04:58

Stick to your guns. Spell out that she gets much more respite from her own child than she actually spends in her company, and that while everyone understands that she is in a difficult situation, her entitlement is not endearing her to anyone.

This

Codlingmoths · 22/08/2023 05:42

I don’t know, some mixed messages here. You can’t simultaneously say dsis gets SO much support and help and holidays away implying it all should be perfectly manageable and also say you can’t do a few days anymore as it’s too stressful. You can’t simultaneously say it’s too physically challenging to look after her now she’s bigger and that also your presumably older mum does a lot. It’s obviously shit, and it can’t help one bit you telling your sister but the other nieces are lovely and FUN. Because obviously you’re saying you don’t want to spend any time with hers. I’d take her for a couple of days and I’d look after her not my Dh- he should be able to cope with his own kids.

LunaMay · 22/08/2023 05:32

Oh boo hoo your 'D'H would have to be responsible for his own children ... hmm who else is in that predicament all the time?? You both sound awful to me.

Fraaahnces · 22/08/2023 04:58

Stick to your guns. Spell out that she gets much more respite from her own child than she actually spends in her company, and that while everyone understands that she is in a difficult situation, her entitlement is not endearing her to anyone.

GerbilTrainerExtraordinaire2 · 22/08/2023 04:51

The other alternative is leaving DH with one child at home and you taking one child, your mum and niece.

OCDmama · 22/08/2023 04:45

You can't win here OP.

According to posters your DN shouldn't be treated differently because of her disability. Ok the same breath she absolutely should, her poor mum etc.

You've done what you can OP. If your DSis wouldn't take her to the cottage because of her behaviour you shouldn't either. Your DSis would just be managing her own DC and can't cope with that, yet she would expect you to manage her DC and your own together.

I also think people are ignoring the quite significant support you are providing. You seem to be offering respite care to your DM, who is both working herself and looking after DN at weekends and some other nights.

GerbilTrainerExtraordinaire2 · 22/08/2023 04:44

I'm on the fence. While I understand the point about fairness and giving a break, managing the child’s behaviour is possibly beyond your capabilities (are you able to keep her child and your children safe if behaviour is challenging). Also there’s the unknown … the child may struggle enormously with being out of routine and not understand what’s going on, with no usual carers and different environment. It might be an idea to trial a weekend, so just two nights with the child, your mum, DH and kids present. Unless your DH is on a knife edge mentally, it shouldn’t be beyond him to be 75% responsible for his own kids.

Itsallok · 22/08/2023 04:33

Frankly, your DSIS gets massive support from her DM - far more than most of us with 24/7 SN children. Of which I am one.

Canisaysomething · 22/08/2023 03:36

Am I the only one thinking why is the OP taking anyone else's children at all on holiday with her own primary aged children to look after? It's your holiday OP. I would put a stop to taking anyone else and call it fair that way.

momonpurpose · 22/08/2023 03:01

hennaoj · 21/08/2023 22:57

You don't owe your sister anything. I have 3 autistic sons and never expected anything from mine, especially when they were younger. She's better off applying for respite from the council or taking it in turns with the child's father to have time out.

Absolutely. It sad and hard on your sister sure however that's part of being a parent. She needs to look into respite not put this on you. Also neice is not being treated unfairly. It is simply not safe to take her. Don't let anybody guilt trip you. Is it sad sure but your husband dc come first. If the shoe was on the other foot I doubt she'd take this on. Sadly it's simply too much