Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect dp to pay half the nursery fees

139 replies

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:03

I haven’t spoken with him about it yet, it’s not that I think he will say no, as he’s not the type to say it’s just up to me but I was telling a friend my plan and she said I shouldn’t ask him for half the fees.

so I want to know if I’m being a knob expecting it of him before I say something!

he works full time, out the house 12 hours a day, often weekends also. I work evenings and and a full day at a weekend, so he gets 2 days in 14 off, I get 2 days a week off. We do a sort of he walks in from work, I walk out, to avoid the child care fees. He gets paid about 4 times what I do if that’s relevant. He does pay for the rent, and half the bills. I do the other half of bills.
he definitely doesn’t shy away from paying for things if the kids need it, he always gets it and also a very good hands on dad, when he’s home he takes over with the kids and does jobs around the house, we both do our share I think and this works.

so, we have a 2.5 year old. I want her to go to nursery. A couple days a week 9-3 so fits in with school run for my older dc. I’m not at work during that time, but obviously I do have things to do at home, food shopping that’s awkward with a toddler, and errands to run that my dp doesn’t have time for. Also, she’s at the age where normally it’s good for them to go to nursery. Up until now she’s been home with me. Weekends my eldest looks after her if both me and dp work, which she doesn’t mind but obviously during the week she’s at college.

now, I’d like her to go 2 days, so I can have those 2 days to get the house done, have time to shower ready for work in the evening in peace! and just get things done without a strong willed toddler about.
I know my dp won’t begrudge me of this, he will want me to have a couple days sort of “to myself” and wouldn’t even care if I spent the day being lazy, but, I want him to pay half the bill. I guess it does mostly benefit me her going to nursery, but I feel a bit burnt out at the moment and just never stop with the toddler, school runs, house, errands then going to work myself till 11pm , I do this 4 nights a week plus a 12-11pm shift on a weekend. I’m exhausted.

happy to be told I’m unreasonable and I’ll just pay the bill myself, but what do you think?

OP posts:
OakAshElm · 20/08/2023 09:00

If I'm reading this right. Most of your "time off" is currently spent in sole charge of your children and running the house (IE. A full time job).
His time off is in the evening whilst you are at work meaning he truly gets time to himself as presumably the kids are in bed.

It sounds like you both work really hard but you are completely justified in pushing to get some child-free time off for yourself and yes, he should pay half as it will ultimately benefit the whole family.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:57

applesandmares · 20/08/2023 08:54

@Hellosausag I get that, but if it was me and my partner came to me with this I'd say you up your hours and I'll drop mine so we both have one day off child free in the week. However, I do pretty much everything round the house anyway, whereas I assume your partner would rather work than have a day off where he was expected to run errands/cook/clean 😂

his job requires him to work the hours that he does, and also pays better than mine so wouldn’t be financially viable for me to work more and him less, but yes, if you asked him, he would say I have the harder job being at home with a toddler and doing everything around the house lol, he always says “how the hell do you do this every day I’m going to work for a break” 🤣

OP posts:
WtfHormones · 20/08/2023 08:57

All family bills should be split according to your earnings. The set up you gave now might not even be fair since he's earning so much more than you. Remember you are earning less than him because you work less than him because you are caring for your child and home. So if course he should be paying more, he's. He's doing you a favour by paying for the mortgage.

Wellhellother · 20/08/2023 08:54

I think you are being very unreasonable. He works 12 hours a day, 6 days a week, and yet you think he should pay for you to have have more down time?! I agree that childcare should be a joint expense when it is needed (because both parents are at work) but not because one has decided they want more time to themselves. If anyone should be getting a break, I think it should be your partner - maybe he can use the money saved to cut down his hours slightly

applesandmares · 20/08/2023 08:54

@Hellosausag I get that, but if it was me and my partner came to me with this I'd say you up your hours and I'll drop mine so we both have one day off child free in the week. However, I do pretty much everything round the house anyway, whereas I assume your partner would rather work than have a day off where he was expected to run errands/cook/clean 😂

TicTac80 · 20/08/2023 08:52

YANBU. It's a good idea. It'll help you out, and that's important. It will also be a nice change for your little one to go to nursery and have new experiences there. My two DC loved their nursery (I had to send them to nursery as I was working those hours) - they had lots of fun things to do and learn about, lovely staff, chance to play with lots of children their own age etc. They really thrived, and they still look back to their time at that nursery with fond memories. You guys sound like you have a lovely set up.

FWIW, I work FT (compressed into a four day week) but have a day off in the week. I could put my youngest in wraparound care and go to work, but that day off in the week is my time to get things organised in the house, catch up with admin, etc. It does help a lot (and my DC are 16 and 9!).

Dotcheck · 20/08/2023 08:52

applesandmares · 20/08/2023 08:35

Hmm I totally agree that childcare costs should be split in whichever way is fair although this isn't a necessary childcare cost as you're home, this is a "I want two days off child free" situation, while he is working 12 hours a day 6 days a week. I don't think I'd be happy if my partner asked me for that while I was working flat out, but if he's happy with it then there's no harm done!

However…

OP is essentially looking after children or working from first thing in the morning until 11 at night for 4 days a week. No down time. That’s pretty exhausting.
If they can afford nursery fees, why not use it to get on top of everything else?

saraclara · 20/08/2023 08:52

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:29

He pays all the rent and council tax and food. I pay half of the other bills. Just how we have always done it. Like I said he isn’t stingy and pays for anything the kids or I need. I don’t have to ask really, he will happily pay for the kids clothes and trips and holidays and pocket money for them and he pays for the car that only I use, he has a work car so doesn’t have to pay for that, he pays for anything unexpected. Also, we only share the toddler, I also have children from previous relationship that are with us half the time and he pays for anything they need also. I don’t need childcare for them though as Old enough to look after themselves these days and go to their dads half the week

Wow. He's astonishingly generous then. He pays all the rent, council tax, food, your car, and everything for not just his kids, but your kids by someone else too?

It seems that all that's left for you to pay is half the utilities bills.

So I've completely changed my mind. If you're putting the children into nursery to give yourself time at home without them (so no benefit to, or obligation for your partner) then I'd consider stepping up for once and paying for your free time.

Maybe your friend sees you as taking him for granted. MN would be all over this if the sexes were reversed, and the word cocklodger would be all over the place.

MariaVT65 · 20/08/2023 08:43

Yes he pays half.

I have a day off in the week while my son is at nursery. My DH is at work but I don’t just sit on my arse all day, I use it to run errands and help the household. It’s never been questioned that we pay half each. Plus my DS would be bored shitless if he spent a day with me like that. He loves nursery.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:42

wyrm0 · 20/08/2023 08:40

At 2.5 years old?

Think she means when toddler is 3. But it’s the term after that so will be April in my case.

OP posts:
Peony654 · 20/08/2023 08:41

of course he pays half. But bigger problem - if you’re not married and have shared kids and he earns a lot more than you, you are in a seriously financially risky situation. If you split you could be in a bad financial situation as you have no legal entitlement whilst not married. I’d insist on all income in a joint account with equal access. He should pay much more than half the fees if he earns 4x more.

wyrm0 · 20/08/2023 08:40

AnnieKayTee · 20/08/2023 08:19

Everyone gets 15 hours regardless. You may be entitled to 30 but you would have to check eligibility.

At 2.5 years old?

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 20/08/2023 08:39

If the child is half his then he pays half of what the child costs whether it's nursery fees, school trips, school uniform or shoes. So unless there's a backstory of you having a one night stand or something then your friend is very wrong.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:38

applesandmares · 20/08/2023 08:35

Hmm I totally agree that childcare costs should be split in whichever way is fair although this isn't a necessary childcare cost as you're home, this is a "I want two days off child free" situation, while he is working 12 hours a day 6 days a week. I don't think I'd be happy if my partner asked me for that while I was working flat out, but if he's happy with it then there's no harm done!

But I could argue that when partner gets home and gets toddler to bed he basically is child free from 7pm where as I’m working till 11pm and have the toddler all day. Also when he gets home i have done most around the house he only needs to pick up a bit really and have a quick hoover around before sitting down for the evening, which he does deserve to do of course.

OP posts:
applesandmares · 20/08/2023 08:35

Hmm I totally agree that childcare costs should be split in whichever way is fair although this isn't a necessary childcare cost as you're home, this is a "I want two days off child free" situation, while he is working 12 hours a day 6 days a week. I don't think I'd be happy if my partner asked me for that while I was working flat out, but if he's happy with it then there's no harm done!

StillMissV · 20/08/2023 08:32

I don't understand your friend. Once you share a home etc and share kids then surely everything becomes sort of joint? I earn less than my husband, partly because my career has been slowed down by two lots of mat leave as well as being so tired that just keeping my head above water was enough, I have not had the energy. I did those things for our kids, for us as a family. Id think it was pretty shitty if he was saving a great chunk of his earnings every month and I was scraping by. Everything we do is for the family as a whole; that means jd we want to make a bigger purchase for ourselves as individuals we run it past each other and it's not "your money" or "my money", it's just "the money".

Nursery will benefit your child socially, id split it proportionally to your incomes if you have separate finances

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:29

Todaywego · 20/08/2023 08:22

When a couple are committed to each other, when they have a child together of course they share costs. At least equally, although I'll be honest, I can't really understand why you'd be going halves on bills etc when one person earns 4x what the other does.

He pays all the rent and council tax and food. I pay half of the other bills. Just how we have always done it. Like I said he isn’t stingy and pays for anything the kids or I need. I don’t have to ask really, he will happily pay for the kids clothes and trips and holidays and pocket money for them and he pays for the car that only I use, he has a work car so doesn’t have to pay for that, he pays for anything unexpected. Also, we only share the toddler, I also have children from previous relationship that are with us half the time and he pays for anything they need also. I don’t need childcare for them though as Old enough to look after themselves these days and go to their dads half the week

OP posts:
Mumsanetta · 20/08/2023 08:28

Your friend is jealous.

DisquietintheRanks · 20/08/2023 08:28

Todaywego · 20/08/2023 08:22

When a couple are committed to each other, when they have a child together of course they share costs. At least equally, although I'll be honest, I can't really understand why you'd be going halves on bills etc when one person earns 4x what the other does.

Did you miss the bit where he covers all the rent? I imagine he and the OP have arranged finances so everything is covered and it feels fair.

Clymene · 20/08/2023 08:27

Your friend is a fool.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:25

FiftyPenceWorth · 20/08/2023 08:21

Why on earth does your friend think you shouldn't discuss this with your partner? If he's as reasonable as you make him sound, you'll come to a reasonable agreement.

Which - in my opinion - should include setting up a shared account for family costs so you don't need to go cap in hand asking for anything to do with your shared children.

She said because I’m at home anyway I should really just look after toddler myself. But yeah I do think he will be fine about it, sometimes he is almost too reasonable that I think I’m taking the piss! I’m glad I posted now, I’m going to mention it later today. As a poster pointed out, this would only be till April then she gets free hours when she’s 3.

OP posts:
Sleepygrumpyandnothappy · 20/08/2023 08:25

Of course he pays half. She’s his child. He pays half the cost of her being looked after.

Todaywego · 20/08/2023 08:22

When a couple are committed to each other, when they have a child together of course they share costs. At least equally, although I'll be honest, I can't really understand why you'd be going halves on bills etc when one person earns 4x what the other does.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:21

User63847484848 · 20/08/2023 08:17

can you change you days so that you don’t work a weekend so aren’t asking your Dc to mind your younger one, whilst you get 2 days in the week when she’s at nursery and you’re at home? You could also get some jobs done on the weekend, and maybe your eldest could mind her for a short time whilst you go to the supermarket or something?

I think that would be fairer on your older Dc who must have college work, or socialising or might want to get a job themselves.

Unfortunately my job requires I work one day at the weekend. I can’t just do weekday evenings, also I get paid more for that shift at the weekend as it’s a longer shift and a higher rate. My eldest doesn’t mind doing this, it’s not every weekend as dp has every other weekend off, so it’s 2 weekend days a month my eldest looks after her. She doesn’t mind as she is wanting to actually work in a nursery after college so wants the experience.

OP posts:
FiftyPenceWorth · 20/08/2023 08:21

Why on earth does your friend think you shouldn't discuss this with your partner? If he's as reasonable as you make him sound, you'll come to a reasonable agreement.

Which - in my opinion - should include setting up a shared account for family costs so you don't need to go cap in hand asking for anything to do with your shared children.