Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Culpability of consultants in Letby case

229 replies

curaçao · 20/08/2023 10:40

Why did any of the 7 consultants who suspected Letby nit go to the police themselves? If you had strong suspicions that someone had committed murders, wouldn't you feel you had a strong moral duty to go to the police? OK maybe it was protocol to report it to managers, but surely they had a moral duty to whistleblow and report their suspicions to the police
But they are trying very hard to deflect blame onto managers who wouldn't even have known Letby nor understood the medical stuff

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
anunlikelyseahorse · 20/08/2023 15:27

It's like going round in bloody circles. Don't people actually read other posts? Does it go in? There js only one person to blame and that is the person who killed the kids.

Oh yes Daliesque, I agree only one person murdered. But had the 7 consultants been listen to, then Lucy could have been put on gardening leave whilst an investigation was undertaken, then no more babies would have died. So I'd argue that those who were in a position to stop this do need to be held to account for why they failed to take action, and protect the very weakest members of our society, don't you?

Also following on from your comment "I'm currently on secondment elsewhere but in my substantive role I'm a Clinical Director. I had no training to take up that post. It is only because of the support and experience of my non clinical colleagues that I didn't end up ignoring a patient safety issue myself. The director of nursing at my trust was known to never accept criticism about nursing staff and brushing off complaints. As a fairly new Clinical Director (title is misleading, I am more like the Clinical Lead of a specific unit) she saw me as an ally and hinted that if I didn't support her I would end up having nursing resource lost from my unit. It wasn't an empty threat as she had done that to another colleague. It was only when I mentioned it in passing to a non clinical senior manager that I realised what was happening. Action was taken and I basically pulled up my big girls pants and started doing my job properly.
Can I ask why you applied for a clinical director role with no experience? How did you get the job? I actually think your post goes to show the huge level of hierarchies and managers and directors and executives there are, bloated in fact so bloated nobody seems to know who to turn to or what to do in a crisis, once it's beyond the clinical level, managers managing managers managing managers.
I've worked as an HCP for many many years, as a result I've worked in some fantastic hospitals and some complete flea pits which need a full on pruning out of the deadwood. What I've observed is this, good managers, good clinical and non clinical directors, good executives who all have the patient well-being at heart, who are very proactive, who see HCP as colleagues not underlings, who listen to those at grass roots, who take seriously complaints and look into them
straight away, who badger the strategic health authority and look to implement improved clinical outcomes, who are quick to deal with bullying and call out bad behaviour are quite literally worth their weight in gold. These are the well run hospitals. Sadly they have become fewer and fewer as more people enter these roles for monetary gain, quite often they themselves have been mediocre failed HCPs.
I do think all HCPs should be required to take an aptitude test though, I know in my profession not all universities offer interviews for perspective students, to me this is very very wrong. Worth looking at the case of Colin Norris a Scottish nurse...

misteek · 20/08/2023 15:20

The medical Director was an ex Orthpaedic consultant,and there must have been a director of nursing in there somewhere,

Fluffybunnytiptoes · 20/08/2023 15:15

Zodfa · 20/08/2023 14:12

Good to know if I murder someone at work the police won't bother investigating if my boss thinks I'm too nice a person to have done it. Because that's how it works, apparently.

I'm sure it helps if you're young, blonde, pretty and white.... you'd be amazed what people get away with in the public sector if their face fits and they're in the right club. Or actually, maybe you wouldn't.

Greenvelvetdress · 20/08/2023 15:15

curaçao · 20/08/2023 15:07

They didn't known that and you don't either.I think if they were approached by several consultants on a unit with a,suspicion of murder backed up by the circumstantial evidence ( ie large increase in unexplained deaths and the same nurse on duty every time) they would have had no choice but to havevtaken it seriously .The police would have had no reason to pander to hospital management

'you think' just proves you don't know either... You clearly have very little knowledge of the cases or how these things worse. You're talking about real people who tried to raise the alarm and quite frankly it's disgusting the way you're blaming them.

curaçao · 20/08/2023 15:07

WomblingTree86 · 20/08/2023 14:11

Do you seriously think that the police would have done anything if the management had insisted that they had thoroughly investigated, and that it was merely a case of consultants bullying a nurse? If so, you are deluded.

They didn't known that and you don't either.I think if they were approached by several consultants on a unit with a,suspicion of murder backed up by the circumstantial evidence ( ie large increase in unexplained deaths and the same nurse on duty every time) they would have had no choice but to havevtaken it seriously .The police would have had no reason to pander to hospital management

OP posts:
Fluffybunnytiptoes · 20/08/2023 14:57

Those of you wondering about the NHS senior managers who attempted to shut this case down so many times have evidently not worked in the NHS recently. For every conscientious manager at this level there are at least a dozen who are only in it for the awards ceremonies and the PR opportunities. Freedom to speak up staff are routinely silenced, ostracized, and frozen out and the HR departments supposed to support them are often staffed by utter witches, and incompetent, spiteful, underqualified ones at that.

The north west in particular seems to have made this into a fine art. Not saying it doesn't happen elsewhere but in the north west of England cases seem to happen with alarming regularity.

In this particular case I suspect there is so much more to come out still and I'm very curious about the role of the father in threatening to report the consultants to the GMC as from the evidence so far apit seems to be after he threw a tantrum effectively on behalf of his precious little girl that the managers really stopped doing their job.

benfoldsfivefan · 20/08/2023 14:55

Not mentioned yet on here, but there was a meeting in July 2015 with the head of nursing and some consultants in which suspicions about Letby were raised. This was after three babies had died within two weeks.

raabbgghhrbb123 · 20/08/2023 14:41

Drs tried to raise the alarm by following the correct procedures. They are not at fault. The higher ups are the ones to investigate. Policies and procedures were inadequate.

nocoolnamesleft · 20/08/2023 14:38

The consultants were dismissed, belittled, threatened, bullied, coerced, and gaslit. And still they pushed to try to safeguard the babies. They even told CQC that they were trying to raise safeguarding concerns and being ignored. They're the only ones that come out of this with honour intact.

User8646382 · 20/08/2023 14:34

JanieEyre · 20/08/2023 13:59

I'm no expert, but I would have thought it vital for nurses on these units to be able to intubate quickly if a baby needs it. If a tiny baby isn't breathing, they don't really have the luxury of time to wait for other people to leave what they're doing to supervise.

But doesn’t everyone who is intubated have a metal instrument forced down their throat? And wouldn’t it cause extensive damage to a baby under normal circumstances? Was this particular baby intubated when he/she collapsed? There’s a lot of missing information here that could add some context.

RedToothBrush · 20/08/2023 14:26

Yabu and trolling.

The panorama documentary makes the point that "to their credit despite being threatened" they continued to push and say there was a problem.

If they had gone to the police sooner, without management being on board the chances are they wouldn't have been listened to anyway as they would have shut down the police.

They couldn't do anything until it reached a point that management could no longer deny the problem.

BIossomtoes · 20/08/2023 14:24

Charlieiscool · 20/08/2023 13:59

The doctors feared being reported to the GMC more than they feared further deaths of babies. The management were terrible and cared more about their reputation. Who was the registrar she was loved up with who was called in for emergencies and why is he allowed to be anonymous? Yes she was the murderer but no one comes out of it well.

The doctors knew if they went to the police there would be more “nothing to see here” from the executive team. Personally I think the consultants are the only ones to emerge from this with an ounce of integrity. The guy on Panorama looks utterly broken.

Badbadbunny · 20/08/2023 14:24

HorseyMel · 20/08/2023 14:09

The mantra of the medical profession is to deny and cover up at all costs. Anyone raising concerns is shut down and threatened.

It's a great big club that the patients are not in. When we go into hospital, we end up on the end of a coin flip as to whether we will be helped or harmed.

Nail on the head!

PrincessTigger · 20/08/2023 14:21

I kind of agree … the managers were awful but come on, some things are more important

PollyThePixie · 20/08/2023 14:18

GabriellaMontez · 20/08/2023 10:47

That doesn't explain why they didn't approach the police directly.

I’ve wondered about this also

WomblingTree86 · 20/08/2023 14:17

curaçao · 20/08/2023 10:40

Why did any of the 7 consultants who suspected Letby nit go to the police themselves? If you had strong suspicions that someone had committed murders, wouldn't you feel you had a strong moral duty to go to the police? OK maybe it was protocol to report it to managers, but surely they had a moral duty to whistleblow and report their suspicions to the police
But they are trying very hard to deflect blame onto managers who wouldn't even have known Letby nor understood the medical stuff

At least some of the managers would be clinicians and perfectly able to understand the "medical stuff".

frippu · 20/08/2023 14:16

I think they would have been well aware that, if they did go to the police, the police would immediately speak to management.

So when they did go to the police, is that what the police did? I thought the police didn't initially think she was definitely the culprit @JanieEyre?

Zodfa · 20/08/2023 14:12

Good to know if I murder someone at work the police won't bother investigating if my boss thinks I'm too nice a person to have done it. Because that's how it works, apparently.

WomblingTree86 · 20/08/2023 14:11

Zodfa · 20/08/2023 14:06

Of course the management should take most of the blame here (other than Letby herself of course). But put things in simple terms:

(1) You have reasonable suspicion that multiple people have been unlawfully killed.
(2) Your boss tells you he will sack you if you go to the police about it.

How is going to the police not the morally correct thing to do?

Do you seriously think that the police would have done anything if the management had insisted that they had thoroughly investigated, and that it was merely a case of consultants bullying a nurse? If so, you are deluded.

HorseyMel · 20/08/2023 14:09

The mantra of the medical profession is to deny and cover up at all costs. Anyone raising concerns is shut down and threatened.

It's a great big club that the patients are not in. When we go into hospital, we end up on the end of a coin flip as to whether we will be helped or harmed.

Zodfa · 20/08/2023 14:06

Of course the management should take most of the blame here (other than Letby herself of course). But put things in simple terms:

(1) You have reasonable suspicion that multiple people have been unlawfully killed.
(2) Your boss tells you he will sack you if you go to the police about it.

How is going to the police not the morally correct thing to do?

JanieEyre · 20/08/2023 14:05

Charlieiscool · 20/08/2023 13:59

The doctors feared being reported to the GMC more than they feared further deaths of babies. The management were terrible and cared more about their reputation. Who was the registrar she was loved up with who was called in for emergencies and why is he allowed to be anonymous? Yes she was the murderer but no one comes out of it well.

Why do we need to know the registrar's name? Exactly what difference would it make?

JanieEyre · 20/08/2023 14:04

I don't think the fear of a report to the GMC was the deciding factor that people on here are making out.

I think they would have been well aware that, if they did go to the police, the police would immediately speak to management. Management would have told the police that they were clinicians, they had already looked into it thoroughly and were satisfied that no crime was involved. They might well have thrown around accusations that the consultants were bullying the nurses etc. How confident can anyone be that a busy police force would have continued with the investigation in those circumstances? So for the consultants it would have been the worst of all worlds - no investigation, and they get removed from their posts leaving inexperienced replacements and, in particular, leaving Letby with free reign to carry right on.

It's so easy to pass judgment with hindsight from the comfort of your sofa, but few if any of us have all the relevant facts, let alone the relevant expert knowledge.

JanieEyre · 20/08/2023 13:59

User8646382 · 20/08/2023 13:41

Is it normal for a nurse in a high dependency unit to have the opportunity to force a metal instrument down a baby’s throat? Aren’t there other people around all the time?

I'm no expert, but I would have thought it vital for nurses on these units to be able to intubate quickly if a baby needs it. If a tiny baby isn't breathing, they don't really have the luxury of time to wait for other people to leave what they're doing to supervise.

Charlieiscool · 20/08/2023 13:59

The doctors feared being reported to the GMC more than they feared further deaths of babies. The management were terrible and cared more about their reputation. Who was the registrar she was loved up with who was called in for emergencies and why is he allowed to be anonymous? Yes she was the murderer but no one comes out of it well.