Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say no to having dp's mum's name as middle name

532 replies

thunderthunder3 · 20/08/2023 20:23

dp and i are due our baby girl at the end of sep and he wants his late mum's name to be her middle name. the name we both agreed on just does not go with it at all and it makes me hate the name and so he said we should just pick the second name we liked then but i don't like it as much and honestly his late mum's name is really quite bad (no offence to her at all) but i want to love our daughter's name... i think he doesn't even consider it not being there as she has passed and has always been what he has known middle names to be. he says if we have another girl she can have my mum's name in the middle, which i wouldn't want either. aibu to say no?

OP posts:
Soozikinzii · 21/08/2023 09:53

Came here to jump on because DH wants a tribute to his DM which is lovely. Willow as first name does change it up though because that is so similar you are paying tribute through first name . But they do actually sound nice together . It's a difficult one I must admit !

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 21/08/2023 09:49

LTB :)
No, seriously, he sounds like a bit of a jerk. Has he not given any thought to how life will be for your DD if she has to go through life saddled with "Willow Wilhemina"?! Put your child first! Whatever names you use, give some thought to what her initials will be.

Inertia · 21/08/2023 09:45

If MIL was generally called Will in everyday life , then the name Willow already references that. There’s no need to add Wilhelmina as well.

This is your baby, an independent person who will have to live with this name - she isn’t a tribute act for dead relatives. And with the greatest of respect, MIL isn’t going to know anyway.

I would be putting my foot down here-no to Wilhelmina as Willow remembers MIL. As you have no immediate plans to marry, I would prioritise giving the baby both surnames. At a push, if MIL had a short middle name (not beginning with W!) then I would consider using that so e.g. Willow Hope Roberts-Smith.

As you’re not married, you have the final say over registration.

CR7 · 21/08/2023 09:38

Partner sorry!

CR7 · 21/08/2023 09:38

Having read back, both @thunderthunder3 and her husband decided on willow. I didn't get the impression that he had forced both Willow and Wilhelmina on OP

Wimpeyspread · 21/08/2023 09:36

Did his mum have a nickname you could use?

Timeless01 · 21/08/2023 09:34

Wilhelmina is not a nice name full stop! I’ve never met one ever.

You could use it as a middle name if the first name was not Willow. Even as a second middle name it sounds daft.

Hibiscrubbed · 21/08/2023 09:26

Well, they sound dreadful together, but I’d probably just interject a second middle name in between them and try not to think about it.

Gothambutnotahamster · 21/08/2023 09:26

He's being extremely unreasonable - what an awful name to saddle a baby with.

You'll regret giving in if you do but definitely stick to your guns on your dd having your surname.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 21/08/2023 09:25

Spreadbed · 21/08/2023 09:19

Willow Wilhelmina is a terrible name to saddle a child with, because of the first two syllables being the same. I bet he wouldn’t call his son Benji Benjamin or William Wilbur, it’s ridiculous.

You are the mother who has gone through 9 months of pregnancy, and will be giving birth. You get the final say, he can sulk all he wants. When he pushes a watermelon out of his nether regions he can have the final say.

Willow Mina and Olive Wilhelmina are both lovely names and very good compromises.

All of this!

Or, call your dd Willow [second name] Wilhelmina] your surname].

I've not read the full thread but did your MIL not have a middle name?

Spreadbed · 21/08/2023 09:19

Willow Wilhelmina is a terrible name to saddle a child with, because of the first two syllables being the same. I bet he wouldn’t call his son Benji Benjamin or William Wilbur, it’s ridiculous.

You are the mother who has gone through 9 months of pregnancy, and will be giving birth. You get the final say, he can sulk all he wants. When he pushes a watermelon out of his nether regions he can have the final say.

Willow Mina and Olive Wilhelmina are both lovely names and very good compromises.

fruitstick · 21/08/2023 09:12

I had a crazy debate with DH over DS2.

DS1 was named after DH's grandad. Fine by me as I liked the name. I got the middle name.

DH wanted to make DS2 after his OTHER grandad. I said hard no, but he could have the middle name.

DH tried to argue that it wasn't fair I got to choose the name of I wasn't going to name him after one of my male relatives.

dS2 was five days old when finally FIL came up with some random great uncle with the name to placate DH.

People are weird about baby names.

BiIIie · 21/08/2023 09:12

Is he always like this where he refuses any kind of compromise? He sounds so selfish! Lots of alternatives are so much better:

Willow Mina
Willow Billie
Willow Hemina

All still lovely tributes to MIL.

UnctuousUnicorns · 21/08/2023 09:11

SpongeBobSquarePantaloons · 21/08/2023 09:05

He was Icelandic though. That's how Icelandic names work.

Yes, like Magnus Magnusson?

UnctuousUnicorns · 21/08/2023 09:09

2pence · 21/08/2023 08:32

Also the name Willow might work if she's likely to be willowy, tall, graceful etc. Not a great name to be saddled with if you're short, chunky and clumsy.

I used to work with a clumpy, flat footed, deep voiced, bellowing "Grace" which always seemed a cruel twist of fate.

But grace doesn't just mean in the physical sense; there is grace of mind/outlook. Although I find it odd and irksome that many if not most of the virtue names are feminine ones, when really they name attributes that should be hoped for and admired in anybody, male or female. Right can of worms there.

BreatheAndFocus · 21/08/2023 09:07

The first thing I’d say is dont give the baby his surname whatever her first names turn out to be. He sounds controlling and obsessive.

I understand the idea of honouring parents/grandparents/great-grandparents, but where does it stop? Each parent of a baby has/had 4 GPs and 2 parents. Thats 12 names in total. They can’t all be honoured. More importantly, often the names don’t go. Say you decide to honour both grandmothers and so you get Charlotte Doris Betsy or some clunky combination? It just sounds horrible and the focus is on the clunky names not the child as an individual.

Wilhelmina is an ugly name IMO and it doesn’t go with Willow (or Olive really). If he won’t compromise by using a shortened form of it like Mina, then don’t use it. Mina would still be a tribute and a link to her.

The easiest thing to do to stop this agonising is to do what my ex-H and I agreed - no naming after relatives. It made things so much easier and meant our DC had names we really liked, names that went together, and names that were them.

Olika · 21/08/2023 09:07

So your husband has how then decided on first name, middle name and surname.

SpongeBobSquarePantaloons · 21/08/2023 09:05

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 20/08/2023 21:30

Willow Wilhelmina just gives me Stefan Stefansson vibes, like Robbie rotton from lazy town.

He was Icelandic though. That's how Icelandic names work.

2chocolateoranges · 21/08/2023 09:05

He’s admitted the Willow is his favourite as it’s a nod to his mums nickname(Will, Willie) he can’t be the one to choose both first and middle. There needs to be compromised.

my friend was bullied/manipulated into using 2 names for their baby as her dh went on and on and on and she eventually gave in, regretting it ever since.

poor baby having 2 names that sound extremely similar.

if he’s that adamant about the middle name there is no way he will change his name if you get married.

midlifecrash · 21/08/2023 08:49

A baby is born (not a bevy!)

winteriscoming2022 · 21/08/2023 08:49

Just call her Wilhelmena known as Willow, no middle name
Simple

midlifecrash · 21/08/2023 08:48

Good luck OP. Remember you have quite a long time (a year?) after the birth to register/ change the first name… And I believe it’s not uncommon once a bevy is born to realise that a preferred name, however beautiful, does not “fit” them somehow, eg “this baby is a Clementine not a Samantha” so who knows…

bridgetreilly · 21/08/2023 08:44

Two middle names:

Willow Grace Wilhelmina
Willow Joy Wilhelmina
Willow Maud Wilhelmina
Willow Dawn Wilhelmina

ZiriForEver · 21/08/2023 08:42

I don't understand the naming after predecessors at all. Each child is a new separate human being. The child isn't a tool to alleviate adult's grief. A name is there for the child, not a child for the name.

Naunet · 21/08/2023 08:40

Do not put the last name up for negotiation. Tradition is babies get the same last name as mum, I don’t know where this sudden male entitlement to last names has come from or why women are complying with it.