Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say no to having dp's mum's name as middle name

532 replies

thunderthunder3 · 20/08/2023 20:23

dp and i are due our baby girl at the end of sep and he wants his late mum's name to be her middle name. the name we both agreed on just does not go with it at all and it makes me hate the name and so he said we should just pick the second name we liked then but i don't like it as much and honestly his late mum's name is really quite bad (no offence to her at all) but i want to love our daughter's name... i think he doesn't even consider it not being there as she has passed and has always been what he has known middle names to be. he says if we have another girl she can have my mum's name in the middle, which i wouldn't want either. aibu to say no?

OP posts:
thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 14:37

to the people saying to just make her first name Wilhelmina Confused i honestly wouldn't do that in a million years, i hate the name, so the last thing i would do is put it as her first name and try to cover it up with everything by demanding she actually goes by willow.

his mum's middle name was her grandmother's so think it would be a bit pointless to use it again and it is also not a very nice name and her maiden name is a surname most would not have really heard of, so really doesn't work as a name either

OP posts:
Sugargliderwombat · 21/08/2023 14:35

Do your surname and then you just reregister when you marry. Please don't make the same mistake as SO many women have.

It's making me cross that he is trying to choose the entire bloody name.

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 14:32

yeah he is at work now so we are getting a much needed break from the name talk! i am still very much undecided on everything but one thing for sure now is willow Wilhelmina is completely off the table, i do not want so much reference to his mum especially now he even admits he fell in love with willow as it did remind him of her name (this was never mentioned btw and i admit i always very much loved the name too) so it actually seems the perfect thing! just have her as willow because we both love it and it gets the nod to his mum but as i say when i said about mina, he seems to think he needs her actual name in there to make it meaningful.

to be honest, i have never had any issues in our relationship and when i started this thread it was genuinely about me seeing if i am unreasonable or not to pipe up about a middle name i do not like, i genuinely assumed the surname (as i said earlier on i was undecided what i was picking) and if we go with willow or not with that middle name was something i could also decide on quote easily if the argument was "yeah it is unreasonable" hence i said we would just go for our second fave name with it. never did i think it would blow into such a big thing with him and i have honestly never seen him be like this! it has rather upset me to be honest. i am hoping he is just acting out of emotion and will apologise and try and be fair about the whole thing after a day at work but who knows

my due date is 27th September to whoever asked so we do have a little bit of time and obviously we could finalise after i have had her and he has seen me go through bloody labour

you are definitely making me want my surname though but then i am still unsure what we will do on marriage and no, marriage has not been decided/planned yet but obviously it is obviously what we do want one day. am thinking maybe we just do willow and then a double surname? urgh i don't know

OP posts:
truthhurts23 · 21/08/2023 14:26

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 10:49

he says he really wants willow again now and i am seriously just like wtf. he says it will be nice to always hear "will" like with his mum and i am like exactly!!! you are getting at least the nickname people called her at the start of her name every single time she is called. i would never say this to him but the fact he wants our daughter's whole name to basically be his mother + a name kind of like his mum's is just a bit much imo. i admit i have not lost a parent so maybe that is quite normal but it feels a lot for our daughter who will always be a part of him and subsequently his mother.

i have said how about we do willow (middle name be related to his surname) and then my surname and be done with it and he is saying that is the worst option i have given him, so i told him to pick one of the damn options then. he says if he gives up on Wilhelmina he wants his surname

fucking exhausted, i tell you. So glad i can at least talk here about it Sad

OP please put your foot down, that name sounds bloody terrible
Willow Wilhemina , it doesn't sound good and you know it doesn't
your husband is not the one who has to live with that name, he will get over it

she might get bullied imagine the children at school singing willow willie
please do not let him have his way
just give his mothers middle name as your childs middle name, that is what most people do

foolishone · 21/08/2023 14:25

Not getting great vibes about your partner tbh. I don't think I'd want to be with someone so unwilling to compromise and see my perspective.

Is he like this about other stuff?

truthhurts23 · 21/08/2023 14:18

Skinthin · 21/08/2023 04:50

she already paid tribute with Willow which is a beautiful name, and then she can add the middle name as mena

ffs will people stop saying this. OP didn’t pick Willow “as a tribute”. It’s not a tribute to MIL, because it’s not her name. Nor is Mena.
OP’s DP has already said these names are not meaningful to him as they are not his late mother’s name. 🤦🏼‍♀️

As I already said upthread I’ve agreed to a name I really dislike as a tribute to my DP’s late grandfather. I wouldn’t accept it as a first name, but I can’t imagine being so callous as to deny him that for a middle name. Middle names aren’t that important. They don’t need to be used and they are usually (and best used as) a tribute to a loved one.

I’ve agreed to a name I really dislike as a tribute to my DP’s late grandfather.

well that was your choice but I would never give my child a name that I didn't like, the name would at least have to sound decent, Wilhemina is not a nice sounding name , hence it being unpopular in modern times
and it also doesn't flow with the first name

UnctuousUnicorns · 21/08/2023 13:54

This is about more than baby names, isn't it OP? I'd think carefully about marrying this man if I were you. Regardless of what I or anyone else thinks of your or his name choices.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 21/08/2023 13:41

Nope!!! He wants everything his own way and won't be happy til he wears you down!!

Willow Whilomena is awful - they don't go together at all.

OhHelloTheres · 21/08/2023 13:40

We named our child after a relative but instead of copying the name exactly, we looked up the meaning of the name and then found a completely different name with the same meaning. So both names eg mean happiness but one in Latin, one in Hebrew. That was our compromise in a similar situation anyway!

WitcheryDivine · 21/08/2023 13:35

I've only just realised that he basically wants his daughter's name to be his mum's entire name (I'm assuming she shared his surname) with a diminutive of her name up front.

That is really, really weird.

So he's the son of Patricia Wilkinson, and he wants to call her Patty Patricia Wilkinson.

Is he OK???????

You are so totally in the right about this OP. I feel sorry for the future baby if she diverges from his mum in any way. What if original Wilhelmina loved peas and the baby hates them, or original W really liked maths and the baby turns out to be shit at it. Is he going to be angry because he's not successfully replicated his mother?

Honestly I think if he keeps banging on about this you need to tell him straight that it's awful what happened with his mum but this baby is her own person, not a replica of her grandmother, and she deserves her own name.

LightDrizzle · 21/08/2023 13:34

While I was sympathetic to him wanting Wilhelmina as ONE of her names, he is being a dick insisting on Willow Wilhelmina when you have compromised so much in letting Willow go.

As for the surname, don’t let him appropriate that as part of negotiations. You aren’t married so conventionally and for hundreds of years, the baby has your name. I’d refuse to even discuss that. It’s not his right to “give up”.

I can’t believe he’s being such an arse with you.

Insidenumber09 · 21/08/2023 13:31

Agree with malificent7 was going to post the same. Use it as a last middle name and have another middle name to split the 2 w names up I think that would sound lovely (hardly ever going to be used anyway). My son has 2 middle names (my grandads first name and my dad’s first name) I figured if he was having my husband’s surname I wanted my families names as middle names. We chose the first name together. X

crazeekat · 21/08/2023 13:16

full mums name even as a middle name, i get u, it's a mouthful but willow is a lovely compromise i think, and is such a beautiful name.
but. it's your baby. u must love the name or at least like it. so unfair either way for ur dp to not consider that daft u just don't like
it. and it's not personal.

ihadamarveloustime · 21/08/2023 13:14

Make sure the baby has your surname no matter what you do. Even if it's a middle name. It will be a nightmare for travel, etc without sharing a name, and there's zero reason not to have your surname on her birth certificate.

Naunet · 21/08/2023 13:13

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 10:49

he says he really wants willow again now and i am seriously just like wtf. he says it will be nice to always hear "will" like with his mum and i am like exactly!!! you are getting at least the nickname people called her at the start of her name every single time she is called. i would never say this to him but the fact he wants our daughter's whole name to basically be his mother + a name kind of like his mum's is just a bit much imo. i admit i have not lost a parent so maybe that is quite normal but it feels a lot for our daughter who will always be a part of him and subsequently his mother.

i have said how about we do willow (middle name be related to his surname) and then my surname and be done with it and he is saying that is the worst option i have given him, so i told him to pick one of the damn options then. he says if he gives up on Wilhelmina he wants his surname

fucking exhausted, i tell you. So glad i can at least talk here about it Sad

Just stop consulting him and name her whatever you want. He’s lucky you’re even giving him a say, you don’t have to. He’s being a manipulative, controlling bellend.

ihadamarveloustime · 21/08/2023 13:12

It does just get worse and worse, doesn't it.

He's starting to show his true colours by the sound of it, OP: controlling and egotistical, thinks his way is the only way.

You're not married. I'd keep it that way. And name the baby what you want with your surname.

Naunet · 21/08/2023 13:10

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 10:31

just lost and struggling a lot with this because i just want it sorted and don't know what to do with it either. i have said we will go Wilhelmina for the middle but can we please have a serious discussion about deciding on a new first name that we love as clearly you aren't keen on olive anymore and that is fine but we need to find something else we both like and he said yes if she has his surname... i do feel like the moment i get something in my favour, i have to them give up 2 things to get it. i am so tired of it

NO OP, find your bloody backbone, she does NOT get his last name, why does he think he’s entitled to that when you aren’t even married? The baby gets the mums last name, as is tradition,

Tell him when he gives birth, he can make the rules, entitled dick.

MissHarrietBede · 21/08/2023 12:59

I would not marry this controlling arse of a man. I would not saddle a child with Willow Wilhelmina. I would register her with my surname.

Gothambutnotahamster · 21/08/2023 12:56

GLORIAGloriarse · 21/08/2023 11:05

And honestly, please just call a time out on this conversation for now. Make your hard lines clear 'willow Wilhelmina is not happening. I am happy to include Wilhemina as a middle name. Come to the table in 2 weeks with serious suggestions for first names/ alternative formats. The baby will have my surname or both until we are married as I am her mother and am the one growing and birthing her'. Don't get bogged down in negotiating over surnames. That's not the issue.

Completely agree with this.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 21/08/2023 12:56

Could you use your surname as a middle name? Willow Yoursurname Wilhelmina Hissurname?

I wasn’t married when I had my two boys and they have my surname as a second middle name so it was on their passport in case of travel etc. I then did change my surname on marriage and did the same with my name - changed it by deed poll so I could add my own surname as my middle name.

In our case my surname is the second middle name, but in your case you could switch it to break up the Willow Wilhelmina (which is ridiculous).

pikkumyy77 · 21/08/2023 12:47

He is bargaining with you to get the child’s surname and unwilling to concede anything. He really comes across here as extremely selfish, rude, and dismissive of you.

This is not a healthy way to approach any decision. He does not recognize any of your wants. Its all about him.

Just tell him child will be named Willow Your Surname. At this rate you may never marry him so she should not be stuck with his name. He should be taking care of you and the baby. Not whining and demanding.

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 12:36

pamplemoussemousse · 20/08/2023 23:55

Don't tell the OP she's being horrible, she's trying to accommodate her dp while not saddling her child with a name she doesn't like.

She's suggested alternatives and he's having none, I'm not sure she's the horrible one...

Why not when that is what I think? Middle names are an irrelevance, so it doesn't matter at all. I didthos for my dp without a second thought.

malificent7 · 21/08/2023 12:34

Why not have 2 or more middle names and include it as the last middle name?

Olika · 21/08/2023 12:33

I am actually getting pissed off on your behalf. This is getting worse. All I hear is 'if I give up this then I want that'. Naming a child should not be so transactional. I would leave this now until she is born and then if you agree go with Willow (something) his sure name. If you are taking his at marriage anyway then no point to complicate it by giving your first.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/08/2023 12:33

2pence · 21/08/2023 08:19

Why can't her first name be Wilhelmina? Known as Willow while young or as she chooses when she has her own autonomy.

It's a far superior name to Willow for a powerful women, and is uncommon and striking.

Willow is pretty with no power. Can you imagine a female CEO named Willow? Willow is someone's pretty girlfriend or wife, or a cute little girl when younger. And what happens if she's not pretty or cute, how will she wear the name then? Conversely, a Wilhelmina holds power.

This.