Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does being married to a doctor make you middle class?

137 replies

GirlGeorgina · 19/08/2023 15:05

Like if you got married to a doctor (who is male) and you’re not a doctor yourself, does it make you middle class now?

I am not married but someone who is marrying a doctor but not a doctor herself said it makes you middle class too.

Yes it does - YANBU

No it doesn’t - YABU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DosCervezas · 22/08/2023 21:32

Sociological definitions of social class use the occupation of the chief income earner as the allocation of a person's social class. A doctor would be either class I or class Ii, depending on their responsibilities and level. The term ' middle class ' doesn't actually exist in the measure, but it can informally be taken to include either those two groups a doctor could be in.

bleuclair · 22/08/2023 20:26

AllyCart · 22/08/2023 16:39

Your friend is slightly bonkers...

Off-topic but I work in the US a lot and notice that Americans talk about class as if it's wealth dependent.

And by middle class they mean average. When I've heard it and asked.

SallyWD · 22/08/2023 17:08

Oh who cares?! The fact is if a cockney marries a doctor they'll always be seen as working class and so what? Nothing wrong with that.

AllyCart · 22/08/2023 16:39

Your friend is slightly bonkers...

Off-topic but I work in the US a lot and notice that Americans talk about class as if it's wealth dependent.

Lingfield01 · 22/08/2023 16:24

It makes you a doctors wife. Why does class even matter?

Bellyblueboy · 21/08/2023 10:21

I have a friend who is a mechanic - he is married to a doctor. They drive an Audi and live in a nice house. But he is still the same person he was before he met his husband. Still has the same hobbies, accent, qualifications, tastes etc.

nameitagain · 20/08/2023 14:34

Have you never come across couples where one is middle class and one is working class? That's what your friend will be OP

Beezknees · 20/08/2023 14:15

palygold · 20/08/2023 12:32

I don't think you can change your class. It's more than a job and how much money you earn, it's to do with your upbringing, it's something that is intrenched in you from childhood.

Absolutely agree with this.

An unskilled manual worker, or someone claiming benefits, living on a council estate, can be middle or upper class, we learned this early on when studying politics, but I think it's common sense. They don't suddenly become working class because their financial situation has changed. They wouldn't be accepted as such. They still have their accent and background and would find it difficult to fit in.

Reverse that for the working class person with increased income, after say becoming a doctor, and it's quite the same really.

In the class threads the consensus is usually that it can take a generation or two to change class, so your children's children. A couple of celebrity examples are often used (I think the Beckhams is one).

Absolutely this.

If Prince William decided to quit royal life and went to work in a warehouse, he still wouldn't be working class. He's had an upper class upbringing, his values, ideologies and experiences in life are not working class and never will be. Equally if I won the euromillions tomorrow and never had to work another day in my life and started going to the opera and michelin restaurants, I'd still be working class due to my upbringing and life.

palygold · 20/08/2023 12:32

HarrietJet · 20/08/2023 11:17

Doctors are most definitely not working class as even brand new graduates doing their foundation training earn over £32k
Earning £32k catapults you straight into the middle classes? Ok...

😀

palygold · 20/08/2023 12:32

I don't think you can change your class. It's more than a job and how much money you earn, it's to do with your upbringing, it's something that is intrenched in you from childhood.

Absolutely agree with this.

An unskilled manual worker, or someone claiming benefits, living on a council estate, can be middle or upper class, we learned this early on when studying politics, but I think it's common sense. They don't suddenly become working class because their financial situation has changed. They wouldn't be accepted as such. They still have their accent and background and would find it difficult to fit in.

Reverse that for the working class person with increased income, after say becoming a doctor, and it's quite the same really.

In the class threads the consensus is usually that it can take a generation or two to change class, so your children's children. A couple of celebrity examples are often used (I think the Beckhams is one).

HarrietJet · 20/08/2023 11:17

Doctors are most definitely not working class as even brand new graduates doing their foundation training earn over £32k
Earning £32k catapults you straight into the middle classes? Ok...

Beezknees · 20/08/2023 11:12

I don't think you can change your class. It's more than a job and how much money you earn, it's to do with your upbringing, it's something that is intrenched in you from childhood.

So no, being married to a doctor doesn't make you middle class, nor does actually being a doctor make you middle class if you had a working class upbringing.

CoffeeBean5 · 20/08/2023 11:05

BarbaraofSeville · 20/08/2023 09:21

Your average plumber, builder or any other trade will likely earn more than a newly qualified doctor.

Plus there's a lot more to whether 'things and experiences' are affordable than income and profession, such as age and where people live.

A 50 YO digger driver in Leeds will likely have far more disposable income than a 30 year old doctor in London, especially if the doctor has young children.

What are these 'things and experiences' to which you refer?

These threads always go the same way, with comments that make no sense unless you are incorrectly mistaking the working classes for people who wouldn't look out of place on the Jeremy Kyle show instead of people with very similar incomes, outlooks and interests to those described as middle class but without the snobbery and long established access to education.

I was raised in a working class family and had/have young parents. Dad worked full time, mum was a SAHM before going into part time employment. Neither are in a 'middle class' jobs. I wasn't raised on a council estate surrounded by 'Jeremy Kyle' types as you mention in your comment.

However, I went to university and have a career that isn't working class. Doctors are most definitely not working class as even brand new graduates doing their foundation training earn over £32k. If a tradesman earns lots of money and lives in a 4 bed detached house etc then yes, he is middle class too. Social class depends on your job, education, and lifestyle. There's so many factors that determine social class.

Finishingoff · 20/08/2023 10:33

I’m from what people would probably describe as a (lower) middle class background. I’m a university lecturer, have a PhD etc. I’m ‘well-spoken’ (I’m often told), like art, literature, opera etc and I’ve often been described as middle class.

DH was brought up on a council estate, has a strong Liverpool accent, like football and boxing and the pub. He has a first class RG degree, works in banking in a very senior role and earns 200k. No-one ever describes him as middle class and he often describes being looked down on by the old boys in work. People constantly underestimate him and assume he’s a bit of an oik (other people’s words there, not mine).

The perception of class is complex, and isn’t just about occupation or salary but a whole host of interrelated factors.

For those saying class is outdated, it should be, yet we’re still talking about it so in that sense it’s still very much relevant.

RosesAndHellebores · 20/08/2023 10:22

@HarrietJet I agree about the earnings in the bank or pocket but the difference between trades and doctors (and other professions/public sector vocations) is: generous pension scheme (with generous death in service benefits), paid annual leave/compassionate leave/bereavement leave, sick pay (often 6 months full/6 months half), and for NHS HCPs in particular significant job security.

HP89 · 20/08/2023 10:10

RosesAndHellebores · 20/08/2023 08:49

Medical Dr's are well educated. I'm not so sure how middle class they are nowadays. More usually they seem to be a bunch of whinging, striking ingrates who appear unable to keep their personal politics outside the workplace.

Sadly their conduct is losing them respect.

You sound Pretty whiny to be honest. Let’s hope you don’t need a Dr soon.

Jk987 · 20/08/2023 09:36

Do people think being middle class is superior?

BarbaraofSeville · 20/08/2023 09:21

CoffeeBean5 · 20/08/2023 08:38

A medical doctor can be raised in a working class family but they cannot be working class once they are a doctor. They earn too much to be considered working class. This includes new doctors in foundation training. This means they can afford things and experiences that aren't easily available for working class people.

Your average plumber, builder or any other trade will likely earn more than a newly qualified doctor.

Plus there's a lot more to whether 'things and experiences' are affordable than income and profession, such as age and where people live.

A 50 YO digger driver in Leeds will likely have far more disposable income than a 30 year old doctor in London, especially if the doctor has young children.

What are these 'things and experiences' to which you refer?

These threads always go the same way, with comments that make no sense unless you are incorrectly mistaking the working classes for people who wouldn't look out of place on the Jeremy Kyle show instead of people with very similar incomes, outlooks and interests to those described as middle class but without the snobbery and long established access to education.

HarrietJet · 20/08/2023 09:21

CoffeeBean5 · 20/08/2023 08:38

A medical doctor can be raised in a working class family but they cannot be working class once they are a doctor. They earn too much to be considered working class. This includes new doctors in foundation training. This means they can afford things and experiences that aren't easily available for working class people.

They earn too much to be considered working class??
Plenty of trades people earn far more than your average doctor.

Helpfulperson123 · 20/08/2023 09:18

The first rule of being middle class is you don’t talk about being middle class.
The second rule of being middle class is you don’t talk about being middle class.

OilOfRoses · 20/08/2023 08:53

I think it depends on the doctor. The doctors I've known who are GPs are very much ordinary every day people in terms of lifestyle and how they find affordability. Specialists, on the other hand, have a much higher income I believe.

RosesAndHellebores · 20/08/2023 08:49

Medical Dr's are well educated. I'm not so sure how middle class they are nowadays. More usually they seem to be a bunch of whinging, striking ingrates who appear unable to keep their personal politics outside the workplace.

Sadly their conduct is losing them respect.

LunaTheCat · 20/08/2023 08:44

“Middle Class” is a state of mind 😉

Sigmama · 20/08/2023 08:42

Doctor is a middle class profession

CoffeeBean5 · 20/08/2023 08:38

LunaTheCat · 20/08/2023 07:00

It’s absolute possible for a doctor to be completely working class!

A medical doctor can be raised in a working class family but they cannot be working class once they are a doctor. They earn too much to be considered working class. This includes new doctors in foundation training. This means they can afford things and experiences that aren't easily available for working class people.