Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been OW and regret how my marriage / family began

471 replies

otherwomanregrets · 20/08/2023 11:55

16 years ago I had an affair with a married man, I was single and mid 20s with a toddler (split with their dad when they were a few weeks old and was raising them on my own)

He left his wife for me quite quickly, about 8 weeks. He had said all the usual stuff like they're unhappy etc and he'd wanted to leave for ages but I now know that was probably a load of crap. And of course I always worry he'll do it to us (even though so far he seems devoted to us all you never know )

We are still married and we are "happy" and have a good life, a nice home etc and we are honestly best friends and still love each other and fancy each other. but I know that my good life and my younger two children came from a horrible situation

I desperately regret it now I'm older and wiser and have children, a house and a family. and I completely imagine the devastation it causes where as I did not back then and also did not care or think about his ex wife and DCs . If I'm honest I was not a nice person at all and although I really liked my H some of it was about "winning" and being chosen over another woman. Our first dc was born only 18 months after we got together and she was planned. Although I don't regret her at all, I regret having her so quick because I can't even imagine what a slap in the face that was to his old family. We also got engaged fairly quickly (he asked me)

My H's now adult dc want nothing to do with him and have not done since he left them. And I have never met them and neither have my DC. and in the first few years I could not understand this now I completely do as I'd fully expect my dc to be the same if he ever left us

As the person I am now - I'd have ran a mile 16 years ago and found someone single. But how do I reconcile my deep regret as I would not change having my two younger DCs or the life that we all have now.

If I could I would apologise to his old family for my part in their lives being destroyed. No need for posters to tell me what an awful person I am because believe me I know (although I'm sure they will anyway). I also feel guilty that my H doesn't get to see his DC and my DC do not know their older sibling and it's my fault

I was young naive and fucking stupid and I'll be ashamed of what I did and regret it til the day I die.
So I guess this is also a warning to other potential OW even if your affair partner leaves for you in all likelihood your life together will always be tainted

OP posts:
RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 20/08/2023 17:06

Re-read the OP, @LaurelandHedgy. Your third paragraph is BS.

hotpotlover · 20/08/2023 17:06

IdealisticCynic · 20/08/2023 15:55

Putting aside the affair issue, I couldn’t be with someone who said that they would rather not see their own child ever again than stay in an unhappy marriage. I cannot imagine ever choosing my happiness over seeing my child ever again. I couldn’t like or respect, let alone love, someone who thought like this.

That's exactly what I thought.

I couldn't be attracted to a man that a) left his children for me b) prefers not seeing his children again rather than being in an unhappy relationship

I'm afraid your husband isn't much of a prize, OP, and I'm sure you subconsciously know this.

Fallingthroughclouds · 20/08/2023 17:00

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 20/08/2023 14:03

Do you think she has, though? I think all that’s happened is that she’s now in the position her husband’s ex was in (children, house, family) and she’s realised she’d really hate it if her husband left them all for a younger woman.

I don’t know if I’d call that growth or empathy. It’s still 100% self-centred - ‘but what if this happened to meeee?’

There may be a bit of that. I try to take these posts as face value though, we could all put any kind of spin on anything otherwise. Difficult to know, since I've never met the OP and it's all just text. No point in psychoanalysising the crap out of it.

uneffingbelievable · 20/08/2023 16:59

OP - do you DCs know about their siblings?
Are you and their DF going to be honest about why they do not see or know them?

If your DCs do not know /never seen a picture then they are in for a very big shock

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/08/2023 16:46

Greensleeves · 20/08/2023 12:52

You have a child with a man who has actually stated that he would rather lose contact with his children than be in an unhappy relationship...yeah, I wouldn't be feeling secure and comfortable either OP.

I don't take any pleasure in your unhappiness, but I can't pretend to understand what makes someone like you tick. You must know he isn't a good person - and you must know you aren't, either. Living with that knowledge must be awful.

This

It must be awful having it constantly hang over a relationship that your husband is a cheat and a deadbeat father. That your relationship is born out of lies and deceit and that any children you have are equally at risk of being abandoned and potentially scarred for life.

I don't know how OW who have subsequently become the wife sleep at night for the worry.

For the life of me I don't know how anyone could find that kind of shitty person attractive either -the husband or the OW. Looks fade and you'll be stuck with their character.....doesn't bear thinking about really.

notlucreziaborgia · 20/08/2023 16:41

I don’t consider anyone else’s relationship to be any of my business, so judgement on my part.

It’s one thing to realise that, in retrospect, you regret your behaviour, but wallowing in guilt and regret is entirely self indulgent. You can’t change the past, so what exactly are you going to achieve by dwelling on it? In what way is this making your life, and the life of your family, good and happy? There’s clearly been enough unhappiness caused, don’t compound it.

Daffodilwoman · 20/08/2023 16:35

Also do not take on any of the guilt your dh expresses about his dcs not seeing his new set of dcs.
Don't wallow in that. That is all on him.

Daffodilwoman · 20/08/2023 16:33

I haven’t read all the thread but here is my take.
Your dh deserves the treatment he receives from his children, I hope they have managed to overcome the shitty hand he dealt them and done well for themselves. As for seeing your dcs, that again is 100% their choice and I doubt their would give a damn about your family set up.
As for you there isn’t anything you can do. You say you are happy and don’t regret having your dcs so there you go. Carry on as you are. From your posts I doubt your dh is about to leave you.

ImNotReadyToMakeTea · 20/08/2023 16:26

How you got in to your relationship with your DH is really, really common I suspect. I would say that a very large number of women on here have had complicated beginnings to their relationships which have involved other parties. And not all cheaters are complete bastards who will do it again.

So really you need to stop berating yourself. Otherwise it will consume you. You weren't (aren't) perfect - just a normal fallible human who sometimes makes decisions they later question and regret. Join the (very big) club.

If your marriage is otherwise good then don't let these thoughts overwhelm it. Maybe talk to your husband about your feelings?

Grumpy101 · 20/08/2023 16:26

Is it maybe making you look at your DH in a different way? Affair is one thing, it sounds like it was a very unhappy marriage anyway. But not seeing his child for 16 years is....cold and heartless on a different level. What kind of father chooses to not fight for his kid and be involved with their life? That's awful. I'm not sure how you get past that tbh.

Flyinggeesei234 · 20/08/2023 16:25

OP I know this is not the main point, but as they have no contact how is your husband paying money to his adult child? How can he know bank info? It doesn’t ring true.

LaurelandHedgy · 20/08/2023 16:25

All these women justifying their actions by saying that married men only cheat if they are unhappy.

What about all the men who cheat, then are found out, then instantly dump OW, and are on their knees begging to be forgiven, as seen regularly on this board? I’ve a friend whose DH left her and her DC for someone 15 years younger, now he wants to come back, wife said get to fuck, so yes back with the OW. He gave the lame excuse of leaving wife as never been happy etc.

OP’s example is a classic case of married man with children, meets younger woman with no kids, has hot sex, decides that he was never happy in the first place, and leaves wife for hot, buff 20 something. I doubt he’d do the same if OP had been a mid 30’s single mum.

Maybe you can do something to make up for the situation by telling his ex wife that you're sorry, and can your children meet their half siblings.

OP, the damage is done, it was 16 years ago. That makes the child at least 26. She’s an adult. If she wants to contact you both she will. Leave her alone to be happy. If she wants a relationship she will come looking. By the way is she married? If so, was your DH not invited? Honestly, just leave his exW and DC in peace.

IdealisticCynic · 20/08/2023 15:55

otherwomanregrets · 20/08/2023 12:20

Exactly

I don't think he does feel that guilty, no. When we've talked about it he just says he was so unhappy when he was married before. and while he is sad he doesn't see his DC he'd rather that than be in an unhappy relationship.

He says he regrets even meeting his first wife and wishes he could have met me first. Kind of impossible though as I'm 10 years younger and he got married early 20s I think

Putting aside the affair issue, I couldn’t be with someone who said that they would rather not see their own child ever again than stay in an unhappy marriage. I cannot imagine ever choosing my happiness over seeing my child ever again. I couldn’t like or respect, let alone love, someone who thought like this.

BetterWithPockets · 20/08/2023 15:47

OP, you’re getting a pasting on here because this is MN — but part of me wonders if that’s why you posted… you said you’ve been on MN often enough to know the cheaters’ script (although FWIW, I don’t think that normally involves leaving your wife for the OW after 8 weeks, so although your DH did indeed cheat on his then wife, he didn’t follow ‘the script’ and it sounds to me as though he was truly unhappy and you were the catalyst, not the cause), but if that’s the case, you’d also have known you’d get slated. Is that what you were hoping for, at some level? Confirmation that yes, you are a terrible person? Many people on here will definitely agree, but I don’t. You did something stupid and wrong, yes — but lots of us do things we later wish we hadn’t. I think your idea of going to counselling is a good one, though; as another poster said, I think some of the guilt you’re holding should actually belong to your DH. I also think what’s done is done and while we can’t always let go of guilt (or indeed other emotions), it’s worth exploring why you’re clinging so firmly to yours. Good luck, OP.

BadNomad · 20/08/2023 15:15

Maybe looking at her own behaviour in the past is also making her look at her husband's and she is now realising what a horrible prize she has "won". It would be hard to see him the same way.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/08/2023 15:13

You have a good life, kids, husband. Just be happy

Except that in describing their lives OP put happy in inverted commas

Hard not to wonder the reason for that ...

Minfilia · 20/08/2023 15:12

The cheaters script gets peddled a lot on here OP, but it’s not always accurate.

My dad left for an OW, although he should have left years ago. My mother was a pretty awful person tbh and treated him horrendously. Nasty, spiteful, jealous, and abusive. His only error was not leaving sooner.

I was also the OW. I know that my now DH only stayed with her to “do the right thing” and look after his kids, but she is also a pretty awful person. She lied about being on the pill and got pregnant after only a few weeks together, had an affair, wouldn’t look after their kids as they were too much effort, quit her job as soon as they got married and made it clear she was only with him for his money. When he left she didn’t bother seeing the DC much for the first year as she “wanted her independence back” and they went NC with her by choice in their early and mid teens after seeing how neglectful and selfish she was.

Of course sometimes the script is accurate, but you only see it on here in response to posters who have been cheated on, and nobody is going to kick them when they’re down. Sometimes marriages really are horrendous though and the man isn’t lying. It would always be better not to leave as a result of an affair, and to leave for the ACTUAL problems in the relationship, but the point is you probably weren’t breaking up a happy marriage!

ZiriForEver · 20/08/2023 15:08

There is zero value in your guilt and martyring about "not deserving to feel better".
Get help with your feelings and enjoy your life.

I would be more concerned, that your DH doesn't make more effort keeping in touch/reconnecting with his child.

otherwomanregrets · 20/08/2023 15:06

BaroldandNedmund · 20/08/2023 14:48

Oh for goodness sake op!! It was sixteen years ago! I’m sure I was an absolute idiot all through my twenties but I was a different person then. Attractive women that age are competitive - it just isn’t spoken about. Why do you think the young women on Instagram are doing what they do? They’re trying to outdo each other and get the most male attention. It’s easy to look back and think ‘God I was awful and pathetic’ but that’s what hormones do.

It seems like you’re determined today to beat yourself up. You’re already doing it so you’re inviting others to do the same. You’re just being daft!

I was massively competitive with other women and also very jealous of ones I perceived to be better looking or have more money or whatever

I am not like that at all now

OP posts:
DysonSpheres · 20/08/2023 15:05

I regard marital infidelity as one of the worst things a person (bar a psychopath) can do.

The cost to society both fiscally and socially as a whole is huge and it is ever growing.

However you were young, naive at the time and with youth and naivety comes an inclination to be selfish. Now having matured and put your soul into building up your family you realise that a family is a precious and sacred thing.

I think the fact you recognise this and feel bad about it and have developed your conscience means you should now put this aside, realise you did bad, but have a right to grace and move on. Ask God if you're a believer in order to get past it, if necessary.

Your DH though is a different matter. It's not jus much that he cheated and broke his vows, but his remaining flippancy about it. Even if he were terribly unhappy, I would think after time, maturity and some reflection, his stance at the very least ought to be one of wishing he had behaved differently or better. Instead, he's shown he can prioritise himself even above the wellbeing of his child. That's an example of self-interest and shallowness of character that would have me putting my glasses on and questioning how I fell for him.

I suspect he got a very 'good deal' in you, and you certainly appear to be the better out of the two of you, so no wonder you might have pause as to perhaps thinking you got trapped at a young age in a situation that otherwise you'd not have been in, were it not for him being so morally lacking (and perhaps emotionally coercive?)

But such is life. If you're happy together no point ruining what you have for a past you can't fix. Move on.

Saoirse82 · 20/08/2023 14:59

daliesque · 20/08/2023 12:10

My relationship started in a similar way. We don't have kids together, it he does from his previous relationship. I don't have anything much to do with them as im not interested in them and they aren't in me. Their relationship with their dad is ok, but it's his responsibility to,keep it going and nothing to do with me.

We had an affair for about a year before he left her for me. I never asked him to, I left it to him to decide and he decided he wanted to be with me. Im sure there was a bit of drama at the time, but he a,ways saw our relationship as separate to that one and so didn't involve me in what was happening during the split.

We've been together about 3 years now. I do believe that he was unhappy with her and had only stayed so long because of the kids. The ins and outs of their past is irrelevant to me and our present and future.

We too are very well matched and have a strong relationship and love for each other. He is my soulmate and I am his. We will eventually get married, but neither of us are bothered. Neither of us are tempted by other people.

OP whatever people like to think, people who are happy in their relationship don't have affairs. We all know that it is better to split with someone before finding another person, but sometimes life doesn't work out that way and when that happens why turn down a chance of happiness just because society says it's wrong to have an overlap.

You have a good, happy marriage. Try and concentrate on what you have got rather than how you got together. That is now inconsequential.

You can tell yourself that all day long because it'll make you feel more assured in your relationship but happy people do have affairs, sometimes it's all about having their ego stroked.

LifesIsABeach · 20/08/2023 14:55

There’s no point hashing over the past. If he didn’t leave for you he would of for someone else eventually.

You have a good life, kids, husband. Just be happy.

I also met my husband when he was with someone else, he left quickly and we went on to have two kids and get married (he wasn’t married the first time). I feel no guilt, it was years ago and I was also young.

Iwasafool · 20/08/2023 14:55

Justwonderinghow · 20/08/2023 14:42

For the posters saying the OP’s husband was not happy I’m his relationship. That is completely irrelevant and does not make the start of their relationship any more palatable or acceptable.
if the husband was indeed unhappy, he should have left. But as many of us know, too many people are absolute cowards and are only prepared to leave a current relationship one they find a replacement.
I think we can all agree that if the OP’s husband had left “pre affair”, it is lilkely that he would have had a chance to prepare his children and when, he had eventually got with a new partner, it would have been easier for his children to understand and consequently, less likely that the father-child relationship would be breakdown.

just because it’s been many years, it doesn’t mean OP husban won’t cheat.
he has show how very little regard he has for family and he could do it in a heartbeat.
it many people, family is a drawing made using pencil, you can easily erase and start afresh.

Sorry, you seem to have matures but I do hope you get to experience some of the pain you have caused.

i was cheated on and although I mostly blame him, when I found out, I was so upset I cried and had words with her over a telephone call- she was an absolute nightmare and laughed at me.

Not my finest hour I must admit. Ex was very remorseful and I did try to forgive but broke up with him a few months later as I couldn’t trust him.

good luck

Or some people might stay when they are unhappy because they think it is better for the children. Then they meet someone, fall in love and they realise that their happiness also matters and if the ex is reasonable it can work out for the children.

The bitter ex poisoning the children can do more harm than the original break up.

Togastorm · 20/08/2023 14:51

I don't really think you're to blame. You were single, young and stupid and have clearly matured emotionally. He sounds pretty cut throat. Are you sure you're not more worried about him doing the same to you?

RestMasks · 20/08/2023 14:51

There's no point in lending my opinion on people who cheat and break up families (theirs and other people's) but I will offer a perspective on why you might be unable to let this go which I don't think had been mentioned so far:

Not only do I think there is residual fear that he will do this to you, which I think is a reasonable fear to be honest, but you also know he feels no guilt about what he did which must affect your view of him as a person, consciously or subconsciously. He's also content with not seeing his first child and it doesn't sound like he made much effort to do so. Ditto. Heartless. Could easily do the same again.

Finally, an 11/12 heart old child continued to see him for a year AFTER he left and then chose to stop, forever. That doesn't strike me as normal - what on earth went on there? You must surely wonder about the truth of what happened there too. It wasn't a knee-jerk reaction to the affair; it was a year's delay. How did he treat his first child? How did he treat their mother (while in a relationship and afterwards)? Did he make any effort whatsoever to continue contact? How does he have his 12 year old child's bank details now their in their 20s to continue making payments? There's something word in the background here which you either don't mention or don't know.

In short, I think there's a lot of mistrust nagging at you beyond just the possibly he may cheat on you too.

Is this getting somewhere close to the truth?