Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think housing associations should have more accountability who they choose to allocate homes to.

111 replies

JenniferBooth · 21/08/2023 18:22

DH and i have lived in a top storey block of flats in a two storey block since October 1994.
1994 to 1998 Elderly lady lived underneath us. No problems or complaints. Lovely woman We even used to exchange Christmas cards.
1998 to 2017. Single man lived underneath. Really nice man Again no problems or complaints Unfortunately died in the flat at Easter 2017

Empty for a year.
2018 to 2019 Drug dealer who used to argue with his girlfriend and i used to hear things being thrown around.

Flat empty between summer 2019 and Feb 2022
Feb 2022 to present day now we have an abusive alcoholic underneath us who bangs on the ceiling if i so much as move. Our flat is carpeted and rugged. NO laminate flooring. He called me a cunt when i left the flat to go out one Thursday morning. He also called me a cunt when i took out some recycling yesterday afternoon. I went for a pee at 1.30 this morning and he chanted You fat cunt You fat cunt You fat cunt three times at me through the bathroom floor.
His mum provides him with money and food due to his habit
As ive already posted we have never had this kind of crap before and we have been here nearly 29 years. HAs need to be more accountable especially when these decisions affect other tenants

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Elleherd · 22/08/2023 11:19

RedToothBrush My impression was that staff were just lazy and uninterested in doing their jobs more than there being a wider company desire to put profit first. It was a culture of not giving a shit rather than one of ruthless capitalism.

Staff being "just lazy and uninterested in doing their jobs" tends to be the tail of the 'we're more interested in property developing' HA snake IMO.

TBF I'm not sure it's generally laziness, (though obviously you know yours) IME the culture of "not giving a shit" runs deeper than laziness, and some staff definitely do actually care, but feel their hands are tied. They definitely feel they are treated poorly from above and daily by tenants.

Whammyyammy · 22/08/2023 09:43

Ichabodandme · 21/08/2023 18:28

Perhaps they could live next door to you?

Brilliant 👏

RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 09:20

I used to live on a mixed estate. It had full ownership, shared ownership (managed by housing association) and housing association only properties. For the most part it worked well. It socially is better in my opinion. However at times over the years, there were problems with the HA tenants. Regularly police and neighbours had a nightmare. The Housing Association were absolutely useless. We were in shared ownership and dealing with the HA was a total nightmare so had real sympathy for the other HA tenants and it used to piss me off rotten that there was a certain snobbery locally amongst some about the estate. I used to put those people firmly in their place. It was the HA failing to tackle the issues that made issues worse that they should. Eventually the police stopped as the tenant left.

I now live in a private house. It's right next door to a council estate. And there's a rented property opposite. For the most part the council estate is fine - there was an issue with one house which ended up minus a front door and the tenants being replaced which I didn't know the full story too (house is less that 25 m from mine) but nothing else. The most problems are currently with the rented house. One of the kids has issues and has anti-social behaviour issues. He's at a school to deal with his issues. There's regularly a police car outside the house. We've not had dealings with them but one of my friends (who lives in the council houses) has talked with the Dad. He's really good about things which is a relief.

But I am aware that it's luck. And housing associations don't care and are fucking useless. Reasonable requests were ignored and not dealt with (eg 'we've just bought the other half of our house please can you ensure your records are updated properly as we no longer pay rent' only to get threats of court for none payment of the said rent, levels of fuckwittery amongst others). My impression was that staff were just lazy and uninterested in doing their jobs more than there being a wider company desire to put profit first. It was a culture of not giving a shit rather than one of ruthless capitalism.

CoffeeCantata · 22/08/2023 09:06

Roosmarjin · Yesterday 18:26

And where would people like your current neighbour live?

Well not in a lovely spacious flat with well-behaved families!

They should be put together in a block or in hostels with appropriate wardens/security to stop major antisocial behaviour.

People like this destroy lives.

Elleherd · 22/08/2023 08:53

I have a set of violent bullying criminals who abuse mine and everyone else's property, and me when it suits, so get it. As well as the occupants, the visiting fathers and so called 'gardeners' & 'decorators' ('have machete will cut down jungle/rip out neighbors fences, nick paint from work', in exchange for drugs, sex etc,) and serious dogs, make life scary for everyone.
Prison, court and CP, are all occupational hazards to them and their bigger issue is tracking down who 'grassed them up.' Just one family and friends, demanding everyone else lives by their standards. Abh, Gbh, violent assault and police on blues and twos on our road, has gone from rare unlucky instances of mugging or burglary gone wrong, to common place events.

Police play cat and mouse with them knowing little meaningful will happen in court, and advise us to keep our heads down. Little point in complaining to HA any more as it's immediately turned into supposed 'neighborhood dispute' with the implication that others have somehow done something wrong to deserve what's meted out to them, and then we have to live with the repercussions of causing trouble for the aggressors.

Water flooding from above and sewage flooding are also turned into 'neighborhood disputes' rather than maintenance and repair issues. Set all the tennants against each other and increase 'social intervention' teams, rather than using rent to cover repairs.
Lots of methods used to dissuade tenants from complaining about poor conditions, and bad repairs.

It's the symptom of HA's treating tenants as cash cow caretakers for the business assets they own and increasing market growth, rather than seeing themselves as landlords with responsibility to tenants, who shouldn't put growth over their ability to manage.
As HA's they get away with stuff private landlords can't, the council bows to them turns a blind eye to conditions, no one wants to know, and the bigger they and their assets grow.

RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 08:25

SinisterBumFacedCat · 22/08/2023 00:44

This is happening at my Uncle’s place, a block of 4 flats previously all tenants single people in their 50/60s on low incomes. Social housing is so scarce that the people with the highest needs and often the biggest problems are first on the list. So they moved a young girl in who is an addict, has mental health problems, sleeps all day and plays loud music all night, shouts at the neighbours, has a succession of boyfriends and is regularly sectioned onto a quiet cul de sac of families and people who need a good nights sleep to go to work in the morning. Unsuitable for everyone.

Nail on the head. This type of accommodation isn't suitable for the anti-social neighbour - they aren't getting the support they need. They need specialist accomodation. And the lack of this has ramifications for everyone else. It's really not ok.

Saying we should be inclusive misses the point. Inclusivity is increasingly a byword for put up and shut up and accept a lack of resources for people who need social support for additional needs or quite frankly putting in prison. It's about unmet needs by government and local government which comes at the expense of others.

CampsieGlamper · 22/08/2023 07:38

Every time an incident happens, take a written note of everything with date and time, every time call the police and ask for an incident number. Every time contact the HA.
Does the council have an anti social behaviour investigation team ASBIT?
Zero tolerance towards anti social scum.

The concept of social housing was to "replicate the village street, with the doctor next to the ploughman, the vicar by the shop assistant." Ideal then, but now councils house gimps, chimps and blimps next the normal people, and the council leaders, hand wringers and social workers, do gooders all live well away from the Losers.

Saltovinegar · 22/08/2023 07:25

YANBU. I had a similar neighbour, when I complained I was told the HA thought this would happen and they knew it was a nice street but they had to put him somewhere.

It was years of misery, police visits, stress. I was close to moving and then he died, I'm quite happy to say I was ecstatic.

110APiccadilly · 22/08/2023 07:10

It sounds awful for you and you should complain to the HA. Hopefully they'll act. Could you speak to your neighborhood policing team? I know they're supposed to be able to deal with harassment, and you might meet the criteria for that.

I don't know what the broader answer is though as presumably even terrible people should be housed somewhere? Short of bringing back workhouses for them, where do we put them?

LlynTegid · 22/08/2023 07:03

Re the alcoholism- are the HA or police allowed to tell the local supermarkets so it becomes more difficult for him to get alcohol? Has his mum got space for him to live in, so the HA would not be evicting him knowing he has nowhere to go?

Yfory · 22/08/2023 02:15

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz so you live in a diverse area with a wide variety of people amongst which some are rather dodgy/anti social behaviour.

Big deal, clap clap - so do a lot of us. I do.
That is absolutely not the same as living directly next door/underneath someone who is for whatever reason a difficult neighbour. I live in a diverse area but have at the moment got wonderful neighbours. But I havent in the past and I may not in the future if any of the current ones move. A difficult household (or several even) around the corner is entirely not the same as having them directly next door (which is a possibility in nice neighbourhoods as well as in not so nice - Ive experienced that too)
@JenniferBooth sympathies I totally get it. You've lived there a long time and have been happy up until about 5 years ago. Ive no suggestions but I hope you can find a solution soon.

ConsuelaHammock · 22/08/2023 01:42

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 21/08/2023 22:50

All humans deserve somewhere to live. Even if they are dicks, even if they are ASBO'd up to the eyeballs. Every human should have a home they can live in.

I disagree . If you want to live in a civilised society you have to behave appropriately. I’d stick them all in a tent on an island somewhere 🤪
Record record record and report him every opportunity you get. I really feel for you.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 22/08/2023 00:44

This is happening at my Uncle’s place, a block of 4 flats previously all tenants single people in their 50/60s on low incomes. Social housing is so scarce that the people with the highest needs and often the biggest problems are first on the list. So they moved a young girl in who is an addict, has mental health problems, sleeps all day and plays loud music all night, shouts at the neighbours, has a succession of boyfriends and is regularly sectioned onto a quiet cul de sac of families and people who need a good nights sleep to go to work in the morning. Unsuitable for everyone.

Im99912 · 22/08/2023 00:28

My ex neighbour certainly don’t deserve social housing .
living under a bridge or on the streets would be to good for him

he made my life and my family and other neighbors life absolute hell for several years in part aided by the council as they were to scared to evict him and do anything .

thankfully Im a dam sight smarter than the council
and the neighbor and used the law to get the fucker out and I take great satisfaction that he lost his councilor house and he knows that it was down to me

if he was dying on the street I would happily walk over him I wouldn’t piss on him if he was on fire

i feel awful for anyone who has him as a neighbor because he isn’t just mentally Ill he’s actually very dangerous and even the judge said that really he should be in hospital but there simply isn’t the help for people like him so they are able to carry on making peoples life hell until they really hurt or kill someone’s
then they get all the help they need

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/08/2023 00:11

I have not said the OP was not being harassed. Anyone who is harassed should report it. Where have I said they werent?

FerryPink · 22/08/2023 00:10

I hope the housing association sort it for you @JenniferBooth but if it persists please follow their complaints procedure and if that fails try the housing ombudsman

JenniferBooth · 22/08/2023 00:10

Thankyou Red and others for your support. Flowers

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 00:10

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/08/2023 00:06

OP, I hope your HA staff visiting the estate goes well, that they are able to solve this matter, and that you can return to quiet enjoyment of your home.

To the others who seem to want to pile on simply because I have a slightly different opinion overall on this wider matter, I'm content to agree to disagree.

I'd argue that saying "oh but I intentionally moved next to XYZ so that someone else didn't have to endure them" would actually be peak virtue signalling, so thanks for that humorous comment, whoever said that above.

Best of luck OP.

Annnnnnndddddd dodged the request to explain why the OP isn't being harassed...

...I rest my case.

RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 00:09

JenniferBooth · 22/08/2023 00:00

My second post about it is self explanatory You are one of those posters who gets off on making people type stuff over and over.

Na they are trying to make the thread all about them and how wonderful they are because they accept everyone.

It's reverse snobbery. Hence the comments about NIMBYs. It's effectively trying to paint you as somehow a middle class prick who doesn't like people who are different and isn't accepting enough. Cos they are cool and ultra working class and down to earth.

The comment saying if you think youve been harassed, when you've clearly detailed an example of obvious harassment is the killer comment that illustrates how this poster is making it all about them and not you

Because they are trying to minimise and suggest that shouting cunt doesn't necessarily constitute harassment/abuse somehow. And it's perfectly normal behaviour which isn't designed to intimidate.

Ignore.

Others can see what they are and how they are on a wind up mission.

FerryPink · 22/08/2023 00:09

RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 00:02

You are virtue signalling.

It's easy to say 'oh they have to live somewhere' when it's not your life being destroyed.

In effect you are happy for the lives of others to be destroyed cos well that's just being inclusive. .

Bollocks is it.

Unless you are happy to volunteer and actually move next door to a problem neighbour so that others don't have to deal with it, save your armchair comments. It's meaningless hot air aka virtue signalling.

Look how wonderful I am for saying I love in an area where there's everyone and none of those dreadful snobby horrible NIMBYs.

Newsflash: not wishing to live next door to someone threatening you, abusing you or scaring you doesn't make someone a NIMBY. It makes them a victim of a crime.

Agreed. No idea who pissed on Bernadette's chips tonight but it's bizarre to keep going on at someone who is clearly distressed

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/08/2023 00:06

OP, I hope your HA staff visiting the estate goes well, that they are able to solve this matter, and that you can return to quiet enjoyment of your home.

To the others who seem to want to pile on simply because I have a slightly different opinion overall on this wider matter, I'm content to agree to disagree.

I'd argue that saying "oh but I intentionally moved next to XYZ so that someone else didn't have to endure them" would actually be peak virtue signalling, so thanks for that humorous comment, whoever said that above.

Best of luck OP.

RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 00:04

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/08/2023 00:01

Just read back in your posts and sw this.

I'm not sure where jve said its not harassment? Have you misinterpreted my comments?

If you are being harassed, report it to the police. If the harasser is housed in HA property, report them to the HA.

My comments on this thread are addressing the suggestion that HAs house "difficult" tenants more responsibly - aka away from you (is my interpretation of your comments). So where?

She's having cunt shouted at her.

Explain to me how that's not targeted harassment and abuse?

JenniferBooth · 22/08/2023 00:03

Oh so its your INTERPRETATION of my comments now Backtracking now i see

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 22/08/2023 00:02

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 21/08/2023 23:46

Polish the halo with the virtue signalling

So when I say "people need homes" I get asked "where? Next to you?"

Then I say they do live next to me I'm virtue signalling?

This place is fucking mental some times.

And as for the "designated ASBO" homes suggestion above. Come the fuck on. This is how you end up with ghettos and pockets of areas which are 100% no man's lands in terms of safety.

You are virtue signalling.

It's easy to say 'oh they have to live somewhere' when it's not your life being destroyed.

In effect you are happy for the lives of others to be destroyed cos well that's just being inclusive. .

Bollocks is it.

Unless you are happy to volunteer and actually move next door to a problem neighbour so that others don't have to deal with it, save your armchair comments. It's meaningless hot air aka virtue signalling.

Look how wonderful I am for saying I love in an area where there's everyone and none of those dreadful snobby horrible NIMBYs.

Newsflash: not wishing to live next door to someone threatening you, abusing you or scaring you doesn't make someone a NIMBY. It makes them a victim of a crime.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/08/2023 00:01

JenniferBooth · 21/08/2023 23:38

Bernadette You are saying i think im too good because i dont want to be abused. WOW Red flag much.

Well riddle me this. If i had walked past this man in the street where he had shouted abuse at me it would be street harassment no question.

So why is it not harassment just because its been shouted up from one flat to another??!!!!

Just read back in your posts and sw this.

I'm not sure where jve said its not harassment? Have you misinterpreted my comments?

If you are being harassed, report it to the police. If the harasser is housed in HA property, report them to the HA.

My comments on this thread are addressing the suggestion that HAs house "difficult" tenants more responsibly - aka away from you (is my interpretation of your comments). So where?