Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect dp to pay half the nursery fees

139 replies

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 08:03

I haven’t spoken with him about it yet, it’s not that I think he will say no, as he’s not the type to say it’s just up to me but I was telling a friend my plan and she said I shouldn’t ask him for half the fees.

so I want to know if I’m being a knob expecting it of him before I say something!

he works full time, out the house 12 hours a day, often weekends also. I work evenings and and a full day at a weekend, so he gets 2 days in 14 off, I get 2 days a week off. We do a sort of he walks in from work, I walk out, to avoid the child care fees. He gets paid about 4 times what I do if that’s relevant. He does pay for the rent, and half the bills. I do the other half of bills.
he definitely doesn’t shy away from paying for things if the kids need it, he always gets it and also a very good hands on dad, when he’s home he takes over with the kids and does jobs around the house, we both do our share I think and this works.

so, we have a 2.5 year old. I want her to go to nursery. A couple days a week 9-3 so fits in with school run for my older dc. I’m not at work during that time, but obviously I do have things to do at home, food shopping that’s awkward with a toddler, and errands to run that my dp doesn’t have time for. Also, she’s at the age where normally it’s good for them to go to nursery. Up until now she’s been home with me. Weekends my eldest looks after her if both me and dp work, which she doesn’t mind but obviously during the week she’s at college.

now, I’d like her to go 2 days, so I can have those 2 days to get the house done, have time to shower ready for work in the evening in peace! and just get things done without a strong willed toddler about.
I know my dp won’t begrudge me of this, he will want me to have a couple days sort of “to myself” and wouldn’t even care if I spent the day being lazy, but, I want him to pay half the bill. I guess it does mostly benefit me her going to nursery, but I feel a bit burnt out at the moment and just never stop with the toddler, school runs, house, errands then going to work myself till 11pm , I do this 4 nights a week plus a 12-11pm shift on a weekend. I’m exhausted.

happy to be told I’m unreasonable and I’ll just pay the bill myself, but what do you think?

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 11:53

Doyoumind · 20/08/2023 11:37

I'm with you on this. He's paying the vast majority of outgoings, including for her other DC. Perhaps he should contribute something towards nursery fees but the child is going to nursery to give her downtime, not to allow her to work, which seems like a bit of a luxury rather than a necessity.

Again. It is not for my downtime. I’ve said this a million times. It’s not for downtime.

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 11:52

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 11:26

We do a sort of he walks in from work, I walk out, to avoid the child care fees.

It seems bizarre to me that you have decided on this working arrangement which you say is completely exhausting you and sounds like you barely see your family, in order to avoid child care fees, yet are talking about paying hundreds/thousands of pounds for non-essential childcare?!

It’s not that simple. Around here the only childcare option is 8.50 till 3.30. No childminders are taking on at the moment and no other nurseries, apart from one that has a year long waiting list and I don’t really like the place if I’m honest. Anyway, it’s not about the money for childcare, it’s just not available for the hours I and dp would need to work if I got another job. Also, the amount of time parents have off for child sickness ect.. we decided after my maternity that I would do opposite work to him to avoid that.

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 11:48

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 11:48

I’m fully aware of what my own children cost thank you. And nope, we’re not in a much larger house because of them, I lived in this house long before dp came along.

Also, most don’t work most evenings so different situations.

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 11:48

Batatahara · 20/08/2023 11:16

The costs for them are not loads anyway as they are with their dad 50% of the time and he pays for 50% of everything they need also.

I think you're massively underestimating this.

Costs for your older DC aren't just things like food/phone, but the costs of a much larger house than you would need if it was just you, him, and the toddler.

I don't think you're not contributing or anything, you clearly are but I think asking him to pay for unnecessary childcare does tip it from sounding like a balanced relationship to taking the piss a bit. Most parents of toddlers don't get two days a week to sort their shit out. I certainly don't.

I’m fully aware of what my own children cost thank you. And nope, we’re not in a much larger house because of them, I lived in this house long before dp came along.

OP posts:
Doyoumind · 20/08/2023 11:37

saraclara · 20/08/2023 09:34

He pays all the rent and council tax and food. I pay half of the other bills. Just how we have always done it. Like I said he isn’t stingy and pays for anything the kids or I need. I don’t have to ask really, he will happily pay for the kids clothes and trips and holidays and pocket money for them and he pays for the car that only I use, he has a work car so doesn’t have to pay for that, he pays for anything unexpected. Also, we only share the toddler, I also have children from previous relationship that are with us half the time and he pays for anything they need also.

The majority of posters seem to have ignored this information.
What does your money pay for? I can't see anything left but half of the utilities bills. He seems extraordinarily generous to me. Yet people are still posting as if he's not doing enough.

I'm with you on this. He's paying the vast majority of outgoings, including for her other DC. Perhaps he should contribute something towards nursery fees but the child is going to nursery to give her downtime, not to allow her to work, which seems like a bit of a luxury rather than a necessity.

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 11:26

We do a sort of he walks in from work, I walk out, to avoid the child care fees.

It seems bizarre to me that you have decided on this working arrangement which you say is completely exhausting you and sounds like you barely see your family, in order to avoid child care fees, yet are talking about paying hundreds/thousands of pounds for non-essential childcare?!

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 11:23

There's also the question her having seemingly stalled her career progression, pension contributions, et cetera.

Though that was possibly already the case before they met, as she has an older DC at college and others at school.

redskytwonight · 20/08/2023 11:22

This whole situation sounds unsustainable long term. What will you do when your DC starts school? You'll scarcely see them under this current arrangement.

I would say

  1. DP contributes towards nursery fees (not necessarily half, other finances should be taken into consideration)
  2. Both OP and DP need more "down time" and it would be fair for DP to also have some evening childcare paid for to allow him to go out.
  3. I hope you're paying your older DC to look after her younger sibling. If you're not, that actually sounds the most unreasonable part of the whole post.
PaminaMozart · 20/08/2023 11:17

MrsRandom123 · 20/08/2023 10:16

He already pays for everything (bar half of some
bills which op pays) including what her older kids need who aren’t his. Apparently he will pay for half of this if she asked as he is so generous but the point is he doesn’t need to as it’s not essential childcare. op should pay for the hours herself if she wants them for herself. Down the line he will likely pay all childcare when it’s required so i’m with her friend!

Whatever OP's partner currently pays vs what she pays, it should ALL be proportionate to income.

There's also the question her having seemingly stalled her career progression, pension contributions, et cetera.

Quite apart from the fact that they don't seem to be married, thus leaving her vulnerable.

Batatahara · 20/08/2023 11:16

The costs for them are not loads anyway as they are with their dad 50% of the time and he pays for 50% of everything they need also.

I think you're massively underestimating this.

Costs for your older DC aren't just things like food/phone, but the costs of a much larger house than you would need if it was just you, him, and the toddler.

I don't think you're not contributing or anything, you clearly are but I think asking him to pay for unnecessary childcare does tip it from sounding like a balanced relationship to taking the piss a bit. Most parents of toddlers don't get two days a week to sort their shit out. I certainly don't.

SpongeBob2022 · 20/08/2023 11:03

sake of working that should say.

SpongeBob2022 · 20/08/2023 11:01

The OP's DH has met someone with children and embraced them financially and practically and become a family, which is fantastic for the children. This should be seen as the ideal and he should be applauded...not the OP criticised.

People criticising the days off...I don't think it's fair to criticise...maybe if she was working normal hours...but she is working evenings and this changes the context completely.

However, I do think the way of thinking in the post is different from mine. I think it needs a discussion overall about how much income is needed between you, outgoings, prospects, balanced with the need for family and downtime, rather than taking each thing in complete isolation and as individuals.

To be honest I think it's really hard because with this arrangement you're almost working for the sake or working, but I completely understand why you want to work, and should work. Hopefully it'll become easier long term.

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 11:01

if I were you, I'd just say to him, I think Sarah/katie/Meg would really benefit from a couple of days in nursery & I would like some time to get stuff done without her 'help'. What do you think? It would cost £x until April when she'll get some free hours.

That sounds like a perfectly reasonable conversation opener. If he were to reply with ‘that’d work out as £2500+ all in, which is a lot of money, do you reckon we could get food delivered and have another look at what you think we’re getting behind on in the house instead and wait till April’ that would be perfectly reasonable as well.

This really all depends on their finances and how he feels about it.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 20/08/2023 10:56

NeedTheSeaside · 20/08/2023 10:34

@@Hellosausag

I am losing the will to live! It's like dumb & dumber on here these days. People don't read all the OP's posts & when they do the comprehension level is dire.

it sounds (to me) like you & DP have a lovely relationship, where you both work hard, in slightly different ways.

Personally I'd have a joint account, then each have a spends account of your own if you want to, but essentially you've got that, just done slightly differently.

He earns a lot more, because you support his career & home life. He pays more because you do that.

you are in NO way a cocklodger.

He's not tight.

if I were you, I'd just say to him, I think Sarah/katie/Meg would really benefit from a couple of days in nursery & I would like some time to get stuff done without her 'help'. What do you think? It would cost £x until April when she'll get some free hours.

I came on to write something like this, but @NeedTheSeaside has put it so well, I'm not going to try to rephrase it! Also, to the best of my understanding, a cocklodger would be someone who contributed nothing to the household at all, didn't have a paying job and stayed at home without doing any childcare, cleaning, shopping, cooking, washing, ironing, life admin or anything else that keeps a home running smoothly for the other partner who is then able to pursue their own career goals without having to worry about anything else.

Totaly · 20/08/2023 10:51

Sorry, don't have time to read the full thread but why, if he earns 4x as much as you, why are you paying half the bills? It should be proportionate to income, i.e. 80% vs 20%.

And this obviously applies to childcare as well

So on top of all the rent, food, council tax and everything for OPs children including clothing etc

Whilst OP pays half the bills, why should he pay for unnecessary childcare?

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 10:44

@Doteycat sorry I quoted wrong person

OP posts:
Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 10:43

Doteycat · 20/08/2023 10:40

No I wouldnt.

New partner?! We’ve been together over 5 years lol.

OP posts:
Doteycat · 20/08/2023 10:40

saraclara · 20/08/2023 10:02

Swap the sexes round in your post. You'd be calling a man who expected his new partner to pay for his children by another woman, a cocklodger. Even if she was the higher earner.

No I wouldnt.

xyz111 · 20/08/2023 10:39

I don't understand how some people have all money separate, so you have to ask each other to pay for half of everything. Must be very stressful. DH and I both have separate accounts we get paid in to, we have a joint account we put money in to, and all bills, eating out comes out of that.

Aprilx · 20/08/2023 10:38

PaminaMozart · 20/08/2023 10:12

Sorry, don't have time to read the full thread but why, if he earns 4x as much as you, why are you paying half the bills? It should be proportionate to income, i.e. 80% vs 20%.

And this obviously applies to childcare as well.

She s paying half of the utility bills. He pays for literally everything else, rent council, tax, food and everything for her children from a previous relationship.

I generally find the idea the childcare costs are the mothers costs to pretty offensive, but I think the friend here might have something of a point here as these we not even necessary childcare costs.

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 10:37

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 10:33

It will cost about roughly £45 a day. I don’t really want to wait till April as it’s a long way off, and I’m just shattered. It’s the age she is now, terrible 2s, just trying to get her out and about with me is hard work. This has come about because this week I just felt like I couldn’t keep up with the house and I spent all day yesterday catching up which is eating in to our rare time we do get together. I may just pay for it myself until April. It will come out of my own disposable income not dps

If you have £3000 to spend on that, then go for it. That would have been a tonne of money I couldn’t have spared, but maybe you have more savings than I did! I’d hang on till April and muddle through.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 10:34

WunWun · 20/08/2023 10:31

I'm not ignoring it, but I'm a parent myself. I've been a mum at home during the day with a toddler. I didn't need to full days off to do fucking shopping and housework!

Did you work 5 evenings a week also?

OP posts:
NeedTheSeaside · 20/08/2023 10:34

@@Hellosausag

I am losing the will to live! It's like dumb & dumber on here these days. People don't read all the OP's posts & when they do the comprehension level is dire.

it sounds (to me) like you & DP have a lovely relationship, where you both work hard, in slightly different ways.

Personally I'd have a joint account, then each have a spends account of your own if you want to, but essentially you've got that, just done slightly differently.

He earns a lot more, because you support his career & home life. He pays more because you do that.

you are in NO way a cocklodger.

He's not tight.

if I were you, I'd just say to him, I think Sarah/katie/Meg would really benefit from a couple of days in nursery & I would like some time to get stuff done without her 'help'. What do you think? It would cost £x until April when she'll get some free hours.

Hellosausag · 20/08/2023 10:33

Shinyandnew1 · 20/08/2023 10:23

How much is the childcare for two days a week going to cost, @Hellosausag ?

Could you just hang on until April when the funded hours kick in? Do online food shops so you don’t have to wangle that with a small person in tow.

It will cost about roughly £45 a day. I don’t really want to wait till April as it’s a long way off, and I’m just shattered. It’s the age she is now, terrible 2s, just trying to get her out and about with me is hard work. This has come about because this week I just felt like I couldn’t keep up with the house and I spent all day yesterday catching up which is eating in to our rare time we do get together. I may just pay for it myself until April. It will come out of my own disposable income not dps

OP posts:
araiwa · 20/08/2023 10:32

PaminaMozart · 20/08/2023 10:12

Sorry, don't have time to read the full thread but why, if he earns 4x as much as you, why are you paying half the bills? It should be proportionate to income, i.e. 80% vs 20%.

And this obviously applies to childcare as well.

If you can't be arsed to read the thread, thus missing a lot of information, why on earth would anyone give a fuck what you think

Swipe left for the next trending thread