Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel affected by the Lucy Letby case

62 replies

GemGi · 19/08/2023 02:55

I gave birth to my first DC in April. During my pregnancy there was lots on the news about Lucy Letby. One thing I explicitly told DH was if anything happened to me during childbirth, not to let DC out of his sight and to ask what each and every thing (if anything) was being done to DC and why. I was absolutely terrified. DC is nearly 5 months now and all this Lucy Letby stuff in the news feels really grim. I can't bear to watch/read about it. It makes me feel sick and so nervous and scared for babies and parents. I wonder if I've developed some kind of anxiety.

AIBU to feel this way? The entire story is sickening and scary and sad so I don't know if I am BU..?

OP posts:
Azaleah · 20/08/2023 03:10

Is there anything REASONABLE about this case? No. It's perfectly reasonable to be UNREASONABLE. Don't let this feeling control you but learn how to be vigilant.

tempgernard · 20/08/2023 03:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

coxesorangepippin · 20/08/2023 02:25

I agree with a lot that's been said on here

What surprises me the most is her motive. I just cannot get over it at all. No doubt it's power and a god complex.

But how easily she was accepted and trusted and believed. We judge people too easily on their appearance

Those poor parents of those poor children. My heart is absolutely with them all

Mammadibambini · 20/08/2023 01:42

You’re not being unreasonable.

my baby is 1 year now and I feel it too. I was suspicious of harm coming to her and I hadn’t heard about this case at that time. I wouldn’t let her go anywhere without my partner. He went with them when they put her nappy on etc. She’s the most precious thing in the world to me and i didn’t trust strangers with her when she was just born.

That being said if you’re struggling with these feelings and they’re affecting your everyday please reach out to your local perinatal mental health team.

reesewithoutaspoon · 20/08/2023 00:22

There are already systems in place to monitor for unexpected deaths the PIMS score and Mbrace in neonates. They predict expected mortality using algorithms based on observations at admission. All units should be monitoring their mortality rates. You compare your predicted mortality Vs your actual mortality and any variance should be investigated.
The sudden rise at coch was noted by the clinicians quite early on. It was the failure of management to recognise how serious it was and to act on it. There should have been serious case reviews and mortality and morbidity meetings.
Going from 3 death's a year to 3 per month was a huge increase and a massive warning sign that something was seriously wrong

Hunkydorybalamory · 20/08/2023 00:06

@Yellowlegobrick

HDU is often cubicled. ICU environments are mostly not, for good reasons (which I'll come to).

So we are are talking 8+ critically or at least seriously unwell babies in one room with constant alarms. Parents and babies who have a need for privacy and dignity at critical moments (which may require the other parents to leave the room). Staff who need to perform safely and effectively whilst they undertake technically challenging high stakes procedures, and could not reasonably do or even have space to move if being being scrutinised by 8+ sets of parents. Parents could get no sleep at all, having parent beds would be almost pointless. Babies are in these nurseries sometimes for weeks-months.

So there's no way parents could sleep next to their babies in a non-partitioned (eg open plan) NICU setting (other than in the low intensity feeding, growing and soon to go home nurseries - in which case there is already a big drive for this but it is limited by the need to overhaul the physical layout of units / space available which often isn't logistically possible). Even if it were logistically possible to introduce partitioned ICU spaces (eg cubicles) to allow 24/7 parent presence with facilities for sleep - this approach would come with inherent safety risks in an ICU setting (reduced oversight of critically unwell patients, difficulty re where to keep lifesaving equipment - the more duplicates of critical equipment there are the more likely a stock or settings error, but you ideally want this equipment immediately to hand and in the same room as critically unwell patients).

Also, the approach of partitioning medical spaces could counterproductively increase the risk of malicious harm by increasing the opportunities for perpetrators to be alone and unwitnessed with a patient.

The truth is that injecting air into an IV line is easy and takes seconds. You could probably do it whilst a parent was awake at the bedside and they may not be aware. You could easily do it whilst they were asleep.

The only thing I can think of on a systems level to tackle the issue of medical serial killers is to embed a formalised process of asking "could this be a serial killer?" into the SI review process. Every single unexpected death is investigated but the question of whether it is a serial killer is not likely to be asked. But there are risks also to this approach - the possible effects on staff morale, the possible effects on staff relationships (because generally, respect, empathy and trust make teams more effective at keeping patients safe but these are effectively barriers to identifying a colleague as a serial killer), the possible room for abuse (imagine such an investigative approach being weaponised against a whistleblower for example), the possible damage to systems focused culture (which is more likely to result in system change and improved patient safety vs individual blame culture which makes people afraid to reflect honestly on mistakes and why they occur, and ultimately reduces patient safety). So it's a quandary. I guess maybe there could be national mandatory safeguarding guidance on when to involve the police (or potentially some specialised expert professional whose entire job is to look for evidence of medical serial killers?) - eg if insulin OD is suggested or plausible, if unexpected deaths cross a certain threshold, if a member of staff feels concerned about it, if there is an identifiable but unexplained pattern of some kind to the deaths. I think it is very hard to systemically detect/prevent something so rare and so different to other patient safety hazards (and the overzealous pursuit of which could potentially increase those other less dramatic but more impactful hazards).

Sorry didn't mean to ramble on.

HeddaGarbled · 19/08/2023 23:48

I think it’s healthier not to want to read all the details. People who read it all avidly are prurient and a bit warped, IMO. Of course it’s upsetting.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 19/08/2023 23:42

I'm so so glad that I didn't hear about her before I had DS earlier this year, my anxiety would have been through the roof. There is so much that is done that is barely explained

Lou670 · 19/08/2023 23:27

It hasn't affected me because I have a baby/young child. It has affected me as one of my babies is now a paediatric nurse! 😕

Friggingfrog · 19/08/2023 23:27

I think it’s normal to be affected by the case- it’s unthinkable cruelty. CoCH is one of my local hospitals. I didn’t have my kids there but my sister and friends did around that time, with one friends baby being in nicu there in 2015. Lots of people where I am know of people affected and it’s so close to home I can’t get it out of my mind. Just have to remind yourself that it isn’t the norm and like a pp says 99.999999% of nurses are trustworthy and doing the job to help people. She is an outlier and is safely behind bars now.

IWasFunBeforeMum · 19/08/2023 23:24

My first child was born at the countess the year after she was stopped and it's chilled me watching it all. Those poor poor families.

CClaire · 19/08/2023 23:21

I was talking to dh about this and he pointed out that it’s such a shame that 99.999999% of paediatric nurses are in it for the right reasons and yet she’s brought the whole lot of them into disrepute through the actions of one completely anomalous nutter and now their jobs are going to be so much harder when really we should be recognising that she’s not representative of them in any way. It’s just hard to get past the mind blowing aspect of it though.

Yellowlegobrick · 19/08/2023 23:12

I think there'll be a backlash of parents refusing to leave little babies in nicu and insisting it become like paed wards where you can sleep by the bedside.

I remember when my DC was in hospital at a few months old being surprised it was a given i could stay with them in the hospital, because i thought it would be like nicu and be sent home. Even then i remember thinking it was odd & that if they could have the fold out bed in paediatric high dependency unit they could have it in NICU.

Yellowlegobrick · 19/08/2023 23:08

I had to leave my prem baby overnight in nicu for 2 weeks. You weren't allowed to sleep there.

I just have constant shudders thinking about this case and that my baby was out of my sight for 10 hours every night, entrusted to nurses. I feel sick thinking about it.

KenIsAnAccessory · 19/08/2023 23:02

YANBU. We put our /our DC'/loved ones lived in these peoples hands. This will shake the trust of many people to the core, in the same way Wayne Couzens did for the police (along with many other cases). I am already thinking of responses to being asked to leave if any of my DC are admitted because no matter how small the chance I just won't be taking it. In the same way that after Sarah Everard was murdered I thought about how I'd react if pulled over late at night by a police officer.

These institutions are supposed to be here to serve us (at our cost, of course, and I'm happy to pay), but they are all too quick to say that it is indivduals at fault, however in both the police and NHS there are serious cultural and systemic failings that have allowed these things to happen.

Rockfordpeach · 19/08/2023 22:50

I think it's normal. I had a preemie who was on life support and spent a month in NICU, it was a very distressing and vulnerable time and the nurses were incredible but all the Letby stuff sends a shiver down my spine that it could have been so different

FarmGirl78 · 19/08/2023 22:47

Riapia · 19/08/2023 06:46

I believe in God. And know that those babies are now in heaven which does help knowing that.

You are claiming to know something that you cannot possibly know. It’s just a belief.

@Riapia, learn when to pick your battles. There's a time and a place, and this isn't it. Leave it be.

mrshenny · 19/08/2023 11:27

Riapia · 19/08/2023 06:46

I believe in God. And know that those babies are now in heaven which does help knowing that.

You are claiming to know something that you cannot possibly know. It’s just a belief.

Irrelevant

Dolores87 · 19/08/2023 10:10

I don't think you are being unreasonable.

Tbh when my girl needed taking to NICU i asked partner to stay with me instead because I was very overwhelmed and I felt i needed his advocacy. I absolutely hated leaving her when I was discharged and she wasnt though. If this trial had gone off at the same time she was born I think i would have ended up very ill with post natal anxiety about leaving her.

Daveismyhero · 19/08/2023 10:06

Absolutely not. I'm fue in December and having this all over the news has made me absolutely terrified to go into hospital (I suffer from anxiety and catastrophise everything) I will absolutely not be letting baby out of my or my husbands sight after reading all of this

ssd · 19/08/2023 08:33

I think the most bewildering thing in all this is she seemed so normal.

It reminds me of a scene in The Addams Family when they are all dressing up to go to a Halloween party and Wednesday Addams ,the young girl in pigtails, comes downstairs dressed in her normal clothes.. Morticia her mum says Wednesday aren't you dressing up and Wednesday says yes mum I'm going as a psychopath they look like this all the family nod and agree with her

So bloody scary. YANBU.

Andthereyougo · 19/08/2023 08:28

I think it’s totally normal to feel affected.
I’m probably much older than your mum ( so not likely to have a baby, even my dgc are getting older) but was in tears and so depressed last night. The Letby case, those poor parents, the shock and grief they must be going through. The little girl found dead, alone in a house and it seems her father who had custody of her has simply fled the country. What did the poor child go through. I just felt total despair.
Take time for you today, cuddle your dc. It’s normal to take time to process emotions.

ChesCazza · 19/08/2023 08:19

It's normal OP.

Firstly, having a baby affects women in a lot of different ways and it's common to be anxious etc afterwards. It also sounds like you had a possibly traumatic birth if you needed surgery afterwards? That increases the likelihood of PND/post natal anxiety etc. If you haven't already, I'd recommend counselling to talk about the birth. You can also ask for a de-brief.

I think for anyone who has had children, the case is heart breaking because it relates to a parents worst fear and nightmare, the loss of a child. It is emotional viewing for every parent. I had both of my children at the Countess in 2013 and 2015. I can't really describe how I feel about it all. Devastated and heartbroken to think about what happened. Anger that she has tarnished the excellent work done by others at the hospital (my friend is a MW there). It's just horrible and the whole thing makes me cry when I think about it. That's the only way I can describe it.

crossstitchingnana · 19/08/2023 08:01

When my eldest was about two months old there was a news story (over 20 years ago) about a mum who left her baby in a drawer so she could party. That baby was 8 months and died at the weight my newborn was at the time. It broke me.

My second was in hospital for a few days, in a room with me, and I would not leave her even for a wee until my dh arrived.

Goatymum · 19/08/2023 07:27

It’s a horrible, tragic case so not BU but if your feelings continue def talk to someone IRL about it and it might help.
What I find sickening is the paediatricians were suspicious and the ward manager basically gaslit them and
Lucy continued to kill.
I was vvvv ill as a newborn and in nicu for a long time - the nurses were lovely to my DPs and we kept in touch for many years as a family. That’s what it should be like. I still remember their names and I’m in my 50s now.
DD also had some interventions as a newborn although not in a ward, but DH went off with her as a literal newborn for a lumbar puncture. We just have to think how unlikely it is for this to happen to our children, but be vigilant anyway.