Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:54

ismu · 21/08/2023 15:53

@thedancingbear @blubberyboo in all honesty if you think about it you and some other posters seem similar to LL rather than the people you're accusing of being sympathisers. I don't want to hurt or harm anyone or make other nameless employees and guards torture prisoners. Those are not far off the kind of things LL has actually been convicted of.
What kind of punishment would satisfy you? If it's the death penalty just come out and say it

What the actual fuck are you talking about?

don’t dare put words in my mouth

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 15:53

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:42

There could be a camera in the cell that is played to the court so that the judge and public gallery can see their reactions

they could be handcuffed so that they can’t stick fingers in ears

if the convict starts making rude gestures the court officials could turn the video off so the gallery can’t see but the convict never knows if they are being seen or not.

if they shout then the audio to the court can be turned off

meantime the court audio is continually played to the convict

it takes their power away

I agree. We should also cut off their eyelids so they can't help looking at the victim's faces.

Fucking mental. Honestly.

ismu · 21/08/2023 15:53

@thedancingbear @blubberyboo in all honesty if you think about it you and some other posters seem similar to LL rather than the people you're accusing of being sympathisers. I don't want to hurt or harm anyone or make other nameless employees and guards torture prisoners. Those are not far off the kind of things LL has actually been convicted of.
What kind of punishment would satisfy you? If it's the death penalty just come out and say it

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:52

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 15:31

Isn't that a bit pointless if in effect they have a mental barrier which means the shame you throw slides harmlessly off them? Or indeed if they enjoy it?

How does anyone know what shame a person feels?

Letby might have felt shame not about the babies, but about the affect on her own parents. She might have felt shame to know that her lover, friends and colleagues were hearing what she was hearing and would now be disgusted by her. She wanted to be nice Lucy.

every single murder case is different and it’s very sweeping to assume all murder convicts won’t feel some shame.

as a society we have a duty to try

it might not work and truth is we’ll never know as many will have crocodile tears. But it’s the victims only chance to inflict that upon them so they should have the opportunity. They should also have the opportunity to control what they see by use of technology. It gives the family all the power and the convict none

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 15:47

She may well get a thrill hearing them rather than the remorse and upset many posters seem to think will happen. She might just sit there humming away in her head, smirking or grinning, not giving two hoots of what the parents are going through

in Letby’s case specifically I don’t think those scenarios are likely based on the fact she refused to go to the sentencing. To me that indicates there’s a degree of shame and/or understanding of the gravity the consequences of her actions on her part. Certainly a denial of the reality that is currently happening.

We don’t know enough about her motivations or thought processes to make that kind of call tbh. The victim statements are essentially evidence of the repercussions of her actions and she should hear them in the same way she’s heard the rest of the evidence. I genuinely didn’t realise that it is so easy to simply refuse to attend your own trial but that does leave victims with questions about watching the reactions of the person who’s harmed them which I recognise is important. No reaction or ‘mocking’ gives a point where perhaps victims can let go of an element of their anger about not getting an admission or any remorse because it’s clear that the perpetrator just doesn’t care. It makes that more real.

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 15:44

JaukiVexnoydi · 21/08/2023 15:37

Human rights means that the only qualification needed to have those rights is the fact of being human. Additional rights accrue to those who aren't criminals but if something is a human right then it cannot be lost. Any rights that are removed from convicted criminals will also be removed from the wrongfully convicted, and from those who are convicted of crimes which are generally understood to be "the best they could have done under the circumstances" (eg if someone is convicted of manslaughter where the circumstances are such that it wasn't far off from being what might be considered "lawful killing" or "self defense" but for some detail that made the manslaughter charge stick.) - so no I don't want anyone to lose their human rights. The justice system isn't perfect, and does make mistakes. You cannot make good law from a place of emotive hatred of the evil done by one criminal.

You can prove anything with facts

you are a SYMPATHISER And i think you are DISCUSTING

Am I doing this right?

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:42

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 15:39

How does audio in the cell set an example to anyone? By definition it's not public.

It's not something I actually object to, because it least it doesn't entail expecting prison officers to risk their lives. But I don't understand the point. Presumably no-one could stop her sitting there with her fingers in her ears and singing? How would victims feel if they heard she sat there laughing as if she was hearing a funny story and begging for it all to be played again? Or, worse, if she was using it all as some sort of sexual stimulant?

There could be a camera in the cell that is played to the court so that the judge and public gallery can see their reactions

they could be handcuffed so that they can’t stick fingers in ears

if the convict starts making rude gestures the court officials could turn the video off so the gallery can’t see but the convict never knows if they are being seen or not.

if they shout then the audio to the court can be turned off

meantime the court audio is continually played to the convict

it takes their power away

Dontcallmescarface · 21/08/2023 15:40

FrillyGoatFluff · 21/08/2023 14:22

I have sat in a court in sentencing and heard a judge sentence someone who caused harm to my children.

I studied their faces as they heard the victim statements, saw the tiny flickers of emotion. I watched them as he issued the sentences and believe me, watching them hear what they were facing, seeing the light of hope go out in their eyes - that helps. Doesn't make it better, but it feels good.

She should have been made to be in court, fucking coward.

When I read out mine, he just smirked all the way through it and laughed at the end. I'd rather he hadn't been there at all if I'm honest. It felt like he was attacking me all over again.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:39

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:35

Quite ironic that this post should appear two posts below the one linking to the report of a prison officer being kicked to death by an inmate whilst escorting them.

Do you think that might just be a reason why this can't happen? To say nothing of the further reasons explained on this thread that you haven't bothered to read.

you think a convict suddenly develops more power to kick someone to death after spending a few weeks or months on remand?

if we are able to apprehend people in the first place then we are able to move them to where they need to go

or at least force them to be in a room where the sentencing is played on a screen

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 15:39

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 14:02

No it isnt

it serves as an example to others in society

for many relatives it’s something they have waited for

Many experts have been talking of ways to achieve it it conjunction with the victims eg via audio into the cell

How does audio in the cell set an example to anyone? By definition it's not public.

It's not something I actually object to, because it least it doesn't entail expecting prison officers to risk their lives. But I don't understand the point. Presumably no-one could stop her sitting there with her fingers in her ears and singing? How would victims feel if they heard she sat there laughing as if she was hearing a funny story and begging for it all to be played again? Or, worse, if she was using it all as some sort of sexual stimulant?

JaukiVexnoydi · 21/08/2023 15:37

Human rights means that the only qualification needed to have those rights is the fact of being human. Additional rights accrue to those who aren't criminals but if something is a human right then it cannot be lost. Any rights that are removed from convicted criminals will also be removed from the wrongfully convicted, and from those who are convicted of crimes which are generally understood to be "the best they could have done under the circumstances" (eg if someone is convicted of manslaughter where the circumstances are such that it wasn't far off from being what might be considered "lawful killing" or "self defense" but for some detail that made the manslaughter charge stick.) - so no I don't want anyone to lose their human rights. The justice system isn't perfect, and does make mistakes. You cannot make good law from a place of emotive hatred of the evil done by one criminal.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 15:31

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 13:58

It’s not about what they feel

sure anybody capable of such crimes is unlikely to feel shame

but that doesn’t mean we can’t throw shame at them in bucketloads

Isn't that a bit pointless if in effect they have a mental barrier which means the shame you throw slides harmlessly off them? Or indeed if they enjoy it?

Wakintoblueskies · 21/08/2023 15:20

There are certainly people who are gleeful at the prospect of Letby being attacked in prison.

As this keeps being brought up….
How will the prison officers protect her?
Will she be kept in solitary for her own protection?

There have been many reports of misconduct by prison officers towards inmates. What steps are taken to prevent this?

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 15:16

BeverleyMacker · 21/08/2023 13:24

I'm sorry?! She lost any rights when she committed those murders!!

As a matter of law passed by our Parliament, no, she didn't. If you want a system whereby people convicted of serious offences have no human rights, would you want that to apply to you given that no-one can guarantee that they will avoid wrongful convictions?

If you want a system where everyone convicted of murder automatically loses all human rights, where does that leave us with people like Andrew Malkison, Sally Clarke, Angela Canning, Stefan Kiszko? If we had then away their rights, the chances are that they would all have been killed in prison without any chance to prove their innocence.

If you set up a system where convicts people automatically lose all their rights and therefore the weaker ones won't survive any sentence, you will find juries increasingly unwilling to convict. That is what happened in the days of death sentences, so it would undoubtedly happen again now.

BloodyPrime · 21/08/2023 15:13

jessycake · 21/08/2023 15:07

I think she should at least have to attend through a live video link , there can be no excuse for that .

But why though? I mean, you're right, that could probably be done - though it would involve some costs to allow for the technology, and again, she'd have to be restrained in some way so that she stays on camera and 'looking'. She still can't be forced to listen/watch because she can close her eyes and concentrate on something other than listening. She could spend the time smirking, laughing, making gestures. Who does that benefit?
So I don't really understand what is to be gained by her being there via video link (or in person) - other than appeasing some sort of belief that she 'should be there'.
(Also, can you imagine the faffing 'you're on mute!' 'oh, wait, the internet has dropped out - hang on everyone while we sort the connection')

Qilin · 21/08/2023 15:12

People saying you think she should be forced to,listen to the witness statements?

You're thinking about this from your own pov, how you think you'd feel hearing those statements.

But she clearly isn't like you. She carried out those actions, over and over. She may well get a thrill hearing them rather than the remorse and upset many posters seem to think will happen. She might just sit there humming away in her head, smirking or grinning, not giving two hoots of what the parents are going through. How does that benefit the parents? To see someone sat not caring about that they say? If anything it could make the whole ordeal even harder.

You can't force a killer to care about their victims.
Even dragging them out by their hair, as some posters want, doesn't mean they will care.

Quite possibly the best thing now is for the sentence to be done and for her to be locked away indefinitely. Her name and face no longer dominating the news of the events. Left to play out her life behind bars with her name kept out of it. Not for her sake - but because quite often killers seek the notoriety and the publicity, so taking that away means they can't feel the thrill of hearing themselves spoken about.

It's time for the families and the victims to be the one remembered. For their stories to be heard, for their children's stories to be known.
For their children's names to be the one that are remembered.

JaukiVexnoydi · 21/08/2023 15:11

I think it's right that she can't be forced to attend. The fact that she choses not to attend can and should be used as evidence that she hasn't engaged with the enormity of her crimes and any kind of remorse is a long long way off from her current state of mind - in the unlikely event that she is ever considered for release, that should be taken into account as reasons why she shouldn't be. I hope that recordings of todays testimony are permanently kept and available such that Lucy can never claim that she "regrets" this decision without it being very clear that she can and should engage with them and listen to them because they will always be available to her.

jessycake · 21/08/2023 15:07

I think she should at least have to attend through a live video link , there can be no excuse for that .

WeetabixTowels · 21/08/2023 15:07

Brieandcamembert · 21/08/2023 14:48

Sedate her and force her there if need be. She had no human rights left.There's always a way. The thing is. She's obviously so mentally unwell that im not sure she would feel empathy towards the families or remorse.

What’s the point of having her sedate if she’s there? She can’t hear if she’s asleep.

And she does have human rights. Her legal rights are just restricted as if everyone’s at HMP

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 15:06

Brieandcamembert · 21/08/2023 14:48

Sedate her and force her there if need be. She had no human rights left.There's always a way. The thing is. She's obviously so mentally unwell that im not sure she would feel empathy towards the families or remorse.

From what I understand she almost certainly is not ‘mentally ill’. She’s a human being. One capable of atrocious acts.

I also agree there is no point in sedating her. If she was wheeled in half conscious she will be viewed with more sympathy than someone fully aware.

Given the ease with which you dismiss human rights I suspect you don’t fully comprehend what they are. funnily enough this thread is only here because someone found it easy to dismiss the human rights of others.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 15:06

Wakintoblueskies · 21/08/2023 13:19

Nobody is ‘gleeful’ about these horrendous crimes and serial killer. What a strange choice of word you chose to use.

People are horrified, they can’t get their heads around it. Nobody is pleased. Are you quite alright?

There are certainly people who are gleeful at the prospect of Letby being attacked in prison.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 21/08/2023 15:02

FrillyGoatFluff · 21/08/2023 14:48

@ismu no, no guilt - just a misguided confidence that they were going to walk away scotfree and enjoyment of the drama, despite pleading guilty (although this was apparently because they thought they'd make the 'process quicker'). Pair of idiots.

I 100% agree with what everyone is saying with regards to safety of staff having to come first. But really, how have we come to this? It shouldn't be an option. Human rights are one thing, the rules of the court of the land is another. My children didn't have a choice about not attending when it comes to being called to give statements - they're the rules, you obviously abide by them. They had to do it. I fail to see why not attending for sentencing should even be an option?

Because sometimes reality is unpalatable. We don't have a mechanism for forcing dangerous prisoners to be somewhere they don't want to be, without significantly endangering the staff who have to make them. It doesn't exist, which is the reason so many prison staff are seriously assaulted, and occasionally killed on the job.

Yeah, it would be great if it weren't this way. It would also be great if nobody ever committed those sort of crimes in the first place, while I've got my magic wand out, but this is the reality we're stuck with.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 14:57

Mukey · 21/08/2023 13:12

People are saying you can't just force someone to go somewhere even in this situation. Well you can. They force people to go to prison who don't want to go.
For what is worth I don't agree they should force her/ anyone to go to the sentencing. Mainly because of the disruption it could cause if the person says something awful or starts trying to hurt themselves.
But the fact remains that people can and are forced to do things that include being physically forced if necessary. So if the law was to change that they needed to attend then yes they could well be physically forced to go. The same way they would be physically forced to go to prison.

The post was in response to someone asking why not force them because we currently force people to attend trial and it doesn't cause problems. So I pointed out that we don't force people to attend trial.

Yes, we can physically force people to be there if we are willing to put prison officers' lives at risk and can recruit officers who are happy to be put in that situation. But that then brings into play the next bit, about it not causing problems, because obviously it can and probably would. None of them seem justifiable when put in comparison with the highly dubious benefits of forcing convicts to attend.

CurlewKate · 21/08/2023 14:56

We have a rule of law. Let go of that and we have nothing.

AllOfThemWitches · 21/08/2023 14:55

FrillyGoatFluff · 21/08/2023 14:22

I have sat in a court in sentencing and heard a judge sentence someone who caused harm to my children.

I studied their faces as they heard the victim statements, saw the tiny flickers of emotion. I watched them as he issued the sentences and believe me, watching them hear what they were facing, seeing the light of hope go out in their eyes - that helps. Doesn't make it better, but it feels good.

She should have been made to be in court, fucking coward.

Sorry you've been through that but I think anyone expecting this evil piece of shit to feel any 'emotion' in this context is misguided.

Swipe left for the next trending thread