Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PinkCherryBlossoms · 21/08/2023 17:31

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:01

It’s not a silly post

you are saying there is a risk when prisoners are moved and officers should not be placed in an unnecessary risk

there was absolutely no reason for Letby to be put in a van and taken to Manchester today when she had already stated she would not appear.

she was only sent because the rules state that the prison have to send her.

why was this risk acceptable to you?

I'm saying the risk should not be increased by forcing people into court on more occasions than they are now.

You are free to argue that the current level of risk is also unjustifiable if you want, but that's your case to make not mine. It also further strengthens the argument that it shouldn't be increased.

It remains the case that you were wrong to say that when we apprehend people, that means we also have the resources to transport them anywhere we want them to be. And that the comment about remand was idiotic.

As I said, silly.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 17:26

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:52

How does anyone know what shame a person feels?

Letby might have felt shame not about the babies, but about the affect on her own parents. She might have felt shame to know that her lover, friends and colleagues were hearing what she was hearing and would now be disgusted by her. She wanted to be nice Lucy.

every single murder case is different and it’s very sweeping to assume all murder convicts won’t feel some shame.

as a society we have a duty to try

it might not work and truth is we’ll never know as many will have crocodile tears. But it’s the victims only chance to inflict that upon them so they should have the opportunity. They should also have the opportunity to control what they see by use of technology. It gives the family all the power and the convict none

You really are doing victims and their families a massive disservice if you believe that this is the only chance to show a criminal how shameful their actions have been.

The process begins as soon as someone is charged and becomes dependent on the courts for permission even to stay free pending trial. It continues during the trial when they are seated separately from everyone else but where they can be watched by not only their victims but also members of the general public, and their activities can be reported on in the press. Finally, of course, the main source of shame lies in being sentenced, especially if it is a custodial sentence. Basically you're telling people that they can't live in society, can't live with their families, can't go out when they want to, and have to spend their days doing exactly what they're told, no matter how demeaning or actively unpleasant, if they want life to be halfway tolerable. In this case, you're telling Letby that that state of affairs will last for ever.

If you want them to have to acknowledge their victims, part of the work they will have to do in prison will entail facing that also. They don't get to walk away from what they've done.

If you don't think that inflicts shame and takes away power, I struggle to understand your thought processes.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:18

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:13

Just makes me wonder how often you jump to conclusions based on no data...

No I was talking about myself and the fact this is mumsnet

I can’t help it if you are so self centred that you have to make this about you

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:15

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 21/08/2023 17:10

I realise I’m massively in the minority here but no I don’t think she should be made to attend.

As the judge said she relished in what she said. I would worry she would only relish in seeing the pain and hurt in these poor parents. She has shown no remorse and I don’t see what actually seeing her would actually give them anyway. It won’t give them closure or help their pain and I doubt she’s going go show she cares.

I think if she was going to relish in their pain she would have turned up today

she was hiding

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:13

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:07

Well I apologise if you are not a mum but it’s hardly relevant at all to the discussion

maybe you aren’t a member of the public either FFS

Just makes me wonder how often you jump to conclusions based on no data...

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:12

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 17:06

It's a strange day when people basically advocating torture are claiming the moral high ground...

Because they care more you know!

More than the people who work in the prison service and as solicitors or judges

By baying for blood and demanding torture they care more

Just not enough to actually do a damn thing about it. Not even enough to write an email.

Unlike the prison service and the solicitors and judges who are actually out there making the world safer. But what do they know...

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 21/08/2023 17:10

I realise I’m massively in the minority here but no I don’t think she should be made to attend.

As the judge said she relished in what she said. I would worry she would only relish in seeing the pain and hurt in these poor parents. She has shown no remorse and I don’t see what actually seeing her would actually give them anyway. It won’t give them closure or help their pain and I doubt she’s going go show she cares.

HeatherMoores · 21/08/2023 17:09

*lose 🙄

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:07

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:06

As it is , just like you, I’m a mum and a member of public

Well I apologise if you are not a mum but it’s hardly relevant at all to the discussion

maybe you aren’t a member of the public either FFS

HeatherMoores · 21/08/2023 17:07

You can’t force someone like that to do things as getting a life sentence means they have nothing to loose and could behave bow they like putting others at risk. Or severely disrupting the court.
Piping it into her cell doesn’t mean she’d listen.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 17:06

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 15:47

She may well get a thrill hearing them rather than the remorse and upset many posters seem to think will happen. She might just sit there humming away in her head, smirking or grinning, not giving two hoots of what the parents are going through

in Letby’s case specifically I don’t think those scenarios are likely based on the fact she refused to go to the sentencing. To me that indicates there’s a degree of shame and/or understanding of the gravity the consequences of her actions on her part. Certainly a denial of the reality that is currently happening.

We don’t know enough about her motivations or thought processes to make that kind of call tbh. The victim statements are essentially evidence of the repercussions of her actions and she should hear them in the same way she’s heard the rest of the evidence. I genuinely didn’t realise that it is so easy to simply refuse to attend your own trial but that does leave victims with questions about watching the reactions of the person who’s harmed them which I recognise is important. No reaction or ‘mocking’ gives a point where perhaps victims can let go of an element of their anger about not getting an admission or any remorse because it’s clear that the perpetrator just doesn’t care. It makes that more real.

The victims' families have already been able to see her reactions, both at the time of their children's illnesses and/or deaths, and during the trial.

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 17:06

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:02

Because it allows people to pretend they have the moral high ground over those who have pointed out the obvious flaws with the solutions on the thread

It's a strange day when people basically advocating torture are claiming the moral high ground...

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:06

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:05

Where did I make an assumption about you?

As it is , just like you, I’m a mum and a member of public

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:05

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:01

Some incorrect assumptions made about me there but fair enough, I get it, you are willing to spend hours on MN arguing about it but not 5 mins on an email to an MP

So it's not that important after all

Where did I make an assumption about you?

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:02

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 16:57

What does that all achieve for the victims' relatives? I just don't see how anyone gets any closure out of watching someone sitting in a cell, or watching a blank screen? It doesn't take Einstein to work out what behaviour will force the court to turn off the camera and microphone.

The reality is that you can't take away control. Even if you handcuff and gag the criminal, they can still mentally switch off and ignore everything that is happening.

Because it allows people to pretend they have the moral high ground over those who have pointed out the obvious flaws with the solutions on the thread

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 17:01

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 16:54

Lol If had wanted to be involved in overhauling English courts I’d be an MP myself.

As it is , just like you, I’m a mum and a member of public giving my opinion on a current case under the AIBU section of a website called Mumsnet.

The families of many other murder victims who have been affected by this issue have already started campaigns and it is much more meaningful coming from them. They have lived it and they are asking for it to be implemented

if they set up a petition that aligns with my views I’ll certainly sign it.

If you wish to not sign it then you of course that’s what you’ll do

Some incorrect assumptions made about me there but fair enough, I get it, you are willing to spend hours on MN arguing about it but not 5 mins on an email to an MP

So it's not that important after all

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:01

PinkCherryBlossoms · 21/08/2023 16:41

This is another silly post.

Let's agree there's a risk every time a prisoner is moved. That means an increase in the number of times they're moved clearly increases the risk to staff. Not giving a shit about that risk because hey, there's no way to remove it entirely is as fuckwitted as leaving your front door wide open because you can't completely remove the risk of burglary.

The onus is on those people who want to expose prison and court staff to this increased risk not only to justify it, but explain how it would be managed practically in a system where we already don't have enough of them. That will not be done with strawmen about removing the risk entirely, which everyone agrees is impossible.

It’s not a silly post

you are saying there is a risk when prisoners are moved and officers should not be placed in an unnecessary risk

there was absolutely no reason for Letby to be put in a van and taken to Manchester today when she had already stated she would not appear.

she was only sent because the rules state that the prison have to send her.

why was this risk acceptable to you?

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 16:57

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:42

There could be a camera in the cell that is played to the court so that the judge and public gallery can see their reactions

they could be handcuffed so that they can’t stick fingers in ears

if the convict starts making rude gestures the court officials could turn the video off so the gallery can’t see but the convict never knows if they are being seen or not.

if they shout then the audio to the court can be turned off

meantime the court audio is continually played to the convict

it takes their power away

What does that all achieve for the victims' relatives? I just don't see how anyone gets any closure out of watching someone sitting in a cell, or watching a blank screen? It doesn't take Einstein to work out what behaviour will force the court to turn off the camera and microphone.

The reality is that you can't take away control. Even if you handcuff and gag the criminal, they can still mentally switch off and ignore everything that is happening.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 16:54

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 16:44

Ah so you are willing to complain about the current solution but not be one of the people working to fix it

It's so unimportant to you you can't even take 5 mins to email your MP with your support

Wow

Lol If had wanted to be involved in overhauling English courts I’d be an MP myself.

As it is , just like you, I’m a mum and a member of public giving my opinion on a current case under the AIBU section of a website called Mumsnet.

The families of many other murder victims who have been affected by this issue have already started campaigns and it is much more meaningful coming from them. They have lived it and they are asking for it to be implemented

if they set up a petition that aligns with my views I’ll certainly sign it.

If you wish to not sign it then you of course that’s what you’ll do

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 16:44

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 16:37

I don’t need to thanks

Many experts were already discussing it in news reports today

I’m not claiming credit for the idea

Ah so you are willing to complain about the current solution but not be one of the people working to fix it

It's so unimportant to you you can't even take 5 mins to email your MP with your support

Wow

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 16:42

JaukiVexnoydi · 21/08/2023 16:35

If someone is wrongfully convicted then forcing them to sit through an emotive victim impact statement session would be psychological torture. I don't think LL is innocent at all, but I don't want anything to happen to her that I wouldn't be OK with happening to me if I got wrongfully convicted of something due to a miscarriage of justice. I would want to be treated with respect and human dignity and kept safe from harm. Deprivation of liberty is bad enough without being strapped down and forced to listen to/watch anything at all. The Clockwork Orange isn't supposed to be an instruction manual, it's an illustration of a dystopian nightmare scenario. Some miscarriages of justice aren't proven for many years. There was a recent case of a man who spent 17 years in prison for a rape he didn't commit but eventually DNA evidence linked the crime to a totally different person.

Exactly

And people on the thread are basically saying that they would have been okay with him being dragged, tied down, tasered, gagged, had unnecessary sedation, denied family visits, denied privileges, stripped of all human rights, denied the right to appeal if there was new evidence or a miscarriage of justice (as indeed there was in his case) all if he hadn't been able to force himself to go to the sentencing of a crime he didn't commit.

So he went through all of that he would probably still be in prison yet completely innocent, having been tortured.

And give he was innocent that could have been anyones father, son or husband. So if you are sitting there proposing horrific ideas thinking it doesn't matter because it will never apply to you, it could. Because innocent people do end up in jail.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 16:42

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 15:39

you think a convict suddenly develops more power to kick someone to death after spending a few weeks or months on remand?

if we are able to apprehend people in the first place then we are able to move them to where they need to go

or at least force them to be in a room where the sentencing is played on a screen

We know that convicts have the power to kick someone to death. It has happened. Being on remand doesn't prevent people from taking exercise and keeping their muscles fully developed - rather the reverse, as they have so much time to exercise.

Do you really feel you know better than the experienced prison officers on this thread?

As I've said, I don't have any particular problems with the sentencing remarks being played to people in a cell, but I don't see what it would achieve. We still can't force them to listen or pay attention, and we can't stop them laughing at it all.

I'm a bit baffled about what people perceive the magic power of sentencing remarks to be. Do you imagine they will suddenly cause a convict to feel massive remorse? Because I can't help feeling we would have seen some evidence by now if that were the case.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 21/08/2023 16:41

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 16:34

Prisoners are still brought to the courts today

letby was brought there today due to the current rules whereby prisons must send the prisoner

If you are seeking to eliminating all risk to the officers then you need to be advocating that they are not even removed from their remand prison to be sent to court.

This is another silly post.

Let's agree there's a risk every time a prisoner is moved. That means an increase in the number of times they're moved clearly increases the risk to staff. Not giving a shit about that risk because hey, there's no way to remove it entirely is as fuckwitted as leaving your front door wide open because you can't completely remove the risk of burglary.

The onus is on those people who want to expose prison and court staff to this increased risk not only to justify it, but explain how it would be managed practically in a system where we already don't have enough of them. That will not be done with strawmen about removing the risk entirely, which everyone agrees is impossible.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 16:37

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 16:33

And as I said in the post you are responding to:

If you think it's a good idea then set up a campaign for it.

I don’t need to thanks

Many experts were already discussing it in news reports today

I’m not claiming credit for the idea

JaukiVexnoydi · 21/08/2023 16:35

If someone is wrongfully convicted then forcing them to sit through an emotive victim impact statement session would be psychological torture. I don't think LL is innocent at all, but I don't want anything to happen to her that I wouldn't be OK with happening to me if I got wrongfully convicted of something due to a miscarriage of justice. I would want to be treated with respect and human dignity and kept safe from harm. Deprivation of liberty is bad enough without being strapped down and forced to listen to/watch anything at all. The Clockwork Orange isn't supposed to be an instruction manual, it's an illustration of a dystopian nightmare scenario. Some miscarriages of justice aren't proven for many years. There was a recent case of a man who spent 17 years in prison for a rape he didn't commit but eventually DNA evidence linked the crime to a totally different person.