Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no point being hungry if the weight isn’t coming off?

514 replies

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 10:07

The doctor has told me to lose weight because I’m at risk of diabetes. I’m absolutely starving but virtually no weight is coming off! I haven’t had a single biscuit or packet of crisps, no takeaways or alcohol at all, I’ve cut right down on carbs, I’ve started walking for an hour a day, and I’ve still only lost 2lb in an entire month.

AIBU to think being hungry is absolutely pointless if I’m not losing weight? Everyone says you lose loads in the first few weeks but I haven’t. I was expecting to have lost half a stone by now. I’m suffering for no reason because the weight isn’t coming off 😭

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
boboshmobo · 20/08/2023 17:39

You need to calorie count and find foods that are low calorie high return that fill you up .
Like veg stir frys etc . Get more protein in you so you aren't hungry .

A slim fast shake with a protein scoop in it works well for me as a meal when I'm busy

I'm only 5 foot an not much over weight but to lose I need to only eat 1000/1200

venusandmars · 20/08/2023 17:39

9 stone sounds quite extreme as a target for someone who is 5ft6. I look gaunt if if get to that kind of weight. Doctors get very little training in nutrition, so it appears like your doc is applying generic pre-diabetic advice to you - when it doesn't seem like that is the right answer for your body.

I agree with the posters who are suggesting that you reduce your carbs. Ultimately they all turn into sugars, and if you are very sensitive to sugar then this is what you might need to address. I understand that toast seems like your only luxury (and are you also gluten intolerent?) but if you develop pre-diabetes and eventually diabetes your food options might be much reduced anyway.

The trick in this is to find other foodstuffs that feel like what you want. There is a great recipe for cheese and almond muffins (will find it and post it at the end). One of these with some cream cheese and smoked salmon (maybe a chopped gherkin) is full of healthy fats and proteins, and only some carbs; or the same muffin spread with peanut butter - extremely filling. Or cut in half and served with scrambled eggs...

Try to get your carbs from veg, rather than wheat/rice/potoatoes. So if you're having curry serve it with spiced spinach and roasted cauliflower florets rather than rice; if you're having chilli serve it with sliced and fried courgette. For lunch try salad with mackerel pate, or sardines, or an avocado with grated cheese and mayonnaise. They all have protein and healthy fats and will help you to feel full.

If you NEED a snack (and like a previous poster I'd agree that the feeling of slight hunger is something that is OK and that we can learn to get used to) then 5 macademia nuts, or 5 cucmber/celery sticks dipped in St Agur creme cheese. Or two mini pepperoni. There is no scientific backing to suggesting those particular numbers, it is more about a plan to control snacking, and listen to your body, so it doesn't decend into something uncontrolled. The reality is that that amount of protein and fat should be enough to satisfy hunger. It doesn't need to fill you up like a meal does.

You can make most of those adjustments while still serving your dh a huge baked potato, oven fries, rice or pasta. And if he wants a bacon sandwich maybe he can make that himself. Or you could have bacon with keto naan?

Cheese and Almond Muffins
(works best if everything is cold before you put it in the oven)
100g ground almonds
30g cold butter (grated into the mix)
3 cold eggs
1 tsp baking powder
60g grated cheese
mixed dried herbs

Mix everything together, put a dollop into a greased muffin tray or muffin cases.
Bake at 180 degrees for 12-15 minutes

Thewallsof · 20/08/2023 17:37

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 15:10

HBA1C was 42.5. I’ve been told to lose at least 7lb, preferably 2st. I’m a little over 11st so that would take me to 9st. They said I’m limited in how much difference I can make by losing weight because I’m hardly even overweight. So I will have to diet very strictly, no biscuits or treats ever again.

I think you need to do some research on insulin resistance and pre diabetes.

Dr's will often use weight as the go to solution for all sorts but especially this. Although there are people who are will overweight and have diabetes. But because other things cost money it's easier to just tell you to lose weight.

Your hba1c isn't that high. Things like exercising and reducing sugar plus increasing protein will help without weightloss. Supliments like inositol and berberine can help too. There's a lot of info about getting your blood sugar more under control in Facebook groups on insulin resistance or advice online.

I know you say you want to be normal, but I think it's a balance. Maybe have toast on a weekend and something more protein based most of the time. I find having stuff which feels like it is supposed to be like it is helps rather than making wild changes. Like a protein yoghurt and protein granola. Rather than egg and veg instead of toast.

Honestly I'd look at the stuff I talk about and not just weight loss.

Scarfweather · 20/08/2023 17:31

Try keto for 3 months and the results will speak for themselves. I had tried everything and this was the only thing to work.
Load up on green veg, peppers, courgettes, tomatoes and cauli too - any suggestion that low carb is unhealthy comes from people who haven’t read or done it properly.
Literally no need to weigh or measure food - aim to be 10g-15g of carbs a day. Lots of water. Try to eat chicken, fish or steak rather than processed meats.
Once you go into keto, you’re simply never ‘hungry’.

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 20/08/2023 17:20

That was meant as a reply for @lljkk sorry.

nameXname · 20/08/2023 17:19

@Lljkk The OP gave the number up-thread. It was borderline diabetic.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 20/08/2023 17:19

OP, I’d say the first thing you need to do is work out how many calories you are eating a day and how many you need to eat to lose weight. An app (like the free version of MyFitnessPal) is probably the way to go.

Your diet doesn’t sound low cal to me -2 slices bread + Philadelphia (depending on amount of Philadelphia) can run to several hundred calories.

The calorie count for soup on the can is for half a can. If you are eating a full can and you have it with bread, that’s another lot of added calories. A sandwich with two pieces of bread plus contents can easily be 500-600 calories (or more depending on the filling).

Chili and curry, depending on ingredients in the sauce - again high in calories.

Sadly, walking doesn’t burn a lot of calories. I’ve started walking and a power walk for 40 minutes burns roughly 100 calories. You should still do it - it’s good for cardiovascular health (so long as you power walk rather than meandering along) but it won’t do much for your weight.

It takes 3,500 calories cut from your diet to lose 1 lb of fat. That means that as you have lost 2 lbs, you must have cut 7,000 calories from your diet over the last month (possibly less if you are burning 100 calories a day walking, which would be 2,800 calories over the month).

If you look at an online calculator, it will tell you how many calories you need to be eating to lose weight.

Once you know this and know your current calorie count, you will know whether you do have an issue with insulin resistance or similar or whether you need to eat fewer calories. At the moment, you may have the worst of both worlds - relatively high calorie food that you don’t particularly enjoy that is still leaving you hungry.

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 20/08/2023 17:18

There is currently a programme in our area that is focusing on diabetes and asking for patients to be assessed for this.

GEC44 · 20/08/2023 17:18

Not RTFT so it might have already been mentioned, but a low carb high protein 'diet' will guarantee weight loss. South Beach or Atkins. I lost 6 stone on the latter and not once did I feel hungry or have to count calories.

lljkk · 20/08/2023 17:13

Is OP in UK?

Does anyone else have a GP who would give them this much attention for a 36" waist & BMI of 25.5 ? How did you get the HAB1C test, OP?

And what were the HAB1C numbers?

Manicpixidreamgirl · 20/08/2023 17:13

Take outs that should say!

Manicpixidreamgirl · 20/08/2023 17:12

@Flaribeau read The Obesity Code by Dr Jason Fung. The Fast 800 is also a good read. As a fellow potential diabetic, following these two are changing, if not saving, my life. It’s hard but I’d rather have good health and a longer life than buttery toast. Fasting and low carb is hard for the first 3-5 days. Then it’s a walk in the park. I don’t miss pizza or my favourite take seats because I’m out of the craving cycle. Good luck to you.

ReginaRegina · 20/08/2023 17:02

But if you are hungry all the time you are either not eating enough or not eating the right foods.

Not sure I agree completely. I've got ADHD and massively crave the dopamine rush of eating sugary stuff. Somebody who's used to eating loads of biscuits may still crave them. I know I did even after a big protein meal. It wasn't connected to the amount I'd eaten.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 20/08/2023 17:00

Oblomov23 · 20/08/2023 16:55

I'm struggling to understand, if it's only 7lb. The GP seems to have scared the OP senseless.

The OP has said she’s 7 lb over the max BMI but the doctor wants her to lose 2 stone total.

XioXio · 20/08/2023 17:00

It's not the amount of weight. It's the position of the weight - largely abdominal which is more unhealthy than an even spread. Plus the increased blood sugar levels.

Regardless of the weight you need to get your blood sugar under control. Eating less carbs / sugars is the way to do this.

You'll either then loose weight, or not. But if you're only 7lb over and your blood sugar is better then perhaps the weight doesn't matter?

ReginaRegina · 20/08/2023 16:58

Dentistlakes · 20/08/2023 14:05

I would suggest starting resistance training alongside a calorie deficit of no more than 500 calories. Ensure you are eating 1g protein per pound of body weight (or your target bw if very overweight). One of the reasons we gain weight as we age is because we lose muscle mass from around 30y if we don’t make a concerted effort to maintain/build it.

I lost around 4.5 stone through a low calorie diet (1200 cal) and running 50+ miles per week. I only lost the last stone when I started lifting weights and now maintain my weight on over 2000 cal and, weight training and no running. Plus my body is a much nicer shape than it was.

This is what I'd do. I've always found it miserable not being able to eat much so I lift instead and eat loads.

At one point I followed the guidelines from The National Strength and Conditioning Association and had 20 cals per lb of bodyweight, which was 2800 cals for me. I didn't get fat but did stop it as I don't want to be too muscley, decided I'd rather try and get stronger at my current weight.

Still eat way over 2k cals though.

PeloMom · 20/08/2023 16:57

Add veggies. Lots of veggies- they’ll keep you feel fuller

Oblomov23 · 20/08/2023 16:55

I'm struggling to understand, if it's only 7lb. The GP seems to have scared the OP senseless.

TheFretfulPorpentine · 20/08/2023 16:50

Think of hunger as a natural physical event, not as 'suffering'. It's normal to feel hungry some of the time, even if you are not dieting. But if you are hungry all the time you are either not eating enough or not eating the right foods.

nurseshiv · 20/08/2023 16:48

I don't think you're being unreasonable to be feeling hungry. Definitely do not follow the advice of others who are suggesting you cut down more carbs or shouldn't eat breakfast. It's about making smart choices.

You need to balance your carbs with fats and bulk out meals with vegetables and protein. So it's not to say you can't have toast, but also have two eggs too, and maybe some avocado. It'll fill you up for longer. You can definitely have more than one potato. Your body needs carbs to function and to use as energy.

You've recently just started exercising an hour a day that you weren't doing before, but you've cut out all your carbs. You need them for energy to burn! You will find if you increase your carbohydrate intake you will probably lose more weight. I know it feels counter productive to do that, but it should work. And you need to be smart about which carbs you are having. So use seeded or granary bread when having toast, pasta is ok for some people (actually number of carbs in white or wholemeal pasta isn't all that different). Potatoes are higher in carbohydrates, but smaller new potatoes are better than say a big 'floury' white potato or Maris piper. Whenever you have carbs have them with fats. Hopefully you'll see an improvement.

Also, make sure you're drinking plenty of water and you are allowed a biscuit, just digestives/rich teas are preferable! Good luck

Hyppogriff · 20/08/2023 16:12

You need to up your healthy fats and protein to fill up and cut down the bread portions

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 16:10

I’m 5ft 6. Healthy weight for me is 11st 2, currently 11st 9. The doctor felt that 7lb wasn’t enough to cause prediabetes, he was immensely puzzled because my tummy is huge (waist 36) even though I’m only a little bit overweight. So he wants me to aim for 9st.

OP posts:
andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 20/08/2023 16:06

By what you have said, it seems that you are about 5'2 if you are 7lbs overweight at 10 stone?
Only thing for it is to cut out the white carbs. Bread and rice and pasta.
It's what I have to do, to stay on the BMI line between normal and overweight even though like you I still cook or make sandwiches with them for DP and DC.
It's hard I know.

Rosscameasdoody · 20/08/2023 16:05

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 15:10

HBA1C was 42.5. I’ve been told to lose at least 7lb, preferably 2st. I’m a little over 11st so that would take me to 9st. They said I’m limited in how much difference I can make by losing weight because I’m hardly even overweight. So I will have to diet very strictly, no biscuits or treats ever again.

If you’re miserable at the thought of controlling your diet to stop you tipping over into type 2 diabetes, maybe you need to know what you what could be facing you should that happen ? Consistently raised levels of blood glucose gradually affect your organs, so you’re at increased risk of heart disease and stroke, kidney failure and problems with eyesight. If you need meds to help control your sugar levels, following a suitable diet becomes even more important to avoid having to increase your meds. You’re also at increased risk of lower limb amputation due to diabetic ulcers - caused by a combination of poor circulation, susceptibility to infection and nerve damage from high blood sugar levels.

A condition called polyneuropathy damages nerves and causes numbness in the feet, and makes injury more likely - even the smallest of traumas can result in an ulcer that either takes a very long time to heal or won’t heal at all. 60% of diabetics develop polyneuropathy leading to a foot ulcer. A relative has been struggling with diabetic ulcers for about eighteen months, as a result of failing to regulate blood sugar levels. He lost the fight, along with his leg about a month ago. Surely it’s better to take steps now to avoid the horrendous effects of type 2 later on.

IamnotSethRogan · 20/08/2023 16:02

Cut out all the carbs. This is especially good when diabetes is an issue. I would say based on the food you're listing you're not cutting down on carbs at all as you state in the OP. Toast with philedephia is not a healthy breakfast by any stretch of the imagination. Try eggs and bacon or lean sam instead. Salad for lunch and meat and veg for dinner.