Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Culpability of consultants in Letby case

229 replies

curaçao · 20/08/2023 10:40

Why did any of the 7 consultants who suspected Letby nit go to the police themselves? If you had strong suspicions that someone had committed murders, wouldn't you feel you had a strong moral duty to go to the police? OK maybe it was protocol to report it to managers, but surely they had a moral duty to whistleblow and report their suspicions to the police
But they are trying very hard to deflect blame onto managers who wouldn't even have known Letby nor understood the medical stuff

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
witheringrowan · 21/08/2023 10:09

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/aug/19/trust-me-im-a-nurse-why-wasnt-lucy-letby-stopped-as-months-of-went-by

This article suggests that when they heard she would be returning to the ward in 2017, consultants did go to the police and were taken seriously - that is what started the external investigation.

Less than three months later, after weeks of anguished meetings about how to prevent Letby from returning to work, Brearey and his colleagues contacted Cheshire police.
It was that meeting, on 27 April 2017, that triggered one of the biggest and most complex murder investigations of recent times in Britain.
Brearey’s colleague Jayaram said he “could have punched the air” when the now-retired detective chief superintendent, Nigel Wenham, listened to the consultants and said that their concerns were “something that [the police] have to be involved with”.
Letby had been just six days from returning to work on the neonatal unit at this point. Instead, she never set foot on the ward again. The next time senior doctors would see her was when her picture appeared on the television news, after her arrest more than a year later, in July 2018.

So while I don't think they were really culpable, the idea that the consultants couldn't have raised it in 2015 with the police as it would have just been batted away by senior management doesn't hold up.

‘Trust me, I’m a nurse’: Why wasn’t Lucy Letby stopped as months of murder went by?

It took almost two years for the police to be called in to investigate baby deaths at the Countess of Chester hospital. Now, after Letby’s conviction, a picture of ‘Kafkaesque’ obfuscation is emerging

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/aug/19/trust-me-im-a-nurse-why-wasnt-lucy-letby-stopped-as-months-of-went-by

Wouldyouguess · 21/08/2023 10:05

IAmAnIdiot123 · 20/08/2023 10:52

If you thought someone was actually killing babies, would a threat of a disciplinary really stop you reporting to the police?

If you're blacklisted and can never find a nother job in your profession, and everyone tells you you are wrong, then possibly this is why they started doubting themselves.

Bouledeneige · 21/08/2023 09:59

I have some sympathy with you at least asking the question. All of it needs to be looked at by the inquiry that will follow the trial. I'm sure listening to some of the doctors that they are very personally harrowed and affected by this very question - as we all would be. Could I have done more or acted sooner?

There seem to have been so many factors at play. Firstly that it's very unusual and hard to believe that someone on staff would set out to murder babies, such instances are thankfully extremely rare, and big organisations often struggle with whistle-blowing and safeguarding issues. There are powerful professional hierarchical tensions between the different grades - doctors and nurses - in hospitals, that could engender scapegoating (or bullying) of staff as a smokescreen for wider poor treatment or malpractice by doctors (being too quick to blame others). And clearly in this case that institutional pressure to protect reputation at all costs can override duty of care. Much to ponder. Inevitably the inquiry will recommend sone changes in policy and approach but we also have to recognise that all the processes in the world won't prevent evil people doing evil things.

AIstolemylunch · 21/08/2023 00:04

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 19:09

Even by October 2015, they suspected her.

BBC News:

*But by October 2015, things had changed. Two more babies had died and Letby had been on shift for both of them.

By this point, Dr Brearey had become concerned Letby might be harming babies.*

Yes, and like I said, initially they were concerned about her competence, like both of the main consultants have publicly said.

TizerorFizz · 20/08/2023 23:52

The hospital eventually went to the police.

ohsuzannah · 20/08/2023 23:52

@Salacia great post!

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 20/08/2023 23:32

@AgathaMystery Spot on.

Whatsthepoint1234 · 20/08/2023 23:22

FarmGirl78 · 20/08/2023 22:57

I think if you've not worked in the NHS you can't understand the pressure, the gaslighting and the fear of how things can affect you. They were promised things would be investigated, examined and actioned taken, but these things take time (even the police took 12 months to arrest her). In this instance the senior managers DIDN'T eventually do things they were advised needed doing. I really don't think fault could be found with the consultants who as far as I know WHERE the ones who went to the Police when things promised didn't materialise.

This a million times over.

FarmGirl78 · 20/08/2023 22:57

curaçao · 20/08/2023 10:56

Ah so they put their own self interest before the lives of the babies they were responsible for.Just like the managers did.The consultants are no less to blame than the management

I think if you've not worked in the NHS you can't understand the pressure, the gaslighting and the fear of how things can affect you. They were promised things would be investigated, examined and actioned taken, but these things take time (even the police took 12 months to arrest her). In this instance the senior managers DIDN'T eventually do things they were advised needed doing. I really don't think fault could be found with the consultants who as far as I know WHERE the ones who went to the Police when things promised didn't materialise.

Towdalinenow · 20/08/2023 22:51

@daliesque not lacking!! I meant you DO have self awareness and I commend you for what you shared here. Thank you x

Towdalinenow · 20/08/2023 22:50

@daliesque What you write is the truth. People have no idea until they see it with their own eyes. You are obviously lacking in the self awareness that others are sadly not, so I can imagine you make a great CD.

With poor staff retention, people are being promoted above their competence without the support and supervision to upskill. So it gets worse (at all levels of clinical management).

I hope this shines a light on the systemic problems across the NHS which did not cause- but did not stop - this murder spree. I honestly believe that we would have a much more efficient and effective healthcare system, with better outcomes for patients, if we address these unsaid truths about culture and management.

JanieEyre · 20/08/2023 22:47

frippu · 20/08/2023 14:16

I think they would have been well aware that, if they did go to the police, the police would immediately speak to management.

So when they did go to the police, is that what the police did? I thought the police didn't initially think she was definitely the culprit @JanieEyre?

It was a whole different scenario, because it was senior management who actually asked the police to investigate.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 20/08/2023 22:20

Lucy Letby is a convicted murderer-fact

consultants raised multiple concerns about babies dying, which were dismissed by management several times and threats made with disbarment-fact

that no one who worked with Letby thought she was murdering babies is established. The Consultants weren’t the only professionals there. Numerous professional bodies investigated and did not point to deliberate harm or murder by Letby-in fact they found for her, resulting in consultants being forced to apologise to her for supposed bullying and a witch hunt.

What no one seems to understand or have knowledge of is that the Consultants no longer have the power or influence they used to have. They have been marginalised by management and bureaucracy and are undermined consistently. They remain in constant fear for their professional livelihoods and are no longer even allowed to comment negatively on anyone, including trainees for example; (as discussed above by someone stating the trouble they had for not allowing a student to progress) Whistle blowing and coming against that is close to impossible.

it it easy with hindsight to make assumptions about why no one went to police but would anyone not immediately consider murder rather than a mistake when they had worked with a person for years and to all records considered her a friend?

The whole issue around reporting needs looking out without all of the current work subjects around bullying etc. it is not bullying to suggest that someone is not competent to do the job and supervisor’s should not be pressured to allow someone to continue who should not. There is more that needs looking at here and need addressing.

TizerorFizz · 20/08/2023 21:55

The police investigation took from the initial contact from COCH May 2017 to the trial date in 2022. Clearly a huge amount of investigative work and prep for the trial. It’s very complex. Some posters seem to think it’s easy like a tv show! To succeed in bringing a prosecution there has to be watertight evidence.

curaçao · 20/08/2023 21:22

Missgemini · 20/08/2023 20:03

@Sunnydays41 That’s exactly right. You cannot go to the police.
There is a clear chain of command in terms of how things are supposed to be reported. You report to line manager, who reports to a manager above them, then an investigation is triggered at some point etc.

But yes I agree, people should not be at risk of losing their livelihood if they report a potential crime, but many whistleblowers have gone through hell in recent times! An example is Dr Chris Day. Someone posted a list of others upthread.

It is categorically unlawful to tell employees they cannot go to the police.( I am not saying of course employers might not try to manage people out using other trumped up reasons).But at the end of the day, ghese very vulnerable patients were 100% dependent on the doctors who were responsible fir them, and those doctors put their careers before their lives.

OP posts:
KateReddy · 20/08/2023 20:25

If I know absolutely fuck all about an extremely contentious, controversial and upsetting topic I avoid starting an opinionated thread about it. It’s a
ways stood me in good stead.

Missgemini · 20/08/2023 20:03

@Sunnydays41 That’s exactly right. You cannot go to the police.
There is a clear chain of command in terms of how things are supposed to be reported. You report to line manager, who reports to a manager above them, then an investigation is triggered at some point etc.

But yes I agree, people should not be at risk of losing their livelihood if they report a potential crime, but many whistleblowers have gone through hell in recent times! An example is Dr Chris Day. Someone posted a list of others upthread.

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 20:01

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 19:57

No, but I did used to work in the police.

So, if someone suspects someone of anything illegal, including murder they are not allowed to go to the police?!

Well, there needs to be some serious changes made to procedure when illegality is suspected.

There have been numerous accusations about police forces being corrupt over the years, but perhaps NHS trusts need to be given the same scrutiny.

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 19:57

Missgemini · 20/08/2023 19:49

@Sunnydays41 multiple attempts have been made on this thread to explain why they didn’t call the police. Do you work in the NHS? Or any other organisation that has a similar structure to the NHS?
Unless you saw LL wielding a knife over a baby, you cannot call the police if you have concerns. It is simply not how it works. Management would likely close ranks and refer you to your governing body like the GMC, NMC etc.

No, but I did used to work in the police.

So, if someone suspects someone of anything illegal, including murder they are not allowed to go to the police?!

Well, there needs to be some serious changes made to procedure when illegality is suspected.

Missgemini · 20/08/2023 19:49

@Sunnydays41 multiple attempts have been made on this thread to explain why they didn’t call the police. Do you work in the NHS? Or any other organisation that has a similar structure to the NHS?
Unless you saw LL wielding a knife over a baby, you cannot call the police if you have concerns. It is simply not how it works. Management would likely close ranks and refer you to your governing body like the GMC, NMC etc.

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 19:09

AIstolemylunch · 20/08/2023 18:58

Initially they did, and of course, you would. You wouldn't leap to there is a serial killer nurse. The consultant interviewed on panorama said exactly this, at first we worried about competence.

Even by October 2015, they suspected her.

BBC News:

*But by October 2015, things had changed. Two more babies had died and Letby had been on shift for both of them.

By this point, Dr Brearey had become concerned Letby might be harming babies.*

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 19:06

AIstolemylunch · 20/08/2023 18:58

Initially they did, and of course, you would. You wouldn't leap to there is a serial killer nurse. The consultant interviewed on panorama said exactly this, at first we worried about competence.

Yes, obviously initially they did, but they then did realise. Why else would they request that the police were brought in because "they were all under suspicion" and that the police were the only ones who could look at all factors, including their lives outside of work?

SoShallINever · 20/08/2023 19:04

Hummingbird89 · 20/08/2023 10:49

Because they were threatened with disciplinary action if they went to the police.

Yes, I've had similar said to me as well, I've seen awful racism and homophobia covered up.
NHS managers have a lot more power than the medical consultants do. They will also do anything to cover up data/mistakes/anything that discredits their Trust.
I have a lot more faith in my local constabulary than I do in NHS executives, that's for sure.

FleetwoodMacAttack · 20/08/2023 18:58

curaçao · 20/08/2023 16:35

Are you not aware of the legal protection afforded to whistleblowers.If an employer tells an employee they will be disciplined fir whistleblowing, then they are in breach of the law.

Complete naivety. Far from
that simple.

There needs to be proper, presumably
criminal investigations into those they blew the whistle to.

AIstolemylunch · 20/08/2023 18:58

Sunnydays41 · 20/08/2023 18:49

They didn't just think she was incompetent though...

Initially they did, and of course, you would. You wouldn't leap to there is a serial killer nurse. The consultant interviewed on panorama said exactly this, at first we worried about competence.