Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking strangers for money, Go Fund Me, just giving etc.

133 replies

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 06:13

I’ve seen so many fundraising posts on social media, another two this morning for people I don’t know prompted me to do this thread. Some for disabled people, some for pet care, some for funerals, some for charities etc.
I’m not specifically talking about people using their own page, I suppose it’s a good way to reach out to family and friends (I’ve donated to friend’s charity fundraisers this way. I mean news pages, community interest pages etc. reaching the general public.

I have a really strong urge to eye roll when I see people essentially asking strangers to give them money. In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this. Why ask strangers.
Some fundraising for sports/activity clubs too, just give us money. When I was a child we used to do some sort of service to collect money, E.g. bag pack at the local store, clean cars etc.
I know I can scroll past them and I do, would literally be a pauper if I gave to all that I saw. I just hate the default, something has happened let’s set up a fundraising (in some/most cases begging) page.
I don’t know why I feel so strongly about this, so I guess I’m after your views.

AIBU-
YABU- it’s a legitimate way for people to raise money for what they need.
YANBU- there literally doesn’t need to be a just giving, go fund me page for everything, people should take more responsibility for themselves, help should be sought from friends and family not the general public.

OP posts:
Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 11:24

@MistressoftheDarkSide I’m still not sure why making my own funeral arrangements is distasteful.

I’m not judging anyone who genuinely needs help, seeking it. My post was about setting up pages to ask strangers for money and this being the default first choice for many, as you’ve said you would not have approached the people who knew your DH if you didn’t absolutely have too, therefore my original post is not aimed at you at all. I have given to my friends and people I know through their just giving pages, when I know it’s genuine. I’ve seen people set up pages for the ‘help’ they need and then book a holiday.
I have asked friends and family for help when I have needed it too. I don’t have an issue with charitable giving at all, it’s the ever increasing volume of requests by those who don’t need it and the scamming and advantage taking I am judging.

OP posts:
CrystalCascade · 20/08/2023 11:21

@MistressoftheDarkSide sorry for what's happened to you. But I sort of get where the OP's coming from.
As someone who has donated to these things myself.
It seems to be the 'default' position to immediately get money together when something bad happens. Like in the Nicola Bulley case a 'friend' started a fundraiser, without the family's knowledge. What for?
The requests are also relentless. My local community FB page is chock full of them but worse still, knowing the families at least a quarter of them don't actually need the money.

There are lots of charities that will help in many situations, funerals for example you can get government help. People don't want to do all that. I understand that in times of bereavement they may not be thinking straight but the GoFundMe's are not set up by them anyway... by friends, who can surely do the research?

Of course, of course, I can just scroll past, but I can't say that I have zero reaction when I see it. I still donate - but only to people that I know are genuine.

Also your comment about 'deserving' vs 'undeserving' poor is ironic. Because this is exactly what direct fundraising perpetuates. It is imploring people to give directly to causes THEY find worthy, by logical extension of course they're going to judge what deserves their money! The point of paying taxes is that it gets distributed, ideally, fairly, without being subject to the vagaries of individual judgement. But that doesn't happen.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/08/2023 11:14

@BroomHandledMouser

Thank you - that truly means alot x

BroomHandledMouser · 20/08/2023 11:11

@MistressoftheDarkSide thank you for sharing. Your posts are beautifully written and heartbreaking. I wish you a brighter future, truly x

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/08/2023 10:56

Every situation is different. I would love to have been in a position where I didn’t have to rely on the kindness of community to get me through.

In the 11 years my DP and I were together his Mum succumbed to dementia - we cared for her in our home for 18 months until we couldn’t keep her safe - and mine to ovarian cancer. MIL is now a vegetable in a care home, all her assets used up on that. No inheritance as such from my Mum. Although we were both working it was a never ending game of chasing one’s tail.

Mea culpa, we didn’t get things sorted out because we lurched from one crisis to another.

My future now is simply focused on not leaving a shitstorm for my son to sort out and it’s daunting.

You simply have no idea how things are for other people is all I’m saying and the judgement in this particular area is hard to swallow. It smacks of the whole deserving versus undeserving poor rhetoric.

I’ve tried to take responsibility and stand on my own two feet for 54 years. Unfortunately I am also one of those people who gets the rug pulled out from under them in the most unforseeable ways on a regular basis. My resilience now has all the consistency of porridge.

I don’t want sympathy or charity, I want, just for once for life to be a straightish line rather than a fucking scribble.

Money is just a tool that keeps the world turning. I don’t resent those who have it, nor begrudge when people need a helping hand. If a go fund me or just giving helps someone in crisis, so be it.

One day I’ll hopefully be in a position to pay it forward. In fact I have - I’ve donated when one of my adult son’s friends took his own life, to a friend suffering with cancer, to someone with a sick pet, when I was able. Because having no money is shit and drives people in crisis to very dark places.

x2boys · 20/08/2023 10:34

JusthereforXmas · 20/08/2023 10:11

Also I have seen lots of these for funerals of children being shared by people on Facebook. Now if a child has died thats obviously very sad but I instantly get scammy vibes from a lot of them (and some where proven to be scams).

They are usually asking for a large chunk of money and in the UK funerals for under 18s are actually free its only add ons and extras that cost money.

I know because its a service I have personally received. Everything was sorted for us by the hospital (cremation, casket, hearse, ceremony, urn) the only thing we had to do (if we wanted) was provide flowers and the local florist did that for £15.

We also provided things to go in the coffin (like a teddy) but we wanted and ask to do that, it was never expected.

I'm assuming they play on the fact that those that haven't lost a child don't know about them being free (It kind of something most people either need to be told or find when googling for funeral stuff for children).

https://www.gov.uk/child-funeral-costs

Im.sorry for your loss
I did see this ,this week.a young chilld local to.me sadly passed away suddenly and a go fund me was set up, for funeral.costs .

TallerThanAverage · 20/08/2023 10:33

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 10:24

@JusthereforXmas thanks so much for sharing. Very useful for people to know if they are ever in the horrendous position you have been in. Also for others who might be at risk of scammers.

Very sorry for your loss.

OP posts:
JusthereforXmas · 20/08/2023 10:11

Also I have seen lots of these for funerals of children being shared by people on Facebook. Now if a child has died thats obviously very sad but I instantly get scammy vibes from a lot of them (and some where proven to be scams).

They are usually asking for a large chunk of money and in the UK funerals for under 18s are actually free its only add ons and extras that cost money.

I know because its a service I have personally received. Everything was sorted for us by the hospital (cremation, casket, hearse, ceremony, urn) the only thing we had to do (if we wanted) was provide flowers and the local florist did that for £15.

We also provided things to go in the coffin (like a teddy) but we wanted and ask to do that, it was never expected.

I'm assuming they play on the fact that those that haven't lost a child don't know about them being free (It kind of something most people either need to be told or find when googling for funeral stuff for children).

https://www.gov.uk/child-funeral-costs

Support for child funeral costs (Children’s Funeral Fund for England)

How to apply to the Children’s Funeral Fund for help paying for a funeral for a child under 18

https://www.gov.uk/child-funeral-costs

mcmooberry · 20/08/2023 10:11

I have no problem with these at all and regularly give even if I don't directly know the person/family if it's a reliable link. Wouldn't ever donate to someone fundraising for a trip but sometimes awful things happen to people and if the only way you can help a tiny bit is financial, then happy to do that.

sparklelikeadiamond · 20/08/2023 09:55

I would never donate to any where the purpose for the money is unclear. Also ones which involve someone not bothering to take out travel insurance!

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 09:54

Another family member is an 80 year old carer, she waited months for two weeks respite and can't just work harder if there was something she needed. Even if she was younger, she wouldn't be able to work at all.

AvengedQuince · 20/08/2023 09:47

boboshmobo · 20/08/2023 09:13

@AvengedQuince child goes to school /
Playgroup/ respite

That's not going to be the case for many people with a family member with a disability or illness though. My family member's husband is struggling to make ends meet on one wage let alone save for the mobility aids she needs.

OilOfRoses · 20/08/2023 09:42

Lorrymum · 20/08/2023 09:30

If a total stranger appeared on your doorstep asking for a donation would you give them money? Its the "distance" that social media provides that makes it acceptable.

It's also easier to just click away than say no to someone's face. I wasn't asked for money but gave the local homeless man a 20 as I walked past him the other day. I prefer that sort of giving as it's on my own initiative and not demanded.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 09:37

Thanks @Lorrymum for this perspective. I think you have articulated how I feel about it, much more succinctly than I could.

OP posts:
Lorrymum · 20/08/2023 09:30

If a total stranger appeared on your doorstep asking for a donation would you give them money? Its the "distance" that social media provides that makes it acceptable.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 09:26

@HalliwellManor so sorry for your loss. The loss of anyone is heartbreaking, but especially harrowing, someone so young.

My post isn’t against Gofundme in the way your sister did. It’s the ones aimed at strangers.

OP posts:
Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 09:19

@FutureThroughLensOfThePast it doesn’t have to be that much. Obviously costs vary on location, but plans can be as little as £900. In one of my responses I explained that we did a payment plan with the funeral director with a small deposit and a more expensive memorial when we could afford it.
I personally don’t think it should be the responsibility of the friends and family and that’s why I’m trying to make provision for mine and DH is doing the same, but I definitely don’t think it’s the responsibility of strangers either, which is the point of my post, there are so many just giving pages asking strangers to cover costs.

OP posts:
HalliwellManor · 20/08/2023 09:18

My sister set one up on my behalf when my 22 year old son died of Cancer in 2021,as a single (working) mom with an 8 year old I had no spare cash to fund his funeral,or to even save up prior,I couldn't even comprehend the thought he was going to die let alone try to save up for a funeral.As a normal working family even if we all pitched in it wouldn't have been enough to cover everything.One day he was getting ready to go to see his favourite football team then he took a sudden turn for the worse one and was gone 3 days later.
Most of the donations were from his friends,their families,wider families etc and I will be eternally grateful from the bottom of my heart that we could give him a funeral that reflected the beautiful,courageous and amazing young man that he was.
Every penny went on the funeral,headstone and memorial to him and I genuinely don't know what I would have done without GoFundme and the utter kindness of people 💔.

boboshmobo · 20/08/2023 09:13

@AvengedQuince child goes to school /
Playgroup/ respite

OilOfRoses · 20/08/2023 09:11

People can give if they want to. I have a policy of not giving if I don't know the people personally. Knowing someone personally, there was one time I chose not to give to their fundraiser. I don't like funeral ones. Yes, they are expensive and sudden but when I had to pay for one in full, I used credit cards and paid them off over time. I just feel like, "I had to pay for my funeral, pay for yours." Maybe that's not fair but I can't help how I feel. Like everyone, use your own judgement.

Cringeworth · 20/08/2023 09:10

@MistressoftheDarkSide I’m interested to know why it’s distasteful to prepare for a funeral. I hope I’m not going anywhere soon, but I’ve spoken to DH about my wishes, what I would like, what I don’t want money to be wasted on. We do have a pot which we absolutely try not to touch (I starting saving this when my nana explained what a pauper’s funeral in the ‘olden’ days was.) Of course with the cost of living and everything else, it’s getting harder and harder to keep that pot going to one side, but if we do dip into it I would prioritise replenishing this first. We don’t have a pot for DC, but God forbid if they went first we would use our pot. I absolutely don’t think everyone has to do what I have done at all, but just wonder why what I have done is ‘distasteful.’?

If people haven’t made their own preparations one of the options I suggested was asking friends and family and said these pages are a good way to reach out to them. Payment plan with funeral directors and options with the council which I added to my more outing response. I don’t think a just giving page so be the default option for all the situations I see them for. I don’t see anyway that strangers can know if someone is genuine and it’s not a scam if it’s common place to ask strangers.

OP posts:
FutureThroughLensOfThePast · 20/08/2023 08:51

In the case of funerals, the only thing certain in life is death, so I’m not sure why people do not prepare for funerals (I get unexpected deaths re: accidents) but I can’t understand that family and friends can’t cobble enough together to cover this.

The average cost of a funeral is about £4k. That's a lot to 'cobble together'. Not everyone has a large family or lots of friends. And it isn't the fault of those left behind that the deceased hasn't made provision for a funeral.

No one is forced to donate.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 20/08/2023 08:45

My second post was aimed at a poster who loftily claimed that is what they would do.

Look, there are scammers out there, there is actual fraud, some “causes” may be dubious.

These platforms exist and if your main concern is protecting people who can’t afford to donate from being scammed then that’s fine.

But your opening post specifically mentioned funeral cost fund raising and that it’s something that should be covered or prepared for in advance. Others have said it’s distasteful end of story.

I appreciate this is very personal on my part, but guilt and shame and the grieving process mean that it’s a touchy subject and one I struggle with as the reason I got “free money” was because my soul mate died horribly and my life as I recognise it is now over.

I’m fully aware I don’t have to look at threads or comment if it upsets me, before anyone suggests I step away from the internet, but actually there are some judgemental comments here about motivation and morality that really do twist the knife and it’s very much a “walk a mile in my shoes” situation.

I didn’t want money. I wanted my DP not to be dead. Without the money though I might now be homeless. I might still end up that way, but hey ho.

People can ask for money for anything they want. They can set up frauds. People can choose to donate - or not. You can judge people for doing it, or being gullible enough to fall for it all you like.

If you have concerns then report them.

But is it a case of “It’s not right” or…. “It’s not fair” ….. ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread