Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say no to having dp's mum's name as middle name

532 replies

thunderthunder3 · 20/08/2023 20:23

dp and i are due our baby girl at the end of sep and he wants his late mum's name to be her middle name. the name we both agreed on just does not go with it at all and it makes me hate the name and so he said we should just pick the second name we liked then but i don't like it as much and honestly his late mum's name is really quite bad (no offence to her at all) but i want to love our daughter's name... i think he doesn't even consider it not being there as she has passed and has always been what he has known middle names to be. he says if we have another girl she can have my mum's name in the middle, which i wouldn't want either. aibu to say no?

OP posts:
Changedforthetoday · 21/08/2023 20:36

Not sure if anyone has suggested this as have not read through the thread - what about Willow Mina ?

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 20:34

if it was a boy he didn't care for any sort of will name and our boy name isn't even close. he has claimed his mum "definitely sent us a girl" and he is really into that whole idea of this is her giving a sign or something which is weird because he is so far from religious or spiritual! i try to be sympathetic about him being upset she will never meet our baby, of course i do. i cannot imagine what that feels like Sad will definitely try and bring as many memories from his childhood back with our dd.

he is home again now and the name situation has already come up... told him we are leaving it for now and he just asks "well is she still willow or not as we need to know what to refer to her as" he is really brilliant at brining this up a million times and getting us to go around in circles Hmm definitely not doing it again tonight lol.

appreciate all the replies on this thread

OP posts:
HappyScales · 21/08/2023 20:31

Will he go for Willow Rose Wilhelmina, or something similar, as I think that could be a great compromise and works better than Willow Wilhelmina imo.

Tinysoxx · 21/08/2023 19:59

I think some people are being harsh here. The father is obviously grieving for his own mother who he loved very deeply and is getting more upset that she won’t be there when his daughter is born as the pregnancy continues. He wants to keep her memory going by calling his daughter the same as his mum. I imagine the not budging with the name (Willow Wilhelmina ??) is more to do with his not being able to have his mum with him at this big life change.
We briefly considered a dead relatives name but both decided it wouldn’t bring them back in any form and the new life was its own person. Instead we kept photos out and talked about them. OP why don’t you ask your partner about his mums favourite things and try and incorporate books/ toys into the nursery that she read to your partner from what he can remember?

bobaloo · 21/08/2023 18:59

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 10:31

just lost and struggling a lot with this because i just want it sorted and don't know what to do with it either. i have said we will go Wilhelmina for the middle but can we please have a serious discussion about deciding on a new first name that we love as clearly you aren't keen on olive anymore and that is fine but we need to find something else we both like and he said yes if she has his surname... i do feel like the moment i get something in my favour, i have to them give up 2 things to get it. i am so tired of it

Your "partner" is an uncompromising dick. He's acting like a 4 year old.

SeriousLeigh · 21/08/2023 18:23

People saying how about a compromise, what about this variation or that are not seeing that thunderthunder3’s partner does NOT want to compromise! Willow reminds him of his mother, Wilhelmina was her name so he wants his daughter to have both those names. He thinks OP is just an incubator for his mum 2.0.

Coulditreallybe · 21/08/2023 18:11

What if you have a boy next @thunderthunder3 ? Will he want Will William??

MisschiefMaker · 21/08/2023 17:43

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 10:31

just lost and struggling a lot with this because i just want it sorted and don't know what to do with it either. i have said we will go Wilhelmina for the middle but can we please have a serious discussion about deciding on a new first name that we love as clearly you aren't keen on olive anymore and that is fine but we need to find something else we both like and he said yes if she has his surname... i do feel like the moment i get something in my favour, i have to them give up 2 things to get it. i am so tired of it

So he thinks it's acceptable that you're:

Giving up your first choice of first name (Willow)
Giving up your second choice of first name (olive)
Giving her a middle name you hate
Giving the child his last name.

He does know that you're the mother, right? not just a vessel to carry his child?

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 15:56

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/08/2023 15:25

If middle names are irrelevant and don’t matter then you could also say that it doesn’t need to be Wilhelmina.

It does not "need" to be anything, but it would mean something to her dad and maybe the child herself. It is an irrelevance as it does not need to be used, ever. The sentiment has value however.

Adorapan · 21/08/2023 15:44

Willow Wilhelmina is pretty marmite and most people would hate it. If you both loved it fine but definitely one that needs both parents enthusiastically wanting it. Calling her Willow (or Willow Mina which is basically just … Wilhemina) is more than generous on your part. Why are you making all the compromises here? if he wasn’t involved what would your ideal name be? That’s your starting point, Willow Wilhelmina is his and see where there’s room to meet. I’d be giving her my surname as a non negotiable thought. Change it if you want to if you do get married and take his name.
The more I type Willow Wilhelmina the more I think this has got to be a wind up. If he is genuine then do remind him that your daughter is her own person not some weird rerun of his mum. I speak as someone who used part of their mums name for her daughter - but she has her own names too!

MNetcurtains · 21/08/2023 15:44

Pinkea · 20/08/2023 20:31

Willow as a first name 100% changes things, actually! That’s the tribute to her (and is lovely tbh).

I think she was saying that they have chosen Willow as her first and that Wilhemina a a second name is not going to work.

Blinkblinkblink · 21/08/2023 15:37

I think you should summarise to your DP that you both like the name Willow, and that he has acknowledged that it is also a tribute to his mum. Then be clear that under no circumstances will she be named Willow Wilhelmina as that would be an embarrassing, ridiculous name and your child's experience of her own name is simply more important than his memory of his mother.

If he won't engage with you to compromise on either the first or middle name then instruct him that you will take the baby to registrar without him and call her what you like, which is your right.

I would suggest very strongly to him that insisting upon the middle name Wilhelmina will mean the following:

  • Not having the first name Willow and the nickname "Will" which he obviously likes a lot and references his mum
  • You disliking the middle name which is a pretty big compromise and should mean that you have a free rein to decide your next child's middle name without his approval
  • He has used up the tribute to his mother and there is no guarantee that a future child will be called William or Willow or any other Will name.

I think that is very reasonable. Don't go back and forth on this. State your position and refuse to engage in further debate. You are pregnant and going to give birth to this child FGS.

It is absolutely ridiculous and very selfish of your DP to believe that he can dictate both your daughter's first and middle names, particularly when his choice is frankly ridiculous - that's true no matter how much he loves his mum who passed away. You can give her whatever surname you want and his preferences don't come into it and that is also not a bargaining chip for him to try to use in this decision. Deciding the surname is your privilege as the mother, something for you to think about and decide and not something he is "giving" you under any circumstances.

PurpleFlower1983 · 21/08/2023 15:30

Random thought! What about going with something like Willa? There’s a character in Succession with that name and I think it’s really pretty.

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/08/2023 15:25

Snugglemonkey · 21/08/2023 12:36

Why not when that is what I think? Middle names are an irrelevance, so it doesn't matter at all. I didthos for my dp without a second thought.

If middle names are irrelevant and don’t matter then you could also say that it doesn’t need to be Wilhelmina.

FatBurger · 21/08/2023 15:21

Going against the grain, I actually think Willow Wilhelmina is really cute! And Wilhelmina is quite fashionable currently.

Could you add in a 3rd name? Both my kids have 2 middle names for reasons.

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 15:20

yes but just say we did break up and our relationship didn't work out i would not want to change her surname if it was a double surname I would be more than happy for her to always have her mum and dad's surname regardless of our relationship status, it seems most fair

OP posts:
Naunet · 21/08/2023 15:18

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 14:48

yes sorry i just meant we do hope the end goal to be marriage and i do understand not just giving her his surname to be honest but it feels right to have both? as i am drawn to that if we do marry but it just would be very long and yes maybe i do just do my surname until we reach that point and then change it but out of everything i actually think he would be fair to ask for it to be a double surname

I do have a job to go back to Smile i actually earn more than him haha

Just give the baby your last name and change it on marriage IF you change your name. It’s better that way around, than to give her his name, then you never get married and he refuses to ever let you change it. Give yourself options.

Id take the last name off the table though, it’s not up for discussion, focus on the other names, and refuse his ridiculous suggestion. I think you really need to assert yourself. Is he normally like this when you disagree with him?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 21/08/2023 14:52

Sugargliderwombat · 21/08/2023 14:35

Do your surname and then you just reregister when you marry. Please don't make the same mistake as SO many women have.

It's making me cross that he is trying to choose the entire bloody name.

Exactly. The OP has to do all the work of growing the baby, having the discomforts of pregnancy and then going through the birth and yet he thinks it should all be about him?

RubiRage · 21/08/2023 14:52

That’s awful OP! What about Willow Mia, or just Mia?

thunderthunder3 · 21/08/2023 14:48

yes sorry i just meant we do hope the end goal to be marriage and i do understand not just giving her his surname to be honest but it feels right to have both? as i am drawn to that if we do marry but it just would be very long and yes maybe i do just do my surname until we reach that point and then change it but out of everything i actually think he would be fair to ask for it to be a double surname

I do have a job to go back to Smile i actually earn more than him haha

OP posts:
Lilyoverthevalley · 21/08/2023 14:47

I think he's slipped up by admitting that Willow reminds him of his mum's name and that he'll enjoy hearing "Will" as his mum was often called Will. He was obviously refusing to admit this previously but now he has admitted it you need to use this to your advantage and insist that Willow is the tribute, there is no need for Wilhemina.

You could offer to use his mum's middle name as your daughter's middle name even though you don't particularly like it. I think the fact it was also his grandmother's name makes it more of an argument to use it as it's then a family name with links to both women.

Then if he gets this middle name you get your surname. Please use your own surname!

Zena88 · 21/08/2023 14:45

OP this is your baby too, give her the name you want. Willow is tribute enough, your DP sounds uncompromising and the emotional blackmail when you’re heavily pregnant is disgusting. Please give her your surname. Take care X

ihadamarveloustime · 21/08/2023 14:44

you are definitely making me want my surname though but then i am still unsure what we will do on marriage and no, marriage has not been decided/planned yet but obviously it is obviously what we do want one day. am thinking maybe we just do willow and then a double surname? urgh i don't know

There's nothing 'obvious' about it, tbh. If you have agreed to get married and set a date, you're not planning to get married right now. Just look at the numerous posts on mumsnet similar to your 'obviously ... one day ... we'll get married' sentitment and how wrong so many posters were. And how many problems it's caused in their relationsihps and how screwed over many women were when they sacrificed so much to have and look after the children as primary caretakers.

Give the baby your surname and make sure you have a job to go back to after maternity leave. Make him pay his fair share of childcare, etc.

Ienjoyedthebarbiemovie · 21/08/2023 14:38

thunderthunder3 · 20/08/2023 20:29

wasn't sure on posting the name but did name change just in case it came up. name is wilhelmina and we had decided on willow as her first name... i really don't like them together and i really do not like wilhelmina but i don't want to be awful and if it is genuinely really bad to say no, i will obviously have to suck it up and go with it and i think reading the opinions on others will definitely make me feel better about that if that is the case

Fuck that, ugliest name ever. Say no, it’s your body that’s going through this.