Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get rid of the dining table?

35 replies

FatBurger · 21/08/2023 21:33

Ok, so hardly the AIBU of the century!

We had an extension 12 months ago which has an island that seats 8 comfortably..since having the kitchen extension we've used the dining table once, for Christmas dinner (10 people). We always eat at the island, kids included.

The dining room is largely a toy storage room now. With the dining table in there's not enough room for a comfortable chair or sofa as well and hardly enough floor space for the kids (4&7) to play so they end up dragging all their toys through to the lounge or kitchen (which has a sofa area) because it's where the floor space, and we, are.

I'm proposing to remove the dining table (it's an extendable one) and replace it with a comfortable chair and a rug. But will I regret it? For the one or 2 times a year we'll use it we could get a trestle table and store it in the garage.

The current dining table is too heavy and cumbersome to take apart and store when not in use.

So WIBU to get rid of it?

YANBU - Get rid, you don't need it

YABU - Think of Christmas

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Murphs1 · 24/08/2023 00:34

And also would appreciate the link to the comfy stools. Mine are from dunelm but have to say my 75 year old dad sits on them over my sofa more time than not.

Murphs1 · 24/08/2023 00:32

I agree, we have a kitchen diner with a big breakfast bar, we all eat at the breakfast bar. Even when more people than stools we end up dragging the dining room chairs up to the breakfast bar!!
Im looking at ways to make the dining area more useable, but as a PP said, is very useful area for the kids doing homework.

LoveBluey · 24/08/2023 00:22

@FatBurger can you share a link to your bar stools/seats? I'm on the lookout for some comfy ones!

HeddaGarbled · 23/08/2023 23:51

But …. but …. don’t you ever have anyone over 50 round?

FatBurger · 23/08/2023 23:40

Angie147836 · 23/08/2023 08:48

Get rid of it now but prepare to re-buy in a few years when the kids get towards exam years or if someone gets a WFH job. Our dining room has never seen so much use as the last three years!

We both work from home permanently, so have already got that set up thankfully.

OP posts:
annahay · 23/08/2023 09:14

@Xrays amazing!

Xrays · 23/08/2023 09:12

annahay · 23/08/2023 09:01

I love that you have indoor Guinea pigs! My rabbits used to live indoors when they were little but we have them outside now. I do miss them being in the living room with us.

😊 I love having them indoors as they are so much more interactive and part of the family. They are also a good fridge alarm - if they hear the fridge door open they wheek like their lives depend on it! 😆(No one can get away with having a sneaky chocolate without giving them a veggie snack at the same time)!

annahay · 23/08/2023 09:01

Xrays · 23/08/2023 08:49

I think it’s important you live for your life. What I mean is who cares what others do or what you feel you “should” do - don’t have a dining table if you’re not going to use it. We have a huge kitchen / diner - nearly 30ft long. When we first did it we had a dining table but we are all neurodiverse and can’t stand sitting eating at a table - sensory reasons, too confrontational etc and we all eat at different times - we do however eat out quite a bit and can manage sitting at a table then so didn’t see it as important to us. We all eat on the sofa in the living room, plates on our laps etc. So we got rid of it and got a huge Guinea pig indoor set up instead 😆 People who come round (few and far between, we don’t have a lot of people coming in anyway) are horrified and think we’re all weird but really who cares? It’s our house, we’re the only ones here. We never have dinner parties or people over for Christmas. It’s important to be happy in your own home.

I love that you have indoor Guinea pigs! My rabbits used to live indoors when they were little but we have them outside now. I do miss them being in the living room with us.

Xrays · 23/08/2023 08:49

I think it’s important you live for your life. What I mean is who cares what others do or what you feel you “should” do - don’t have a dining table if you’re not going to use it. We have a huge kitchen / diner - nearly 30ft long. When we first did it we had a dining table but we are all neurodiverse and can’t stand sitting eating at a table - sensory reasons, too confrontational etc and we all eat at different times - we do however eat out quite a bit and can manage sitting at a table then so didn’t see it as important to us. We all eat on the sofa in the living room, plates on our laps etc. So we got rid of it and got a huge Guinea pig indoor set up instead 😆 People who come round (few and far between, we don’t have a lot of people coming in anyway) are horrified and think we’re all weird but really who cares? It’s our house, we’re the only ones here. We never have dinner parties or people over for Christmas. It’s important to be happy in your own home.

Angie147836 · 23/08/2023 08:48

Get rid of it now but prepare to re-buy in a few years when the kids get towards exam years or if someone gets a WFH job. Our dining room has never seen so much use as the last three years!

CoffeeCantata · 23/08/2023 08:43

Go for it. We did this because we have a kitchen table for family use (seats 5 or 6 at a push). For years our dining room was taken up with a massive antique table which for most of the time was just used as a dumping ground for all kinds of stuff.

We bought one of those folding tables which seats 8 and we get it out when necessary, cover it in long table cloths etc and no-one is any the wiser. It lives behind a wardrobe when not needed and the dining room is now a calm and attractive space with seating away from the TV etc etc.

We'e never regretted it!

NotTheSlugandLettuce · 22/08/2023 20:30

Will no one think of Christmas !!!

Iknowthis1 · 22/08/2023 19:50

It's not like, for example, getting rid of a bath, where it's a big deal if you regret it. If you miss the table put it back. It's worth at least trying not having a table.

FatBurger · 22/08/2023 19:48

And thanks for all the links, I'll take a look

OP posts:
FatBurger · 22/08/2023 19:48

jannier · 22/08/2023 14:25

I think the toys will still come through to wherever you are.

I'm not bothered about that so much. But if I had space for a comfy chair or sofa in the play room I would spend more time in there rather than the sofa in the kitchen.

OP posts:
FatBurger · 22/08/2023 19:46

jannier · 22/08/2023 14:23

Me too I leave rather than sit on one if we're eating out ....why can't breakfast bars be a normal height? If I turned up to someone's house and had to sit on one I'd hate it.

I won't sit on them when out. Hate them generally, but love ours! We hadn't got rid of the table before as I expected to keep using it. The bar stools were more for people to perch whilst I'm cooking or the kids to do crafts on. But we love them!

We did consider one of those step down tables attached to the island, but I wanted more prep space and a normal height table would have killed my back.

OP posts:
jannier · 22/08/2023 14:25

FatBurger · 21/08/2023 21:33

Ok, so hardly the AIBU of the century!

We had an extension 12 months ago which has an island that seats 8 comfortably..since having the kitchen extension we've used the dining table once, for Christmas dinner (10 people). We always eat at the island, kids included.

The dining room is largely a toy storage room now. With the dining table in there's not enough room for a comfortable chair or sofa as well and hardly enough floor space for the kids (4&7) to play so they end up dragging all their toys through to the lounge or kitchen (which has a sofa area) because it's where the floor space, and we, are.

I'm proposing to remove the dining table (it's an extendable one) and replace it with a comfortable chair and a rug. But will I regret it? For the one or 2 times a year we'll use it we could get a trestle table and store it in the garage.

The current dining table is too heavy and cumbersome to take apart and store when not in use.

So WIBU to get rid of it?

YANBU - Get rid, you don't need it

YABU - Think of Christmas

I think the toys will still come through to wherever you are.

jannier · 22/08/2023 14:23

Vettrianofan · 22/08/2023 13:46

Same here. I would need a hoist to get in and out of one because of my arthritic hips😆

Me too I leave rather than sit on one if we're eating out ....why can't breakfast bars be a normal height? If I turned up to someone's house and had to sit on one I'd hate it.

Hillarious · 22/08/2023 14:15

The tables recommended by @50fedup look good. I couldn't NOT have a dining table, but they look like a good option for Christmas. I work for an organisation which hosts very special dinners, and their table are nothing to write home about. However, once dressed with tablecloths etc, you'd have no inkling of what's underneath.

TheDogsMother · 22/08/2023 13:54

The layout of our open plan space doesn't allow for a permanent table so we got one of these and had a longer top made for it. It sits against the wall most of the time but can seat up to 8 when needed.

https://www.laredoute.co.uk/ppdp/prod-324396722.aspx#searchkeyword=Console%20Tables%20ampm&shoppingtool=brandpage

Vettrianofan · 22/08/2023 13:46

MrsJamin · 21/08/2023 23:28

Can I just say I bloody hate sitting at bar stools round an island. If you have people round for dinner they might also want to be able to put their feet on the floor whilst eating.

Same here. I would need a hoist to get in and out of one because of my arthritic hips😆

UniversalTruth · 22/08/2023 13:45

You don't need a 10 seater fold away table, you need a 4 seater kids table or how ever you want to split the group for Christmas surely.

FoggyDay58 · 22/08/2023 13:41

FatBurger · 22/08/2023 13:02

We bought bar stools that are particularly comfy, as we knew they'd be used a lot. People have commented on how good they are (unprompted). They aren't suitable for everyone or every occasion, which is why I want an alternative, I just don't need the alternative taking up space all the time.

Off topic I know, but can you say more about the bar stools? Yours sound like the dream. Picture, or even a link, would be great.

PS yes, ditch the dining table.

CantFindTheBeat · 22/08/2023 13:06

We've done the same thing, OP.

Only thing we have to do is beg & borrow chairs for Christmas, as we have room to store the table, but not 10 dining chairs.