Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 08:52

LAHallucinations · 20/08/2023 22:59

I dont know why people are so hung up on this, its irrelevant if she attends, it means nothing. The sentence is the sentence, she has already been convicted, the job is done regardless of whether she is sitting there to hear it or not.

Well the families of the victims might not think it's 'irrelevant' or 'means nothing'. They might want to see justice being done, with Letby in the dock. And it's not just the sentencing she'll miss, but also the victim impact statements. It might be very important to those parents that Letby is forced to listen to their words and hear how much damage she's caused.

There definitely has to be some sort of punishment for not attending sentencing. Either a longer sentence, or (for people already facing life in prison) some sort of removal of privileges. I saw that an MP has suggested that the audio is live streamed into Letby's cell, which is a good idea.

The thing is that, as much as they may want it, there is still nothing that can make a defendant listen if they don't want to. Why promise something that can't be delivered?

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 08:51

mumof1or2 · 21/08/2023 01:37

The same way she was "forced" to attend the court case I guess? To everyone saying you can't physically make them go, we physically make defendants attend their own court cases and it doesn't seem to cause too many problems. So why not the sentencing?

She wasn't forced to attend. It was her one and only chance to defend herself, she obviously wanted to attend.

Hoppinggreen · 21/08/2023 08:50

She has a legal right not to attend. Even people who have committed such awful crimes as this still have legal rights and so they should.
We can’t pick and choose who is worthy of our legal system and it’s protections

Stormyseasallround · 21/08/2023 08:50

Those wanting her to hear the effect on those poor families seem to be missing a key point:

When she murdered each baby, she saw the effects on the family up close and personal. She saw them collapse to the floor, heard them howl in unimaginable agony, watched their faces collapse. She stood there and watched it all first-hand, while pretending to care and to console them. She watched them cuddle their dead baby, heard their conversations, even made memory boxes for them.

Then she did it again and again and again.

She presumably gets some sort of self-gratification from their grief. Listening to them relive it at sentencing isn’t going to get the reaction you’re all hoping for.

BreatheAndFocus · 21/08/2023 08:49

I still don’t get why she can’t be forced (within reason). Surely some prisoners are very obstructive to purposely be a nuisance, refusing to do anything they’re told? They’re still put in their cells at night, they’re still handcuffed when necessary, they’re still transferred to other prisons, etc. Letby is a normal-sized woman. Couldn’t two or three male officers put handcuffs on her and frogmarch her into court?

If she started shouting and disrupting proceedings, she could be removed back to the court cell, remain in cuffs and supervised, and be forced to listen to the proceedings via audio.

What if she or future prisoners then refuse to leave the prison to go to court? Broadcast the proceedings to their cell or a suitable prison room where they listen cuffed and supervised.

It can’t beyond the realms of imagination to ensure such people are made to listen. Although a tiny, tiny minority might shout and worse, I think the majority will comply grudgingly when they realise there’s no choice and they’ll be hearing it anyway, whether in the court or their cell. People like Letby shouldn’t be given the power of having the choice.

MansfieldLark · 21/08/2023 08:48

If she went on hunger strike and refused to eat or drink, noone could make her could they?

itsgettingweird · 21/08/2023 08:48

Soffin I get you disagree with me fine.

But why quote something I've said and then out a bold sentence underneath that is not my words as evidence to disagree with me?

MrsToothyBitch · 21/08/2023 08:48

I read that the UK has become a more punitive society within the last decade. In terms of stiffer sentences, I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing. But the mouth frothing and baying for blood and suggestions of brute force on here suggest we're becoming a much less rational society. I feel the mark of how we as a state treat our lowest, meanest members needs to be set higher than the level of those lowest, meanest members themselves. Emotion doesn't lend itself to this. It undermines it and twists it. There is a reason Justice is depicted as blind; she will be sentenced either way, life will go on, process will trundle on.

So no, don't force her or change the law. We should let her absence show her up for the coward she is. Let her cowardice and the statements of her victims be the headlines and the conclusion to the case. Then let her be forgotten. I personally think her absence puts her victims at the forefront anyway.

GlobetrottingPercy · 21/08/2023 08:42

If an offender genuinely did not feel remorse about what they had done and were proud of it, the victim impact statement would either have no impact or make them feel even better knowing the pain that they have caused to someone. In that case, what would be the benefit of forcing them to attend? Or forcing them to listen to the judge saying that they have committed a ‘heinous crime’?
What benefit would there be for the families to see them smiling and laughing at them the whole time?

I’m not saying this is LL as none of us know what her thoughts are on it, however it is a wider discussion to be had. I agree with the PP that, with the greatest respect, we cannot allow family members to dictate how the law is enforced. If someone refuses to attend court for sentencing but the family wish to look them in the eye, even if that person will take pleasure in their pain, could this not be arranged as a prison visit?

Solonge · 21/08/2023 08:41

MansfieldLark · 20/08/2023 22:12

Said this on a different thread but I strongly believe she will be in a secure hospital like Rampton and not prison.

Didnt an expert witness, a psychiatrist say she was born with a psychotic personality? My understanding is psychosis can be treated with drugs but never cured.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 08:40

flapjackfairy · 20/08/2023 22:36

Well the victims families should have the right to read their statements to the perpetrator in court if they want to. Some have said that it was a v important part of the process for them
And of course they could make her attend. They could hand cuff her and gag her if needs be.
She should not have any rights at all at this point. So the families wishes should be paramount and if they want to see her sentenced face to.face then they should be afforded that right.

What if they read their statements to her and she blatantly doesn't listen? Suppose she's sitting there with her hands in her ears shouting and singing? Indeed, some people can make themselves not mentally "present" so that none of what is going on around them penetrates. Will that make the families feel better?

User15387500 · 21/08/2023 08:38

Are the Daily Mail readers on here, they are calling for her to be dragged to court

MadamWhiteleigh · 21/08/2023 08:35

Sofifn · 21/08/2023 08:18

its irrelevant if she attends, it means nothing

Not to victims and their families. It means something to them. And they should be the ones who people care about, not the criminals. Get them there with a taser, or in a straight jacket, tell them there’s no chance of parole if they don’t, stop their family visits, I really don’t care how. When you’re the family of a victim and you want that person in court, and as I’ve said, in some cases people don’t, in other cases, you damned we’ll do, then they should be forced to attend.

If the victims want it, it isn’t a case of people on here saying ‘what does it matter?’ It bloody well matters to them. So sick of hearing about people defending murderers and rapists rights. Fuck their rights. They didn’t care about the rights of their victims or their families and loved ones.

With the greatest respect, decisions on law shouldn’t be made based on the feelings of the families of victims. They are, naturally, emotionally charged and heavily biased opinions, whereas you need a balanced and impartial decision-making process. We wouldn’t allow a family member to be judge or jury for the same reasons and everyone understands and accepts that.

Why does it need to be a balanced and impartial decision-making process? So that the law is as robust as it can be and therefore we can bring these people to justice in the first place. If you want those people to be tried and punished, you need a functioning justice system.

user1471505494 · 21/08/2023 08:34

ohcrums · 20/08/2023 22:13

I agree it needs reviewing, perhaps they could add 5 years on and no privileges ever if they don't attend

You would rather force a defendant into court to possibly cause even more grief to the families by outbursts or other similar unpleasant behaviour for what reason. Prisoners do have rights and knee jerk reactions to horrendous acts helps no one

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 08:34

ohcrums · 20/08/2023 22:13

I agree it needs reviewing, perhaps they could add 5 years on and no privileges ever if they don't attend

If someone has a whole life term then the extra 5 years is meaningless. Prison officers would strongly resist any sort of "No privileges ever" punishment because it removes any incentive to behave in prison. If you're looking at the rest of your life in prison with nothing that will ever make it better but also nothing that can make it worse, you have nothing whatsoever to lose by being violent or homicidal.

lollipoprainbow · 21/08/2023 08:33

I didn't realise that offenders refusing to attend court for their sentencing was a thing? Has it always been the case they can refuse??

Beersinshropshire · 21/08/2023 08:33

jlpth · 20/08/2023 22:18

I think the bigger issue is that there has been no explanation from her that could provide the tiniest morsel of an answer as to why she did this for the poor families. That said, I do think attendance at sentencing should be mandatory.

It’s quite likely she doesn’t really know herself.

DisquietintheRanks · 21/08/2023 08:32

Fallingthroughclouds · 21/08/2023 08:27

I wondered this. She wouldn't have been willing to do any of it, so surely the same should apply here. As an aside, I'm not sure I would be able to attend court and look at the person who had murdered my baby. I definitely wouldn't be able to read a victim statement. That shows a lot of strength, which I can't imagine that I'd have.

Why do you think she wouldn't have wanted to go to court? I'm sure she didn't want to be charged but, as she was, I expect she was hoping to be found not guilty.

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 08:31

mumof1or2 · 21/08/2023 01:37

The same way she was "forced" to attend the court case I guess? To everyone saying you can't physically make them go, we physically make defendants attend their own court cases and it doesn't seem to cause too many problems. So why not the sentencing?

She willingly attended most of the trial.

I think a lot of posters here don't understand the practicalities of dragging someone into court.

Someone unwilling to be moved is a risk to themselves and all the staff involved. They could be kicking, biting, scratching, spitting, wetting themselves or defecating. Refusing to walk.

So okay, some posters say well strap her to a stretcher and gag her (you really want that? you want our society and justice system to do that?) plus being gagged could kill her). So there's a fight doing that and she could injure herself and numerous staff. Even if they get her onto a stretcher and strapped down, they have to carry her out of her cell. Then through however many narrow doorways, up and down however many flights of stairs, in and out of however many vehicles.

Serious risk of injury to staff every step of the way. They could lose their footing, slip, fall downstairs, slip and hit their head and sustain a serious head injury. Have limbs knocked or crushed going through doorways. Sustain a back injury.

Plus the utter trauma of being involved in a scene like that.

So, so many prison staff and Police receive injuries in restraints. Some that end careers through being unable to physically work so they are then reliant on disability benefits to survice. Or truama related mental injuries. Which leads to relationship breakdowns, drug and alcohol use, self-harm or suicidality and more costs to the NHS, the benefits system and society.

And before anyone says "well that's the nature of the job, they are involved in restraint anyway. Yes, in emergency situations or other situations where there is no alternative. Not putting themselves and others at risk to satisfy a public who just want to see the look on LL face in court.

User15387500 · 21/08/2023 08:31

Fallingthroughclouds · 21/08/2023 08:27

I wondered this. She wouldn't have been willing to do any of it, so surely the same should apply here. As an aside, I'm not sure I would be able to attend court and look at the person who had murdered my baby. I definitely wouldn't be able to read a victim statement. That shows a lot of strength, which I can't imagine that I'd have.

But there is no 'what should apply here' things have to be done within the law.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 08:30

This is one of those things that people seem to fasten on without any real logic. Why do you think it's so essential, OP?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/08/2023 08:27

Sofifn · 21/08/2023 08:07

More people who have zero understanding of what it is like to be a victim in such a case.

It isn’t about public wrath when you’re a victims family member. It’s a lot more personal and to those saying ‘it won’t help closure’ for some of us, it does.

I'm someone who has lost a family member to a criminal act, and I still think it's ridiculous to shouting about "forcing" people into the dock.

It's not a "one size fits all" scenario. You might want your perpetrator to be there, but personally I couldn't care less whether mine was or not, in fact, I had no desire whatsoever to ever set eyes on them again once the verdict had been delivered.

My concerns lie in the fact that if people like you get your way, then it's inevitable that sooner rather than later the families of victims are going to be confronted by the sight of the person who murdered or otherwise harmed their loved ones pointing and laughing at them, taunting them, sneering, and generally going out of their way to be as obnoxious and harmful as possible. If you play stupid games with nasty people, then you are going to win stupid prizes.

As you said yourself, stop telling victims and their families what's right for them. Your opinion carries no more weight that anyone else's, so victim or otherwise, you have no right to try and claim ownership over a matter than is of no relevance to you beyond your own individual case.

Fallingthroughclouds · 21/08/2023 08:27

MisschiefMaker · 20/08/2023 23:33

I have no real opinion on whether she should go but I genuinely don't understand why people think it's impractical for her to physically be forced? She will have been forced to go to court, and forced to go to prison, why should this be any different? Just put her in cuffs and frog march her there.

I wondered this. She wouldn't have been willing to do any of it, so surely the same should apply here. As an aside, I'm not sure I would be able to attend court and look at the person who had murdered my baby. I definitely wouldn't be able to read a victim statement. That shows a lot of strength, which I can't imagine that I'd have.

LizzieSiddal · 21/08/2023 08:23

@Sofifn Flowers I hope people read your post and reflect.

Clafoutie · 21/08/2023 08:23

Oftenaddled · 21/08/2023 07:34

This isn't a question of whether we have compassion for Lucy Letby or not. What kind of people are we creating if we sanction dragging people in restraints around by the hair for a public spectacle? Who else will it be acceptable to treat this way? You don't make society safer by making it more brutal.

Well said.