Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect dp to pay half the nursery fees

139 replies

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:03

I haven’t spoken with him about it yet, it’s not that I think he will say no, as he’s not the type to say it’s just up to me but I was telling a friend my plan and she said I shouldn’t ask him for half the fees.

so I want to know if I’m being a knob expecting it of him before I say something!

he works full time, out the house 12 hours a day, often weekends also. I work evenings and and a full day at a weekend, so he gets 2 days in 14 off, I get 2 days a week off. We do a sort of he walks in from work, I walk out, to avoid the child care fees. He gets paid about 4 times what I do if that’s relevant. He does pay for the rent, and half the bills. I do the other half of bills.
he definitely doesn’t shy away from paying for things if the kids need it, he always gets it and also a very good hands on dad, when he’s home he takes over with the kids and does jobs around the house, we both do our share I think and this works.

so, we have a 2.5 year old. I want her to go to nursery. A couple days a week 9-3 so fits in with school run for my older dc. I’m not at work during that time, but obviously I do have things to do at home, food shopping that’s awkward with a toddler, and errands to run that my dp doesn’t have time for. Also, she’s at the age where normally it’s good for them to go to nursery. Up until now she’s been home with me. Weekends my eldest looks after her if both me and dp work, which she doesn’t mind but obviously during the week she’s at college.

now, I’d like her to go 2 days, so I can have those 2 days to get the house done, have time to shower ready for work in the evening in peace! and just get things done without a strong willed toddler about.
I know my dp won’t begrudge me of this, he will want me to have a couple days sort of “to myself” and wouldn’t even care if I spent the day being lazy, but, I want him to pay half the bill. I guess it does mostly benefit me her going to nursery, but I feel a bit burnt out at the moment and just never stop with the toddler, school runs, house, errands then going to work myself till 11pm , I do this 4 nights a week plus a 12-11pm shift on a weekend. I’m exhausted.

happy to be told I’m unreasonable and I’ll just pay the bill myself, but what do you think?

OP posts:
Pineapples198 · 20/08/2023 10:03

Instead of saying you want your child to go to nursery so you can have a break, sit down with DP and discuss how the child is getting older and you would like to consider nursery a couple of days a week, for socialisation and education and time to do the housework. Give him the costs and ask what he thinks. Ask if you should split the bill 50/50. She will get 15 or 30 free hours the term after she turns 3 anyway.

also instead of this “he pays the rent and I pay the bills stuff” why don’t you have a joint account where all your wages go and all bills come out of. Set up a direct debit from this to your personal accounts of an agreed amount each for “fun stuff” like clothes, cinema and treats. This way all bills are covered from the joint pot and no one is left feeling out of pocket. Your choice of course but I’ve had friends have to ask their partners for money to cover grocery shopping and it feels a bit unfair

saraclara · 20/08/2023 10:02

Doteycat · 20/08/2023 09:59

No, he married her knowing she had kids already. He should pay as he earns a lot more.

Swap the sexes round in your post. You'd be calling a man who expected his new partner to pay for his children by another woman, a cocklodger. Even if she was the higher earner.

GrazingSheep · 20/08/2023 10:01

Where does she say they are married?

Doteycat · 20/08/2023 09:59

GrazingSheep · 20/08/2023 09:52

so of course he should pay half.

He already pays for everything for the op’s older children who are not his. Should she not be paying half of their costs? If not all of them??

No, he married her knowing she had kids already. He should pay as he earns a lot more.

GrazingSheep · 20/08/2023 09:56

Definitely split, like you do for all bills.

They don’t split all bills. He is paying for almost everything already.

bridgetreilly · 20/08/2023 09:55

What benefits you will benefit the whole family, including him. Definitely split, like you do for all bills. No one calculates who benefits most from a TV license or running water.

GrazingSheep · 20/08/2023 09:52

so of course he should pay half.

He already pays for everything for the op’s older children who are not his. Should she not be paying half of their costs? If not all of them??

caringcarer · 20/08/2023 09:44

Your friend is being stupid. Just ignore her. The child is half yours half your partner's so of course he should pay half.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 09:41

GrazingSheep · 20/08/2023 09:37

How much do you actually spend on your share of the bills?

so it works out that we have the same amount of disposable income left at the end of the month, for ourselves. That’s how we have done it. He is generous, and he treats my kids that are not his financially like his own, which I’m grateful for. But at the same time, I do look after the house, run all errands and look after our toddler all day, so he can go up in his career. He even says himself he couldn’t do what he does with work if it wasn’t for me being at home during the day.

OP posts:
GrazingSheep · 20/08/2023 09:37

How much do you actually spend on your share of the bills?

Aprilx · 20/08/2023 09:35

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 09:09

It’s not really so I can have child free time. It’s so I can get more done at home and do errands without the toddler. So yes would be easier for me, but also beneficial to our daughter I feel

And I was responding to another poster that suggested you should ramp up monthly expense by £1000 on, what is desirable but definitely non essential, expenses without so much as a discussion.

ActDottie · 20/08/2023 09:35

Ofc he pays half!!!

Your friend who suggested it was wrong is just ridiculous!

saraclara · 20/08/2023 09:34

He pays all the rent and council tax and food. I pay half of the other bills. Just how we have always done it. Like I said he isn’t stingy and pays for anything the kids or I need. I don’t have to ask really, he will happily pay for the kids clothes and trips and holidays and pocket money for them and he pays for the car that only I use, he has a work car so doesn’t have to pay for that, he pays for anything unexpected. Also, we only share the toddler, I also have children from previous relationship that are with us half the time and he pays for anything they need also.

The majority of posters seem to have ignored this information.
What does your money pay for? I can't see anything left but half of the utilities bills. He seems extraordinarily generous to me. Yet people are still posting as if he's not doing enough.

MumApril1990 · 20/08/2023 09:30

I don’t see why he would mind paying half, just add it to the list of household bills/ family expenses.

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 09:26

How much is it going to cost? With rising costs of everything at the moment, I’d be tempted to get online food deliveries if this is what’s proving difficult with a toddler and then put them in nursery at 3 when the funded hours kick in.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 09:17

Heronwatcher · 20/08/2023 09:15

So I agree that if both parents are working and running a house together it’s normal for both to pay for childcare. But I think this does sound a bit of an odd situation. It sounds like you’d still be tag teaming during the week, so you and your partner barely see each other, and probably you’d be out one day a weekend (with your partner out another) and having your daughter mind the baby. I think with so little family time and having to rely on family members for childcare it perhaps wouldn’t be my priority to pay to have 2 days at home on my own in the week, I’d probably try to reduce my weekend or evening work. But if works for you and your DH then that’s all that matters really.

Any days off at weekends are spent together. We do appreciate our days when we are together. None of us can give up working weekends as our jobs require us to work them. I would have to change jobs if I wanted weekends off and I love my job. Dp loves his.

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 20/08/2023 09:15

So I agree that if both parents are working and running a house together it’s normal for both to pay for childcare. But I think this does sound a bit of an odd situation. It sounds like you’d still be tag teaming during the week, so you and your partner barely see each other, and probably you’d be out one day a weekend (with your partner out another) and having your daughter mind the baby. I think with so little family time and having to rely on family members for childcare it perhaps wouldn’t be my priority to pay to have 2 days at home on my own in the week, I’d probably try to reduce my weekend or evening work. But if works for you and your DH then that’s all that matters really.

Dotcheck · 20/08/2023 09:14

Ohmygiddyauntie · 20/08/2023 09:12

So technically you want dp to pay half for some down time.😳
He already pays the majority of bills too.😬

It's fine for posters to suggest pooling money but this doesn't mean every single request is going to be met with enthusiastic consent.

I feel this is one of those occasions.

How is looking after the house down time?

Hibiscrubbed · 20/08/2023 09:13

Your friend is a fucking idiot.

Ohmygiddyauntie · 20/08/2023 09:12

So technically you want dp to pay half for some down time.😳
He already pays the majority of bills too.😬

It's fine for posters to suggest pooling money but this doesn't mean every single request is going to be met with enthusiastic consent.

I feel this is one of those occasions.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 09:11

He also does get one evening a week where I’m not working, he goes to the pub after work and sees mates.

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 09:09

Aprilx · 20/08/2023 09:03

I think household bills which include childcare should come from the central pot, but that attitude is not on either. He already covers rent, council tax and all food and this is a non essential childcare cost so that OP can have a bit of child free time. It should at the very least be a discussion.

It’s not really so I can have child free time. It’s so I can get more done at home and do errands without the toddler. So yes would be easier for me, but also beneficial to our daughter I feel

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 09:08

OakAshElm · 20/08/2023 09:00

If I'm reading this right. Most of your "time off" is currently spent in sole charge of your children and running the house (IE. A full time job).
His time off is in the evening whilst you are at work meaning he truly gets time to himself as presumably the kids are in bed.

It sounds like you both work really hard but you are completely justified in pushing to get some child-free time off for yourself and yes, he should pay half as it will ultimately benefit the whole family.

Yes, so I either have the toddler or I’m at work. The only down time I get is 2 evenings a week when toddler is in bed. Dp would be happy for me to do my own thing at weekend while he was home with toddler but I would rather spend it with him to be honest doing family stuff. We don’t see each other much, he always says we are like ships in the night just passing lol.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 20/08/2023 09:03

Rainbowsandrainclouds1 · 20/08/2023 08:16

Of course he pays at least half. I dont understand how people get to the point of having a child and yet there be so much angst over something that shouldnt need to even be a conversation.

If you don't have a joint account the conversation should be a "oh, babe, the nursery have confirmed the fees will be £1000 paid on the 2nd. If you send your half/ two thirds over by the 1st Ill arrange for them to come out of my account". Doesnt need to be a sit down formal chat either could be a comment in passing when cooking dinner.

This is why so many women with high earning spouses end up in poverty unable to buy basics whilst their husbands build a nice little nest egg.

I think household bills which include childcare should come from the central pot, but that attitude is not on either. He already covers rent, council tax and all food and this is a non essential childcare cost so that OP can have a bit of child free time. It should at the very least be a discussion.

OakAshElm · 20/08/2023 09:02

And actually as other posters have said he should be paying more than half (proportional to income. )