Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of quality « me time » with my parents. Who is BU?

65 replies

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:17

I need some perspective.

I’ve always had a great relationship with my parents who’ve always been loving and helpful when we needed it with the DCs.

However things have been deteriorating over the past few years as my DB has been taking a lot more space. He’s got a fairly good job, his wife works too, they own their house, but they have nowhere near the same situation as we do as both DH and I have very good careers, have been carefully with money, basically investing everything wisely, to the point we’ve been helping several family members (DB and DSIL included) buying a home. They also don’t have the same situation as our parents had, ie can’t afford a secondary home, expensive holidays, nice car etc My dad can’t stand the fact his son can’t have the same lifestyle as he had so they are now subsidising his lifestyle with holidays, childcare, pet care and many other things (such as house deposit but that doesn’t bother me as doesn’t impact me).

The consequences of that is that whenever I see my parents, they’re never on their own, there is always someone from my DB’s family spoiling the party and we don’t have quality time. It will be either my SIL who’s a nice person but there are lots of subjects we’re not allowed to talk about in front of her so conversations will be super bland (my dad despite being in his 80s is still very alert, on top of everything, politics, economy, latest trends etc but we can’t talk about any of that when my DB’s family are around).
Or it will be my DB’s dog being sick/eating our dinner (the dog is a covid puppy, and my DB had to give the dog to my parents when he realised dog care would be too expensive when going back to work 🙄).
Or my nieces and nephews having tantrums/seeking attention until midnight when we want to spend quality time among adults.

We see my parents much less than my DB as we live abroad and they can’t come and visit us as much as they used to due to their age so it saddens me deeply to no longer have quality « me time » with them as they won’t be there forever. It’s the same with my DCs, they love their grand parents but have been put off visiting them lately when they realised my DB’s family would be around.

What also worries me is that my parents are in their 80s and 70s and whilst still relatively fit and healthy, they’re ageing and my DB doesn’t see that. He will ask them to look after their 3 young DCs + 2 friends of my niece for one week in their holiday home. My parents always say yes but I could see they were exhausted after this week but will never say no to their son.
Likewise this week my dad came back exhausted from walking the dog (big active dog) and we had to tell him to stop doing it as he’s starting to have some cardiovascular problems.

This is starting to create real issues and tensions, with my mum in particular, as she can see we are annoyed whereas she thinks there is no issue and we should all live happily together. My dad is sad about this situation and more understanding but my mum will always win.

Basically I feel like my DB is asking too much from my ageing parents (who will never dare saying no to him) and should retreat sometimes to let me and my family have some quality time with my parents.

AIBU or not?

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/08/2023 08:12

If you're the one giving them money for things, then you have every right to ask to have a look at their finances, you could say that you're worried something is happening to the money and are surprised they are making so little from their holiday rental investment.

That kind of depends on whether the parents are actively asking the OP for money or whether she is just choosing to pay for stuff. She doesn't make this clear either way.

What she has made clear is that her dad still has full mental capacity. In light of this, I don't think the OP has any "right" to look into her parents' finances at all. The only "right" that she does have in that situation is to choose not to subsidise their financial choices.

bozzabollix · 21/08/2023 08:11

I know how you feel, my sister always takes a lot more resources from my parents than me and I do get frustrated, however it is their decision. I think you need to accept that too.

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 21/08/2023 08:07

I think they know that they'll need your DB and DSIL in their older years. I mean, are you planning to move back to look after them?

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 08:07

If you're the one giving them money for things, then you have every right to ask to have a look at their finances, you could say that you're worried something is happening to the money and are surprised they are making so little from their holiday rental investment.

Even if you are very comfortably off you can say it's because you're thinking about future retirement so you can't be spending so much.

Frankly the only real power you have to change their behaviour is to stop writing them cheques so they can then hand all their money to the golden child.

harriethoyle · 21/08/2023 08:06

Don't finance your parents then moan about it. Either do it freely and generously with no strings or say no.

ChubbyMorticia · 21/08/2023 08:05

So, as I understand it, your parents enable your brother’s lifestyle to the point that it’s straining their finances. You’re enabling your parents by sending them money.

Perhaps you should start saying no, stop enabling, and start a chain reaction. If they need money, they can sell the second home, quit paying for your brother and his family.

Everyone in this situation is an adult. Nobody HAS to financially carry someone else, you’re all choosing it.

Aprilx · 21/08/2023 08:05

I cannot reconcile you wanting quality time with your parents with moving abroad. I expect it is nice for your parents to have your brother and his family so involved in their lives. You cannot expect them to clear off because you decide to fly into town. I also don’t think it is your place to look across from overseas ad criticise their choices.

And the dog is now your parents dog, not your brothers dog, you seem to be deliberately referring to it as brothers dog so you have another thing to criticise.

wizzywig · 21/08/2023 08:04

Why don't you pay for your parents to visit you? Then you can have your quality time. And say no you won't pay for your brother to come along

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 08:03

To those suggesting we take my parents away this is very topical… We have just offered to take them somewhere nice (it’s already booked and there is space for them) for a week away during Xmas holidays. We were discussing it last night, my dad is very exited and really wants to come but I can see that my mum is less than enthusiastic.

I’ll probably have a discussion with him this week and make the point they have to start being sensible with money and listen to their body!

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/08/2023 08:01

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 08:00

Here's an idea. As they spend so much time in your DPs holiday home, why not find out when they plan to use it and come to visit then.

That's what I suggested above.

They can't be "always" on holiday while simultaneously being always with your parents.

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 08:00

Here's an idea. As they spend so much time in your DPs holiday home, why not find out when they plan to use it and come to visit then.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 07:58

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:55

I fully understand what you mean, moral support/presence vs financial support but my DB is not really there every day to provide moral support either... He or my SIL didn’t go and visit her at hospital despite the fact they live and work relatively close to the hospital (ie less than 30mn by public transport). My adult DD happened to be in town at the time and went there every day (she’s the one who cooked and brought the meals!!).

Hmmm. I still think you're underestimating how much support your brother provides them - after all, if your parents didn't want to provide the childcare or take the dog - they would have said no, surely?

They clearly get something out of it - time with their grandchildren, company from the dog, and it means they see their adult son on a regular basis as an added bonus as well.

Hospital visits and meals are one tiny part of life - he's there for the everyday, maybe he feels as though you/your daughter should do some of it too?

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 07:56

I get you OP. I would suggest that once the roles reverse and your DPs need more help than they provide, you won't see DB or his family for dust.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/08/2023 07:56

Your parents clearly aren't badly off. They own a second property. If they need money, they can sell that property, maximise rental income, look into equity release etc. They clearly have options and you indicate that they have the mental capacity to make their own decisions. Sorry, but that means that they can make decisions that you don't like.

You don't have to subsidise this. That's also a choice and you can choose not to do it.

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:55

I fully understand what you mean, moral support/presence vs financial support but my DB is not really there every day to provide moral support either... He or my SIL didn’t go and visit her at hospital despite the fact they live and work relatively close to the hospital (ie less than 30mn by public transport). My adult DD happened to be in town at the time and went there every day (she’s the one who cooked and brought the meals!!).

OP posts:
Commonhousewitch · 21/08/2023 07:55

If you are only back periodically you just need to arrange things so your brothers family aren't there- eg book a cottage away with your parents. go and see your parents when your brother is using their second home.
It is difficult- i'm overseas and when we're back we only ever seem to see my brother plus mys sisters family as one unit -it annoys me more as I'd like to see my sister/her family separate from my mum - as the whole dynamic changes.
My mum also (on the surface) does a lot for my sister and her family but i think a huge part of this is her embedding herself into their family and feeling helpful.

Are your children older than your brother's? maybe your parents are trying to be as involved in their lives as they were in your children's but it is just harder because they're older

Out of interest why can you only talk about bland subjects when your SIL is there?

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 07:53

I don't think you can move abroad and away from your parents and then go on to complain that you don't get quality time with them when you do visit.

You see your brother as selfish but maybe he views you in the same way for disappearing overseas and leaving him to support your ageing parents alone?

They may provide him with childcare but he also provides them with day to day support - a listening ear and plenty of company. If they have a fall or need to get to an appointment it will him they rely on for it all, not you.

LoverofGreen · 21/08/2023 07:52

Are you able to take your parents away with you somewhere when you visit?

I understand you wanting to spend time with them alone absolutely.

I had similar problem years ago when my sibling and family moved in with my parents permanently because of financial reasons, used to take my mum out somewhere nice when I used to visit for an uninterrupted chat plus she used to visit me a lot, I understand your parents are too old now to do that.

Hope you come up with a solution.

Raindancer411 · 21/08/2023 07:52

HamishTheCamel · 21/08/2023 07:48

OP, I agree with you that it sounds like your parents are doing too much for your brother (considering their age) and it's putting a strain on them. But I'm not sure what you can do about it really. At the end of the day it's up to them and they need to say no.

This is sadly the case. Your parents aren't always going to be there to bank roll them, and they are not helping him out in the long term. What will he done once any inheritance (if any left) runs out?

As for you helping your parents out, in the nicest way, you are enabling the parents to then continue. Maybe just say things have become tighter and you don't have the money to help them. Then hopefully you can suggest they should be asking your DB for money when they use the holiday rental?

declutteringmymind · 21/08/2023 07:49

Maybe next time your there, take them on a little break.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 07:49

What do you mean by more available? He uses them but doesn’t help them/contribute to anything.

Does he use them? Or does he ask for help and they say yes? I don't think it's fair to blame this all on your brother when presumably your parents are more than capable of turning around and saying "no" if they feel that it's too much.

I also think you're hugely underestimating how much your brother does for your parents. He may not be ordering them hospital meals but he's the one who is there everyday - listening to them and providing company and day-to-day support.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/08/2023 07:48

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:42

What do you mean by more available? He uses them but doesn’t help them/contribute to anything. They hardly ever ask for help but if they need something they will call me!
My mum recently had an operation and I sent her some meals during her hospital stay (she wouldn’t touch hospital food) and organised some help at home afterwards. My DB didn’t lift a finger!

In my experience, company is what older people crave the most. Your parents will be well aware that your DBIL and his family are the ones who will be present as their needs get greater. Paying for help and support is great, but it isn't the same and a lot of older people would rather manage stuff for themselves if family can't help them. We are going through this with my aunt at the moment.

HamishTheCamel · 21/08/2023 07:48

OP, I agree with you that it sounds like your parents are doing too much for your brother (considering their age) and it's putting a strain on them. But I'm not sure what you can do about it really. At the end of the day it's up to them and they need to say no.

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:47

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/08/2023 07:42

Then if he is alert and on top of things as you say he is, he can explain to DBIL that he needs the holiday let rental income.

If your DBIL and family are away using the holiday let so often that it is having a crippling effect on your parents' finances, surely there must be plenty of opportunities for you to visit your parents when they are on holiday? They can't be simultaneously with your parents all of the time but always on holiday?

It doesn't sound like your brother and his family are destitute by any means, so you have to face the reality that your "alert and on top of things" parents are choosing to support them financially. And they have a right to make that choice, whether you approve of it or not.

Honestly, it sounds to me like your dad is sad that you're so jealous of your brother. I don't blame him.

It actually concerns me that they are choosing to support them financially… As a result we’re now starting to have to support my parents financially too (paying for major houseworks, send them home help etc) so effectively indirectly funding my DB’s lifestyle.

OP posts:
LoveThisUsername · 21/08/2023 07:46

It will be either my SIL who’s a nice person but there are lots of subjects we’re not allowed to talk about in front of her so conversations will be super bland (my dad despite being in his 80s is still very alert, on top of everything, politics, economy, latest trends etc but we can’t talk about any of that when my DB’s family are around).

What can't/can you talk about and why?

Swipe left for the next trending thread