Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking strangers for money, Go Fund Me, just giving etc.

133 replies

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 06:13

I’ve seen so many fundraising posts on social media, another two this morning for people I don’t know prompted me to do this thread. Some for disabled people, some for pet care, some for funerals, some for charities etc.
I’m not specifically talking about people using their own page, I suppose it’s a good way to reach out to family and friends (I’ve donated to friend’s charity fundraisers this way. I mean news pages, community interest pages etc. reaching the general public.

I have a really strong urge to eye roll when I see people essentially asking strangers to give them money. In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this. Why ask strangers.
Some fundraising for sports/activity clubs too, just give us money. When I was a child we used to do some sort of service to collect money, E.g. bag pack at the local store, clean cars etc.
I know I can scroll past them and I do, would literally be a pauper if I gave to all that I saw. I just hate the default, something has happened let’s set up a fundraising (in some/most cases begging) page.
I don’t know why I feel so strongly about this, so I guess I’m after your views.

AIBU-
YABU- it’s a legitimate way for people to raise money for what they need.
YANBU- there literally doesn’t need to be a just giving, go fund me page for everything, people should take more responsibility for themselves, help should be sought from friends and family not the general public.

OP posts:
JMSA · 20/08/2023 07:35

I'm with you, OP.

Dotcheck · 20/08/2023 07:27

Depends on the request really.
I really hate those ‘ donate so I can walk the Great Wall of China for charity ’. Noooo you just want to have a marvellous adventure

Perthsmurf · 20/08/2023 07:26

I’m sort of with you OP. There’s one going round at the moment where the coach is asking for money for a sports trip for a team to the US. On the face of it all very noble and worthwhile, and something I would have considered giving to, had I not known that the students in question are the coach’s son and his 2 close friends (this is not stated anywhere), he earns a shedload of money, AFAIK they’re making no attempt to fundraise by actually doing anything, and the “sports trip” is only one day of a competition where there are equivalent tournaments in the UK and Europe (which they’re not going to- maybe because Birmingham doesn’t have Disney?).

They’re crowdfunding for a holiday which includes 1 day of competition, that’s actually what he’s doing and it stinks. I’m obviously keeping out of it but this kind of behaviour is where I have a problem and people need to treat these things with extreme caution.

WandaWonder · 20/08/2023 07:22

I have no problem them asking no one, including me, is forced to give people can just move on

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/08/2023 07:21

I hope you never find yourself in a position where the kindness of your community is the only thing that carries you through a completely unexpected death and the chaos it can cause.

I was in that position 18 months ago when my DP died. We hadn’t planned for him to have undiagnosed cancer that metastised to his brain and had been virtually symptomless.

I was immensely grateful and embarrassed at the same time that it was necessary. My friends set it up as DP was well known in the community. It covered funeral costs and enough to help with living costs until I could pull my head out of my ass and start to try and rebuild my entire life.

Have I learned my lesson and prepared for my own possible demise? Well, I’d love to but my business is failing, my mental health is in the toilet and my future is precarious.

Frankly, if these platforms exist and people want to donate so be it. Caveat emptor and all that. It’s not easy and straightforward to achieve financial stability these days, so in times of crisis these things can be particularly helpful.

More “frivolous” causes? So what. Live and let live. The law deals with fraud and scammers.

Like I say, just be grateful you aren’t in a position where you’re dependent on the good will of others for your very survival, even if it’s only for a short time.

I’m about to start leaching off the state now, as for some reason despite best efforts I just can’t make things work. But I’m not going to ask for help elsewhere.

Trust me, if you’re the recipient of generosity due to bereavement you don’t feel good about it, or rub your hands with glee and plot a future dependent on it.

TerrorAustralis · 20/08/2023 07:20

There are some that are clearly scammy that are easy to avoid. I saw more of these living in Asia. For example, a sidebar ad with a photo of a baby in hospital bed, saying the child will die without treatment.

The ones that wind me up are when people have travelled and had an accident or health incident and they don’t have travel insurance. Or they have limited insurance that doesn’t cover the activities they were doing (e.g. quad biking, jet skiing, skiing off piste, riding scooters without a helmet/drunk/without a valid licence etc). If you can’t afford travel insurance, you can’t afford to travel. And you need to make sure your insurance covers whatever activities you want to undertake.

Clymene · 20/08/2023 07:19

Unfortunately those who can afford to give the least often give the most - the poor give proportionally more of their income to charity/a sob story than the wealthy. And people who are more vulnerable are more likely to be taken in.

For every genuine person, there are many more scammers. The internet is a scammer's paradise.

Amanda from Scamanda is in the US but Megan Bahri and her mother scammed thousands in the U.K. for a fake brain tumour and there was a woman called Nicole who lied about having cancer and spent tens of thousands she raised to pay for fake treatments on holidays and luxury goods. I think she ended up in prison.

Those are just the tip of the iceberg.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 07:16

@Hairyfairy01 we had one saying family member had a diagnosis and only one in the UK, they are raising £10000, they don’t know what they need yet, but will update people on what they spend it on when they need it. I personally know this family and would have donated, but I’ll donate when they need it, not in advance as a just in case…

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 20/08/2023 07:14

In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this. Why ask strangers.

You can’t see how a family can’t cobble together enough to pay the funeral for an unexpected death? Most of the GFM that I see for funerals are for young people who have died very suddenly. Most people don’t take life insurance until they’ve bought a home or had chikdren and usually life insurance covers the cost. And if that death has been unexpectedly or in tragic circumstances you can’t see how the family might want something more than the most basic of funerals, especially if there are a lot of mourners to accommodate.

How fortunate you’ve never been in such circumstances, how sad you can’t imagine anyone being in a different financial position than you are. You don’t need to give, you can scroll past.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 07:13

@littleblackcat27 read my response to @Nagado
It has nothing to do with being fortunate, it’s about not leaping to just giving as if it’s the only option.
I’ve seen people have a just giving for funeral costs and go on a lavish holiday abroad, why should generous people pay funeral costs so they can still have their holiday.

I’m not sure why you are calling me smug and it’s up to me what I do with my time. I don’t recall asking for opinions on me, but on the topic of my thread. If my thread triggers you so much for some reason, (and you don’t give a shit) you could feel free to scroll past or perhaps tailor your response to just your last sentence. Have a nice day.

OP posts:
Roosmarjin · 20/08/2023 07:12

boboshmobo · 20/08/2023 06:39

It's modern day begging and nothing else but you can choose to ignore it .

I only ever give to things I know are true and want to help but overall I find it quite untasteful

I have a disabled child who needed a wheelchair so I worked harder to buy it . End of !

How do you work if you're a single parent and your child has night time care needs? I used to belong to a group who helped raise money to get a girl a device so she could communicate.

Lwrenagain · 20/08/2023 07:10

Goldenboysmum · 20/08/2023 06:38

I think YABU, if you dont want to give money then dont. I dont think many people can afford to give to every one they see.

On the other side of it...when my son took his life in Australia, Christmas 2020, his ex girlfriend set up a Go Fund Me (I think it was that one) so I could have my boy home.

I will be forever grateful to the family, friends and strangers who donated.

Over £27,000 was raised, which more than covered the cost of his repatriation and funeral.

The remaining money was donated over the next couple of years to various mental health charities and Go Fund Me/Just Giving fundraisers, when suicide was involved.

I'm so sorry for your loss, generic words sound so meh, but I truly am. Much love to you ❤

Hairyfairy01 · 20/08/2023 07:09

The ones asking for 'equipment to get dad home from hospital' or 'money for rehab' bother me especially when the person in question has only had their stroke, car crash etc a few days ago and family set it up without talking to the staff working with the person. NHS / social services do provide equipment, adaptations and rehab plus at such an early point family have no idea what their needs are.

littleblackcat27 · 20/08/2023 07:05

I have a really strong urge to eye roll when I see people essentially asking strangers to give them money. In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this. Why ask strangers.

You eye roll away - no one gives a shit whether you're bothered or not. Just don't give - tailor your facebook/social media feed better - or don't spend as much of your time and thoughts on social media.

The last option probably being the best one.

And yep - you do sound smug and fortunate. Not everyone has a few thousand spare for a funeral.

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 07:04

So sorry for your loss @Goldenboysmum 💐

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 07:04

@Goldenboysmum I’m so sorry for your loss. How utterly heartbreaking.

I’m absolutely not against charitable giving, I don’t know about in Australia, but in the UK there are repatriation charities that can help if anyone found themselves in the same horrendous position as you and I’m sure those assisted would then become lifelong supporters.
My issue with all the fundraising pages is there are so many for everything, it seems to be the default (of course worthiness is a value judgement) and they are unregulated. I would hate to think that someone set up a page fraudulently claiming to be experiencing what you have and you gave to it.

(I know regulation of charities is problematic too and that’s why I tend to give to local ones that I can see make a difference in my community)

OP posts:
AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 07:03

boboshmobo · 20/08/2023 06:39

It's modern day begging and nothing else but you can choose to ignore it .

I only ever give to things I know are true and want to help but overall I find it quite untasteful

I have a disabled child who needed a wheelchair so I worked harder to buy it . End of !

How do you work more if you are the carer for the disabled person? The husband of my family member with a disability/illness is working for day to day living expenses which are much higher than for a healthy person. Frequent hospital admissions would affect work, and there are costs like parking associated with those.

lljkk · 20/08/2023 07:01

following sudden accident death of their young person, a local grieving family set up a GFM to pay for the funeral. Their target was X and they raised 3X.

How mean of me is to know how they will spend the large extra amount? If you donate after they achieved their target then I assume you are happy if they spend it on a nice family holiday or a new car, whatever they reckon they need. If I raised that extra I would make a statement how I spent it, though.

I don't mind GFM exercises, but I'd like some transparency about what happens to any huge excesses raised.

iloveeverykindofcat · 20/08/2023 06:59

There's a sub-reddit r/dontfundme dedicated to showcasing the cheekiest

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 06:53

@Nagado, yes, I’ve seen advertisements for as little as £900, of course some of the fundraising I’ve seen have been for much more ‘high end’. If the friends and family can’t afford it, sometimes the council will pay and claim from the estate. If there is no estate the funeral directors often will agree instalments as long as they get some of the money up front. I genuinely don’t believe that the only option is to set up a just giving page for £10000 like some of the ones I’ve seen. It’s got nothing to do with being in a lucky position.

OP posts:
HamishTheCamel · 20/08/2023 06:46

I never give to a stranger's GoFundMe - only someone I know.

whatchagonnado · 20/08/2023 06:46

I guess it's a case of filtering out what is a worthy cause ... but there's no guarantee that the person requesting the money will actually spend it on what they're fundraising for.

There seems to be a number of DIY bands crowdfunding for their costs to write and perform songs -this really gets my goat. They are effectively requesting money from other people to fund their hobby. Most of the output is really mediocre and will never make it into the charts. Grrrr.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 06:44

Just to add, I’m not against charitable giving, I choose to support those making a difference in my community (blood bikers, food kitchen, neo-natal unit) and one national charity who helped me when I was unwell. It’s more the incessant nature of lots of posts for everything (e.g. young person died in an accident, all these from the same person’s family, 1st fundraiser for funeral, second fundraiser for designer outfit from ‘inspirational’ designer for them to be buried in, third fundraiser for headstone, fourth fundraiser for charity that helped at scene of accident). I feel for those who need help, but lots just take advantage.
As pointed out there are a lot of scams and I can’t see how these would be vetted. If people just asked those who they know, and people just gave to who they know are genuine it would stop the inroad for scammers.

OP posts:
Nagado · 20/08/2023 06:44

In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this. Why ask strangers

You cannot understand how family and friends can’t cobble together thousands of pounds to pay for a funeral? What a lucky position to be in. 🙄

Kweeky · 20/08/2023 06:43

im not on SM so don’t see these but I’d find it a bit depressing -like the cruelty to animals ads on day time tv -I don’t want to be constantly reminded of misery - I give a little to a couple of animal charities.

Swipe left for the next trending thread