Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking strangers for money, Go Fund Me, just giving etc.

133 replies

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 06:13

I’ve seen so many fundraising posts on social media, another two this morning for people I don’t know prompted me to do this thread. Some for disabled people, some for pet care, some for funerals, some for charities etc.
I’m not specifically talking about people using their own page, I suppose it’s a good way to reach out to family and friends (I’ve donated to friend’s charity fundraisers this way. I mean news pages, community interest pages etc. reaching the general public.

I have a really strong urge to eye roll when I see people essentially asking strangers to give them money. In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this. Why ask strangers.
Some fundraising for sports/activity clubs too, just give us money. When I was a child we used to do some sort of service to collect money, E.g. bag pack at the local store, clean cars etc.
I know I can scroll past them and I do, would literally be a pauper if I gave to all that I saw. I just hate the default, something has happened let’s set up a fundraising (in some/most cases begging) page.
I don’t know why I feel so strongly about this, so I guess I’m after your views.

AIBU-
YABU- it’s a legitimate way for people to raise money for what they need.
YANBU- there literally doesn’t need to be a just giving, go fund me page for everything, people should take more responsibility for themselves, help should be sought from friends and family not the general public.

OP posts:
usernother · 20/08/2023 08:45

LakeTiticaca · 20/08/2023 08:35

The ones that annoy me are the ones where someone has had an accident r on holiday and needs to pay hospital bills etc. Then you scroll past all the sympathetic tutting to the part where they didn't take out insurance as they " didn't think they would need it"

Sometimes they have insurance but the insurance won't pay up. I saw a programme on tv a few weeks ago where a woman had gone on holiday and had ended up in hospital to be told she had a brain tumour. Because she had previously visited her GP once to complain about headaches (GP hadn't thought it was anything to worry about) the insurance company refused to pay. The hospital abroad wouldn't release her until the family came up with £65,000 which they were lucky enough to be able to provide.

usernother · 20/08/2023 08:40

I think it's up to people if they want to donate or not. But there is, in some cases, no way to know if the money is being used for the purpose that is supposed to be used for. See what some Twitter users are saying re Jack Monroe for instance.

Sueveneers · 20/08/2023 08:39

LakeTiticaca · 20/08/2023 08:35

The ones that annoy me are the ones where someone has had an accident r on holiday and needs to pay hospital bills etc. Then you scroll past all the sympathetic tutting to the part where they didn't take out insurance as they " didn't think they would need it"

And as long as kindly and well-meaning but gullible people keep paying their bills, they won't think they will 'ever need it' because someone will always come along and pay it for them. They soon learn if anything happens that can rinse money from everyone else so why bother?

ssd · 20/08/2023 08:38

@Goldenboysmum , I'm so sorryFlowers

JobMatch3000 · 20/08/2023 08:37

Anyone else remember the Nicola Bulley one asking for £50k? With all the public interest in the case, if their initial target had been £5k I'm sure they would have raised A LOT more.

JusthereforXmas · 20/08/2023 08:36

My DH has an old friend from college (from before we met) that we have probably 'bumped in' for a 10 second conversation about 6 times in 15 years.

I don't know him except knowing that he cheated on his wife then bailed leaving her with their HEAVILY disabled child. Knocked the other woman up then bailed on her too. His ex wife remained part of the group most cut ties with him.

I have only actively spoke to him once. To invite him to our wedding (DH wanted to invite him as he wanted the 'old crew' there) to which he responded 'whats in it for me' and 'I'll come if you pay me' (honestly my facial expression must have been like a Deer in the headlights at that response).

He has on several occasions messaged me on facebook (we are not friends) with thes go-fund-mes for his holidays and to buy a new car because he is 'depressed' and needs 'cheering up'.

I have honestly never met such a leech before... utterly baffling why no one wants to hang out with him anymore.

LakeTiticaca · 20/08/2023 08:35

The ones that annoy me are the ones where someone has had an accident r on holiday and needs to pay hospital bills etc. Then you scroll past all the sympathetic tutting to the part where they didn't take out insurance as they " didn't think they would need it"

LlynTegid · 20/08/2023 08:31

Providing that the reasons given are honest and genuine, then you have the choice to donate or not.

Personal responsibility would be ideal of course, but not the reality. Funds for unexpected life events are something many have reduced because of the need for basic things such as keeping the roof over your head and food.

Sueveneers · 20/08/2023 08:26

Yeah, it's just pure irresponsibility. It doesn't cost much to have even cheap funeral insurance. We do the right thing by having insurance and preparing, and these people basically get free funerals because they can't be bothered to do the right thing. They're being rewarded for not being responsible. It's unfair and wrong. If it was the unexpected death of a child, that would be one thing. But adults who should know better and should adult properly and plan? No. I won't contribute to their laziness and CFery when I did the right thing and they didn't. Why should they get a free funeral?

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 08:21

@MistressoftheDarkSide not sure who your second post was aimed at.

If it was me I’m certainly not suggesting that prostitution or selling organs on the black market should be options ahead of asking others when in need.

I’m not sure where you are getting the holier than thou judgement from. I’m sure you don’t agree with those who set up a page for anything and everything, asking others for money when they don’t actually need it, reducing the amount people can afford to give to those who genuinely do. I’ve already said I’ve given to friends I know are genuine through these pages.

OP posts:
SunWorshipping · 20/08/2023 08:15

I mean it does depend. I know a family who were expecting twins, they lost 1 of the twins due to twin to twin syndrome, the other twin survived but is severely disabled. They set a charity up in his name and do lots of challenges etc to raise money to provide therapy/equipment etc the NHS just doesn't provide, I have no issue donating to these people.

What I have issues with is people who don't buy pet insurance or don't factor in vet bills when they take on a pet, we don't have pets as we don't have thousands to spend on a dog when something happens and the insurance only covers up to x amount. Then there's the accident abroad brigade who take out no insurance, I went travelling for over a year in my 20s I paid for the top insurance to make sure I wasn't left with a bill for thousands or I could get home in the event of an accident. The number of people I met with no insurance was shocking, a friend of mine was seriously attacked (unprovoked) after a night out and he had an ambulance called (he was hit over the head with a metal bar!!), his bill was thousands and he had no insurance, his parents paid it for him. Lots of young people particularly lads will decide not to buy insurance as it's money you pay out but seen to get nothing in return for (unless it goes wrong!). I struggle to sympathise with them when they turn to just giving because they didn't bother with insurance.

Young people don't tend to have life insurance as I guess they don't anticipate death, I'll admit I didn't have life insurance until I bought a house. Maybe these things should be taught in schools more along with learning about money, interest rates, debt, mortgages etc etc.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/08/2023 08:11

Thank you for the kind words.

One day I hope to stop feeling like an utter failure in every regard.

OrwellianTimes · 20/08/2023 08:08

There’s some piss takers for sure.

But when one of my friends died suddenly at 35 I happily helped setup a go fund me and gave to it so his widow wouldn’t have the stress of trying to magic money for the funeral out of thin air whilst trying to manage her 3 young kids.

Sometimes life throws a shit curveball. Why would they be any less worthy than traditional charities.

x2boys · 20/08/2023 08:07

I can't see the priblem.if peoo!e want to.give that's up.to.them I personally wouldn't donate to a go.fund me but don't object to other's doing so.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 08:05

@MistressoftheDarkSide see my response to @Jellycatspyjamas I’m not in some fortunate position.

I’m sorry for your loss, and your ongoing struggles. I don’t see any issue with what you have done. Your page was targeted at people who knew your loved ones. I’m not against giving to those who I know who need it.

You are right the law does deal with scammers, but only after they are caught and unfortunately not until they have already ripped lots of people off and a lot of those who give generously struggle. For every genuine case, there are several more scams, or people who ask for more than they need, or expect the public to cover all their costs to ensure they are not out of pocket at all. I’m sure the people who contributed to your loved ones funeral knew you needed it genuinely and were not taking their money whilst booking yourself an all inclusive holiday.

Once again, I’m sorry for your loss and hope you can get the help you need.

OP posts:
PlayedCatsEyeMarbles · 20/08/2023 08:03

Kweeky · 20/08/2023 06:43

im not on SM so don’t see these but I’d find it a bit depressing -like the cruelty to animals ads on day time tv -I don’t want to be constantly reminded of misery - I give a little to a couple of animal charities.

I don’t see these adverts as charities, they are big business.

I once followed one such charity on companies house, looking up directors with businesses in far off countries to see the huge dividends they were each getting.

Its all a scam, don’t fall for it

roselune · 20/08/2023 08:01

Some of the most annoying ones I've seen have been people with high profile Instagram accounts asking for people to contribute to the vet fees when their puppy needs surgery. It's always a puppy they bought from a breeder of course, just seems they failed to think about getting pet insurance or having adequate savings so now their followers should pay £££.

I tend to only donate to small charities and community groups because I know it can be a good way for them to fundraise quickly, and they don't have the man power to do many other fundraising activities.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/08/2023 08:01

If prostitution or selling a kidney had been an option I’d have done it - unfortunately when you’re bereaved suddenly it’s tricky fitting in a session in the red light district while managing the fall out.

Everybody’s life and situation is different and frankly the holier than thou judgement is very distasteful. More distasteful than those getting a helping hand in times of crisis. If you don’t like it don’t get involved. Simple.

Clymene · 20/08/2023 08:01

Fizbosshoes · 20/08/2023 07:42

Things like funerals or pioneering medical treatment that us only available privately in abroad, I can understand.
When people use GFM for nice things that they can't afford I have less inclination to give. I've seen someone fundraising to take their kids to Disney . Either save up or go somewhere budget friendly like the rest of us have to!

Pioneering medical treatment abroad was exactly what that woman Nicole I mentioned in my post said she was raising money for. But it was a lie.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 07:53

@Jellycatspyjamas look at my response to @Nagado. There are options.
I resent the assumption that because I think the volume of just giving etc. pages is unnecessary (and there are other options, that somehow I am so fortunate and smug). Unlike you, the ones I see are not all unexpected, some who are putting them on are still having holidays, getting new cars etc. It’s my view that if they can afford ‘luxuries’ they should redirect this to their loved ones funeral before asking strangers for money.
I didn’t put this in my earlier post as I didn’t want to be outed on the thread, but I’m from a working class background. We had a family member who had a funeral plan, but she didn’t know it was a scam, her funeral costs were supposed to be covered. They weren’t, we got a measly £150, she had paid more than that, a widow scraping and saving to try to not leave us with the costs. She would be mortified if she knew.
We couldn’t afford her funeral at the time, we made a payment plan with the funeral directors and looked into the options with the council. We absolutely wanted to do more than the payment plan would permit us, so we held a memorial a year later (I happily give up my holiday, social occasions with friends to raise additional money for this). I’m not saying this is what others should do. I would gladly give to a friend who found themselves in the position we did. I just don’t want you to be mistaken that I’m sitting so high up with my fortunate life, looking down on all those with their monetary needs and see just why I think some of the pages and those targeted at strangers are unnecessary.

OP posts:
Medusaismyhero · 20/08/2023 07:43

When my eldest (and most feckless) sibling died, his wife asked our family for money to pay for his funeral. I grumbled about that as I was (at the time) a lone parent and she was earning more than any of us. We paid it but I thought less of her for asking.

When my sister lost her DC unexpectedly at 18, we rallied together as a family and paid for the funeral. She could have afforded it but we wanted to help.

I absolutely detest all the social media begging for money in times of tragedy. I'd have prostituted myself or sold a bloody kidney before I'd have allowed public begging to pay for my nephew's funeral. Some people have no shame.

GreenBurritos · 20/08/2023 07:42

For every genuine person, there are many more scammers. The internet is a scammer's paradise.

Yep, saw this earlier this week

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cambridgeshire-66532728

Fizbosshoes · 20/08/2023 07:42

Things like funerals or pioneering medical treatment that us only available privately in abroad, I can understand.
When people use GFM for nice things that they can't afford I have less inclination to give. I've seen someone fundraising to take their kids to Disney . Either save up or go somewhere budget friendly like the rest of us have to!

TicTacNicNak · 20/08/2023 07:41

I've donated to fundraising before when it's someone I know, or there's a link via someone I know.

I don't donate to requests for funds towards funeral costs of young people, as funerals are free for people under 18 in England (used to work in funeral directors). There would be a cost for a headstone if a burial, but you have a year to save up before it can be placed.

Krampers · 20/08/2023 07:35

Hopefully with the COL crisis this will mark an end to this- I cannot for the life if me understand why anyone would gift to 90% of these causes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread