Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no point being hungry if the weight isn’t coming off?

514 replies

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 10:07

The doctor has told me to lose weight because I’m at risk of diabetes. I’m absolutely starving but virtually no weight is coming off! I haven’t had a single biscuit or packet of crisps, no takeaways or alcohol at all, I’ve cut right down on carbs, I’ve started walking for an hour a day, and I’ve still only lost 2lb in an entire month.

AIBU to think being hungry is absolutely pointless if I’m not losing weight? Everyone says you lose loads in the first few weeks but I haven’t. I was expecting to have lost half a stone by now. I’m suffering for no reason because the weight isn’t coming off 😭

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
PerspiringElizabeth · 21/08/2023 10:54

Ah ok. You’re a coeliac. I have an autoimmune disease too and it’s known to make losing weight much harder.

In September I’m starting the autoimmune protocol (Google it). If I was you OP I’d focus on sorting out and calming your immune system first, rather than losing weight. Research it though - you obviously don’t want to boost your immune system so don’t just go in taking supplements etc willy nilly.

FrogTaped · 21/08/2023 06:57

If I eat bread, my appetite increases. I've lost 6 stone and kept it off, when dieting my average day:

Breakfast, scrambled eggs with veg like mushrooms. No butter or milk, not needed! Or blueberries and Greek yoghurt.
200kcal

Lunch, homemade soup or salad with hummus
300kcal

Dinner - truck load of veg, with fish or chicken. Veg curry, veg chilli, quorn sausages with roasted veg, etc swap potatoes for sweet potatoes
500kcal

snack - apples & nuts
200kcal

Total: 1200 (I'm very short so this was right for me )

I lost 1lb a week. I never felt I was going without. The trick is to fill up on veg!! I eat the same now, but to maintain I add a bit, like few extra nuts, enjoy a meal out, slice of cake over the week it adds up to keep my weight steady and I've never re gained. If I've over indulged one day, I enjoy it and just cut back the next.

I exercise every day too. But when losing weight, never eat back your calories.

You do have to really measure your ingredients and portions.

The hardest thing is mentally not looking at food as a crutch but as fuel. Treats should never be food related. Finding pleasure in non-food things.

I'd suspect you have loads of hidden calories somewhere; what do you drink?

liann34 · 21/08/2023 04:51

Your responses are all very dramatic. Its like you're looking to blame someone. Most people have some health issue or other to manage.

I'm slim at was still prediabetic because of my genetic heritage. I'm also an apple shape so any weight I gain goes to the middle. I accept that because of my fat distribution I need to stay in the lower range of BMI. It makes no sense that you're "terrified" of sugar yet eating multiple slices of bread. You've been given lots of sensible advice on this thread about low carb eating and filling up on vegetables and sensible amounts of fat and protein, which is what people with our genetics need to do for health. Lose the 'can't do' attitude and take it on board. Or don't, and accept the health repercussions. Its your life.

Modifiedovipositor · 20/08/2023 23:52

Are you taking any steroid medications?

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 20/08/2023 22:54

Haven't read whole thread op, sorry! However I have pcos and I'm in danger of type two diabetes and I struggle with sugar highs/lows. The blood sugar diet and fast,800 has been the only way I've lost weight and not felt hungry. First month was hard though. Good luck !

Crikeyalmighty · 20/08/2023 22:49

@Hadenough62 it's interesting you mention water retention- when I first lost half a stone it so in Nov/Dec last year the first place to go was lower legs- it was as if all the water just disappeared. I had ankles again!!

Hadenough62 · 20/08/2023 22:38

Your clearly doing somthing wrong then. Your probably under eating at this point so your body is going to continue storing fat / not get rid of fat because you keep missing meals and your hungry constantly

You need to start eating foods that fill you up. Every single one of your posts your being a martyr and a bit ridiculous to be honest,

Even people who do these fad diets lose weight easily those first few weeks due to water retention,

Your not eating enough and starving yourself is just ridiculous isnt it. Your being ridiculous. If you want to genuinely lose weight lose this no can do attitude, research healthy filling foods and crack on with it

Oblomov23 · 20/08/2023 22:28

I'm drinking wine now. 🍷 My diabetic consultant is happy with my my Hba1c. Wink

hulahooper2 · 20/08/2023 22:07

I am doing slimming world , can highly recommend it , you don’t seem to be eating enough , and at the same time eating a lot of bread

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 22:04

lljkk · 20/08/2023 17:13

Is OP in UK?

Does anyone else have a GP who would give them this much attention for a 36" waist & BMI of 25.5 ? How did you get the HAB1C test, OP?

And what were the HAB1C numbers?

Yes I’m in the UK. I have coeliac disease, which is an autoimmune disease which means I can’t eat gluten. I get monitored annually to see if I’m healthy, including bone scans and blood tests. I haven’t been tested since pre pregnancy, at the time my HBA1C was 34. Now it’s 42.5. I also have some vitamin deficiencies for which I’ve been prescribed supplements.

I’m aware I’ve not been exercising much (I briskly walk the dog an hour a day while pushing the buggy). And I’ve been eating too much chocolate crisps and biscuits (reaching for the easy carbs because I’m tired and stressed). But I didn’t expect to be told I’m pre diabetic. Like you said, I’m BMI 25 and a 36 inch waist, plus I exercise and don’t drink alcohol, so I didn’t think I was at risk. It’s been a horrible unexpected shock.

OP posts:
inloveandmarried · 20/08/2023 21:40

@Flaribeau

''I am only 7lb over a healthy BMI. But the advice to prevent t2 diabetes is to lose weight and cut out treats and alcohol. I don’t drink alcohol so all I can do is stop eating food. They’ve also told me that 7lb won’t make a huge difference, people who reverse diabetes normally lose a few stone. So I should forget about normal BMI and try to lose about 2 stone.''

Just read this.
In your case you are so close to your optimum BMI losing weight won't affect you getting diabetes.

You don't need concentrate on losing weight. It will just start to reduce naturally.

You do need to stabilise your blood sugar.

You can still have keto cakes and sweet treats.

Go onto Pinterest and have a look. Sadly you can't buy keto sweet treats easily but they aren't hard to make at home.

I enjoy very low carb lemon curd spread on sweet keto muffins. Made with almond flour, butter, eggs and sweetener. The bonus is they fill you up for hours.

You can enjoy wine too.

Another thing to add is if you have a meal, especially one containing more than 30g carbs. If you have a brisk 15 min walk it puts your blood sugar back to the level it was before you started to eat. Walking 20 mins after eating is like a super boost to clean your blood.

You can do this!

mumof1or2 · 20/08/2023 21:24

You need to go online and do a TDEE calculator to work out how many calories you need everyday to maintain your current weight. Once you know what your TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) is, minus 500 calories from it and that's how many calories you need to eat everyday to lose weight. You can then factor in treats as long as they fit into your calories allowance. Use MFP or similar to track your calories.

What you are doing right now sounds miserable and you have no idea how many calories you're eating so it doesn't make much sense. I also echo what a pp said about Sean Casey on Insta. He gives loads of good ideas for easy low calories meals.

lljkk · 20/08/2023 21:21

And yes, if your GP suspects type 2 then you will get this much attention

That is terrific. MNers so often say it's impossible to get their GP to take their health issues seriously.

brentwoods · 20/08/2023 21:05

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 11:17

I would try cutting down or cutting out bread for a bit and see how you get on
I’m already incredibly miserable. No biscuits or chocolate or cake. No wine or beer. No takeaways. Bread is literally the only thing I have left. And I’m going to have to suffer like this for the rest of my life. While everyone around me seems to be eating normally and not having these problems.

Everyone keeps pointing out that you're eating a lot of bread and carbs (and the poster who pointed out blood sugar drops causing your faintness or weakness was spot on), but you keep arguing.

Drop the bread and add something back in that gives you joy -- maybe a small glass of wine or a treat occasionally. Your current diet is carb heavy. Focus on protein and it will help with the hunger pangs and keep your blood sugar more even.

inloveandmarried · 20/08/2023 20:46

Didn't mention alcohol. Non sugary alcohol helps lower blood sugar but it's not a recommended method!

inloveandmarried · 20/08/2023 20:44

@Flaribeau

For people with diabetes or risk of diabetes you need to control blood sugar. Doing this solves dieting as you are really not hungry.

Cut down on bread. One slice of lower carb bread a day (warburton plant loaf is 14 carbs a slice). No potatoes, rice, pasta or corn. No sugar or syrups.

Eat whatever you like of above ground vegetables. Eat meat, fish, shellfish, dairy products and eggs. Limit fruit to berries and avocados.

The weight will fall off as your blood sugar stabilises. It takes about a week to stabilise. Your appetite will reduce. Eat to feel comfortable then stop.

I can loose 4-5lbs a week doing this. I currently have a libre2 continuous blood glucose monitor so I can tell when I'm spiking high sugars. Sticking to these eating habits have transformed my blood sugars and quashed my appetite.

Jeevesnotwooster · 20/08/2023 20:07

DP has been told to change his diet, permanently, to manage his diabetes. He has been put on a special low carb diet no ultra processed food (Adelaide diet)by his GP. It's a lifestyle change but I'm mostly following it too we have both lost about a stone in 6 weeks but we had more to lose than you. You might want to ask your GP about it.

I've also been listening to this

It's Chris Van Tulleken talking about weight gain and ultra processed food.

From what you've said it sounds to like the issue isn't the amount you're eating but what you are eating.

What is "Ultra Processed" Food, and Why Does It Lead to Weight Gain?

Ultra-processed foods have become ubiquitous in modern diets. Many of us eat them regularly without understanding their potential impacts on our health. From...

https://youtu.be/uMv2TZUSPdg

FerryPink · 20/08/2023 20:00

FinallyHere · 20/08/2023 19:54

If you feel absolutely starving and are carrying extra weight, something is stopping your body using its reserves of fat.

The culprit is most likely insulin.

Eating carbs raises your blood sugar levels, so your body releases insulin to clear tbe sugar from your blood and store it as glucose and then fat.

It's tricky for your body to balance out the sugar and insulin, so too much insulin is released. Your brain notices the blood sugar dropping and panics, signally your body that it needs more carbs. At the same time, your body cannot access its fat supplies when insulin is circulating.

It's really really difficult to loose weight by burning fat when this is all going on.

One solution is to drastically reduce the starchy carbs you are eating. Expect a few days even weeks when your brain that think of nothing but wasting sugar / starch. This fades after say two weeks. Suddenly you wake us and are not hungry. Your body has found how to burn fat and everything is well.

Drink lots of water. Eat as much meat, fish, dairy and leafy green veg as you want, so you are not hungry. You soon get used to a new kind of hunger. A quiet hey, could eat something now. If you ignore it, nothing much happens. It goes away and comes back a little more insistent.

There is a MN low carb boot camp thread that provides the information you need for success. It's such a very different way of eating healthily that I now, years later, still have to pinch myself that o can eat such delicious foot, no need to feel hungry and slowly, slowly loose all that weight.

The kind of hunger which screams at you, where you get the shakes and feel hungry/angry, where you feel sick and dizzy is not hunger, it's too much insulin in your bloodstream.

Come and try the low carb high fat way of eating.

This makes so much sense to me, I used to get awful hunger pangs/shaked, I have cut carbs down but not entirely and don't get them anymore

In fact I ate a fish salad at lunchtime with just one small cracker and I still don't feel hungry now

I would have had the hunger shakes after a few hours previously.

What I struggle with is finding enough protein based variety. It feels like I have to be more organised

FinallyHere · 20/08/2023 19:54

If you feel absolutely starving and are carrying extra weight, something is stopping your body using its reserves of fat.

The culprit is most likely insulin.

Eating carbs raises your blood sugar levels, so your body releases insulin to clear tbe sugar from your blood and store it as glucose and then fat.

It's tricky for your body to balance out the sugar and insulin, so too much insulin is released. Your brain notices the blood sugar dropping and panics, signally your body that it needs more carbs. At the same time, your body cannot access its fat supplies when insulin is circulating.

It's really really difficult to loose weight by burning fat when this is all going on.

One solution is to drastically reduce the starchy carbs you are eating. Expect a few days even weeks when your brain that think of nothing but wasting sugar / starch. This fades after say two weeks. Suddenly you wake us and are not hungry. Your body has found how to burn fat and everything is well.

Drink lots of water. Eat as much meat, fish, dairy and leafy green veg as you want, so you are not hungry. You soon get used to a new kind of hunger. A quiet hey, could eat something now. If you ignore it, nothing much happens. It goes away and comes back a little more insistent.

There is a MN low carb boot camp thread that provides the information you need for success. It's such a very different way of eating healthily that I now, years later, still have to pinch myself that o can eat such delicious foot, no need to feel hungry and slowly, slowly loose all that weight.

The kind of hunger which screams at you, where you get the shakes and feel hungry/angry, where you feel sick and dizzy is not hunger, it's too much insulin in your bloodstream.

Come and try the low carb high fat way of eating.

Yellowlegobrick · 20/08/2023 19:50

Cut out bread and basically change any starchy carbs for much smaller portions and only have:

  • wholemeal
  • skin on potatoes
  • brown rice

Instead of the starches, you want your meals to mainly comprise:

  • vegetables - roots, leafy greens, legumes
  • pulses - lentils, beans, chickpeas etc
  • salad - peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, beetroot, celery etc
  • protein eg chicken, fish, prawns, turkey

For flavour use herbs, chili, garlic, spices like ginger, turmeric, cumin, balsamic

Rosscameasdoody · 20/08/2023 19:46

Crikeyalmighty · 20/08/2023 17:55

@Flaribeau as I said earlier my HBAC1 was 44 and I got down to 38 in 4 months. But having lost 29 ibs - I'm still just under 14 stone and 5ft 4-- I appreciate that weight loss helps but certainly with me as I'm still quite a bit overweight I think it was the huge carb reduction that helped get that pre diabetes reversed.- I do still eat a decent amount of carb, I eat porridge quite a few times a week for breakfast and I eat a slice of gluten free toast with eggs quite a few days too- I don't however eat cake and no more than 3 or 4 biscuits a week. however I try to keep to under 100 grams of carb every day and I try to stick to 1400 calories most days. After a while it becomes habit. I also followed the technique of walking round briskly for 10 minutes post meals which apparently helps with blood sugar levels.

Yes, exercise after eating stops unused carbs being stored as sugar. There was a chart on one of the diabetes website showing the effects on blood sugar of different types of exercise.

Rosscameasdoody · 20/08/2023 19:42

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 20/08/2023 19:21

It's really not easy!

No, and I think worrying about being pre-diabetic is enough to be going on with.

Rosscameasdoody · 20/08/2023 19:41

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 20/08/2023 19:22

What meds are you on?

My DH was prescribed vitamin D alongside his type 2 meds to reduce insulin resistance. It can also be addressed by fasting, but obviously this would be medically supervised for anyone with type 2.

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 20/08/2023 19:22

4timesthefun · 20/08/2023 10:50

I would be querying insulin resistance. It’s not popular here to suggest that you couldn’t lose weight through calorie restriction and exercise, but that was my experience. I actually had gastro for 7-10 days and held down virtually nothing. My husband suffered similar and lost 15lb. I gained weight. I’m now on medication for insulin resistance and the issues are fixed. I no longer gain weight walking past food; and if I want to lose weight then I can do it it the normal way…. I.e upping the exercise and eating better.

What meds are you on?

Bubbles254 · 20/08/2023 19:21

Oblomov23 · 20/08/2023 16:55

I'm struggling to understand, if it's only 7lb. The GP seems to have scared the OP senseless.

With an HBA1C of 42.5 the OP already has pre diabetes.
https://www.diabetes.org.uk/diabetes-the-basics/types-of-diabetes/type-2/prediabetes
She also has a high waist/hip ratio which means a lot of visceral fat which is very harmful for health. She needs to look at steps to reduce insulin resistance (significantly reducing sugar/starchy cabs) as if not addressed it will develop into diabetes.

Prediabetes

What is prediabetes? Prediabetes means that your blood sugars are higher than usual, but not high enough for you to be diagnosed with type 2 diabetes. It also means that you are at high risk of developing type 2 diabetes. You are unlikely to be experie...

https://www.diabetes.org.uk/diabetes-the-basics/types-of-diabetes/type-2/prediabetes