Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not helping my dsis with her SN child

440 replies

Ghostedbyfriend · 21/08/2023 22:54

Not UK based, but would go back for one month during the summer. During the summer holidays,I have watched the children of other siblings. Took one NT niece for 5 days to our summer cottage, and another NT niece for 4 days whilst the siblings worked. We have children ourselves.
One sibling who is a single mum has a SN child (10), non verbal with challenging behaviour. Said child gets daytime support whilst my dsis works, however she thinks I am being unfair as summer cottage would be more fun. But I explained that I couldn’t keep my SN niece safe, because she’s a darter and she does not listen. When she was younger and smaller I would watch her for 3-4 days, but now that she’s more grown and larger (overweight) I can’t simply lift her out of “situations”. Sibling acts all hurt her child is being excluded from fun and not treated equally. In my defence, I did watch her over one weekend to give my dsis respite, but apparently that was not enough as I did not take her to the cottage. I watched her at my mother’s house, whilst my dm was busy with gardening and cooking etc (she usually watches my SN niece during the weekend).
Whenever I watch SN niece, my DH has to take full charge of our DCs as SN niece needs 110% attention, it’s simply not fair on my DH, my kids are primary aged. For example when I was talking to dsis over a cup of tea, my niece took a glass she was drinking from and threw it on the tiled floor shattering glasses everywhere. She threw it on purpose, for attention I think.
Yet, my dsis thinks I am being unreasonable for not giving her one week of respite (she thinks watching her child at night is a lot of work)… My DH has put his foot down, he asked me not to bring my SN niece to the cottage as she’s a lot of work and disturbs our family dynamic whereas the other nieces play well with our DCs.
I do feel very guilty of not helping my sis out but I also feel my DH won’t be able to cope. It’s our holiday after all. So AIBU?

OP posts:
WedRine · 22/08/2023 09:57

The sister can't even cope with her own daughter full time, with either school or her parents stepping in to help. And that's in a supposedly adapted, safer environment where she has all her toys etc, and yet she expects the OP to step in and look after her daughter for longer than she does, in a brand-new, non-adapted environment where there'll be more emphasis on making their own fun and she'll have more kids too look after than her sister does . The OP has even offered to take her DN so long as the sister comes too but the sister won't because she wants to absolve herself from any parental responsibility at all. The sister is in a sad situation but she's a complete CF.

OoopsOhNo · 22/08/2023 09:57

OK, making several assumptions but if the child (like most disabled children from my experience) gets up at 5am every day and goes to bed at 10pm but is in school or respite from 8-4 (being generous) the mum is caring 9 hours a day Monday to Friday, and that's assuming no night wake ups, which is rare in my experience. = 45 hours in working week.

On the weekends child is with her grandmother, I'm going to assume she is again dropped off at 8am on Saturday and picked up at 4pm Sunday = another 9 hours weekend care.

= 54 hours a week even with respite, every week

I'd also imagine that the respite / school doesn't operate bank holidays and across all 52 weeks of the year. I'd be surprised if the child's grandmother cares for her every single weekend or takes her for more than 1 week of holiday a year, but could well be wrong there.

I'm definitely not saying that OP should have to take this child for any time at all but I'm feeling a bit defensive on behalf of the sister with all the "how much respite does she need?" type comments.

AllOfThemWitches · 22/08/2023 09:57

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:03

I don't know how much more help you think is reasonable. DSis only has DD at night and holidays without her.

I don't think any help is reasonable hence I don't bother asking for it? Literally what I said.

TheDuchessOfMN · 22/08/2023 09:56

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. You’ve asked her to come and stay with her child?

You admit that you feel unable to meet your niece’s needs and keep her safe. I don’t think you should feel any guilt for feeling that way and admitting to it.

I really feel for your sister but it sounds like she already has quite a lot of family support.

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:53

@OoopsOhNo I'm pretty sure the OP's mum is probably feeling like that too.

Nobody is saying that it's not hard. People are saying the DSis needs help, but she has help, and the OP has helped. People are saying that the DD is being excluded because of her disability. She's not being excluded because of her disability, she's being excluded because the DSis isn't facilitating time with her cousins, she wants someone to give her even more time to herself and they don't have the skills to do that 1:1, especially as DD gets older.

If you have SN DC, you know that as their parent that you are better equipped to manage them, keep them safe and comfortable than anyone else would be. Wouldn't you be happy to do that so that your DC could bond with their family (maybe allowing their family a chance to improve their skills too) rather than just leave them to muddle through it alone so you could have yet more time to yourself?

notlucreziaborgia · 22/08/2023 09:51

OoopsOhNo · 22/08/2023 09:42

And yet, we have no idea what OP's sister's mornings, evenings and nights look like. I mean, having similar children I have some idea but it coild be really, really difficult.

Also, nobody in this family, except the sister, will have to wake up every day knowing that they will have to do this for the best part of another decade, if not much longer. Taking the child, voluntarily, for a week, or even most weekends also isn't comparable.

No, it isn’t comparable, but the sister having it hard does not mean OP has any responsibility here. It’s not her fault she’s ‘got it easy’ any more than it’s the sister’s fault that she’s got it hard.

Spendonsend · 22/08/2023 09:51

I dont think any of us are in position to say or know how much respite is enough or how much help someone needs. Its not a logical thing. Its about how an individual is coping. My DH had a total nervous breakdown just from the stress of thinking about our SN childs future and dealing with the LA around schools, even though I was the primary carer and he had plenty of respite from actual day to day care, including business trips away from home, he wasnt coping and fell apart. He spent 9 months unable to do anthing but therapy and I wish we"d all understood the emotial side more and how things like perceived rejections of our child impacted him. Respite is about what you need to cope rather than what other people think is average or enough.

notlucreziaborgia · 22/08/2023 09:49

ElizabethBennetsBoots · 22/08/2023 09:08

I can see both sides here too. Keeping DN safe does sound hard, but the way you talk about her is hard to read. She's still just a child, if you try to look beyond the disability and the challenges. And she likely does things like push glasses over due to impulse control rather that just 'for attention '...it's often hard for sen kids to match up.cause and effect.
OP, I know it's easier to ignore disability and exclude it from your lovely nice family hollibobs, but just take a minute to think what you're teaching your own children. You're showing them that disabled people aren't worth helping, that only one way of being is worth supporting, and that anyone who is different must be cut out. Surely there is a compromise you could reach? Or just don't take any cousins and be fair? It's so sad when disabled DC are left out.

Or she’ll be teaching them to avoid heading over to the UK for holidays in the future, unless they want them to be hijacked.

The DH has quite reasonably said no. They’ve come over to spend time together as a family, not to be divided with one spending their time looking after their own kids, and the other providing childcare for the niece. It doesn’t even sound like OP even wants to do it, she just feels guilt for not.

Ohthatsabitshit · 22/08/2023 09:46

I think @Ghostedbyfriend should do whatever she likes but be honest with herself about what she’s doing. Including disabled people in any real way in your family will take work, helping you sister will take work. Resources are limited, be they time or effort and when allocating them if you give everyone the same the one who needs more just to attend will miss out. You don’t need to minimise what dsis does or inflate the help she already gets or any of that.

CherryMaDeara · 22/08/2023 09:44

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 08:33

Parents of kids with SEN don't ever get to be selfish. That's the point. I've actually had people ask me to mind their kids (who never mind mine), claiming they 'will be easy next to mine'. Could do without this selfishness myself.

I think you have some very CF friends, I hope you say no.

But I do think OP’s sister is getting to be selfish quite a lot. Having her DM look after her child all weekend every weekend and every time she goes on holiday is extremely selfish.

Stoptheworldpls · 22/08/2023 09:44

Just because someone is your sister you don't through out demands like that.
There is no way I would put my own family in that position.

OoopsOhNo · 22/08/2023 09:42

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:24

It's really disingenuous to edit my post like that. The OPs DSis gets infinitely more help than most parents of SN children, and has more time to herself than any I've heard of.

And yet, we have no idea what OP's sister's mornings, evenings and nights look like. I mean, having similar children I have some idea but it coild be really, really difficult.

Also, nobody in this family, except the sister, will have to wake up every day knowing that they will have to do this for the best part of another decade, if not much longer. Taking the child, voluntarily, for a week, or even most weekends also isn't comparable.

RhymesWithTangerine · 22/08/2023 09:41

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 08:33

Parents of kids with SEN don't ever get to be selfish. That's the point. I've actually had people ask me to mind their kids (who never mind mine), claiming they 'will be easy next to mine'. Could do without this selfishness myself.

But what’s your point in this context @ThickSkinnedSoWhat ? OP should put her family and their holiday second and look after the DN in an environment that ever DN’s mum said would be too challenging for her? And it would be ‘selfish’ to do otherwise?

CleverLilViper · 22/08/2023 09:29

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 00:03

I was understanding until I read this. I am a lone parent myself to a child with SEN. Whilst I understand it may be more difficult for others, or 'a chore' in your words, imagine living like this 24/7 with no break or support. I love my DC but I would be lying if I said it wouldn't be nice to have family who helped with a bit of support every now and then. I certainly wouldn't appreciate my own being referred to as a chore and not a joy. I find that very insulting and excluding, which coincidentally happens every single day when it comes to SEN. Exclusion. Yes help shouldn't be expected, but you are excluding her and calling her a chore compared to other nieces or nephews and she may pick up on being excluded.

Her DM has her DN every weekend.

Her DSIS also has holidays away from DN. it sounds like the sister gets a ton of support and just wants more and more people to fob her daughter off on.

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:24

OoopsOhNo · 22/08/2023 09:20

"Most people don't have most weekends and holidays without their children." @MollyRover please don't compare the care of typically developing children to that of disabled children- it's just not comparable.

Look at it this way, in a typical classroom there can be ratios of 1:30 allowed, for some disabled children they have 1:1 or even 2:1 across all school hours for safety. Often those same children then go home, sometimes to their single parent families.

It's really disingenuous to edit my post like that. The OPs DSis gets infinitely more help than most parents of SN children, and has more time to herself than any I've heard of.

OoopsOhNo · 22/08/2023 09:20

"Most people don't have most weekends and holidays without their children." @MollyRover please don't compare the care of typically developing children to that of disabled children- it's just not comparable.

Look at it this way, in a typical classroom there can be ratios of 1:30 allowed, for some disabled children they have 1:1 or even 2:1 across all school hours for safety. Often those same children then go home, sometimes to their single parent families.

Jamtartforme · 22/08/2023 09:18

fitzwilliamdarcy · 22/08/2023 09:17

Oh good, another one of those threads where posters ignore that the child’s other parent has absolved himself of responsibility because they’re too busy berating a woman without parental responsibility for not #beingkind.

YANBU OP. Your sister’s lot sounds really hard but it’s not on you to solve it for her.

How would it help to rant about it when op is looking for advice on a separate issue?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 22/08/2023 09:17

Oh good, another one of those threads where posters ignore that the child’s other parent has absolved himself of responsibility because they’re too busy berating a woman without parental responsibility for not #beingkind.

YANBU OP. Your sister’s lot sounds really hard but it’s not on you to solve it for her.

MillWood85 · 22/08/2023 09:15

My concern out of this is for your Mum. How on earth is she going to manage as she gets older?

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:14

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 09:10

'Having time to go to work all week' is hardly respite though is it? It is going from one draining situation to the next. When my own DC attends school, I am at university. I myself get positively sick of people telling me that's 'a break', 'respite' or 'time to myself'. It is hardly the same as a haircut, or any form of self care. Whilst I appreciate, fair enough, she has time to herself occasionally other than at work, something I don't have, I would not call working full time 'respite'.

What about the weekends and the holidays without DD? That's not occasionally, that's routinely.

I know having DC with profound SN is very difficult but it doesn't sound to me like DSis is in need of anymore help at all. Most people don't have most weekends and holidays without their children. DSis is demanding that OP takes DD for a week!!

Pollyputhekettleon · 22/08/2023 09:13

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 09:10

'Having time to go to work all week' is hardly respite though is it? It is going from one draining situation to the next. When my own DC attends school, I am at university. I myself get positively sick of people telling me that's 'a break', 'respite' or 'time to myself'. It is hardly the same as a haircut, or any form of self care. Whilst I appreciate, fair enough, she has time to herself occasionally other than at work, something I don't have, I would not call working full time 'respite'.

It's not just occasional outside of work. Her DM takes her every weekend including nights, the occasional weekday night, and when DSis goes on holidays. People are reading their own incredibly difficult situations into this when the fact is it's not the same.

ElizabethBennetsBoots · 22/08/2023 09:13

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:10

She doesn't have to be excluded, DSis is the one excluding her. She can go to the cottage and care taking could be shared, DD would have all the time she wants or is able for with her cousins. DSis wants her taken off her hands and that's it.

I see your point and yes ideally DSis should take her, but we don't know how hard it is for her right now. If you've never raised sen kids, you have literally no.idea.

ElizabethBennetsBoots · 22/08/2023 09:11

And when you say 'DSis says its hard at night to look after DN...', believe her. Nighttime care can be really hard and totally exhausting.

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 22/08/2023 09:10

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 08:36

@ThickSkinnedSoWhat so what do you make of DSis having time to go to work all week because DD is at school, time to herself all weekend because DM looks after DD and holidays without DD? Isn't that enough respite?

'Having time to go to work all week' is hardly respite though is it? It is going from one draining situation to the next. When my own DC attends school, I am at university. I myself get positively sick of people telling me that's 'a break', 'respite' or 'time to myself'. It is hardly the same as a haircut, or any form of self care. Whilst I appreciate, fair enough, she has time to herself occasionally other than at work, something I don't have, I would not call working full time 'respite'.

MollyRover · 22/08/2023 09:10

ElizabethBennetsBoots · 22/08/2023 09:08

I can see both sides here too. Keeping DN safe does sound hard, but the way you talk about her is hard to read. She's still just a child, if you try to look beyond the disability and the challenges. And she likely does things like push glasses over due to impulse control rather that just 'for attention '...it's often hard for sen kids to match up.cause and effect.
OP, I know it's easier to ignore disability and exclude it from your lovely nice family hollibobs, but just take a minute to think what you're teaching your own children. You're showing them that disabled people aren't worth helping, that only one way of being is worth supporting, and that anyone who is different must be cut out. Surely there is a compromise you could reach? Or just don't take any cousins and be fair? It's so sad when disabled DC are left out.

She doesn't have to be excluded, DSis is the one excluding her. She can go to the cottage and care taking could be shared, DD would have all the time she wants or is able for with her cousins. DSis wants her taken off her hands and that's it.