Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of quality « me time » with my parents. Who is BU?

65 replies

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:17

I need some perspective.

I’ve always had a great relationship with my parents who’ve always been loving and helpful when we needed it with the DCs.

However things have been deteriorating over the past few years as my DB has been taking a lot more space. He’s got a fairly good job, his wife works too, they own their house, but they have nowhere near the same situation as we do as both DH and I have very good careers, have been carefully with money, basically investing everything wisely, to the point we’ve been helping several family members (DB and DSIL included) buying a home. They also don’t have the same situation as our parents had, ie can’t afford a secondary home, expensive holidays, nice car etc My dad can’t stand the fact his son can’t have the same lifestyle as he had so they are now subsidising his lifestyle with holidays, childcare, pet care and many other things (such as house deposit but that doesn’t bother me as doesn’t impact me).

The consequences of that is that whenever I see my parents, they’re never on their own, there is always someone from my DB’s family spoiling the party and we don’t have quality time. It will be either my SIL who’s a nice person but there are lots of subjects we’re not allowed to talk about in front of her so conversations will be super bland (my dad despite being in his 80s is still very alert, on top of everything, politics, economy, latest trends etc but we can’t talk about any of that when my DB’s family are around).
Or it will be my DB’s dog being sick/eating our dinner (the dog is a covid puppy, and my DB had to give the dog to my parents when he realised dog care would be too expensive when going back to work 🙄).
Or my nieces and nephews having tantrums/seeking attention until midnight when we want to spend quality time among adults.

We see my parents much less than my DB as we live abroad and they can’t come and visit us as much as they used to due to their age so it saddens me deeply to no longer have quality « me time » with them as they won’t be there forever. It’s the same with my DCs, they love their grand parents but have been put off visiting them lately when they realised my DB’s family would be around.

What also worries me is that my parents are in their 80s and 70s and whilst still relatively fit and healthy, they’re ageing and my DB doesn’t see that. He will ask them to look after their 3 young DCs + 2 friends of my niece for one week in their holiday home. My parents always say yes but I could see they were exhausted after this week but will never say no to their son.
Likewise this week my dad came back exhausted from walking the dog (big active dog) and we had to tell him to stop doing it as he’s starting to have some cardiovascular problems.

This is starting to create real issues and tensions, with my mum in particular, as she can see we are annoyed whereas she thinks there is no issue and we should all live happily together. My dad is sad about this situation and more understanding but my mum will always win.

Basically I feel like my DB is asking too much from my ageing parents (who will never dare saying no to him) and should retreat sometimes to let me and my family have some quality time with my parents.

AIBU or not?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rookiemere · 21/08/2023 12:25

CoffeeBeansGalore · 21/08/2023 09:56

Can you afford to offer to buy their holiday home?
This would give your parents the money to fund their own repairs & have some cash in the bank.
The holiday home stays in the family and you could still let them use it. You could invite them sometimes when you go so you get some quality relaxed time with them.
You could get rental income from it.
You could let your brother use it once or twice a year but he would have to fit in between paying customers.
You then have an investment instead of losing the money you are subsidising your parents (and indirectly your brother) with.

Sorry but I wouldn't be doing that.

If DB knows that DPs have a lump sum he'll be at them like a dog who knows his owners have sausages. DM will expect you to continue the family tradition of DB treating the place like it's own and you'll have a holiday home to manage in addition to everything else.

Whereas if DPs can be shown that they need the regular income of the holiday home ( this may need you to stop writing cheques) it would be the handy monthly addition they need to their income. DB doesn't need to stop using it, he just needs to be give 2-3 weeks per year max so they can rent it out the other periods.

Mariposista · 21/08/2023 11:59

LoveThisUsername · 21/08/2023 07:46

It will be either my SIL who’s a nice person but there are lots of subjects we’re not allowed to talk about in front of her so conversations will be super bland (my dad despite being in his 80s is still very alert, on top of everything, politics, economy, latest trends etc but we can’t talk about any of that when my DB’s family are around).

What can't/can you talk about and why?

Oh she will be one of those super sensitive, easily offended types. Can’t stand them.
OP you’re getting a hard time. But MN hate well off peoples. They sound like bad parents to bratty children, selfish (not helping your mum) and clueless (over the dog).

CoffeeBeansGalore · 21/08/2023 09:56

Can you afford to offer to buy their holiday home?
This would give your parents the money to fund their own repairs & have some cash in the bank.
The holiday home stays in the family and you could still let them use it. You could invite them sometimes when you go so you get some quality relaxed time with them.
You could get rental income from it.
You could let your brother use it once or twice a year but he would have to fit in between paying customers.
You then have an investment instead of losing the money you are subsidising your parents (and indirectly your brother) with.

Theunamedcat · 21/08/2023 09:31

He is probably less concerned about writing checks because he has you to sub him try saying no and he will have to say no to his son

hdbs17 · 21/08/2023 09:07

Your parents funding your DB's life is one thing, and I wouldn't read too much into it from one persons version to be completely honest.

I think you sound jealous that your brother is there for your parents and you're not.
They know that he is the one who is close-by. So they look after the children? They're grandparents! That doesn't mean they're being used, they know that when they need care it'll be there for them.

You say you "arranged for meals to be delivered" whilst your DM was in hospital but in reality, you asked your daughter to cook and deliver them to your parents - so you didn't actually do anything, you just want the credit for "arranging" it.

Ghosttofu99 · 21/08/2023 08:46

At the start of the post you talked about all the support your parents have given you with DCs etc so that it does come across as jealousy that you resent your brother now for receiving similar support and taking the spotlight off of you.

I think you may be a bit oblivious to how the things you say/do come across hence the growing animosity from your parents. Example you have invited them on a nice holiday for quality time with you but the time you have booked is over Christmas so you are really putting them in a no win situation if they usually spend it with other family too.

The dog bit is the only thing I would agree on

Anothernamethesamegame · 21/08/2023 08:42

Other than talk to your parents and DB about the situation I am sure what else you can do. Your parents are choosing to financially etc support your DB and if they are doing that at the expense of their own well-being/financial stability…well that is also their choice. You can highlight your concerns but nothing will change unless they choose to change it.

what you can control is you not getting dragged in to the mix. Why are you funding things your parents can afford to fund but don’t because they are subsidising your DB? I’d be asking why are you not renting out the second home so you can pay for repairs on your main home? I wouldn’t be paying for the repairs so DB is still able to holiday whenever he wants at the second home.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:28

That sounds lovely and like it works for all but genuinely it’s not always the case.

Yep I understand that - but people need to learn to say no at the end of the day - even parents!

LittleBearPad · 21/08/2023 08:26

Who said you have to censor conversation in front of SIL? And why?

Id also like to understand this?

LittleBearPad · 21/08/2023 08:26

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:24

Your own DPs are your dog sitters. Are you certain they are completely happy to do this?

My in-laws asked to do it, we had alternative care lined up for the dog but they insisted on taking him - so yes, they are happy to do it.

They don't have to do anything for him - we walk him and provide everything he needs, he spends the day asleep on their sofa!

That sounds lovely and like it works for all but genuinely it’s not always the case.

xyz111 · 21/08/2023 08:25

I missed the part where you're sending your parents money until I read through it again. Why on earth are you doing that?? You need to have a frank discussion and say why do they need money if they're spending it on your brother? This makes no sense!

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:24

Your own DPs are your dog sitters. Are you certain they are completely happy to do this?

My in-laws asked to do it, we had alternative care lined up for the dog but they insisted on taking him - so yes, they are happy to do it.

They don't have to do anything for him - we walk him and provide everything he needs, he spends the day asleep on their sofa!

RedHelenB · 21/08/2023 08:24

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 07:26

I agree I may sound jealous but disagree with your first statement. My dad would like things to be different and is even sadder than I am, but he’s got no choice.

He does have a choice, he just prefers to moan to you about it. He could say no, he could go elsewhere and let your mum entertain them by herself.

GabriellaMontez · 21/08/2023 08:24

As a result we’re now starting to have to support my parents financially too (paying for major houseworks, send them home help etc) so effectively indirectly funding my DB’s lifestyle.

You don't have to. Don't fall into the same trap as your parents.

Who said you have to censor conversation in front of SIL? And why?

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 08:21

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:17

I think a lot of elderly people don’t say no to requests for childcare from their children because they want to feel helpful / love their children. It’s still a big imposition and so much shouldn’t be asked in the first place.

But that's still not the fault of the person asking - parents should be enforcing boundaries with their adult children.

It really is , some people are simply CFs who can't see beyond their own needs.
I have to remind DH not to give my octogenarian frail DF the dog lead to hold when we go out, one strong pull and he would likely break a bone or end up in hospital.DH simply can't see it, and I suspect the DB is like that but on a grander scale. Or like my SIL who is fed up looking after her DGC two full days a week and has said to me it's too much - particularly with her DH being ill - but her DS and DDIL apparently can't see beyond their own wants as she is too timid to mention it.

NoSquirrels · 21/08/2023 08:21

This is all your parents choice. If they wanted to say no to childcare, the dog (it’s their dog now, anyway, isn’t it?), hosting SIL when you’re there, use of their holiday home or any other ways in which they accommodate your brother and his family, then they could. They’re adults with free will.

But they don’t want to. You can’t say your dad feels bad about it/feels sad and that it’s your mum pushing the idea of no one changing anything and then also say it’s because your dad can’t accept your brother having a ‘lesser’ lifestyle. If your parents have a holiday home it’s pretty usual within a family for other people to use it too.

There’s also a decent chance your brother is planning for his family to be around when you’re around because he thinks it’s nice to see you! Why don’t you offer him
a home swap next time you’re home and then his free holiday can coincide with you getting your parents all to yourself?

Talk to your brother about your concerns about your parents health, by all means. But don’t tell your parents what to do with their money unless you have serious concerns about their mental capacity or that your brother is actively defrauding them (doesn’t sound like it). As other have said, you need to be aware that by living abroad you are in a difficult position to criticise how your parents treat the family who live closer to them.

LittleBearPad · 21/08/2023 08:20

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:17

I think a lot of elderly people don’t say no to requests for childcare from their children because they want to feel helpful / love their children. It’s still a big imposition and so much shouldn’t be asked in the first place.

But that's still not the fault of the person asking - parents should be enforcing boundaries with their adult children.

They aren’t going to, because they love their children and want to help them. It can still mean they wish they’d said no or could say no.

Your own DPs are your dog sitters. Are you certain they are completely happy to do this?

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:18

X-post about you moving back.

You may find things naturally change when you become more available to your parents.

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 08:18

@Ihatemoquitoes there's a bit of acceptance of the status quo in your response about writing the next cheque.

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves has a good point- are they asking for the money or are you just giving it to them ?

It's lovely you are planning to head back and your DPs will be very fortunate to have two sets of DCs close to them, but all this will get old really quickly if you're living nearby.

The financials are they key to it and you need to decide if you're prepared to keep on subsiding DB indirectly. If you're not, there is really only one way to go about it.

WB205020 · 21/08/2023 08:17

I think there are 2 issues here. Possibly 3.
the main issue of them doing too much for your brother you don’t have much control over other than saying to your parents you are concerned and that their age and health is a driver for your concern.
The financial side is their business but again you could wrap it up as a concern about them etc.

The visiting with DB and family over is something you can and should address head on. Tell your parents you want quality time with them and explain you want a few days or a week or whatever with you and them. If they say they can’t then explain you may not be able to visit as you and the kids don’t feel that you get time to spend with them. The ball is in their court but I wouldn’t visit them unless you get a good amount of time alone with them.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:17

I think a lot of elderly people don’t say no to requests for childcare from their children because they want to feel helpful / love their children. It’s still a big imposition and so much shouldn’t be asked in the first place.

But that's still not the fault of the person asking - parents should be enforcing boundaries with their adult children.

LittleBearPad · 21/08/2023 08:15

ChubbyMorticia · 21/08/2023 08:05

So, as I understand it, your parents enable your brother’s lifestyle to the point that it’s straining their finances. You’re enabling your parents by sending them money.

Perhaps you should start saying no, stop enabling, and start a chain reaction. If they need money, they can sell the second home, quit paying for your brother and his family.

Everyone in this situation is an adult. Nobody HAS to financially carry someone else, you’re all choosing it.

Agreed. Stop funding them. Their choice what they do with their money. If they can’t afford to sub DB they will need to tell him that.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 08:15

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 21/08/2023 08:07

I think they know that they'll need your DB and DSIL in their older years. I mean, are you planning to move back to look after them?

Well this is it, isn't it?

We live round the corner from my in-laws and they look after our dog for us while we work and from the outside it could look like we're taking advantage but we're also the ones they rely on to help them get to appointments, or to do their shopping in bad weather.

It's always DH who gets last-minute phone calls to help with various things, it's DH who goes over and does the jobs they can no longer manage etc.

It's all very well sitting there abroad and saying you helped pay for some meals once, but that's nothing in the grand scheme of things.

Ihatemoquitoes · 21/08/2023 08:14

WhaleSharkBootySweat · 21/08/2023 08:07

I think they know that they'll need your DB and DSIL in their older years. I mean, are you planning to move back to look after them?

We are in the process of relocating and will be living nearby so we should definitely have more quality time together. My parents are thrilled about it.

The rest won’t change but as some previous posters have said, I need to ask my dad to have a look at his finances before writing the next cheque (the irony as he was a financial director!).

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 21/08/2023 08:13

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 21/08/2023 07:58

Hmmm. I still think you're underestimating how much support your brother provides them - after all, if your parents didn't want to provide the childcare or take the dog - they would have said no, surely?

They clearly get something out of it - time with their grandchildren, company from the dog, and it means they see their adult son on a regular basis as an added bonus as well.

Hospital visits and meals are one tiny part of life - he's there for the everyday, maybe he feels as though you/your daughter should do some of it too?

Hmmm. I still think you're underestimating how much support your brother provides them - after all, if your parents didn't want to provide the childcare or take the dog - they would have said no, surely?

I think a lot of elderly people don’t say no to requests for childcare from their children because they want to feel helpful / love their children. It’s still a big imposition and so much shouldn’t be asked in the first place.

Swipe left for the next trending thread