Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no point being hungry if the weight isn’t coming off?

514 replies

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 10:07

The doctor has told me to lose weight because I’m at risk of diabetes. I’m absolutely starving but virtually no weight is coming off! I haven’t had a single biscuit or packet of crisps, no takeaways or alcohol at all, I’ve cut right down on carbs, I’ve started walking for an hour a day, and I’ve still only lost 2lb in an entire month.

AIBU to think being hungry is absolutely pointless if I’m not losing weight? Everyone says you lose loads in the first few weeks but I haven’t. I was expecting to have lost half a stone by now. I’m suffering for no reason because the weight isn’t coming off 😭

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Prelapsarianhag · 20/08/2023 12:06

Nairns Oatcakes are your friend, especially with peanut butter. Lose the bread - eat oatcakes instead.

crimsonlake · 20/08/2023 12:05

Just keep going, you will get there. Realistically I agree you are eating too much bread, basically you are eating over a whole loaf a week, it all mounts up.

SunRainStorm · 20/08/2023 12:04

Four slices of white bread is a lot if you're dieting.

Could you try an 'open' sandwich (one slice with toppings on it) or a 'naked' one (no bread just fillings)?

I think you'd be better off adding mushrooms, tomatoes and spinach to your eggs in the morning rather than white bread. It would keep you full longer.

Maybe have the foods you enjoy once or twice a week and be focused on protein and veggies the rest of the week. Then you'll feel full and not so deprived.

There's no point comparing what you're eating to what other people 'get' to eat. You have your own body to take care of.

Walking is really good for you, but not effective for weight loss. You burn very few calories on a walk. One hour a day won't do much for your weight, but it's probably great for your mood, your back, your eyes etc so keep doing it.

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 12:04

I personally would calorie count because that means you don’t have to go without chocolate etc as you can include it in your diet.
I am terrified of sugar now so I won’t eat chocolate. Even a spoonful of plain rice is giving me a panic attack because I’m scared of developing diabetes.

OP posts:
viques · 20/08/2023 12:01

Flaribeau · 20/08/2023 10:53

I should have lost at least 4lb in a month, just by doing a normal level of dieting. I’m literally starving so I expected to lose more. Absolutely gutted to discover that I only lost 2lb.

Where were you last weighed? If it was at the GP using their very accurate scales there could be a mismatch between that and your home scales. So it is possible that you have actually lost more, but your scales aren’t accurate.

egowise · 20/08/2023 12:01

Galiana · 20/08/2023 11:56

I've always been 'naturally slim', it's always confused me a bit because I've always eaten exactly what I want, I really enjoy food.

However what I've realised is that I naturally eat a low carb, high fat, very little sugar and very few processed food diet.

I would say four pieces of bread a day is quite a lot! I probably eat four pieces of bread a week. It's always quality bread too.

I eat pasta or rice one a fortnight probably.

This is also not a 'normal' diet. It's low carb.

Barnabyted · 20/08/2023 12:01

I can sympathise as I struggle to lose weight. People assume that if you are overweight it’s because you eat chocolate, biscuits, crisps, cake, full fat milk, have regular takeaways, etc, and that isn’t always the case.

A few years ago, I lost a lot of weight, as I caloried counted my food and tried to keep below 1200 calories. Plus I was doing 6 - 8 Spin classes per week, walking the dog for an hour a day, Pilates twice a week and a gym session or two. The weight gradually dropped off, but it was slow and only a pound or two a week and it took 18 months to get to a size I was happy with.

Good luck with trying to lose weight. I don’t know what the answer is, but maybe keep a food diary and in a few months go back and see your GP.

Galiana · 20/08/2023 12:01

I don't want to be the UPF dick @Flaribeau, but you seem to be eating a lot of processed food.

What bread is your toast made from.

Tinned soup.

Curry for dinner, I'm going to guess (given what else you eat) that you use a jared sauce?

That's UPF for every meal.

UCinfo · 20/08/2023 12:01

KinellMate · 20/08/2023 10:57

That's too much bread per day.

Definitely. '4 slices a day' and 'on a 'diet' shouldn't be in the same sentence.
Good luck OP - it's really tough x

Genevieve29 · 20/08/2023 12:00

At the beginning of the year, I was diagnosed pre-diabetic. Scary thought! I have been on every diet ever heard of, I reckon, in the past. Nothing seemed to be working for me now I'm older. I decided to give Intermittent Fasting a go, downloaded an app called Bodyfast, (the free version, no need to pay for a "coach" which is actually just an algorithm) and read up on what to do and what NOT to. So I decided to do 16:8 to start with. That means fasting for 16 hours and then being able to eat in my 8-hour window. Nothing happened! So then I started tracking calories too (people doing IF will say it's not necessary, but it worked for me). It took me 5 weeks to see any difference on the scale BUT, my BP came down a huge amount, my blood sugars were back in mid-normal range and my IBS is loads better. After the first 5 weeks, my weight came down bit by bit. No magic loss, but enough to keep my bloods normal. I've plateaued a few times in the 6 months I've now been doing it, but carried on regardless. I was/am not doing it for the weight alone, although I am pleased that I have now dropped a couple of dress sizes. The benefit of calorie-counting alongside IF, for me, was that I could still have wine and occasionally, chocolate or biscuits, I just counted them into my daily calories so it was up to me if I "wasted " my daily allowance (I don't think wine etc IS a waste, lol). I changed my routine to 18:6 once I got used to fasting for 16 hours, so now I fast from about 7 at night till 1 o'clock (lunch time) the next day.
Eating protein before fasting is a good way not to get too hungry (it takes your body longer to digest). I eat a normal meal every evening with the family - last night we had take-away fish'n'chips and wine, but I wouldn't recommend that every day, lol.

I realise everyone is different, but for me, the benefits of IF are the improvement in my general health ( I "feel" better, even though before I never felt ill) and the fact that it is so flexible. Going out to dinner? Just alter my hours that day so that my "eating window" stays open. We went away last week to a hotel where we were on B&B - so I ate breakfast every day (just not a fry-up every morning - had that twice in the week!) ate a light lunch (with gin or wine, lol) and went out-out to eat/drink every night. Basically, I abandoned IF for the week. I put on 4lbs, which was pretty good, considering alcohol featured daily, and that I'm a sucker for an ice-cream!
Tested my glucose again when we got back - still all OK, so now I'm back to shedding those 4 lbs, to start with.

You don't need to make yourself miserable, to do this. Experiment with IF to find a pattern which works for you. There's a Facebook page called "Intermittent Fasting with the Bodyfast App". You can get some good ideas from there, but ignore the zealots that tell you you're "not doing it right". If it's working for you....
Good luck! I hope you find the right solution for you x

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 20/08/2023 12:00

Hi. First time poster so please be gentle with me :)

I hate being hungry OP! That sounds really miserable.

From what I've read, there's another way of reducing insulin resistance by cutting out the fat which blocks the insulin receptors - thus increasing insulin sensitivity. Then you can eat the fruit and starchy foods without spiking . My mum did it - she was eating so much and couldn't believe she would lose weight but she did and her doctor was so impressed. She was able to come off her meds.

I've linked a clip to Dr Neal Barnard on the Forks over Knives website. If you go to the home page there's a film of the same name which includes quite a bit on diabetes and diet.

Good luck and I hope this helps! :)

Webinar: What Causes Type 2 Diabetes (It's Not Sugar!) and How to Reverse It, With Neal Barnard, MD, FACC - Forks Over Knives

Webinar: What Causes Type 2 Diabetes (It's Not Sugar!) and How to Reverse It With Neal Barnard, MD, FACC

In this webinar, best-selling author Neal Barnard, MD, presents proven, drug-free strategies for preventing and reversing Type 2 diabetes. Watch the webinar now for free!

https://www.forksoverknives.com/webinar/webinar-what-causes-type-2-diabetes-its-not-sugar-and-how-to-reverse-it-with-neal-barnard-md-facc/

Milkkbottles · 20/08/2023 11:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Flickersy · 20/08/2023 11:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Yes I know it is. The poster I replied to seemed to think she only had one tablespoon of rice for dinner full stop.

TheAOEAztec · 20/08/2023 11:58

About the slices. Op said it's gluten free bread. They are usually tiny bastards

Milkkbottles · 20/08/2023 11:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

MzHz · 20/08/2023 11:57

How old are you? If you’re late 40s onwards the way our body responds to diets is different

look at the things that drive your blood sugar up. Limit that and you may find some improvement

Flickersy · 20/08/2023 11:57

ShyTed · 20/08/2023 11:52

That’s not very much food - any wonder you’re starving! You should never feel like that. Why are you only eating one tablespoon of rice for your dinner?

I would definitely advise you go online to James smith calculator and input your details and it will tell you your calorie goals. Download my fitness pal or nutracheck and try tracking your calories for a while.

Starving yourself is not the way to go. You should never feel starving. It needs to be healthy and sustainable.

She's not only eating one tablespoon of rice for dinner.

She's eating a tablespoon of rice + vegetables + chicken curry.

Galiana · 20/08/2023 11:56

I've always been 'naturally slim', it's always confused me a bit because I've always eaten exactly what I want, I really enjoy food.

However what I've realised is that I naturally eat a low carb, high fat, very little sugar and very few processed food diet.

I would say four pieces of bread a day is quite a lot! I probably eat four pieces of bread a week. It's always quality bread too.

I eat pasta or rice one a fortnight probably.

katepilar · 20/08/2023 11:56

You cant loose weight if you are starving.
And you need to be eating some fat to make the body learn to burn fat.

CyberCritical · 20/08/2023 11:56

Andbreathe20 · 20/08/2023 11:46

Two pounds per month is fine! We have all been fed the lie that weight loss will be ‘one to two pounds per week’. It won’t be. Some weeks it’s half a pound, some weeks it’s nothing and some weeks you may randomly drop over a pound. It absolutely won’t be linear. I lost 20 kilos a three years ago at 42. I was working out 4 times a week and eating only 1400 calories a day. It took 7 months. I have hypothyroidism so when I need to lose weight my calories are very low. Just keep going and I promise you the weight will come off. Good luck!

This too, losing weight is a Loooooooooong game, you need to just keep going.

Having said that my previous post stands, the method you choose needs to be sustainable, so plenty of water, a reasonable calorie allowance based on your TDEE, a mix of good wholesome foods. Don't starve yourself, don't go extreme with exercise. You need something you know you can do consistently for months without feeling completely deprived and miserable.

Weight will go up and down, sometimes you'll lose nothing even though you've been 'good', sometimes you'll lose loads. This is a graph from a couple of years ago when I weighed myself daily to see the trends. You'll notice there are days when my weight goes up by 2 or 3 lbs overnight which is obviously crap I didn't actually create or lose 3lbs of fat overnight but weight just naturally fluctuates due to hormones, sleep, water retention, heat, dehydration...........

The important thing is the overall trend.

To think there’s no point being hungry if the weight isn’t coming off?
Kizzy192 · 20/08/2023 11:55

Have you had your thyroid tested?

Mygosh · 20/08/2023 11:55

Well done for having the motivation to try, and for losing some weight. I have exactly the same problem as you, but I have hypothyroidism. Have you had blood tests to rule out a medical cause for your weight?

Are you able to install a food diary on your phone? I have MyNetDiary, it's free. I started to weigh my food and was amazed at how many calories are in various foods. And also that a portion of, pasta for example, was half what I had been eating! My daily goal is between 1200-1500 calories and I have lost 8kg in 3 months. Have a look online for high satiety foods, such as boiled potatoes, foods that are filling and satisfy hunger.

Didimum · 20/08/2023 11:55

The dieting mentality is a skewed one, so I’m not coming here to tell you you’re eating too much x, y or z or that you should be calorie counting or whatever - but you’re relationship with food is unhealthy and your mentality towards food is making this journey more painful and unhappy than it needs to be.

I know it’s in jest not talking about topping yourself if you cut down on bread and bring miserable for life on certain kinds of foods is really concerning.

Eating should be a balance of nutrition, satiety and pleasure and the balance will naturally tip meal to meal, day to day and week to week. Calorie counting can be a useful training tool at the beginning to learn what you’re actually consuming and at what calorie intake your body will lose weight - it doesn’t have to be lifelong. At the end of the day, only a calorie deficit will see you lose weight, unless you are muscle building alongside.

Foods with more water content and with less calorie density are more satiating - they will keep you fuller for longer. So vegetables, fruits, soups, oats, whole grains, egg whites, low fat dairy, etc. So asparagus (at the same weight as the bread) and egg will keep you more satiated for longer than the toast. You balance these with more calorie dense foods, because of course eating should be pleasurable, as long as the balance is right.

There’s tons of food psychology material out there to read to discover and change your relationship with food. It doesn’t have to be miserable, but it’s certainly not going to be easy as you have built up your food habits and relationships over decades.

You could try something like Noom, which operates by the above principles.

TheAOEAztec · 20/08/2023 11:54

stayathomer · 20/08/2023 11:49

Ps he heard the day off is so important in the same way it is for excercise but I can’t remember the theory of it! Best of luck op, I’m in awe of people who do this xxxxx

It's for mental break mainly. I had 1 day off a week. Because you know it's every week it's easier not to go crazy and really just have bit of x not x, y and z, because you can simply have y next week. The better you feel overall with better eating etc+ knowing it's not just one chance a year, the less likely you are to absolutely overeat on that day and are still mindful but not counting. That's how it worked for me. Plus, it's not just about weightloss but building habits to keep the weight off so it's a good training.

POmonstermunch · 20/08/2023 11:54

I’ve lost 8 stone and kept it off for 1.5 years. Sadly carbs are the issue for me. I have a protein shake for breakfast, high protein lunch (ham salad/cheese salad on ryvita) with protein yogurt for pud and then a smaller (than I used to have) portion of what the family are having for dinner. So spag Bol, risotto, etc

if I’m snackish I have fruit/veg first, then maybe something protein based (chicken fridge raiders/almond protein ball)

haven’t eaten or missed bread in all this time. Weight loss has been consistent and I have the occasional vino/dessert.