Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say no to having dp's mum's name as middle name

532 replies

thunderthunder3 · 20/08/2023 20:23

dp and i are due our baby girl at the end of sep and he wants his late mum's name to be her middle name. the name we both agreed on just does not go with it at all and it makes me hate the name and so he said we should just pick the second name we liked then but i don't like it as much and honestly his late mum's name is really quite bad (no offence to her at all) but i want to love our daughter's name... i think he doesn't even consider it not being there as she has passed and has always been what he has known middle names to be. he says if we have another girl she can have my mum's name in the middle, which i wouldn't want either. aibu to say no?

OP posts:
Proudmum17 · 20/08/2023 22:20

I think you know when you meet your child face to face what their name will be. They sort of let you know. Whatever you choose all the names you're thinking of sound lovely. Including Wilhelmina.

Amethys · 20/08/2023 22:20

Bloody hell, Wilhelmina?! 🙈

So the child gets his surname, and his family tradition also chooses the child’s middle name, and apparently your feminised surname isn’t an option, and now he’s managed to also make it impossible to use your favourite name.

That’s quite bossy of him. I would not be happy.

I would push back a bit on the middle name but if it means that much to him I would probably as my final offer give the child two middle names (and just never use them except on official paperwork). Plenty of people have four names.

so eg Willow Laura Wilhelmina Jones.

If he isn’t happy with that either then he needs to go look up compromise in a dictionary.

If you actively hate the name Wilhelmina then that’s a problem. You shouldn’t have to gove yiur daughter a name you hate. If you really hate it, just say so. Say you respect him and his family traditions but you cannot give your daughter a name you actively hate.

Surely his mother had a nickname? I do not believe everyone said her full first name every single time they spoke to her.

Icycloud · 20/08/2023 22:20

the grandparents name goes in the middle. The second name is hyphenated (mothers name-fathersname)

Hotflushesinthesunfun · 20/08/2023 22:20

I hate my middle name and it’s surprising how often it is used it’s on all official documents and all my school friends knew it , and actually quite a few of my friends now, as names do get discussed.

The baby is a person in their own right. Why would you saddle them with a name you hate as a pp upthread said they are doing for their dp? You should love the name this person is going to have for hopefully 80+ years.

Scoobyblue · 20/08/2023 22:20

Willow Wilhelmina is awful. Absolutely bloody awful.
I don't like Wilhelmina but would use it as a middle name because it has such sentimental meaning for your partner. But not with Willow as a first name. That's just dreadful (in my opinion).

Takacupokindnessyet · 20/08/2023 22:18

BiIIie · 20/08/2023 20:33

I think I'd be pushing for a compromise of Willow Mina as first and middle name. The both names would still very much be a tribute to your late MIL.

This was my thought to.

SlippySarah · 20/08/2023 22:18

I'm shocked that the overall feeling is that DP should get overall veto and decision making rights on DC name just because his mum died. People die every day. There are plenty of ways to keep their memory alive without saddling your child with an awful name forever.

JenWillsiam · 20/08/2023 22:17

I would say no.

she will presumably have his mothers surname. We had middle name from my family because they got his family surname.

bullywee · 20/08/2023 22:15

Nina for short?

ItLooksLikeChickenSoItMustBeChicken · 20/08/2023 22:15

I think you're being rather unkind and unreasonable. Your partner's mum is dead, so he's feeling sad that she's not here to ever see this baby. What harm could it do to have his late mum's name as a middle name for your child? Nobody ever uses the middle name anyway.

StillWantingADog · 20/08/2023 22:15

Btw if it helps my dh and I couldn’t agree on middle names for either ds so they both have two middle names.
it really doesn’t matter at all, nobody outside our immediate family even knows what they are.

KarmaStar · 20/08/2023 22:14

Yes Yabu to not compromise.She's not just your baby.
Have some compassion.

StillWantingADog · 20/08/2023 22:14

Willow is lovely. Did she use that name? In which case sorted

but you can’t call her Willow Whilhelmina.

thunderthunder3 · 20/08/2023 22:13

said to dp maybe we do just go for olive wilhelmina then and he is saying how he prefers willow... i think i am going to head to bed. what a headfuck. i actually said to him how about we do willow (the female name of my surname) wilhelmina and then his surname and he is saying how we already agreed that 4 names in total is too much. so i have said fine we will go for my surname until we are married then and he is complaining i am just saying this now to make a point about having to use wilhelmina. i have genuinely had enough for one night, to the point i even told him to tell me what first name off our original list he would pick then if he doesn't want olive now and has told me willow. i seriously just don't want willow wilhelmina and that is the only criteria i bloody have anymore.

i really do appreciate the replies and help, but think i need a rest from it for the night before i send myself into early labour Grin

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 20/08/2023 22:12

I think you should just use the name under the circumstances. As it obviously means a lot to your DH.

Skinthin · 20/08/2023 22:12

FeigningConcern · 20/08/2023 22:04

I don't think using a different name is compromising personally.

And he's not insisting the name is a first name. Just that he wants his late mum's name as a middle name. Not sure how much more he could compromise really as I agree with him that using a different name is pointless. You might as well not bother.

The reason I focussed on you compromising is that you can pick a first name you like, no one will use the middle name ever so it's really not that important (except to your DH because it will be his mum's name), and there's lots of options for you to get that middle name in. So lots of ways for you to find a compromise.

Just my thoughts though. You asked for opinions!

Exactly this

hulahooper2 · 20/08/2023 22:12

How about Willow Mina?

Skinthin · 20/08/2023 22:10

Youwho2 · 20/08/2023 21:31

I think you should veto it all together then. He doesn't want to compromise at all. You should at least like the name your child has. I think you need to go back to the drawing board. Honestly I wish I fought more for my daughters name. I wanted Arya he wanted Aria. I wanted double barrel surnames and ge was hugely offended. I think by the end of the pregnancy i was exhausted and just let him have his own way.

This is so unfair: he doesn’t want to compromise on the one thing he’s asked for which is to include his dead mother’s name somewhere in his daughter’s name. It’s the most natural and understandable request imaginable when naming one’s child. He hasn’t asked for the first name, he’s just asked for a middle, which is nothing and so easily granted . So many people have middle names that are never used / heard of again. I don’t like my middle name, I couldn’t care less.

its OP who won’t compromise. She won’t have Willow Wilhelmina , she won’t include an extra name in the middle to break up the two “w”s (eg willow rose Wilhelmina) and she won’t accept a second choice first name.

Utterly heartless about something that is obviously so important and meaningful to her partner. I can’t imagine being like this. My partner has asked to include his late grandfather’s name in our baby’s name. I can’t stand the name and wouldn’t be happy with the idea as a first name, but no chance I would refuse it as a middle. I can’t even imagine even questioning such a request in the case of a late mother.

Meadowflower2023 · 20/08/2023 22:10

so was tempted to just give her his so hers never needs to change but then marriage isn't really in the near future so kind of want her to share mine until then so really don't know!

I'm shocked that given his insistence on your DDs name that this would even be an option with your DP (to give her your surname)

Willow and Olive are both lovely names btw. What a predicament! Good luck and keep us posted on what you decide.

Brotherlove · 20/08/2023 22:10

Teapot13 · 20/08/2023 20:59

Wilhelmina rocks! Use it as first name and call her Willow for short.

Do this. Wilhelmina is so cool.

MeetMyCat · 20/08/2023 22:09

Saddling someone with the name “Willow Wilhelmina” is just ridiculous. No matter whose choice it is.

Very true. Poor child!

porridgeisbae · 20/08/2023 22:08

Some PPs's suggestion of Willow Mina is a great compromise I think.

I agree that it's your DH that isn't compromising.

Scottishskifun · 20/08/2023 22:08

Was she known to her friends as anything shorter?

DS2 has FIL as a middle name (also passed away) as we had a long first name we used the shortened version of Ben instead of Benjamin so it flowed better and less of a mouthful with 2 long names.
Could that be a option for you? I would say if she used a shortened version with friends then it is her name.

BalloonsInWater · 20/08/2023 22:07

Olive Wilhelmina YourSurname then

FWIW there is an olive and two willows in our nursery class

clpsmum · 20/08/2023 22:06

No I agree with you that doesn't go at all. Could you use her middle name/surname/maiden name/nickname instead?