Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just turned 14 year old daughter out until 7am in holiday town

308 replies

Teenoutallnight · 19/08/2023 09:00

I just want to get some other opinions on this as I’m really angry with both my DD14 and her dad. For context we’re not together and haven’t been for many years and at some points have co-parented fine.

They visit a holiday park in the UK several times a year. A couple of months ago, when she was there, it turned out she had stayed out until at least 3.30 in the morning, sitting on the sea front, with a couple of teen boys (friends). I found this out because I was looking for a photo on her camera roll and saw pictures taken of her and friends at those times. Her dad didn’t even stay up to make sure she got back in safely. At the time her punishment was to not be able to stay down there for more than one night and to let me know when she was in and safe.

Fast forward to today and she has come back from a week away down there. We’d turned on family sharing on apple so I could see her location. On her last night she turned this off. It turns out she got home at 7am having been out roaming the town all night. She just turned 14 two weeks ago. She was with two friends and two new kids they’d met. I have no idea what they were doing 10-7am and not did her dad or any of the other parents. Her dad did know she was out though and allowed her to stay out/went to bed himself.

She was given boundaries and trust and I really feel like she’s broken them. She’s also an emotional wreck having had a night of no sleep. I plan to take her phone away for a week and not allow her to go down there again this year (park closes in October)

Her dad for his part lied and said he was stargazing with her and then that he was with them but she’s said he wasn’t. He has also said that he thinks the freedom is good for her and that she was ‘safe’ as she was with other kids. I don’t think freedom is a kid with their location turned off with other kids (some of whom they don’t know) roaming the town until 7am.

I guess I’m asking how you would respond to this, are my punishments too harsh (she’s devastated about losing her Snapchat streak), would you be angry?

For voting purposes

YABU - chill she’s 14 and being out until 7am is reasonable
YANBU - not a chance in hell my 14 year old would be allowed to be out until 7am

OP posts:
TheLadyofShalott1 · 19/08/2023 10:39

liveforsummer · 19/08/2023 09:25

My logic was that it was something she had turned off (location etc) which was part of our agreeement.

This is something you can't really insist on when she's with another parent though. He can of course insist on this but he clearly hasn't so still she's followed the boundary of the one parenting her at the time

@liveforsummer Why do you think that @Teenoutallnight cannot insist on her daughter keeping the app on that shows her location?

Just because she is staying with her dad does not stop her from being the OP's daughter, or stop the OP from being very concerned for her daughter's welfare! Where did you find this "rule" that says
she has to follow the boundary of only one parent at a time? It is nonsensical and potentially a very dangerous thought process.

Life would be great if both parents (any parents of any child) always agreed on what was best for the welfare of their joint child, but when they don't agree, and it is about a subject as important as this one, then the parent with the stronger (and realistic) concerns needs to be the one that is listened to. If the other parent does not agree with any safeguarding rules then that is the hill that the more protective parent needs to be "willing to die on" ie go back to the courtroom if necessary!

In other words, and using this situation as an example, the OP has a safeguarding rule with her DD that the location app is shared with the OP, and must be kept on at all times. If the DD then deliberately goes against that agreement with her DM then Mum automatically has the right to punish her DD in a way to make sure that that situation never rises again.

On this occasion my punishment - way to correct my DD's potentially dangerous behaviour - would not have been as strong as the OP's (if this was the first time her DD had turned off her location on her phone). I would have told my DD that I was giving her one more chance to stick to the necessary safeguarding rules, but if she ever did that again before she reached adulthood, I would be keeping her phone (for varying lengths of time depending on how often those rules get broken in the future - hopefully never - and also, if relevant, not letting her go to her Dad's or wherever the dangerous behaviour takes place.

If my actions meant my ex took me back to Court over my refusal to let my DD visit him, or go on holiday with him, then I would have ready a detailed list of how and/or why it wasn't safe to let my DD stay with her Dad. It would then be up to the Court to decide which - if either of us - was in the right.

Staplesonstamps · 19/08/2023 10:38

I think you need to have a calm chat with DD. Explain you are upset because YOU LOVE HER, you aren’t some raging fun sucker but a mum who would be devastated if anything awful happened to her. Explain you aren’t making boundaries because you get kicks out of it, there are boundaries because it’s what loving parents do, protect their children.

I’d say you understand it’s hard for her to ‘decide’ to come in at a better hour when her dad is green lighting running feral but you did have a deal, location services on, and she went back on that. Explain, if she went missing having her phone traceable is important and gives you some peace of mind that even if her Dad is allowing unsafe things you have some idea of where she is. Tell her if social services knew he just lets his 14 year old go awol overnight and goes to bed they would take a dim view of it.

ask your ex, what’s more important to him? Being a ‘cool dad’ and not doing the hard parts of parenting and in doing so putting his child at risk of unsafe behaviours/ assault/death or actually being a fucking parent and keeping his child safe and making her feel her parents actually care about her safety.

seriously the only part of this that’s on her is turning location services off as you had an agreement. The rest is on her dad allowing this behaviour with his blessing.

wtf is he even doing all evening/overnight whilst she’s out and about? Why does he find it easier to her her elsewhere and not indoors with him? How can he even sleep if he has no idea where she is and what’s she’s doing? How would he feel if the police came knocking on the morning? How would he explain he just lets a 14 year old go wandering all night?

Raptorius · 19/08/2023 10:37

Dad is the problem here, sounds like he just wanted rid of her for the night, but DD still needs sanction for turning off her phone. That was agreed between you and she deliberately tried to deceive. You had explained the consequences of being out late and alone on a different occasion and that it was something she would not be allowed to do under your care…so she tries Dad instead? Just because it is natural teen behaviour doesn’t mean OP shouldn’t give a punishment.
Interested in why her dad lied about the stargazing - guilt/just wanting you out of the loop because he disagrees with parenting decisions?

Twinsmummy1812 · 19/08/2023 10:36

I wouldn’t be too harsh with her because she told you the truth and that shows you have a good relationship. Her father is to blame here and I would be livid with him but your daughter knows what she did wrong and told you anyway. Refusing to let her go there again this year is actually a good punishment because you can just say that you can’t trust her to keep herself safe and make good choices yet and unfortunately you can’t trust her dad to either.

Endofroadinhs · 19/08/2023 10:33

Total lack of safe or effective parenting from your ex.

This would be the last time she would be having overnights with him until she is old enough to make sensible choices and take steps to maintain her own safety.

Yalta · 19/08/2023 10:33

I think punishing her for her dads lax attitude isn’t going to work
All that will happen is she will say she is in bed, tell you she is going to sleep then leave the phone inside and go out without it which to me is far more dangerous.

Friends of dc did this and their parents to this day live in blissful ignorance.

I do think that the main punishment lies with the father and her not going to the holiday park if he won’t put in boundaries and refuses to see the danger and doesn’t wait up for her.

I must admit that dd was out till all hours at that age. But we live in London and she was with friends and they stuck to the busy areas which have loads of people around and she had tracking on her phone. I would also wait up till she texted/rang to say she was back at her friends place or they needed picking up

TakeMeToTheCloudsAbove · 19/08/2023 10:31

Her dad is a dick. She’s 14.

You say she’s an emotional wreck. Are you sure she’s ok and not been raped or sexually assaulted?…How about drink/drugs?

Please don’t be angry with her until you’re sure she’s actually ok. Something might have happened to her, she might need you.

Needapadlockonmyfridge · 19/08/2023 10:30

I feel for you. Teens are tough, doubly so when you have different views from your ex about what constitutes parenting.

Your Ex is being neglectful.
I don't think she is safe in his care overnight . I think you need to spell that out to him. If he can't keep her safe, she can't do overnights.

Jamjarcandlestick · 19/08/2023 10:27

OP I feel sick on your behalf.

are you in communication with any of his family? Ask them to give his head a wobble.

Not to scare you, but maybe give his head a wobble could you ask him to sort out BC for his daughter.

also agree with PP for someone slightly older than her to to give her a chat on staying safe/give her a couple of horror stories.

Guiltridden12345 · 19/08/2023 10:27

And I regularly take phone as a sanction. It’s a killer for a teen (I too have a 13/14 yr old) so it hits home in a way other sanctions don’t. I have a great relationship with my teen so disagree sanctions will make her hate you. They may resent it at the time but they do get it if you take the time to explain reasoning (find my function for safety, you turned it off deliberately, trust issue, here’s the sanction) and are firm in your boundaries. It’s a rare but useful sanction; if I do it my teen knows a) shes overstepped the mark and b) I mean business, hence she doesn’t argue. And afterwards we chat so she understands the underlying learning intended by the sanction.

Gnomegnomegnome · 19/08/2023 10:27

She shouldn’t be going to dads if he can’t ensure her safety. Simple as that.

We see it a lot in Newquay and Rock, young teens on holiday with their families who are no where to be seen. As an adult I wouldn’t be out alone in the early hours around here.

CarSeatNeeded · 19/08/2023 10:27

Another one who thinks she testing her father. She knows this isn’t proper parenting. She’s pushing him to react, respond, worry because she knows from her mother that’s the appropriate parental response. His behaviour is screaming I don’t give a shit, you aren’t worth worrying about. Last time she came back really late and he didn’t notice or care. So this time she stayed out until breakfast to see if that had an impact.

next she’ll find an older boyfriend to be a father figure who cares, and he’ll also treat her badly because that’s the standard she expects from men who are supposed to love you.

BCBird · 19/08/2023 10:24

It easier for him to be cool, read here irresponsible, dad and worse for you to be strict, read here responsible, mom.

LaMadameCholet · 19/08/2023 10:23

She doesn’t need punishing, she needs protecting. This is an appalling lack of care of such a young girl.

CharlieBoo · 19/08/2023 10:23

Absolutely not on.. i just wouldn’t let her go again.

RainCloudsInTheSky · 19/08/2023 10:23

I wouldn’t let my 14 year old do it either so yanbu but I’m not sure about punishing her as she did have her dads permission. It’s not like she snuck out in the night or anything like that. Dad was ok with it. It’s a tricky one.

BCBird · 19/08/2023 10:22

OP I think it her dad who needs to be spoken to severely. He is ridiculous and frim what you say a liar too.. It not fair to punish her because you can't get him to be responsible. As for turning her fone off, no doubt it is because she didnt want you to know.

Guiltridden12345 · 19/08/2023 10:22

Agggh posted too soon!

…that allowed you to check that she was safe. And make it clear that the rules are to keep her safe not ruin her fun and make it clear that boundaries at home must be followed too. Don’t make her an enemy but so point out what can happen to vulnerable girls who are out unsupervised at night.

RadishesForYou · 19/08/2023 10:21

ArabeIIaKarenScott · 19/08/2023 10:15

I think you are in a very tough situation. I am not sure I would want to punish my child for behaving exactly as a young teenager does when parents are absent. It's her dad who needs to be punished; what an absolute waste of space he is.

I don't think all teenagers would go out all night, tbh. I think this may be OP's DD actually begging for someone to look out for her - pushing the boundary as a kind of cry for help.

Yes, I agree she is crying out for boundaries just as all teenagers do, but she isn't going to get any from her useless father. So she will keep pushing - and being at risk :(

Guiltridden12345 · 19/08/2023 10:20

I think I’d be saying to dad that ye can’t have her in overnights at all because of the negligent parenting. Young girjs out all hours are vulnerable and will meet undesirable people who see their vulnerabilities and prey on them. Drugs, sec, crime etc are all too available at night when most Kids are tucked up.

If he doesn’t agree to proper rules that keep her safe then I’d deny access and call in social services with the all nighter story as key evidence. It sounds extreme but it’s your job to keep her safe; you know of his negligent parenting and are obligated to act. If she is attacked, raped or worse, you would never forgive yourself for not acting and arguably would share some responsibility for allowing the situation to continue if you don’t.

i agree on not punishing her for following dads rules. I do agree with sanction for turning off the facility that allowed you to check that eye was

XelaM · 19/08/2023 10:18

I have a 13-year-old and your ex is fucking nuts to have allowed that and gone to bed!

I think not allowing her to go back us reasonable, but taking her phone is not. You're just alienating her. I would also allow her to continue her Snap streaks. But I'm quite soft 🤷‍♀️ Having a good relationship with your teen is important though and taking their phone will just make them hate you.

Sugarfree23 · 19/08/2023 10:17

cocunut · 19/08/2023 09:18

YABU and very precious. They're in a group, they have phones, they're in a holiday park..?? I don't see the issue at all here unless they are drinking underage which obviously is illegal and dangerous.

Are you being serious?
She's 14 little or no supervision, you have no idea who she is hanging out with or what they are doing in the middle of the night, drink, drugs, sex?

Op I'd be asking what the Dad thinks she is doing?

Thesenderofthiscard · 19/08/2023 10:17

MY BFF had absent parents and a lot of freedom, I was very envious when we were teens but she is still dealing with MH issues 30 years on from that time.
She had experiences far too young, she wasn’t ready. And she got in some very dicey situations that could have gone very very wrong.

ArabeIIaKarenScott · 19/08/2023 10:15

I think you are in a very tough situation. I am not sure I would want to punish my child for behaving exactly as a young teenager does when parents are absent. It's her dad who needs to be punished; what an absolute waste of space he is.

I don't think all teenagers would go out all night, tbh. I think this may be OP's DD actually begging for someone to look out for her - pushing the boundary as a kind of cry for help.

bemorelemmy · 19/08/2023 10:15

HamishTheCamel · 19/08/2023 09:10

I don't think it's fair to punish her. Her dad is the one I'd be mad at!

good point

Swipe left for the next trending thread