Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Lucy Letby should be made to attend court for the sentencing

641 replies

Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:06

I know there are other threads on this terrible case. But I just read she has refused to attend court for the sentencing which is to be on Monday morning. The judge said he does not have the power to force her to attend. Can't see she will ever be allowed out of prison. And rightly so.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
ScrambledSmegs · 22/08/2023 09:49

I'm sure I'm repeating PPs but she was in the court to hear the guilty verdicts on the 8th August, and then again on the 11th. There was a media blackout for the benefit of the jury until all the verdicts were returned.

It's not a case I can really cope with even offering an option on so that's that extent of what I'm going to say. My thoughts are with the families of the babies attacked by Letby.

calmcoco · 22/08/2023 07:46

I genuinely don't understand what people think will be improved by forcing a defendant to listen to the victim statements and sentencing. There isn't suddenly going to be a conversion, an acceptance of what they did. Most likely there will be continued denials and more upset for the families.

JanieEyre · 22/08/2023 07:46

NoTouch · 21/08/2023 22:22

Calling it choice, control, power is irrelevant. It is allowing her a choice and taking that choice away from the victims which is wrong, but understandably nothing can/should be forced.

"Don't do it"??? Who made you the thread police? I am winding up noone and will give my opinion how I please.

ODFO with the thread police nonsense. I'm talking in the wider sense - there is a world beyond a Mumsnet thread, and self-evidently I'm not issuing orders to the world.

It's simple recognition of the fact that the victims' relatives are being wound up into thinking she has gained something important and therefore that they've lost out, which just makes them feel even worse. It would be much better if we said, in effect, "OK, you have the choice to show the world how spineless you are, crack right on. It doesn't change one whit the fact that we know you for what you are, and that you are losing your freedom for the rest of your life"

JanieEyre · 22/08/2023 07:36

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 19:43

The guidance states that it also may serve as an opportunity to convey that impact to the convict.

not as a punishment but as part of the victim impact process

"May" is the operative word there.

JanieEyre · 22/08/2023 07:34

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 19:02

Yes, but they haven’t had the opportunity to confront her with their own words or formally have the impacts of the crime against them/their loved ones recognised and recorded. The wider impacts of any particular crime might be taken into consideration when it comes to sentencing but a formal statement removes that ‘might’ and humanises the victims.

I’m not really sure why you’re so keen to discredit victim statements as part of the process of justice? It might not be something you give much weight but I’ve no idea why that would lead you to dismiss the value others might place on it.

I'm not discrediting victim statements. The problem is that everyone seems to think that their primary purpose is to be read to the accused. If you look at the guidance, that is simply not the case. The primary purpose is to inform the judge and, possibly, the parole service at a later stage.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 22/08/2023 07:29

Missingmyusername · 21/08/2023 22:38

Isn’t it to become law? What then?

Yes, I think she should be forced to face her crimes. Though I don’t think she should sit her sentence out behind bars- I don’t think she has a place here.

I doubt that'll actually happen.

Sunak is coming out with what he thinks people are going to hear, and the Tories are going to be out pretty soon anyway. They probably wouldn't have the time.

Starmer has also jumped on the passing bandwagon, as he so frequently does, but he's got enough relevant professional experience to understand how impractical an idea it is. He won't have any intention of actually following through either. It'll be forgotten soon enough.

bellac11 · 22/08/2023 07:24

Solonge · 22/08/2023 00:10

A criminal psychologist said she was born with psychopathic tendencies. Is there really such a thing as ‘bad’, maybe psychosis is the ever present in ‘bad’ people.

Psychosis is not the same as psychopathy.

Anyone could develop psychosis if they become mentally unwell.

Solonge · 22/08/2023 00:10

greyhairnomore · 21/08/2023 21:48

She's not been diagnosed has she ? She's 'bad not mad' as they say.

A criminal psychologist said she was born with psychopathic tendencies. Is there really such a thing as ‘bad’, maybe psychosis is the ever present in ‘bad’ people.

ThinWomansBrain · 22/08/2023 00:06

If someone doesn't want to attend, that's fine
Must mean they don't want to know.
So just put them in prison with no idea of what their sentence is.
With Letby, given the nature of her crime she is likely to be in solitary confinement for her own safety.

Insommmmnia · 21/08/2023 22:42

Missingmyusername · 21/08/2023 22:38

Isn’t it to become law? What then?

Yes, I think she should be forced to face her crimes. Though I don’t think she should sit her sentence out behind bars- I don’t think she has a place here.

Then we risk an even bigger retention and recruitment crisis in the prison services than we already have

The only reason it isn't so front and centre in the news is they aren't allowed to strike

Missingmyusername · 21/08/2023 22:38

LooselyBasedOnAMadeUpStory · 20/08/2023 22:09

Short of manhandling her in there, risking injury to her and/or the officers, how could she be forced to attend?

Isn’t it to become law? What then?

Yes, I think she should be forced to face her crimes. Though I don’t think she should sit her sentence out behind bars- I don’t think she has a place here.

HRTQueen · 21/08/2023 22:34

i think many are concerned she will be moved to a high secure hospital and feel it shall be more comfortable for her

also it’s difficult for many to accept that she isn’t mentally unwell that’s why the question keeps coming up

SoUtterlyDoneIn · 21/08/2023 22:29

No it's tabloid idiocy, you only have to think it through for about ten seconds to see how this would make an mockery of the court process, result in people getting hurt, fail to actually achieve "making people look at you", invite a court jester dynamic and so on.

It's a bad idea, a kneejerk emotional response and people who endorse it should think about how easily they cheer for bad ideas if they are emotive enough.

bellac11 · 21/08/2023 22:24

I dont know why everyone here and on the other threats keeps chuntering on about secure hospitals

She hasnt got (to anyones knowledge) any MH conditions, she hasnt been diagnosed with anything apart from perhaps PTSD which she says is from being arrested 3 times.

Even so, unless she is actively unwell from that, she is not sectionable

Even if she develops depression or becomes suicidal, thats not necessarily a sectionable issue, people suffer with depression and ill MH in prisons every day, in fact the majority of the prison population. People are put on suicide watch all the time, they arent swooped off to psychiatric hospitals

NoTouch · 21/08/2023 22:22

JanieEyre · 21/08/2023 09:35

She doesn't have control and I hate the fact that people are trying to wind up the parents into thinking that this gives her any power. The important thing is that she will be told her sentence and she will have to serve every day of it.

If we make a big issue out of trying to force defendants to listen when ultimately it's impossible, we are giving them power. Don't do it.

Calling it choice, control, power is irrelevant. It is allowing her a choice and taking that choice away from the victims which is wrong, but understandably nothing can/should be forced.

"Don't do it"??? Who made you the thread police? I am winding up noone and will give my opinion how I please.

HRTQueen · 21/08/2023 21:58

Her mh may deteriorate to the point it’s agreed she should be transferred to a high secure hospital

and she can be retuned to prison once deemed she is well enough to

she will be spending a lot of time with mh professionals will she engage that is down to her

AllOfThemWitches · 21/08/2023 21:51

Well, to play armchair psychologist, I'd guess she didn't want to be there because people who previously thought she was wonderful now know she is a child murderer. So, I'd agree she was hiding.

greyhairnomore · 21/08/2023 21:48

MansfieldLark · 20/08/2023 22:12

Said this on a different thread but I strongly believe she will be in a secure hospital like Rampton and not prison.

She's not been diagnosed has she ? She's 'bad not mad' as they say.

mylittleprince · 21/08/2023 21:43

I just wonder if she will ever confess.

Will she have to take part in any kind of treatment programme given that she's been given whole life sentences?

I wonder how long she will maintain she is innocent. The only person I can think of serving a whole life sentence and still protests they are innocent of all crimes is Jeremy Bamber although there must be many, many more.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 21/08/2023 21:29

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 17:15

I think if she was going to relish in their pain she would have turned up today

she was hiding

Was she? There are a number of examples of dangerous violent prisoners refusing to engage as a point of control. We don’t know what her motives were for not attending and we probably never will.

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 21:01

@SnackSizeRaisin you’re only giving any value to any effect a victim statement has on the convicted person.

Sometimes the reaction of the convicted is the least important one. There’s also value in having the real life consequences of their actions recognised and recorded as part of the conviction process. There is value in knowing a judge will take those consequences into consideration in their sentencing. There is a value in having the opportunity to have your own words made known to a court room full of people who’ve listened to evidence from a huge event in your life but you may have only been in the audience alongside.

Sometimes, there’s a value in knowing beyond doubt that nothing you can say to a criminal will give them a reason to show remorse or if they do you will know whether or not that makes any difference to your own process of coming to terms with their acts against you.

There’s a value in the victims knowing that they’ve had their opportunity to say their piece and removes any ‘what if’s’ from the justice process.

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 20:06

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/08/2023 19:59

According to that logic the police could never arrest or detain anyone as they might not like it or it might put police officers at risk. Presumably they have ways of dealing with reluctant prisoners. And not wanting to get in a van or attend court doesn't generally get you out of it if you're accused of a crime

I was making the same point as you in response to the posters who disagreed with me saying she should be forced to have it played to her via video or audio link. They said it would be torture to her and dangerous for the staff (and they decided that it means I must want the death sentence)

To me it is more dangerous for all to put her (or any convict )in a van when she has no intention of going in the dock anyway.

A dangerous one could pretend to happily go to court and then make a violent attempt at freedom

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/08/2023 20:06

Cornettoninja · 21/08/2023 19:02

Yes, but they haven’t had the opportunity to confront her with their own words or formally have the impacts of the crime against them/their loved ones recognised and recorded. The wider impacts of any particular crime might be taken into consideration when it comes to sentencing but a formal statement removes that ‘might’ and humanises the victims.

I’m not really sure why you’re so keen to discredit victim statements as part of the process of justice? It might not be something you give much weight but I’ve no idea why that would lead you to dismiss the value others might place on it.

It seems unlikely that a victim impact statement would have much effect on a cold blooded killer. She would probably like the fact that she has caused so much anguish. She's not going to hear that the parents are upset and suddenly realise the error of her ways.

It's not the same as a drink driver who ran someone over or even someone caught up in gang violence, where however misguided and stupid, the perpetrator has normal human feeling underneath it all. This murderer clearly doesn't have normal human feelings

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/08/2023 19:59

blubberyboo · 21/08/2023 19:00

Presumably it could be considered brutal and torture to force a prisoner into that compartment if they were determined not to get in the van. Many will be big burly dangerous men who know that they have nothing left to lose. Which is why I don’t see the hypocrisy of sending them to the courts putting staff in danger, in this way but then complaining that it would be worse to have an audio piped.

I agree with you that they could well stay in their remand prison and have the audio or visual piped to them.

it probably doesn’t even matter if they stick fingers in ears. Many relatives will just want to see the reaction no matter what it is

a smirk or non listening will perhaps help confirm guilt and help them decide whether to forgive or not.

I think we should listen to the relatives and the important thing is that they are made aware they might see the opposite of remorse. We shouldn’t treat them like children by assuming they wouldn’t want to see the full display of bad behaviour

According to that logic the police could never arrest or detain anyone as they might not like it or it might put police officers at risk. Presumably they have ways of dealing with reluctant prisoners. And not wanting to get in a van or attend court doesn't generally get you out of it if you're accused of a crime

ZeldaFighter · 21/08/2023 19:50

I voted YANBU but I would never be the person who had to drag them kicking and screaming into court. I don't want workers to be injured and the court process made worse by a disruptive convict.

So actually, I don't think there's anything we can do.