Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder that psychopaths can't help being like they are because they're born that way?

38 replies

GemGi · 19/08/2023 02:15

If psychopaths are born psychopaths then can they really help being such awful people? Aren't they just born damned to be really awful people?

YABU - psychopaths CAN help it
YANBU - psychopaths CAN'T help it

OP posts:
QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 19/08/2023 05:07

I read somewhere that in evolutionary terms, having a few psychopaths in society is actually advantageous for group survival.

Psychopaths don’t automatically equal evil people who are a danger to society & will murder you; the majority of psychopaths don’t even have the urge to kill / cause harm, but because they have no empathy, they possess the ability to do so without remorse if they so wish.

Let’s say we go back to caveman days for example, say food was scarce & your tribe was facing starvation; it’s actually beneficial to have people who would have no issues invading & killing another tribe, stealing all their food / resources & bringing it back to keep everyone in their own tribe alive. The most important aspect of this is not just the ability to carry out horrific acts but more importantly to come back unbothered by it / without PTSD therefore enabling them to do it again. This allows a society to survive & thrive without the majority of its population having to get their hands dirty.

If you look at the traits of a psychopath, it’s not difficult to see how these could be advantageous from an evolutionary point of view.

Even in society today, there is a lot of cognitive dissonance in the population. There are so many things the majority of us would either not do ourselves or know is wrong but will turn a blind eye to so we can reap the benefits - you literally see it everyday here on mumsnet.

Autieangel · 19/08/2023 05:07

I assume there's a spectrum of traits and some people are more affected/unable to control impulses than others. Then there's environmental factors often theres early neglect/ abuse which will have an impact. And life circumstances/influences. So lots of rejection or meeting other evil people could impact.

I don't know anything about Lucy letby (I'm assuming she's the reason for the thread) but she's obviously educated. Did she deliberately choose nursing to hurt people? It's hard to know but my guess would be no. I would (layman) guess that she got an enjoyment/need fulfilled from helping/comforting people and over time that need became greater to a point where she began to hurt /kill innocent babies to get that need fulfilled. Which is incomprehensible. She may have dissociated with her actions so the act of supporting parents in grief was not connected to her (in her head)

Regardless of diagnosis I think with something as serious as murder it has to be treated with culpability . Although in some cases a psychiatric hospital would be the safest option

YoureALizardHarry11 · 19/08/2023 05:00

Logically they know right from wrong, but they don’t care. They don’t feel love or empathy or sadness like we do. They feel entitled and can get nasty when things don’t go their way. Because they don’t feel emotion in the same way, killing or committing some other crime allows them to ‘feel’ something I guess.

Not all psychopaths are killers, a lot are powerful though, because they don’t care who they step on to get to the top.

The same can be said for sociopaths really, but sociopaths are capable of empathy to some extent, just not at a normal and expected level.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 19/08/2023 04:20

In a previous role I worked with psychopaths who had committed horrendous crimes. It comes down to the 'mad or vad' debate.

If you take the view that psychopaths can't help being what they are, then they shouldn't be put in prison but rather sent to a secure psychiatric hospital.

I think that they know right from wrong, and can control their impulses/tendencies. Some choose not to.

If you are asking this question in relation to the Lucy Letby case, it will be interesting to see what mitigation is put forward at her sentencing.

tiredofthenoise · 19/08/2023 03:44

There are cases where serial killers go decades without killing. When they do kill, most of them are obviously aware that they've committed a crime and go to great lengths to avoid discovery (though they may also get a sick thrill out of taunting law enforcement).

That tells me that they have a choice. They're not insane.

They can't help being psychopaths, but they don't have to act on their worst impulses. Unless they are completely out of their minds, they still make a choice.

Morestrangerthings1 · 19/08/2023 03:21

Oh very interesting question.

Not all psychopaths are ‘bad’ people. Some head up big business for example, and such people are often admired in our society.

A researcher who was studying psychopath’s brain structure found that he was a psychopath himself. It’s an interesting story. He says he had displayed ‘symptoms’ that are psychopathic - eg lacked empathy, is extremely competitive to the point he won’t let his grandchildren win any games - he has to win.

And in reference to your question about can they help it or not:

He has noted he had a very loving childhood with parents who were very focused on him - his wellbeing, and he thinks that has made a positive difference to his personality. He has set about proving that he can be a more empathetic etc.. He talks about it on the article I linked below. (Ps he’s done Ted Talks so you can watch those if interested).

Researcher who found he was a psychopath from his own research

Compared to a control brain (top), neuroscientist James Fallon’s brain (bottom) shows significantly decreased activity in areas of the frontal lobe linked to empathy and morality—anatomical patterns that have been linked with psychopathic behavior.

The Neuroscientist Who Discovered He Was a Psychopath

While studying brain scans to search for patterns that correlated with psychopathic behavior, James Fallon found that his own brain fit the profile

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-neuroscientist-who-discovered-he-was-a-psychopath-180947814/

RosaCaramella · 19/08/2023 03:20

I don’t believe anyone is born a psychopath but if they inherit some of the classic traits that are then nurtured in certain environments, they may grow up to commit horrible acts.
Psychopaths know the difference between right and wrong legally and maybe even morally but for some of them, their need to harm will override such concerns.

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 19/08/2023 02:37

I think that someone can't help being a psychopath but they can help their actions.

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 19/08/2023 02:36

RitaStairs · 19/08/2023 02:32

I've voted YABU because not all psychopaths are 'really awful people.' People can have psychopathic traits - lack of empathy or egocentricity for example - and go through life without ever being bad or evil.

I've met psychopaths with an intelligent insight into their own condition - it's frightening and sad for them.

Can you tell us a bit more about your experience?

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 19/08/2023 02:34

Interesting question. After spending some time googling psychopaths I really don’t know. I did read that being a psychopath doesn’t always mean someone will intentionally harm people. I guess a psychopath still knows right from wrong, but may think it doesn’t apply to them.

RitaStairs · 19/08/2023 02:32

I've voted YABU because not all psychopaths are 'really awful people.' People can have psychopathic traits - lack of empathy or egocentricity for example - and go through life without ever being bad or evil.

I've met psychopaths with an intelligent insight into their own condition - it's frightening and sad for them.

Perfectlyblended · 19/08/2023 02:25

I don’t think it’s an answer that will ever be 100 percent known.
It’s a hard one.