Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BloodyPrime · 21/08/2023 14:53

Brieandcamembert · 21/08/2023 14:48

Sedate her and force her there if need be. She had no human rights left.There's always a way. The thing is. She's obviously so mentally unwell that im not sure she would feel empathy towards the families or remorse.

So she's sedated and therefore barely conscious - what even is the point? You might as well just bring a cut out of her in to the court if you're going to do that.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 21/08/2023 14:52

Brieandcamembert · 21/08/2023 14:48

Sedate her and force her there if need be. She had no human rights left.There's always a way. The thing is. She's obviously so mentally unwell that im not sure she would feel empathy towards the families or remorse.

Who would sedate her? No medical professional would do it as there is no medical need. Would you have an untrained person sedate her? What if they got it wrong and she was too lively or slept through the whole hearing? What if it caused her harm and she successfully claimed compensation?

Guess what, even prisoners have human rights.

ismu · 21/08/2023 14:52

Brieandcamembert · 21/08/2023 14:48

Sedate her and force her there if need be. She had no human rights left.There's always a way. The thing is. She's obviously so mentally unwell that im not sure she would feel empathy towards the families or remorse.

This thread 😳

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:51

peanutcrumble · 21/08/2023 13:08

@BloodyPrime it's not about her listening to those statements it's about her being present. The choice to be there or not shouldn't even be a thing and whoever made that rule I'd say is very disrespectful towards the family's of these scum her get to have a choice.

And to answer your second question. It's their job! They chose that role just like police/fire/security and any other profession that's dangerous chose theirs. No one's forced them to be there.

You really need to proofread your posts. As that first paragraph stands, you're calling the babies "scum".

Prison officers accept the dangers involved in keeping convicted criminals in custody, and we still really struggle to recruit and keep them. They do not accept unnecessary risks. If we make them take totally avoidable risks just for the satisfaction of baying Daily Mail headline writers and their less critical readers, how many do you imagine are going to stay in the job?

Brieandcamembert · 21/08/2023 14:48

Sedate her and force her there if need be. She had no human rights left.There's always a way. The thing is. She's obviously so mentally unwell that im not sure she would feel empathy towards the families or remorse.

FrillyGoatFluff · 21/08/2023 14:48

@ismu no, no guilt - just a misguided confidence that they were going to walk away scotfree and enjoyment of the drama, despite pleading guilty (although this was apparently because they thought they'd make the 'process quicker'). Pair of idiots.

I 100% agree with what everyone is saying with regards to safety of staff having to come first. But really, how have we come to this? It shouldn't be an option. Human rights are one thing, the rules of the court of the land is another. My children didn't have a choice about not attending when it comes to being called to give statements - they're the rules, you obviously abide by them. They had to do it. I fail to see why not attending for sentencing should even be an option?

BlueMoe · 21/08/2023 14:44

BeverleyMacker · 21/08/2023 13:24

I'm sorry?! She lost any rights when she committed those murders!!

Actually she didn’t- she didn’t lose the right to a fair trial; or the freedom from inhumane treatment (even in the context of her evil crimes).
Because throwing out the right to a fair trial is the end of democracy. It’s basic stuff.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:42

peanutcrumble · 21/08/2023 12:47

@WeetabixTowels anyone who fights for human rights for anyone who does these despicable crimes are sympathisers. They don't have humanly emotions and feelings so why we saying it's her right to not attend. All humans rights should be left at the door when you kill babies. They shouldn't get to choose/decide whether they can attend. Who made that daft rule up?

This is not primarily about human rights, it's about practicability, which you seem determined to ignore.

Or do you think prison officers' rights should be left at the door also?

Can you explain why it seems to make such a difference to you personally?

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:38

CoinsinaJar · 21/08/2023 12:45

Not read all the replies, but if being dragged there kicking and screaming, being physically retrained by however many shackles or other means is the only way, then so be it. There should be no right under law to refuse to attend these hearings.

By definition that means you are saying "So be it" to the high probability of prison officers being killed and maimed.

Could you explain how you justify that?

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 14:38

ismu · 21/08/2023 13:32

@BeverleyMacker human rights are inherent and inalienable.
You can't lose them, even if they are denied or taken away.
That's the whole point.

When should LL have lost her rights? When she was arrested? When she was charged? When she was found guilty?

How would you suggest that the justice system manages this in future?

Yes.

And I think a lot or people don't understand what fundamental human rights are, how they should apply to all humans regardless of how we judge individuals and how they benefit all of us

But also, have literally nothing to do with LL not attending court for sentencing but a lot of people seem to be frothing about it and claiming people are protecting her rights when that has nothing to do with UK criminal justice law or the human rights act.

A judge can make an order that a defendant should attend court. This is passed to a prison governor who has to assess the risks involved.

So they wouldn't want to risk death or injury to the inmate or staff so they usually won't do it. Which is legal and entirely appropriate.

Sorry to all you posters who don't care about staff so long as you'd get to see LL reactions.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:35

beeonmybonnett · 21/08/2023 12:41

Some people will probably disagree with me but yes OP I agree, all defendants in criminal cases should be made to attend court for all proceedings, not just their sentencing hearing .

There should be no choice. Handcuff then and take them to the court room. I don’t see how that can’t happen.

the next thing will be that criminals will be refusing to be arrested!

Quite ironic that this post should appear two posts below the one linking to the report of a prison officer being kicked to death by an inmate whilst escorting them.

Do you think that might just be a reason why this can't happen? To say nothing of the further reasons explained on this thread that you haven't bothered to read.

ismu · 21/08/2023 14:32

What a horrible experience @FrillyGoatFluff I'm glad you felt this helped you.
The perpetrator in your case obviously felt guilt of some kind and even by attending sentencing they showed this.
If someone declines to attend sentencing they aren't going to be in a place to face up to their responsibility and dragging them in isn't going to fix that, it might make it horrendously worse.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:27

peanutcrumble · 21/08/2023 12:38

@NOELScosmichelicopter then you are what I would call a sympathiser. They are human and they don't deserve to breath.

If you have to change the established meaning of well-known English words like "sympathiser" to suit your arguments, you really are admitting defeat.

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 14:26

BloodyPrime · 21/08/2023 14:09

Why does them hearing it matter? With LL, the judge has stated that she will recieve written copies of the impact statements and the sentencing comments, so its not as if she doesn't get to see what was said if she wants to (and presumably she can choose not to read them, just as she can choose not to listen to anything being piped in to her cell...). Why is it so desperately important that she hears the words as well?

There and pros and cons in making a statement as a victim. It’s interesting once you start looking into it.

Ultimately people are offered, but not compelled, to have their say in court as part of the process of achieving justice. Regardless of what a criminal may take from the words it’s generally important to the person who has participated in the opportunity that they hear their words. I don’t believe that Letby, or any other criminal, should be facilitated in hiding from the consequences of their actions.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:22

BeverleyMacker · 21/08/2023 12:34

Why is everyone assuming she's going to put up a fight anyway?

Letby might not, but if you are going to say that all convicts have to be in court for sentencing it's not hard to work out that some very nasty people are highly likely to put up a fight. Should we have different rules for thugs?

FrillyGoatFluff · 21/08/2023 14:22

I have sat in a court in sentencing and heard a judge sentence someone who caused harm to my children.

I studied their faces as they heard the victim statements, saw the tiny flickers of emotion. I watched them as he issued the sentences and believe me, watching them hear what they were facing, seeing the light of hope go out in their eyes - that helps. Doesn't make it better, but it feels good.

She should have been made to be in court, fucking coward.

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 14:18

I see the usual media arse rags have started targeting Letbys parents. Painting their non-attendance at the sentencing as a show of ‘solidarity’.

Got to feed the witch hunters.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:18

Restinggoddess · 21/08/2023 12:33

The issue is - at the moment they have the option to not attend. So by removing the option we develop a culture of them attending

Some may use the opportunity to cause a scene - construct the court in such a way as to mitigate this. Sound proof box which the sound of the court can be fed into but where the court does not hear the shouts etc
The dock being away from the victims family so fewer people see the spectacle of a guilty person kicking off. Personally have no problem in the use of handcuffs etc This person has put themselves beyond the social niceties
This will have to be done for some time to address a culture that has swung too far in the favour of the guilty

Whilst extra months or years cannot be added to a whole life term we could look at some of the privileges prisoners have. Haven’t we heard before of prisoners in more relaxed jails and having days out? Might not happen at first but never ceases to amaze me the opportunities they have. Clearly this will have an impact upon the prisoners and does not reflect a society that hopes for redemption- but there should be some sort of tariff of privileges

Once it is no longer a culture of allowing the guilty person to choose not to attend then the behaviour people fear - will be reduced. It should be normal to attend - we give these people too many rights and do not think of the victims and their families

None of those precautions in court remove the risk to court officers. The government just isn't going to go to the expense of retrofitting soundproof docks in courts, it doesn't even keep them in a state of acceptable repair.

Someone with a whole life term isn't going to end up in a category D prison. If you take away privileges, you take away incentives to behave and refrain from violence thus making life for the staff even more difficult and dangerous.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 14:15

BloodyPrime · 21/08/2023 14:09

Why does them hearing it matter? With LL, the judge has stated that she will recieve written copies of the impact statements and the sentencing comments, so its not as if she doesn't get to see what was said if she wants to (and presumably she can choose not to read them, just as she can choose not to listen to anything being piped in to her cell...). Why is it so desperately important that she hears the words as well?

Ask the relatives of many victims of this case and others some of whom who have spoken about the importance to them!

you forget this is not just about Letby and these relatives, but about all future cases.

she could rip a page up but by forcing her to listen to the audio means she either has to listen or hurt her own throat drowning it out in her own cell

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 21/08/2023 14:10

I wonder how many of the drag them kicking and screaming brigade would volunteer to drag someone like Robert Maudsley into a dock if they didn’t want to go.

BloodyPrime · 21/08/2023 14:09

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 14:04

Throughout the thread and on TV many experts have been discussing ways to make the convict hear the sentencing via technology

im sure it’s easy for society to put directions in place after speaking to the victims

Why does them hearing it matter? With LL, the judge has stated that she will recieve written copies of the impact statements and the sentencing comments, so its not as if she doesn't get to see what was said if she wants to (and presumably she can choose not to read them, just as she can choose not to listen to anything being piped in to her cell...). Why is it so desperately important that she hears the words as well?

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:06

Whammyyammy · 21/08/2023 11:48

What if she goes to court and receives a custodial sentence but 'refuses' to go to prison?
Do theu let her live in court? Let her go? Or drag her kicking and screaming to her cell...

This point has already been answered more than once.

Do keep up.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 21/08/2023 14:06

blubberyboo

What does this look like in practice?
but that doesn’t mean we can’t throw shame at them in bucketloads

Dontcallmescarface · 21/08/2023 14:06

So let's say that the law is changed to "drag prisoners kicking and screaming" into court for sentencing. Then what? Do people honestly think that prisoner will sit meekly in the dock as victim statements are read and whilst they are being sentenced? My guess would be no they won't. They will disrupt proceedings until eventually they are ordered to be removed from the court, rendering the whole "drag 'em there" process worthless. Yes maybe add a few years on the sentence but in the case of LL she got a whole life anyway so no point adding anymore on that.

Honestly some people need to think ideas through before jumping on the nearest passing bandwagon.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:04

peanutcrumble · 21/08/2023 11:42

@BeverleyMacker shocking from some on here. Wonder if they would feel the same if it was their baby murdered.

Who? You keep talking about people who sympathise with Letby, you seem to be wholly incapable of pointing out the relevant posts.

Probably because they don't exist