Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi Sunak and Lucy Lenny Case

246 replies

BackAgainstWall · 21/08/2023 19:25

Why on earth didn’t Rishi Sunak rush to change the law to make it mandatory for offenders to appear in court at sentencing.

One would assume he has known about the Lucy Letby case for months, if not years. As usual with this government, the horse has already bolted.

Why doesn’t he want a statutory inquiry into the Lucy Letby case, where witnesses are legally compelled to present evidence?

Why would he want to rush it and in my opinion miss facts/gloss over such harrowing events?

It’s a complete insult to those poor parents and consultants.

OP posts:
Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 20:17

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 20:08

I dont meet the requirements needed unfortunately but many young unemployed people will meet the requirements and get jobs.

You didn't explain why it was a stupid comment either

How was the poster supposed to know you wouldn't meet the requirements?

PinkCherryBlossoms · 22/08/2023 20:15

These last few posts are gold.

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 20:11

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 20:08

I dont meet the requirements needed unfortunately but many young unemployed people will meet the requirements and get jobs.

Recruitment is down, retention is down. the prison service is in crisis.

Young unemployed people don't necessarily want to risk assault, being made disabled or being killed for a public who doesnt give a shit about their safety and a poor salary funnily enough

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 20:08

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 20:05

The training is only 12 weeks. You would just need to apply like anyone else.

It's hardly a stupid comment. we don't have enough prison officers and if you feel so strongly that things should be done differently, for which we need more staff, why not be happy to help out?

I dont meet the requirements needed unfortunately but many young unemployed people will meet the requirements and get jobs.

Justanotherlurker · 22/08/2023 20:08

Lilithlogic · 22/08/2023 19:50

Can't help but think this call for her to be in court or have to watch/hear the sentencing, is more about the publics want to watch/hear about her reaction rather than her being punished etc.

Yeah, this is more for bystanders for the most part, I would expect if LL came out like T.J. Lane the Ohio School shooter did for his sentencing there would be uproar as well.

It isn't as though an extra life order for being as worse as possible as she could be is going to make any difference.

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 20:05

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 20:00

And how would I do that? What a stupid comment you make. Obviously trained professionals would be needed. Just like trained professionals arrest the accused and get the accused to court and prison.

The training is only 12 weeks. You would just need to apply like anyone else.

It's hardly a stupid comment. we don't have enough prison officers and if you feel so strongly that things should be done differently, for which we need more staff, why not be happy to help out?

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 20:01

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 19:39

Unpopular and unethical

To expect people to put their lives and health at risk for something that poses no risk to the public is not the moral high ground. It is the very opposite.

I wonder if you will feel the same if you have children who go into the prison service.

I would feel absolutely the same.

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 20:00

DarkForces · 22/08/2023 19:47

It's actually a very popular opinion but that doesn't mean it's right. If you want to drag reluctant criminals in front of court I suggest you give it a go yourself

And how would I do that? What a stupid comment you make. Obviously trained professionals would be needed. Just like trained professionals arrest the accused and get the accused to court and prison.

Lilithlogic · 22/08/2023 19:50

Can't help but think this call for her to be in court or have to watch/hear the sentencing, is more about the publics want to watch/hear about her reaction rather than her being punished etc.

DarkForces · 22/08/2023 19:47

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 19:29

“Bleating” - I’m happy to bleat in favour of taking the choice away from a murderer or any other type of serious criminal. Let them be told what to do. Arrests are made, prisoners are in imprisoned so in that logic it’s possible to get a criminal in court for sentencing. That’s my unpopular opinion but I stand by it.

It's actually a very popular opinion but that doesn't mean it's right. If you want to drag reluctant criminals in front of court I suggest you give it a go yourself

Wsmi · 22/08/2023 19:46

Because he is absolutely shit and not delivering anything he said he would. So now looking for brownie points.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 22/08/2023 19:42

It is quite interesting the number of people who, over the course of the multiple threads on the issue, have decided that because resources exist to put people in prison they also exist to drag uncooperative defendants to court. Like it's automatic.

I've given up hoping that any of them will give the slightest fuck about the prison and court staff, the lack of concern has become boring now. But this bit is still a curiosity.

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 19:39

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 19:29

“Bleating” - I’m happy to bleat in favour of taking the choice away from a murderer or any other type of serious criminal. Let them be told what to do. Arrests are made, prisoners are in imprisoned so in that logic it’s possible to get a criminal in court for sentencing. That’s my unpopular opinion but I stand by it.

Unpopular and unethical

To expect people to put their lives and health at risk for something that poses no risk to the public is not the moral high ground. It is the very opposite.

I wonder if you will feel the same if you have children who go into the prison service.

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 19:29

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 19:16

I understand from mumsnet that the majority view is to give murderers the choice on being at their sentencing

I think the majority view is that we would prefer not to put the officers at any further risk of injury or death for something where there is no risk to the wider public. They already risk their lives and health to keep us safe.

The average life expectancy of a prison officer is 20 years lower than that of an average man. I would prefer not to add to their burden just for the sake of a performance.

Many people have written eloquently on this and other threads about just how high them impact is on officers and their families and how dangerous it can be if a prisoner starts to kick off. And still people bleat "it must be possible to do something" safe in the knowledge that they aren't the ones being asked to do the "something".

We already have a retention and recruitment crisis in the prison service. If their jobs are made harder and more people leave I wonder if those of you adamant that this change is needed will volunteer to replace them or waffle on about "how hard can it be".

“Bleating” - I’m happy to bleat in favour of taking the choice away from a murderer or any other type of serious criminal. Let them be told what to do. Arrests are made, prisoners are in imprisoned so in that logic it’s possible to get a criminal in court for sentencing. That’s my unpopular opinion but I stand by it.

Laiste · 22/08/2023 19:19

My knee jerk reaction to this a couple of days ago was yes, bind them and grag them to court.

But i've changed my mind. Lots of reasons, but one thing struck me most: someone on a BBC interview said it's very rare and unlikely that the victim or their family ever get the 'satisfactory' reaction from the defendant that they may have set their hearts on. Total lack of remorse or often the simple total lack of any reaction at all can become an additional source of pain, and disappointment to them.

I don't think court is the place for the victims to look for comfort of any sort.

Out of interest, at the moment the 'right' of the defendant is to go court to hear their sentence. In refusal they are waiving that right.

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 19:16

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 18:56

I am interested to know what the people in charge of the justice system have for ideas on how to manage having the accused in court for sentencing. I understand from mumsnet that the majority view is to give murderers the choice on being at their sentencing. I say don’t give a murderer this choice. Different opinions. I think that the tax system could be better managed to meet the needs of the administration. Paying more into a broken system
wont fix it.

I understand from mumsnet that the majority view is to give murderers the choice on being at their sentencing

I think the majority view is that we would prefer not to put the officers at any further risk of injury or death for something where there is no risk to the wider public. They already risk their lives and health to keep us safe.

The average life expectancy of a prison officer is 20 years lower than that of an average man. I would prefer not to add to their burden just for the sake of a performance.

Many people have written eloquently on this and other threads about just how high them impact is on officers and their families and how dangerous it can be if a prisoner starts to kick off. And still people bleat "it must be possible to do something" safe in the knowledge that they aren't the ones being asked to do the "something".

We already have a retention and recruitment crisis in the prison service. If their jobs are made harder and more people leave I wonder if those of you adamant that this change is needed will volunteer to replace them or waffle on about "how hard can it be".

Laiste · 22/08/2023 19:11

@Locutus2000 They have similar eyes in their mugshots, Joanne Denneh and Lucy Letby.

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 18:56

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 18:40

Many of us don't believe the law needs to change

And if your only solution to potentially problematic behaviour is a soundproof booth in every court costing millions, then the cost of repairs and upkeep then yes the cost is a problem

Are you going to be agreed to be taxed more to pay for it?

I am interested to know what the people in charge of the justice system have for ideas on how to manage having the accused in court for sentencing. I understand from mumsnet that the majority view is to give murderers the choice on being at their sentencing. I say don’t give a murderer this choice. Different opinions. I think that the tax system could be better managed to meet the needs of the administration. Paying more into a broken system
wont fix it.

PegasusReturns · 22/08/2023 18:48

Posters suggesting allowing defendants to appear by way of video link have no idea of the depravity which people can sink too.

even with the sound off there is going to be no benefit to the victims.

I’ve had defendants strip; smear excrement; make lewd comments; masturbate; punch security staff; throw themselves on the ground; kiss their codefendant; attempt to escape; shout abuse. None of this is helpful to a victim

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 18:40

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 17:23

I mean that the cost of a solution to see serious criminals in court for their sentences is small when compared to the cost of life in prison.
As I understand it the cost is not the problem it’s that the law needs to be changed.

Many of us don't believe the law needs to change

And if your only solution to potentially problematic behaviour is a soundproof booth in every court costing millions, then the cost of repairs and upkeep then yes the cost is a problem

Are you going to be agreed to be taxed more to pay for it?

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/08/2023 17:30

Whatever it costs, I still see no purpose in it. It won't necessarily provide victims/families with the closure they are looking for, and in fact could do the opposite.

Seeing their child's murderer visibly laughing and smirking, potentially revelling in the pain they've caused, would be just as disruptive and upsetting to the families as hearing it.

Someone who commits a crime like this is not going to feel or display remorse/guilt in the way that you or I would. So trying to engineer a situation where this happens is doomed to failure.

ButterCrackers · 22/08/2023 17:23

Insommmmnia · 22/08/2023 15:18

You make it sound like somehow the soundproof booth will mean we don't need to pay for life in prison for some criminals

It's both though

And a soundproof both in every single court

There are 150 magistrates court

A sound proof both is approx 15k

So that's £2,250,000 just so you get to see the accused in court for sentencing.

Meanwhile we apparently cannot pay our teachers, police officers, prison service, doctors etc enough

How do you think the public would react to the proposition to spent that much public money on some sound proof booths?

I mean that the cost of a solution to see serious criminals in court for their sentences is small when compared to the cost of life in prison.
As I understand it the cost is not the problem it’s that the law needs to be changed.

WeetabixTowels · 22/08/2023 16:58

I’d really like to think our PM had more important matters, like children living in poverty, to worry about rather than predicting that a woman would be guilty and that she’d refuse to attend her sentencing therefore he has to scrabble to change the law simply so froth-mouthed revenge fantasist can get a kick knowing she was sat in a dock

StellaGibson2022 · 22/08/2023 16:46

Iam4eels · 22/08/2023 16:23

Impact statements aren't for the defendant to hear how the crime has affected the victims, they're for the judge to consider the impact when deliberating what sentence to deliver.

Ah, yes that does make sense.

will remember going forward.

Iam4eels · 22/08/2023 16:23

StellaGibson2022 · 22/08/2023 16:04

My thinking is was that the Witness Impact Statement is there so that those affected by the crime can share how their lives have been ruined (impacted). These are an important part of our court process.

If the sentencing was live streamed into the cell the audio would be the same as if you were in the dock.

I think for impact a laptop might be less effective, especially because cell doors are usually thick metal.

Impact statements aren't for the defendant to hear how the crime has affected the victims, they're for the judge to consider the impact when deliberating what sentence to deliver.