Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi Sunak and Lucy Lenny Case

246 replies

BackAgainstWall · 21/08/2023 19:25

Why on earth didn’t Rishi Sunak rush to change the law to make it mandatory for offenders to appear in court at sentencing.

One would assume he has known about the Lucy Letby case for months, if not years. As usual with this government, the horse has already bolted.

Why doesn’t he want a statutory inquiry into the Lucy Letby case, where witnesses are legally compelled to present evidence?

Why would he want to rush it and in my opinion miss facts/gloss over such harrowing events?

It’s a complete insult to those poor parents and consultants.

OP posts:
DrManhattan · 22/08/2023 08:51

@Cyclingmug you sound like a mug who cycles. And probably votes Tory but doesn't tell anyone. The shame.

Kendodd · 22/08/2023 08:51

It's a terrible idea to do that.
Can you imagine, the criminal would get centre stage to disrupt proceedings and possibly cause injury to the officers in charge of them. Plus, we're not in medieval times anymore.
A better idea is to stream the sentencing a witness impact statements into the cell where the prisoner is held.

Cyclingmug · 22/08/2023 08:51

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 22/08/2023 08:46

Change the law for a statutory inquiry yes, however Lucy letby won’t survive the year in jail so her being at her sentencing makes no difference. Her death will hopefully bring about the families some peace though.

Agree, I'd be surprised if she lives long either by her own hand or someone else's

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 22/08/2023 08:50

drpet49 · 22/08/2023 08:24

Nor me.

The argument is that a judge led statutory enquiry will take much longer than a non- statutory one so it will take longer for lessons to be learnt.
On balance I think it should be a statutory enquiry. I think the power to compel witnesses and the extra weight the recommendations would have outweighs the extra time it would take.

Cyclingmug · 22/08/2023 08:49

DrManhattan · 22/08/2023 08:20

Why would rishi sunak even care about us non billionaires? He is just Tory scum.

You sound like a student out of the Young Ones

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 22/08/2023 08:46

Change the law for a statutory inquiry yes, however Lucy letby won’t survive the year in jail so her being at her sentencing makes no difference. Her death will hopefully bring about the families some peace though.

OttoGraph · 22/08/2023 08:45

ChristmasKraken. go to any crown court near to you and see how video links in court work, its common place to include video links

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 22/08/2023 08:44

User8646382 · 21/08/2023 22:19

TV cameras in courts are a really bad idea. As if society hasn’t been damaged enough by reality television.

There are already TV cameras in the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.

OttoGraph · 22/08/2023 08:44

irrelevant in the case of LL but in other case if you don't appear in court to hear sentencing then you do not get parole until at least 2 years after your sentence ends, as prison is not a punishment but rehabilitation and how can you rehabilitate until you have faced your victims. Then they're would be any calls for early release after half your sentence is served as you're not allowed parole

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 22/08/2023 08:43

ChristmasKraken · 21/08/2023 21:17

I'm amused when I see people suggesting this. Are you imaging they have laptops/screens in their cells set up for a Teams call? Or are they going to wheel one in a la school in the 80s? Or give her a laptop for a bit? Can't see that going wrong at all....

They already use video links for some court proceedings. They may have a remand prisoner attend remotely from prison for case management hearings. The technology already exists. Courts also use video links for vulnerable witnesses to give evidence.

DarkForces · 22/08/2023 08:42

I think I'd rather we reframed sentencing about the chance for the victims/victim's families to be heard and made it as little to do with the criminal as possible. We've heard about them during the trial, this is the opportunity to really listen as a community and justice system to the people who were harmed. All this baying for blood seems pointless screaming into the void.
Lucy Letby would be easy to drag to court. She's a slight woman. We need to make laws that equally apply to all.

OttoGraph · 22/08/2023 08:39

Willmafrockfit · 21/08/2023 19:26

there was an interesting man on radio 4 who strong arm murderers and the like to court, only for them to shout and antagonize the victims in court - so that is another view point

do you have her name wrong on purpose?

They could be placed in a room and view by video camera - that way they could scream and shout all they like but be placed on mute

I recently attended a sentencing and one was on video camera and the other 3 were in a room at court.

TBH to be sat in a chair at a desk and be on camera the view was much clearer - as we could all see him cry as his sentence was given

twinklystar23 · 22/08/2023 08:37

I think having the statements heard from a prison or other cell designed for the purpose is the best idea so the victims are protected from the response of the criminal. Though I think it would have to be assessed on the risk to staff.
We need to be extremely careful of the right wing media and politicians who's intent to get rid of the Human rights act would affect us all. Ironically, article 8 of the HRA right to a fair trial equally belongs to victims, a right to challenge the state where cases are not brought to trial. The sentences handed to LL mean she will die in prison, she will never be free, justice has been served.

VeronicasCloset · 22/08/2023 08:36

Would you force a convicted criminal back in to court for sentencing if it gave them an opportunity to laugh at the victims family/families and say they enjoyed committing their crimes?

You can stop people doing things, but you cannot force anyone to do anything.

Zanatdy · 22/08/2023 08:33

Because Rishi didn’t know she wouldn’t appear for sentencing, he’s not a mind reader and the law doesn’t change quickly. There’s been a whole host of cases recently when defendants haven’t appeared in court. Even if the law changes they won’t be able to man handle defendants. They are talking about adding extra time onto sentences which will do nothing when it’s a whole life like Lucy Letby

TheYearOfSmallThings · 22/08/2023 08:30

Iam4eels · 21/08/2023 19:30

Knee-jerk changes to the law aren't the way forwards, law has to be emotionless in order to be just - have you never heard of the saying "hard cases make for bad law"?

100% agree. It is very important that changes in law are made after calm consideration and debate and not in anger or to appease the electorate.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 08:25

Luana1 · 21/08/2023 19:42

The sentence would remain the same but it may have given the parents of her victims a tiny bit of closure to see her listen to their victim statements and they could look her in the eye as she was sentenced.

And what if she laughed at them while the victim impact statements were read out? Or shouted obscenities at them? Would that help give them closure? Probably not.

While I can see how emotive it is, and why people might want an offender dragged in, I don't think it's necessarily going to be helpful for the victims/families.

drpet49 · 22/08/2023 08:24

EmmaPaella · 21/08/2023 19:29

I don’t understand why the inquiry is not statutory either.

Nor me.

DrManhattan · 22/08/2023 08:20

Why would rishi sunak even care about us non billionaires? He is just Tory scum.

WhenLifeGivesYouLimes · 22/08/2023 08:20

WetBandits · 21/08/2023 20:51

I don’t think she quite counts as human. She gave zero fucks about the human rights of the babies she murdered, why on earth should anyone care about hers? I’d quite like to play the victim impact statements at full volume over a tannoy in her cell, on repeat for the rest of her miserable days.

Again, that's not how human rights work. "Human rights for all! except those individuals over there because they don't count as human IMO"

I'm not a rights-based thinker myself, (I'm a left wing utilitarian) but if you are then everyone gets them.

MotherOfGodWeeFella · 22/08/2023 08:18

Iam4eels · 21/08/2023 19:30

Knee-jerk changes to the law aren't the way forwards, law has to be emotionless in order to be just - have you never heard of the saying "hard cases make for bad law"?

This. What does anyone think it would achieve to drag someone who knows they will get a whole life tariff into the courtroom? For some defendants, letting them know your feelings and emotions gives them power over you.

megletthesecond · 22/08/2023 08:16

They'd need to be drugged, handcuffed and gagged to make it safe. Even then I daresay some criminals could still be disruptive and cause more hurt. It wouldn't work.
This isn't a teenager who has stolen some cars where they might actually learn from it. People like Letby are so far gone that no one will get through to them.

JanieEyre · 22/08/2023 08:10

DreamItDoIt · 21/08/2023 20:07

Where the convicted won't attend court for anything, including sentencing, the proceedings should be live streamed to their cells. The court can chose to show them it not friending on his they are behaving. This way they are made to see and hear even if they don't want to.

You can't make anyone hear anything they don't want to. Given that during the hearing they haven't been convicted of anything, you can't handcuff and gag them throughout the trial, so there is nothing to stop them putting their fingers in their ears. Even if you did that during the sentencing, it can all be blocked out mentally.

JanieEyre · 22/08/2023 08:05

slithytoveisascientist · 22/08/2023 00:17

Streaming it to the holding cell in the court building makes the most sense - it doesn't have to be two way, the purpose is for the convicted to hear the sentencing and the victim impact statements.

No return video of the convicted needed.

I don't have a problem with this, but I don't really see the point. Streaming it to the cell still doesn't mean the prisoner will listen to it.

JanieEyre · 22/08/2023 08:03

Luana1 · 21/08/2023 19:42

The sentence would remain the same but it may have given the parents of her victims a tiny bit of closure to see her listen to their victim statements and they could look her in the eye as she was sentenced.

Face it, it wouldn't give them closure. Nothing will, sadly.

There has been at least one case of a prison officer escort being kicked to death. Making them force prisoners into court would put them at major risk which just isn't justified.