Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS won't show me my notes

221 replies

SnowWhiteAndTheTwoKids · 21/08/2023 18:34

I've had day surgery today, just a local anaesthetic, nothing major, it was done in 15 minutes. After the operation they said there were no doctors around to do my discharge paperwork so they would post it to me. They asked if I was okay with that or did I want to wait an unknown amount of hours for the paperwork. I said I was happy to get the paperwork in the post but please could I just have a quick look at my file? Nurse said "No, the notes are confidential." I said I just wanted to have a quick look at the info the consultant had added to my file and would give it right back to her. She went off and checked with a senior nurse then came back and said I would need to make a formal information request to see my file.
Why on earth would they be so cagey about this? When I gave birth I was given my notes to look through and it was all very transparent.
YABU - you should trust the NHS and not ask to see your notes.
YANBU - you should be able to read notes about yourself after an operation with wasting more NHS resources on a freedom of information request.

OP posts:
GrumpyOldCrone · 21/08/2023 20:21

I don’t think it’s reasonable to argue that patients shouldn’t see their records on the grounds that they might misunderstand things or they might ask questions.

Blanca87 · 21/08/2023 20:18

Do a subject access request. The have 28 days ( I think ) to respond.

Pollyputhekettleon · 21/08/2023 20:16

Letitgonowgr · 21/08/2023 20:11

I work in the hospital and imagine if someone wanted to look at their notes, they’d then be asking lots of questions about what does this mean and why was this written etc etc. can totally see why you weren’t allowed!

You assume she'd be asking lots of questions. And even if she did, if they don't want to answer then 'I can't/am not allowed to answer that' is a perfectly allowable response. That's absolutely no reason not to allow it.

Somuchgoo · 21/08/2023 20:15

stayclosetoyourself · 21/08/2023 20:07

Could the back scar be a chest drain if very unwell??

You might be 50% there. Its drainage related, but of csf.

Its either:

(1) related to a csf lumbar drain (she had 3 sequentially) - I know the 3 x small scars are from that, but I'm not sure if it caused the bigger one (ie so they could access spine but then tunnel through so it pops out at the side)

(2) the aborted surgery to place a permanent lumbar shunt - theatre was called by the lab to stop as samples showed meningitis, and then she quickly became 'unwell' so they aborted the surgery. I didn't think they'd got as far as fully opening her up, but the scar made me wonder otherwise. The surgery wasn't needed in the end thankfully.

That was a 'fun' period of life. Poor kid.

GrandTheftWalrus · 21/08/2023 20:13

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 20:05

Indeed, all you can do is ask. I was surprised as my partner had been with me in previous ivf rounds, but was barred that time as it was just opening up after covid. So only I was allowed in the room. It was the first time we had done it with him excluded from the whole process. I wanted to share it as it felt so much lonelier that round. I do not think all decisions are in patient best interests.

Yeah I wasn't allowed dh with me when I went in to get my mmc confirmed as it was May 2020. But when I had to go to midwife appointments on my own from Sept 2020 to May 2021 I was allowed to record the heartbeat and scans I was given loads of pics.

ReginaRegina · 21/08/2023 20:13

I think you can just call and request access then view it on NHS app. I can see all my prescriptions on there going righr back but can't access notes page.

AndyWarholShoes · 21/08/2023 20:12

SnowWhiteAndTheTwoKids · 21/08/2023 19:15

Your last sentence is key...there was NO ONE available so I would have had to wait hours for a junior doctor to be free to talk to me. All too busy...

I think the main issue is that there was nobody to explain what happened to you and what the plan was. It’s unacceptable really.

londonrach · 21/08/2023 20:11

It has to go through proper channel s..I'm NHS if I shared patient notes to a patient without proper written request to pals I'd loss my job

Letitgonowgr · 21/08/2023 20:11

I work in the hospital and imagine if someone wanted to look at their notes, they’d then be asking lots of questions about what does this mean and why was this written etc etc. can totally see why you weren’t allowed!

Pollyputhekettleon · 21/08/2023 20:07

hellywelly3 · 21/08/2023 19:04

I used to work in health records and what people don’t realise is that the records belong to the hospital not the individual. You can request access and will be given copies but maybe not of everything. If it’s deemed that it could be detrimental to you to read certain things they will blanked out.

That's absolutely mental. What gives medical professionals the right to decide on our behalf what will or won't be 'detrimental' to us? How incredibly patronizing.

stayclosetoyourself · 21/08/2023 20:07

Could the back scar be a chest drain if very unwell??

stayclosetoyourself · 21/08/2023 20:06

Yes a lot of these things like a clinic letter , mri report , picture of x Ray are discretionary on a case by case basis.

ichifanny · 21/08/2023 20:06

If people could just demand notes off you where would it end ? Demanding their next of kins notes while on a ward ? It’s been the way for years you need to apply for access to them .

Somuchgoo · 21/08/2023 20:06

SnowWhiteAndTheTwoKids · 21/08/2023 19:50

Whaattt? You don't know the details of a 4 inch scar on your 2 year olds back? I would have gone apeshit.

I know it could have come from a couple of different surgeries, but not precisely.

Tbh we were all more making sure she stayed alive at that point. I could have asked at the daily rounds but we were so often in crisis mode that it slipped my mind. By that stage she'd had two craniotomies and about a dozen other procedures and meningitis.

So it doesn't really alter anything, it was more curiosity really. Thinking about it, it's probably more like 2-3 inches, but she's small.

I wasn't miffed about the mystery stitches, but that I wasn't allowed to read at what happened at the ditched operation. As it was an emergency no one really explained that bit, and then we moved on to the next crisis, but I thought the notes might clear up a few questions. I just wanted to know if they got as far as the incision or not 🤷‍♀️

agent765 · 21/08/2023 20:05

EVERYONE needs to check their files regularly IME.

I had mine after an assault on me went to court. The amount of incorrect information is shocking.

Not to mention the notes of three other patients with completely different details (including sex in one case) that showed up in my files.

I asked if they could be removed and incorrect details changed but was told no. Once it's in your record it's there for life.

It's nice to know what certain HC professionals actually think of you, too. I was a 'nuisance' patient for returning with the same problems. That problem turned out to be the neurological condition I'd been diagnosed with in my late teens but it never made it into my notes.

It was only after the assault went to court and the legal team insisted I get checked out at the other side's cost that they found out (for the second time) what I have. Now I'm finally getting the treatment that would have slowed progression decades ago.

Check your notes every 5 years.

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 20:05

GrandTheftWalrus · 21/08/2023 20:02

Very true. All I can do is ask I suppose. I know the notes I had to send into the gp after my surgery was the exact same discharge notes I got because it was old school and written on a top sheet and the next sheet down was for the doctor.

Indeed, all you can do is ask. I was surprised as my partner had been with me in previous ivf rounds, but was barred that time as it was just opening up after covid. So only I was allowed in the room. It was the first time we had done it with him excluded from the whole process. I wanted to share it as it felt so much lonelier that round. I do not think all decisions are in patient best interests.

GrandTheftWalrus · 21/08/2023 20:02

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 19:59

They might say no. I was not allowed to take a pic of a scan to show my partner I was doing ivf. It was a scan checking my follicles and we understood well due to being quite the rodeo veterans by that point. But she would not let me take a pic. Said it was her work despite being my ovaries. Shame. That round worked and dc1 has the equivalent pic as no1, dc2 pic begins at embryo transfer.

Very true. All I can do is ask I suppose. I know the notes I had to send into the gp after my surgery was the exact same discharge notes I got because it was old school and written on a top sheet and the next sheet down was for the doctor.

ItLooksLikeChickenSoItMustBeChicken · 21/08/2023 20:01

I was in 3 separate hospitals (over a solid period of 6 weeks, so one to another then the 3rd one), and I requested my records from all 3 hospitals. No fee for that. I got them back on CDs

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 19:59

GrandTheftWalrus · 21/08/2023 19:23

Was that for me? I'm going to ask if I can get a pic of it.

They might say no. I was not allowed to take a pic of a scan to show my partner I was doing ivf. It was a scan checking my follicles and we understood well due to being quite the rodeo veterans by that point. But she would not let me take a pic. Said it was her work despite being my ovaries. Shame. That round worked and dc1 has the equivalent pic as no1, dc2 pic begins at embryo transfer.

Bloatstoat · 21/08/2023 19:56

I can understand the frustration, as others have said as a HCP if I just hand over someone's notes I risk my job, but you can go through proper channels and request them.

I work in stroke rehab, all our notes are kept on computer systems which we access in the office. But, we work in patients' homes, and often need to check the details of what a colleagues has done. So we have created a home notes file for each patient, we document everything in the medical notes online but everyone has a paper file that we update when we visit and they are able to read these as not the full official medical notes, perhaps your maternity notes were something similar?

I had a paper book when I was pregnant that the midwives updated at appointments etc but I think they also updated online, I took the book into hospital and they did put in some details but also used the hospital systems, I could see the notes in my book but not the ones on the system (although as I work for the same trust I technically could, but as people have said would lose my job if I did!)

sparklefresh · 21/08/2023 19:56

I find it totally disgraceful that I cannot access all of the information written about my own body, my own health conditions. How could it harm me to know that? It's so insulting and patronising. Other countries allow it so I don't believe this 'oh it would harm you' rubbish. I'm an adult and the only person living in this body.

ItLooksLikeChickenSoItMustBeChicken · 21/08/2023 19:51

It's the way the NHS operates. I was in hospital and one day was taken for a scan, and the porter gave me my file to hold. I started to flick through it, and he quickly snatched it away, saying I wasn't allowed to look at MY notes

SnowWhiteAndTheTwoKids · 21/08/2023 19:50

Somuchgoo · 21/08/2023 19:45

A while ago I was in hospital for a couple of months with my 2yo. One day when a dressing was removed I saw an unexpected area of stitching on her back. I knew shed had an operation on there but it had to be aborted.

I asked the nurses if they knew how far the surgeons had got with it, they didn't.

I asked if I could just check the notes from surgery and it was a clear 'no'. In the end, they looked up the page and read it out to me with the me standing there. Given the rules it was probably the best we could do (and a year on I'm still not sure what that 3-4 inch scar is about!)

I can understand why with kids/parents there may be some times when it's inappropriate, but it also made me feel like we weren't the team we'd been the previous month. They happily used our records on things like poo/wee/urine/food intake to make decisions, as we were there 24/7 and they weren't, but I couldn't even read what happened in my childs aborted surgery.

I get it (for kids) but I was totally shocked.

Whaattt? You don't know the details of a 4 inch scar on your 2 year olds back? I would have gone apeshit.

OP posts:
Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 19:50

PalomaPalomaPaloma · 21/08/2023 19:11

Yes, but why?

Because some information can be redacted. I am a therapist. A client can request their file and I must respond. I do not hand over the whole file, particularly as I often work with couples.

If they request the notes as a couple, they will get the most complete version. A request as an individual will see the partner's input redacted. I might also redact my input, or even the words of the client, if I feel that there is a significant risk of the reading of the notes leading to trauma.

This can be challenged through my governing body, to whom I would have to hand all notes, totally unredacted. They would then decide whether it was in the best interests of the client to see the notes in full and I would respect that.

Part of our duty of care is to safeguard. Transparency is really important, along with the ability to hold professionals to account, but there is also evidence for note reading to retraumatise, or trigger a whole new trauma response, so there is a balance to be had. I do not believe in hiding info, but sometimes, the phrasing is terribly important and might not be as carefully considered as my transcript would be if I was jotting bits down.

Ponderingwindow · 21/08/2023 19:49

I’m not in the uk, so perhaps that is why I find this policy so utterly bizarre and insulting. At this point, I automatically get a copy of my notes emailed to me minutes after they are made. Test results come that way too. Most of the time during an Appointment, the doctor or nurse sits with the computer screen and we look at it together as they type.

i can’t get my child’s full notes anymore now that she is 14, but that is ok. She can get her own notes. She did have to sign something allowing me to make her appointments and pay for her because she isn’t legally allowed to do either, but I wasn’t legally allowed into her account to do it without her permission.