Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not helping my dsis with her SN child

440 replies

Ghostedbyfriend · 21/08/2023 22:54

Not UK based, but would go back for one month during the summer. During the summer holidays,I have watched the children of other siblings. Took one NT niece for 5 days to our summer cottage, and another NT niece for 4 days whilst the siblings worked. We have children ourselves.
One sibling who is a single mum has a SN child (10), non verbal with challenging behaviour. Said child gets daytime support whilst my dsis works, however she thinks I am being unfair as summer cottage would be more fun. But I explained that I couldn’t keep my SN niece safe, because she’s a darter and she does not listen. When she was younger and smaller I would watch her for 3-4 days, but now that she’s more grown and larger (overweight) I can’t simply lift her out of “situations”. Sibling acts all hurt her child is being excluded from fun and not treated equally. In my defence, I did watch her over one weekend to give my dsis respite, but apparently that was not enough as I did not take her to the cottage. I watched her at my mother’s house, whilst my dm was busy with gardening and cooking etc (she usually watches my SN niece during the weekend).
Whenever I watch SN niece, my DH has to take full charge of our DCs as SN niece needs 110% attention, it’s simply not fair on my DH, my kids are primary aged. For example when I was talking to dsis over a cup of tea, my niece took a glass she was drinking from and threw it on the tiled floor shattering glasses everywhere. She threw it on purpose, for attention I think.
Yet, my dsis thinks I am being unreasonable for not giving her one week of respite (she thinks watching her child at night is a lot of work)… My DH has put his foot down, he asked me not to bring my SN niece to the cottage as she’s a lot of work and disturbs our family dynamic whereas the other nieces play well with our DCs.
I do feel very guilty of not helping my sis out but I also feel my DH won’t be able to cope. It’s our holiday after all. So AIBU?

OP posts:
ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 08:33

RhymesWithTangerine · 22/08/2023 07:56

Would you agree that we all need to be selfish sometimes? The OP putting her own family first on their family holiday sounds like good parenting.

OP is not refusing to help. But this will take her away from her own DC and DH. And even her DSis said the environment is too difficult to look after her own daughter.

Parents of kids with SEN don't ever get to be selfish. That's the point. I've actually had people ask me to mind their kids (who never mind mine), claiming they 'will be easy next to mine'. Could do without this selfishness myself.

OleMioSole · 22/08/2023 08:32

*also needs to pay not only

OleMioSole · 22/08/2023 08:31

Exactly @Gymmum82 .
YANBU OP.
I have no idea whether posters on MN are wilfully obtuse or just struggle with reading comprehension.
So many people talking about 'needing a break' blah2.
Your sister gets a level of help most SEN parents can only dream of!
Full daytime care so she can work.
Mother cares for her every weekend.

@Lifeisgood1 is this common in your situation or most SEN parents? From reading on here and people IRL it's very, very uncommon and you're usually left to your own devices and have to give up work.

Of course, even with all the help it's still hard work. But it's not a case of 'needing a break', she has plenty of that already. It's fair for OP to say she cant manage. on her own holiday, at a cottage. She looks after niece at home and that's enough. Presumably she only needs to pay for any damages etc if she rents the place?

AuntMarch · 22/08/2023 08:29

Is it not common for people to fo more with the necessary and nephews their own children are closer to? I don't see why it would necessarily be equal between all cousins in any family. You only invite other peoples kids on holiday if it is going to make life easier!

Gymmum82 · 22/08/2023 08:27

No one is owed childcare. You’ve already looked after your niece for a weekend at your mums house which is plenty when you’re only here for a months holiday.

It sounds like your sister gets more respite than most people in her situation. Care during the week day. Care every weekend. Care so she can go on holiday alone.
I understand that it must be so difficult for her raising her child alone. But that doesn’t mean she is owed childcare when you already have your own children to care for. What would happen if you did take her to the cottage and were distracted by your own children and she injured herself or worse. Who would be to blame then? Personally I couldn’t take that responsibility, if something happened to my own children on my watch that’s on me. But if something happened to someone else’s. Particularly when the chance of that happening is very high. I wouldn’t be prepared to take on that

ShepherdMoons · 22/08/2023 08:26

It doesn't sound practical for you to look after your dn. I think it must be hard for your dsis though and, if I were you, I'd try to support her emotionally. Also, maybe try to find a way that you can all have a break together that might involve you looking after dn for a shorter period of time. If her child has severe special needs it must be difficult for her to cope.

VisitorDilemma · 22/08/2023 08:22

Jellycatspyjamas · 22/08/2023 00:17

My dsis has always acted as if her child should be more important because of her disability, psychologically I think it makes her feel better her DD takes priority.

You really can’t imagine how relentless and stressful and heartbreaking it is to have a child who has significant additional support needs, who is likely to never live independently? I very much doubt your sister feels better for knowing she’ll never really be done parenting a small child in an increasingly big body.

Its clear you don’t want to take your niece, so don’t but a bit of empathy for your sister - who didn’t chose this for herself or her daughter - wouldn’t go amiss.

These are children. Not chores, or problems - actual children who should still benefit from family relationships, support and care. Your niece will be excluded from everything from parties, to activities, social events, school and, yes, holidays because of her disability. I don’t blame her mum for asking you to treat her equally to her cousins, and I don’t blame you for not wanting the hassle but you don’t need to spend time pointing out how much help your sister gets in a situation that you can’t cope with - she deserves all the respite anyone can give her.

I agree with this.

Spendonsend · 22/08/2023 08:21

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 08:18

Maybe he would enjoy spending time and sharing experiences with his DW and DCs without having any extra stress? You know, like a holiday or something?

It was the way it was phrased in the OP. It sounded like it was beyond his capabilities, but I see they updated to say he was capable but wanted to spend time together. Which is a totally different reason and fair enough.

CherryMaDeara · 22/08/2023 08:20

Spendonsend · 22/08/2023 08:14

I dont really have much of an opinion on whether you should take your niece to the cottage or not. I lean towards thinking if you cant cope with her its not a suitable arrangement for her or you. Which is disappointing for niece and sister but understandable.

I am more surprised that your poor DH cant cope his own with two NT primary aged children all alone though.

OP has explained that her DH is the main caregiver to their kids.

fearfuloffluff · 22/08/2023 08:19

Do your other sisters spend time with the dn?

fearfuloffluff · 22/08/2023 08:19

Not easy for your sister. When they're small there's less of a distinction between NT and SN children because they're all dependent and need constant monitoring but as they grow, it becomes clear the SN children will continue to need that monitoring but are also more challenging to manage physically.

It's sad but the difference between the children will only grow as they get older.

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 08:18

Spendonsend · 22/08/2023 08:14

I dont really have much of an opinion on whether you should take your niece to the cottage or not. I lean towards thinking if you cant cope with her its not a suitable arrangement for her or you. Which is disappointing for niece and sister but understandable.

I am more surprised that your poor DH cant cope his own with two NT primary aged children all alone though.

Maybe he would enjoy spending time and sharing experiences with his DW and DCs without having any extra stress? You know, like a holiday or something?

MrsMarzetti · 22/08/2023 08:16

You are right by refusing to take your niece. Your sister by the sound of it has plenty of time away from her child. Yes her lot is unfair but that is life. You seem a very kind person taking your nephews and nieces, do your sisters and mother offer to take your children for a weekend ?

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 08:15

From my years of experience of parents of SN children, some can be extremely selfish- completely understandable given their circumstances but if someone expected me to give up my precious holidays which are already stressful with small children, so that they can be completely alone like they are every week and most weekends I would be telling them exactly where to go. It sounds like she gets all the respite she needs and more by leaning on your DM. She gets respite from her DD every weekend, and DD is in school 5 days a week. You're doing enough as it is helping her out for a day here and there. If your DSis is so desperate for DD to spend time with her cousins then she could join the trip too, the support would be shared.

Spendonsend · 22/08/2023 08:14

I dont really have much of an opinion on whether you should take your niece to the cottage or not. I lean towards thinking if you cant cope with her its not a suitable arrangement for her or you. Which is disappointing for niece and sister but understandable.

I am more surprised that your poor DH cant cope his own with two NT primary aged children all alone though.

ASDMumof2 · 22/08/2023 08:13

Imagine being non verbal yet you understand everything everyone is saying. It must be awful. That poor child. She smashes a glass to get attention because she can't be heard :(

Honestly I'd get your DSis to try earphones to see if removing some aspect of stimuli helps. They helped my DD - she is ND - bright never stops talking but gets overwhelmed.

I think you're right, your DSis should be with you all. Passing her DD to you so she gets time out is just wrong, she can and should use social care for that. But a nice family break with you sounds so much nicer and more inclusive.

Should you take your DN on her own? No. You're not trained to support her which is why it's so hard for you and affects your young DCs - no doubt stresses you and her all out.

Watch the film Why I Jump. It's hugely eye opening into the world of non verbal kids with ASD - obvs your DN might nit be ASD, but I think it'll help you understand her frustration better.

Well done for helping your DSis out where you can x

whatkatydid2013 · 22/08/2023 08:11

I understand how you feel OP and it’s really tricky. One of my younger daughters school friends has a twin that sounds similar (non verbal, engages minimally with activities, wanders off and does pouring of stuff/smearing with food etc). When we invite her friend over we typically invite both girls as I’m very aware her twin is rarely included and that seems so unfair. It’s hard though. Normally if we invite a couple of friends after school the kids can be left to play for a bit while OH is sorting laundry & I’m making dinner. We often get 15 mins for a peaceful drink and chat then we all eat together and maybe watch a cartoon or play a board game or similar. It’s probably marginally less effort than just having our own kids as they mainly don’t need or want our input. If we invite the twins then one of us has to juggle all the jobs and the other has to keep an eye on her. Similar to your niece when we haven’t she’s done things like empty a full bottle of oil on the floor I had out on the side to cook with or picked up some food we planned to cook with and smeared onto the wall. For an evening it’s not a big deal but I’d really struggle to manage for a week. I think as well it’s a very different thing to look after a child that isn’t your own and that you don’t see super regularly. You won’t necessarily know the best options for managing difficult behaviour and likely can’t employ the same strategies you do with your NT children. Your family will be used to a certain pattern of activities that it may not be feasible to follow and disrupting that may make your own children act out. Your niece may feel super unsettled in a different environment with people she can’t know all that well if you only visit annually and be more likely to behave in ways that are challenging to manage. In your position I’d likely suggest a compromise that sister comes with niece for a couple of nights to help get her settled and then you have her stay over a couple of additional days & 1/2 nights on her own so your sister gets a break. I’d probably also do the weekend at parents to give them a break. Ideally that would also be before the cottage stay and after a family get together so your niece has spent that time with you. I think though it’s wholly understandable you’d be happy to have other nieces for a longer stay as it’s likely reducing work for you and DH vs massively increasing it and it’s also giving the cousins a chance to get to know each other. I’d want to find a way for my niece to participate so my kids and I also got to know her but without it leading to loads of stress and tension. I do wonder how much time those who say you are awful currently spend doing unpaid care for someone else’s SN child while also managing their own families needs. I’d be not at all surprised if most don’t do it and have never done it.

reluctantlondoner · 22/08/2023 08:11

This is an incredibly tough situation for everyone and there is not an easy answer.

Your sister has a drawn an exceptionally unlucky lot in life. I think as her sister if you can do what you can to help her then you should try to where you can. I can understand why she has become a bit selfish / difficult due to her situation. It's just pretty shit isn't it. Thank your lucky stars it isn't you.

But I totally get why it's hard for you to take her to the cottage. It's kind that you're asking on here for ideas and considering alternatives. You are a good and generous person. Perhaps it's something you could consider again for short periods when your own children are older.

To the ignorant people on here saying upsetting things about children with disabilities, you really have no idea. Some of the posts on here are pretty heartbreaking. Be glad it didn't happen to you. It can and does happen to anyone and there is VERY little formal respite available from "the council" or anyone else. Where I am "respite" looks like family days out at farms / adventure playgrounds with loads of other hard work SEN kids there where the parents also have to attend. It is hardly respite, quite the opposite in fact.

OhmygodDont · 22/08/2023 08:11

Sister sounds like she gets plenty of respite it’s the ops mother who needs the rest.

CherryMaDeara · 22/08/2023 08:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Can you quote what OP has said that makes you think this? Because i can’t see anything that shoes OP is like this.

bryceQ · 22/08/2023 08:11

I have a son with severe autism I would never expect my sister to take him. I would expect to join with my son and maybe my sister spend time with him and I could have a coffee to myself but that's it! I really don't think you're being unreasonable.

CherryMaDeara · 22/08/2023 08:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

LookItsMeAgain · 22/08/2023 08:10

Your sister needs respite care for her daughter - why not try to help her find suitable locations that offer just that - a respite holiday for your niece and if it is feasible, could you suggest that you would be willing to pay 50% of the cost of the holiday?
The cottage isn't niece-proofed so your sister has to get the idea of going to the cottage out of her head. but there may be alternatives that would suit your sister and you.

Would that be something that you could talk about.

CherryMaDeara · 22/08/2023 08:10

And there’s no way I would be spending my holiday in the UK looking after dsis’s child. She sounds extremely entitled. Glad your DH has put his foot down.

Heppygum · 22/08/2023 08:09

I don't think excluding your niece completely is fair but if you've invited your niece with your sister and she's rejected this as she wants respite that's a different thing altogether. Just be clear with her that you love her and your niece but you are not able to be her dd's carer for the reasons you've explained. Sounds like sister is burnt out and need of support and respite but you aren't the right person to provide this.