Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 09:27

Mukey · 21/08/2023 09:19

Shes going to now be forced to go to prison right? I imagine she can't just refuse?

There's a massive difference between asking a member of staff to risk serious injury to take someone to prison and to risk serious injury to take someone to court when they don't even have to be there for justice to be carried out

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 09:26

BreatheAndFocus · 21/08/2023 09:12

To be clear, I do think it should apply to all. In the case of the 43 stone man, it might be that he listens in his cell due to his weight, medical issues and practicality.

So in which case you are suggesting that mostly women will be made to attend sentencing and mostly men will be able to listen to it in their cells because on average men are heavier than women

Iwasafool · 21/08/2023 09:26

SovietSpy · 20/08/2023 22:38

Everything Bellac11 said above. The sort of criminal refusing to attend court has either got nothing to lose (facing a long sentence) or likely to be disruptive.

What could be worse for the victims than having sentencing disrupted by the convicted person shouting or screaming, being abusive or pretending to be ill? The judge will send them down which is what they want and then you’ve just created a circus and the headlines in the papers will be about the disruption not the crime.

Also some cases have started to televise the sentencing (camera just on the judge) so any criminal dragged to court determined to disrupt will know they get a tv audience as well as any shouting would be heard.

What if she starts laughing at the parents, what if a bereaved father breaks down reading his statement and she blows him a kiss, what if she is enjoying their suffering. Lots of ways that could hurt parents. There seems to be a bit of an obsession with her being there.

I think it is easy to feel that she would feel like we would, ashamed, embarrassed, remorseful but if she had that sort of human feeling she wouldn't have done the crimes would she.

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 09:24

Claricethecat45 · 21/08/2023 09:19

In my view, elective non-attendance at Sentencing, by the convicted party, ought to carry with it, an understanding/acceptance which 'Excludes the future possibility of an Appeal being made or a Re-trial considered' - for example where a miscarriage of justice is later considered/deemed/proposed, or, where any type of 'new evidence' comes to light.

IMO this may be the only type of incentive for LL to decide she will attend, and if this was indeed accepted law, her Barrister would be able to give her his/her professional advice to do so. Obviously, there is no such process or guidelines in place, so it wont happen...but imo, it should!

So to be clear you are suggesting that if new evidence came up that could prove someone was innocent they wouldn't be allowed a retrial if they didn't attend their sentencing

Or more worryingly if there was a miscarriage of justice they wouldn't be able to have a retrial.

Really? Is someone attending the sentencing so important that we will keep them in prison even if they are innocent or a miscarriage of justice occurs?

That's alarming.

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 09:22

Claricethecat45 · 21/08/2023 09:19

In my view, elective non-attendance at Sentencing, by the convicted party, ought to carry with it, an understanding/acceptance which 'Excludes the future possibility of an Appeal being made or a Re-trial considered' - for example where a miscarriage of justice is later considered/deemed/proposed, or, where any type of 'new evidence' comes to light.

IMO this may be the only type of incentive for LL to decide she will attend, and if this was indeed accepted law, her Barrister would be able to give her his/her professional advice to do so. Obviously, there is no such process or guidelines in place, so it wont happen...but imo, it should!

So if they are in fact innocent, they should be compelled to turn up to sentencing, but if they did it, they can stay in their cell?

Not thought that one through, have you?

GlobetrottingPercy · 21/08/2023 09:20

BreatheAndFocus · 21/08/2023 09:12

To be clear, I do think it should apply to all. In the case of the 43 stone man, it might be that he listens in his cell due to his weight, medical issues and practicality.

So if people are thin, they get hauled to sentencing but if they are fat, they can stay in their cell.

Claricethecat45 · 21/08/2023 09:19

In my view, elective non-attendance at Sentencing, by the convicted party, ought to carry with it, an understanding/acceptance which 'Excludes the future possibility of an Appeal being made or a Re-trial considered' - for example where a miscarriage of justice is later considered/deemed/proposed, or, where any type of 'new evidence' comes to light.

IMO this may be the only type of incentive for LL to decide she will attend, and if this was indeed accepted law, her Barrister would be able to give her his/her professional advice to do so. Obviously, there is no such process or guidelines in place, so it wont happen...but imo, it should!

Mukey · 21/08/2023 09:19

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 08:51

She wasn't forced to attend. It was her one and only chance to defend herself, she obviously wanted to attend.

Shes going to now be forced to go to prison right? I imagine she can't just refuse?

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 09:17

I'm disturbed by the bloodlust that would have Letby hauled to court, possibly literally kicking and screaming.

What she did was appalling. She is also clearly mentally very unwell. She deserves whatever prison sentence she gets, but the law says that is the punishment, and not some additional psychological torture session for the benefit of Sun readers.

Poivresel · 21/08/2023 09:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:14

Alexandra2001 · 21/08/2023 08:53

Don't be silly.

What do guards do when a prisoner refuses to leave the court cells to be transferred to prison? or wont return to their cells in a prison? let them stay there??? violent prisoners have always had to be restrained, often using sprays....

As far as i am concerned, its most victims families that want the guilty there.. & if they do, then their wishes are paramount, not what you or i think.

You do see the difference right? For staff being forced to do something as a last resort (which restraint always should be since people can be seriously injured or die) to protect the safety and security or all involved and the prison..

Compared to risking injury and death to the prisoner and staff to satisfy the calls of public individuals for LL to be forced into court because they want to see her reaction?

You see those 2 things are not the same right?

Fallingthroughclouds · 21/08/2023 09:13

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/08/2023 08:27

I'm someone who has lost a family member to a criminal act, and I still think it's ridiculous to shouting about "forcing" people into the dock.

It's not a "one size fits all" scenario. You might want your perpetrator to be there, but personally I couldn't care less whether mine was or not, in fact, I had no desire whatsoever to ever set eyes on them again once the verdict had been delivered.

My concerns lie in the fact that if people like you get your way, then it's inevitable that sooner rather than later the families of victims are going to be confronted by the sight of the person who murdered or otherwise harmed their loved ones pointing and laughing at them, taunting them, sneering, and generally going out of their way to be as obnoxious and harmful as possible. If you play stupid games with nasty people, then you are going to win stupid prizes.

As you said yourself, stop telling victims and their families what's right for them. Your opinion carries no more weight that anyone else's, so victim or otherwise, you have no right to try and claim ownership over a matter than is of no relevance to you beyond your own individual case.

She is someone who has been through this, so yes I think her opinion carries more weight, just as I think yours does, even though your views are very different.

People who have experienced this surely have a better understanding over those who are just theorising about how they would feel.

BreatheAndFocus · 21/08/2023 09:12

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 08:56

Because if you change a law for one you change it for everyone. Its all very well saying that Letby is a normal sized woman but unless you are suggesting laws that only apply to normal sized women you cannot just think of her.

The largest man to be convicted in recent history in the UK was 43 stone. Whatever you suggest can be applied to Letby would also need to be applied to him.

To be clear, I do think it should apply to all. In the case of the 43 stone man, it might be that he listens in his cell due to his weight, medical issues and practicality.

Motomum23 · 21/08/2023 09:10

My 16 year old son said this at the verdict. He said it just shows complete lack of respect.... my point was what respect - she murdered their babies. She doesn't respect them. :(

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:08

Hillcrest2022 · 20/08/2023 23:12

@LaurelandHedgy sadly some people are forgetting that which is the important issue - the awful acts against such vunerable babies and the devastation caused to the families. Apparently her feelings are more important? Well, I won't subscribe to that sorry.

Literally no-one has said that her feelings are more important. How about addressing the points that have actually been made, nor a fictitious one?

Lwrenagain · 21/08/2023 09:08

Whyohwhywyoming · 21/08/2023 07:44

Would everyone who wants the victim
impact statements broadcast in her cell still want this if they knew she was getting some sort of pleasure from it?

I don't think we (not psychopath baby killers) can comprehend it would bring pleasure, not extreme agony to her to hear it.

But I agree with you, 100% it's very likely she'd love to hear the grief.

Now Thomas cashman who refused, he should have had to hear what he did to little olivia's family. As much as he's a piece of shite who I hope never leaves prison alive, I do believe it would have affected him, he never set out to murder a child, he just didn't let an innocent little girl get in the way of his intended victim.

AutumnCrow · 21/08/2023 09:07

MansfieldLark · 21/08/2023 08:48

If she went on hunger strike and refused to eat or drink, noone could make her could they?

I might be out of date here, but I believe there are two circumstances in which force-feeding can happen in UK prisons.

In the first, a patient detained under the Mental Health Act can be force-fed if it is believed feeding is necessary to treat their underlying mental disorder.

In the second, which is governed by case law, doctors can force-feed patients if they have become mentally incapacitated and they believe it is in their best interests and will save their life. Doctors hate doing this, and the Secretary of State for Justice (used to be the Home Secretary) is normally advised to obtain a specific court order in the High Court.

Otherwise a prisoner can make an advance declaration to refuse food and water while they have capacity, and force-feeding is thereafter unlawful, even if the prisoner dies.

It's a thorny case-by-case issue.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 21/08/2023 09:05

I'm a bit bemused by this idea that you can "force" someone to listen to the proceedings while in a holding cell.

A lot of people are perfectly capable of compartmentalising thoughts and blocking out external stimuli, so you could have it blaring at 100 db on a 70 inch screen, and they'd still look straight through it and fill their heads with enough white noise to block out the auditory part.

It's clearly for no other reason that to slake some sort of vindictive thirst, which rightly has no place whatsoever in criminal justice.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:05

Hillcrest2022 · 20/08/2023 23:08

The nature of imprisonment is that individuals lose their physical automomy @catin8oots

Well no, it isn't. They lose their freedom. It's not the same.

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:05

Sofifn · 21/08/2023 08:18

its irrelevant if she attends, it means nothing

Not to victims and their families. It means something to them. And they should be the ones who people care about, not the criminals. Get them there with a taser, or in a straight jacket, tell them there’s no chance of parole if they don’t, stop their family visits, I really don’t care how. When you’re the family of a victim and you want that person in court, and as I’ve said, in some cases people don’t, in other cases, you damned we’ll do, then they should be forced to attend.

If the victims want it, it isn’t a case of people on here saying ‘what does it matter?’ It bloody well matters to them. So sick of hearing about people defending murderers and rapists rights. Fuck their rights. They didn’t care about the rights of their victims or their families and loved ones.

And what about the rights of the staff that would have to be involved in this? What about their families?

Do you know about the statistics for physical injury and PTSD in prison and police staff?

Do you know how having a disabled parent can do to children? Having to live on the poverty line because they can't work anymore? What it's like living with a partner or partner with PTSD? How it can destroy families relationships and tear families apart? Cause alcoholism, drug addiction, suicide.

And the wider costs. There are already recruitment problems in those areas. What do we do when we no longer have Police to actually ya know, protect the public. Or prison officers?

Have you seen what's happening in some states of the USA where crime is literally out of control, contributed to by the fact there is an inadequate Police force. Wallmart one of the biggest supermarket chain has shut down multiple superstores with one reason being, the insane level of theft. People literally filling trollies and walking out and filming it for Facebook. And these tend to be higher-crime areas which equals - poverty stricken areas. What are poor families going to do when they no longer have a relatively cheap supermarket available to them?

And please nobody say, that won't happen here. We're already on the way to it. Police forces already saying they don't have the resources to attend burglaries for instance.

Thus isn't about defending LL or her rights. There are many more issues to be considered.

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 08:56

BreatheAndFocus · 21/08/2023 08:49

I still don’t get why she can’t be forced (within reason). Surely some prisoners are very obstructive to purposely be a nuisance, refusing to do anything they’re told? They’re still put in their cells at night, they’re still handcuffed when necessary, they’re still transferred to other prisons, etc. Letby is a normal-sized woman. Couldn’t two or three male officers put handcuffs on her and frogmarch her into court?

If she started shouting and disrupting proceedings, she could be removed back to the court cell, remain in cuffs and supervised, and be forced to listen to the proceedings via audio.

What if she or future prisoners then refuse to leave the prison to go to court? Broadcast the proceedings to their cell or a suitable prison room where they listen cuffed and supervised.

It can’t beyond the realms of imagination to ensure such people are made to listen. Although a tiny, tiny minority might shout and worse, I think the majority will comply grudgingly when they realise there’s no choice and they’ll be hearing it anyway, whether in the court or their cell. People like Letby shouldn’t be given the power of having the choice.

Because if you change a law for one you change it for everyone. Its all very well saying that Letby is a normal sized woman but unless you are suggesting laws that only apply to normal sized women you cannot just think of her.

The largest man to be convicted in recent history in the UK was 43 stone. Whatever you suggest can be applied to Letby would also need to be applied to him.

ohcrums · 21/08/2023 08:53

user1471505494 · 21/08/2023 08:34

You would rather force a defendant into court to possibly cause even more grief to the families by outbursts or other similar unpleasant behaviour for what reason. Prisoners do have rights and knee jerk reactions to horrendous acts helps no one

Yeah I've seen that from some of the other responses, they've opened my eyes

Alexandra2001 · 21/08/2023 08:53

bellac11 · 21/08/2023 07:42

Some of us have mentioned, but no one seems to respond, the impact on the guards of either being injured or having allegations of assault made about them.

Its just glossed over but is a huge part of their job, its why there is a massive recruitment problem (part of why)

Don't be silly.

What do guards do when a prisoner refuses to leave the court cells to be transferred to prison? or wont return to their cells in a prison? let them stay there??? violent prisoners have always had to be restrained, often using sprays....

As far as i am concerned, its most victims families that want the guilty there.. & if they do, then their wishes are paramount, not what you or i think.

MarshyMcMarshFace · 21/08/2023 08:53

The criminal is convicted.

Sentencing, to my mind, is for the Judge to be accountable to the public in what the sentence is and why. It is between the Judge and society, the judge telling the people what s/he will do on their behalf.

The prison term is the sentence. We may want to look at her with contempt, bang on the van as she arrives, yell at her, and see her stand in shame in court, but that isn’t actually part of the sentence.

BingoBastards · 21/08/2023 08:52

It's not a soap opera; really can't see the point of frogmarching her in there.

The damage is done and the verdict has been reached.