Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
melj1213 · 21/08/2023 09:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's not sanctimonious claptrap to see the bigger picture beyond just this case and want the law to be upheld for everyone, in every circumstance and not have it changed based on the wishes of victims families.

I have been impacted by crime, I have sat in court and watched the person who killed a family member receive a sentence and even though he say there passively it affected me seeing him; I have been to court to watch the rapist who attacked me at university be sentenced, all the while he was sat there grinning and smirking at the courtroom, waving at his supporters who were in the public gallery; I also have friends and family who work in the criminal justice system and would be the ones having to drag unwilling prisoners from prison cells, prison vans, holding cells, courts and deal with all the consequences of doing so.

I shouldn't have to write it all out on here for you to make a decision about whether I have been affected enough to pass judgement. Regardless of whether you think I should be allowed to post my opinion, I will do so anyway as I have the right to. I am a staunch supporter of the law being applied to everyone. The justice system should be based on rationality and not on emotion - just because a victims family wants something doesn't mean it should be implemented.

The fact that so many people are suggesting essentially torture - forcing someone to be physically restrained/gagged/put on a board, have audio/video forced on them so they have no choice but to listen etc - just because they believe they should be made to experience something shows why these things should be decided without emotion and by impartial people, not families and people whipped up by emotive headlines and cherry picked cases.

Looking at the practicalities is also not sanctimonious claptrap - it's all well and good volunteering other people to have to force prisoners into court but unless you're volunteering to be the front of the line to be spat on, kicked, bitten, punched, defecated on, sworn at, threatened and abused on a daily basis just for doing your job, and risking your personal safety for, then you are in no position to tell others that important practical concerns should be ignored just because of some misguided idea of "justice".

echt · 21/08/2023 09:59

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:56

You should try. Because it was neither word salad nor nonsense, but very reasoned.

This sort of post in a way proves the point made. You're taking part in a thread but you have mentally blocked the post you don't want to read because the points made are so valid. In just the same way, Letby could be physically forced into court but she could completely block out everything that is happening. It won't help anyone.

I agree. Noted it at the time but didn't post. @melj1213 made perfect sense.

DesTeeny · 21/08/2023 09:58

I'm lovingthe responses here from people who have clearly never restrained another human being in their lives, bandying about like it's easy and a bit of excitement in the day so we should be dragging people about willy nilly.

Just stupid. Stop commenting on something you don't understand or have any experience of at all.

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 09:57

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:54

Indeed.

Which and I'm really trying not to be that poster but means in most cases, the women get dragged out of their cells and the big, scary men don't. And often, it'll be big male prison staff that drag the women out of their cells.

I can't be the only one that sees a problem with that.

I think you're right about this.

Somewhat tangential but it seems the inspectors on my regular train route (SouthEastern, I'm looking at you) can only be arsed to fine lone women for not having the right ticket. I wonder why that is?

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:56

Hillcrest2022 · 21/08/2023 02:03

@melj1213 that's a lot of word salad. I really can't make any sense out of your nonsense post.

You should try. Because it was neither word salad nor nonsense, but very reasoned.

This sort of post in a way proves the point made. You're taking part in a thread but you have mentally blocked the post you don't want to read because the points made are so valid. In just the same way, Letby could be physically forced into court but she could completely block out everything that is happening. It won't help anyone.

Ponoka7 · 21/08/2023 09:56

Ponoka7 · 21/08/2023 09:55

@5128gap do you think that Andrew Malkinson doing a 17 year sentence is just unfortunate then? What if it was you or yours?

That was for @Claricethecat45

Ponoka7 · 21/08/2023 09:55

@5128gap do you think that Andrew Malkinson doing a 17 year sentence is just unfortunate then? What if it was you or yours?

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:54

GlobetrottingPercy · 21/08/2023 09:20

So if people are thin, they get hauled to sentencing but if they are fat, they can stay in their cell.

Indeed.

Which and I'm really trying not to be that poster but means in most cases, the women get dragged out of their cells and the big, scary men don't. And often, it'll be big male prison staff that drag the women out of their cells.

I can't be the only one that sees a problem with that.

Ponoka7 · 21/08/2023 09:51

Alexandra2001 · 21/08/2023 08:53

Don't be silly.

What do guards do when a prisoner refuses to leave the court cells to be transferred to prison? or wont return to their cells in a prison? let them stay there??? violent prisoners have always had to be restrained, often using sprays....

As far as i am concerned, its most victims families that want the guilty there.. & if they do, then their wishes are paramount, not what you or i think.

There are multiple families involved in this. What if some of them don't want to witness a person being dragged into court? Olivia Korbel-Pratt's Mum reacted completely different to her Dad over the court proceedings, Cashman's sentencing and him not attending. Sorting all this out could add weeks to the trial.

If we make this law would it apply to every case? There was a case of a hit and run by teens, on a teen and the teens were doing constant thumbs up to the victim's Mum. People rarely get the sense of closure that they think they will from the final day in court.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:49

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 20/08/2023 23:59

Put this demon on a wheeled cart like Hannibal Lector & force her to face the moment of reckoning.

Hannibal Lecter didn't exist. Courts aren't built to accommodate wheeled carts.

You could do all of that, but you still couldn't make her listen. So what would you achieve apart from a bit of cheap sadism and voyeurism?

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:48

lollipoprainbow · 21/08/2023 08:33

I didn't realise that offenders refusing to attend court for their sentencing was a thing? Has it always been the case they can refuse??

It's not so much 'can they refuse?' as 'does it happen because the alternative is not practical.

A Judge can say that a defendant must appear but that ruling is then passed to the Prison governor who has to make a decision about whether they think they can practically direct their staff to force an inmate which carries risks to the inmate and the staff. So most Prison governors will say no, the risks are too high.

echt · 21/08/2023 09:47

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:42

She has a better understanding about how she feels.

But the way we conduct ourselves as a society and how law and the criminal justice system works shouldn't be based on feelings or vengeance.

It should be based on objective, rational analysis of all aspects of the case, and all individuals and aspects of society that it effects.

I'm not being callous but if we had a system that was based on the feelings of victims or some members of the public, we would not be a society that I would want to be part of.

This. Couldn't agree more.

Claricethecat45 · 21/08/2023 09:46

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 09:24

So to be clear you are suggesting that if new evidence came up that could prove someone was innocent they wouldn't be allowed a retrial if they didn't attend their sentencing

Or more worryingly if there was a miscarriage of justice they wouldn't be able to have a retrial.

Really? Is someone attending the sentencing so important that we will keep them in prison even if they are innocent or a miscarriage of justice occurs?

That's alarming.

I was suggesting that the only motivation for someone who refuses to attend sentencing ( where they have nothing to gain or lose as in LL's case ) may agree to attend, IF they felt any future appeal etc could be affected.

Its clear that public opinion, and importantly, the bereaved families, would very much wish that she does attend sentencing. But there is no law that compels her to, or that there is any disadvantage for her, in not doing so. And compared to suggestions of strapping her to a board and being wheeled screaming into court to 'face the music' I was of the view that my suggestion wasn't that thoughtless@thedancingbear

FWIW in This case, based on what we know, I fully expect there to be an appeal of some type.

thedancingbear · 21/08/2023 09:46

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:42

She has a better understanding about how she feels.

But the way we conduct ourselves as a society and how law and the criminal justice system works shouldn't be based on feelings or vengeance.

It should be based on objective, rational analysis of all aspects of the case, and all individuals and aspects of society that it effects.

I'm not being callous but if we had a system that was based on the feelings of victims or some members of the public, we would not be a society that I would want to be part of.

Exactly. If we put victims in charge of the punishment, we'd find ourselves hanging burglars and burglars. That can't be right.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:45

ASDMumof2 · 20/08/2023 23:47

Yes whole heartedly agree.

She murdered babies, she tried to murder several more and we have nonidea I'd there are even more cases against her. She needs to face the jury and everyone in court Especially the families of those babies. What a piece of sh1t she is.

The jury isn't in court unless they want to be, as their function is completed. She has already faced the families.

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:42

Fallingthroughclouds · 21/08/2023 09:13

She is someone who has been through this, so yes I think her opinion carries more weight, just as I think yours does, even though your views are very different.

People who have experienced this surely have a better understanding over those who are just theorising about how they would feel.

She has a better understanding about how she feels.

But the way we conduct ourselves as a society and how law and the criminal justice system works shouldn't be based on feelings or vengeance.

It should be based on objective, rational analysis of all aspects of the case, and all individuals and aspects of society that it effects.

I'm not being callous but if we had a system that was based on the feelings of victims or some members of the public, we would not be a society that I would want to be part of.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:42

Wakintoblueskies · 20/08/2023 23:35

What would have happened if she had refused to attend her trial?

Why would she refuse to attend? It's her one chance to get out of the situation.

If someone does refuse to attend, ultimately the trial continues without them.

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:38

OhcantthInkofaname · 20/08/2023 23:26

Let the mothers be the officers of the day..

Let them be kicked, scratched, punched, spat on, screamed and sworn at?

I don't think so.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 09:37

LizzieSiddal · 21/08/2023 08:12

It’s my understanding that she will be taken to the court, she just will refuse to enter the court room where the judge and public gallery is. So she’ll be sat somewhere in that building, until the impact statements and sentencing has finished, she’ll then be taken back to prison.

The simplest solution would be for there to be cameras set up in the room so she has to listen to what’s going on in the court. However she may then refuse to get in the van which brought her from the prison, so maybe they would have to set up a room in the prison with linked cameras to the court. But then she may refuse to move into that room. It goes on and on……..

What ever happens she deserves to rot in hell.

This is the most sensible solution.

audio played to wherever she is sitting so that she can hear the impact statements from the families that want to speak to her, and hear her sentence and the judges comments .

audio can be turned off if a particular relative feels uncomfortable with her hearing them

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:35

NoTouch · 20/08/2023 23:21

If she wont attend then let the parents go to her cell with the judge and tell her there.

I know that isn't practical either. But I feel so sorry for the parents that she has any control and is able to take away them witnessing justice being served upon her. It will be a big milestone for them in the horrific journey they are still on.

She doesn't have control and I hate the fact that people are trying to wind up the parents into thinking that this gives her any power. The important thing is that she will be told her sentence and she will have to serve every day of it.

If we make a big issue out of trying to force defendants to listen when ultimately it's impossible, we are giving them power. Don't do it.

NOELScosmichelicopter · 21/08/2023 09:32

AutumnCrow · 21/08/2023 09:07

I might be out of date here, but I believe there are two circumstances in which force-feeding can happen in UK prisons.

In the first, a patient detained under the Mental Health Act can be force-fed if it is believed feeding is necessary to treat their underlying mental disorder.

In the second, which is governed by case law, doctors can force-feed patients if they have become mentally incapacitated and they believe it is in their best interests and will save their life. Doctors hate doing this, and the Secretary of State for Justice (used to be the Home Secretary) is normally advised to obtain a specific court order in the High Court.

Otherwise a prisoner can make an advance declaration to refuse food and water while they have capacity, and force-feeding is thereafter unlawful, even if the prisoner dies.

It's a thorny case-by-case issue.

No. No physical or psychiatric treatment cannot be forced in prisons unless an immediate emergency with threat to life such as providing wound care to someone who's slit their wrists.

If a prisoner is felt to be suffering from a mental disorder they would need to be assessed, sectioned under 47 or 48 of the mental health act and transferred to a psychiatric hospital before psychiatric treatment can begin. There are seriously psychotically unwell individuals languishing in UK prisons because a bed in a psychiatric hospital is not yet available though they have been assessed and sectioned.

Even after transfer to hospital, physical health treatment can only be forced without consent (unless an emergency) under specific legislation of the MHA if the refuse to eat is a direct result of the mental health condition they are in hospital to be treated for. So Beverly Allitt was NG fed in hospital as she had a diagnosed eating disorder. Ian Brady wS NG fed in hospital as his care team argued his 'hunger strike' was a result of his antisocial PD causing him to use a 'hunger strike' as a means to cause disruption for the staff and unit, disrupt his care and 'challenge authority'.

Had either of them been diagnosed with cancer for jnstance, they could refuse treatment even while sectioned unless the care team could present a case that the refusal was due to their mental disorder, and mental capacity would be assessed as part of that.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 09:32

melj1213 · 21/08/2023 00:46

But why should it be the victims families choice? What of one family wants her there and another doesn't, whose choice gets ignored?

What next will we give the victims family a right to decide in the courtroom regardless of the practicality of enforcement?

Whether or not you agree with a defendant's right not to be present on a moral level, as hard as it might be to take all the emotion and feelings out, just looking at it on a practical level - and not just in this case for Letby but for every case, with every defendant as any rule would have to apply across the board - it is impossible to force a defendant to sit in the courtroom and respect the process if they don't want to.

They will either potentially cause physical harm to themselves and/or others in the course of getting them to the court and between the various places they need to be; cause psychological harm to others who have to deal with dragging prisoners into court on a daily basis and/or those who have to witness their behaviour and listen to them if they start screaming upsetting things in the courtroom etc; cause damage and potentially cause significant delays to the court proceedings if they resist.

All of these things add up to the fact that while we could force defendants into court, on balance it is better to allow a defendant not to attend than force them to do so as that is the safest and most practical option for everyone.

What you are saying is contradictory. You say it’s fine for some families to refuse and be respected but not for other families to expect to have their chance to speak directly to the defendant

If families don’t want to see her they could be accommodated in another way using screens etc

at the end of the day there should be an expectation that the defendant is presented in court to hear their sentencing.

If they choose to disrupt then other methods can be used such as a video link where they cannot be heard by the family

the court should make all reasonable attempts to get them there. To disrupt is contempt of court which For many defendants could result in a harsher sentence.

in a whole of life case they probably won’t care but at least they will have had their own day disrupted and had some shame directed towards them .

sixswans · 21/08/2023 09:30

If the families want her to listen to their impact statements then she should be there. She had to attend the whole trial so how is this any different.

DesTeeny · 21/08/2023 09:30

You can't physically force someone to go, that's the end of it. The sentence will remain the same, whether she is there or not.

After with PP that I wouldn't be surprised if she's given a Hospital order rather than a custodial sentence as there's no end date to a Hospital order, she could be detained indefinitely until she was deemed 'suitable' for release.

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 09:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Or unless they have been impacted by their family being prison officers and becoming injured during the course of their work?

Officers really are the collateral damage no one gives a shit about on this thread aren't they?